Is it apostasy for a catholic bishop or laity to pray in a mosque/synaguge/hindu temple, while holding or venerating their holy book? Asking for a friend, he said it is apostasy because of some encyclical from the 1920s.

Email
Comment *
File	Select/drop/paste files here
Password	(Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field	[▶ Show post options & limits] Confused? See the FAQ.

Embed	(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options	Do not bump (you can also write sage in the email field) Spoiler images (this replaces the thumbnails of your images with question marks)
Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf Max filesize is 16 MB. Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000. You may upload 5 per post.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 12:42:22 b5d465 No.762741

Is it apostasy for a catholic bishop or laity to pray in a mosque/synaguge/hindu temple, while holding or venerating their holy book? Asking for a friend, he said it is apostasy because of some encyclical from the 1920s.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 12:50:43 d448fb No.762743

Going to those places to do anything but spread the Gospel and convert the non-believers is a waste of your time.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 13:15:04 9ef494 No.762753

>>762743

That's bigoted. We should respect all faiths and cultures. Everyone is equal.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 13:16:41 c0d345 No.762754

>>762753

Gr8 b8 m7

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 13:22:27 b5d465 No.762759

>>762753

quite a few modern popes partake in pagan rites and have prayed in non-christian temples and so forth

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 13:24:54 d448fb No.762762

>>762753

and you could f*** off right back to your safe space, leftist. God gave us the Great Commission to convert All Peoples and All Nations to the one true God.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 14:32:21 5e55e0 No.762776

File: 50a547b12277c0d⋯.jpg (69.21 KB, 1019x655, 1019:655, download.jpg)

>>762753

>Peak heretical Interfaith Nonsense

If you would had read the New Testament even once, you'd realize how stupid your statement sounds just now.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 19:28:46 3801cc No.762913

But of course not. You are in a temple of demons.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 19:30:57 3801cc No.762914

Not apostasy, but it's a sin.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 19:32:00 3801cc No.762915

Wait I misread.

Venerating their shit yep it's a mortal sin and very close to apostasy.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 20:18:40 a75eff No.762924

>>762741

If I hold and say "This is a book for Muslims" then no, it's not a sin because the book has no power, it's an inamiate object, it has no sway over you.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 20:48:53 9a04a0 No.762941

File: 4c92145854afe8f⋯.jpg (43.66 KB, 462x320, 231:160, pope11.jpg)

>>762741

No.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 21:48:50 d5c53b No.763008

What about priests/bishops praying together with people of other religions? Or allowing these people to pray in a catholic church during a mass? (I saw that recently in TV, it was during a funeral mass)

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 22:31:59 3801cc No.763023

>>763008

Those bishops praying with the heathen folk are praying for their convertion to Christ. So it's a good practice because in their eyes you aren't rejecting them and they might gain more respect for the church and eventually convert.

Better than the "stay away from me heathen".

>Or allowing these people to pray in a catholic church during a mass? (I saw that recently in TV, it was during a funeral mass)

As a rule we don't kick out people from the churches (specially in a funeral of a friend of theirs) we must assume they are asking God for the good of his soul (that is they must be like an atheist that goes to Mass, stay there silent, and respect the Christian rites).

Now if they do their satanic rituals they shouldn't be allowed to be there and if a priest knows this and does nothing, he should be reported to the Bishop to punish him according to his actions, and in the case of a Bishop he should be reported to the local Episcopal Conference and/or the Holy See herself.

Christanon 01/28/19 (Mon) 23:07:25 c4424a No.763045

Go ahead and read the Old Testament. Half of it is about punishment for allowing altars, temples, sacred poles, sacrifices etc to other gods to be built and used in Israel and Judah.

One path, one Lord - Christ.

Christanon 01/29/19 (Tue) 17:30:25 f2c9d7 No.763424

>>762741

> apostasy from the RCC

No, Islam was created by the c*tholics and the Vatican says that muslims will go to heaven

> apostasy from the church of God

The bishop is already an apostate so no

Christanon 01/29/19 (Tue) 18:27:45 27ee5c No.763445

>>762941

Why is the pope kissing a book made by a pedophile?

Christanon 01/29/19 (Tue) 20:03:58 3801cc No.763484

>>763424

>Islam was created by the c*tholics

Nice tinfoil.

>Vatican says that muslims will go to heaven

"…those who reject the Catholic Church will not be saved"

in Nostra Aetate, the same document that talks about the common points we have with Muslims.

Why do you lie? Sincerely answer my question.

Why do you people lie so hard that don't even bother to read the real thing?

Why do you lie knowing that might endanger the souls of some of your brothers?

Do tell me anon. Pls tell me.