I find all of the qualities you mentioned previously attractive, and necessary for every relationship.
But going more in depth, I'm a very shy and secluded person, so I find it hard to open myself to new people, I need and find attractive a guy that's extroverted and includes me in stuff and really pulls me out of my comfort zone, I also find attractive guys that whenever you open up they actually try to make an effort to help you instead of saying "damn that sucks". I want them to communicate with me and try to be openly smart. However I disagree on your view of the family structure, I believe that both people are responsible for providing, protecting, mantainng and nurturing, all according to their abilities and personality. For me, both men and women should play all of those roles so a relationship and a family works, it's a 50/50, of course one is going to be better at one thing than the other, but it's a group effort.
ADDITIONAL PERSONAL PERSPECTIVE
I don't generally go by appearance, and if I do, I'm not very picky either, I have a very diverse taste on men and I don't care about the "beauty standard", because what I find attractive might be unattractive for some.