bd85b5 No.15924723
Video game discussion online is plagued by those who shill unapologetically for corporate interests. Most of these people aren't paid (the journalists are, but the aren't even really "people") - they literally do it for free (video gaymers are retarded faggots). Why do you think people shill? Why do you think gaymers are so susceptible to shilling? What are some common or uncommon shilling tactics you've noticed? What communities are particularly affected by it?
Here's a few that I've been seeing a lot lately:
The Shill-22
>if you don't like "X", don't buy/use/play "X"
then conversely,
>you don't even own/use/play "X", why do you care?
The shill insists that anyone who criticizes a corporation's product should just stop using it. Of course, if you don't use it, that same shill will insist you have no reason to criticize the company for their products. A variation on the "traitorous critic" fallacy. End result: no criticism allowed.
Muh Private Company
>it's a private company, so free speech doesn't apply!
>it's a private company, so you can't critique the ToS!
>it's a private company, they can censor their game if they want!
You've all heard this before I imagine. The logic behind it is that you are not allowed to criticize companies for their legal actions/decisions. And also, that free speech is not a socio-cultural value but purely a legal term. It'd be like if you posted on /r/TacoBell and complained about a new fucking taco or some shit and they said "WELL TACO BELL HAS THE LEGAL RIGHT TO PRODUCE THIS TACO AS THEY SEE FIT" etc etc. (actually rebbitors probably do say this).
The Tinfoil Hat
>anyone who shows any degree of skepticism towards a corporation is just a tin foil hat conspiracy theorist who needs to CITE and PROVE that a company is going to go back on its word (no matter how much a company has done this in the past)
For example, if you suggest that Classic WoW might have sharding, or that Star Citizen might not meet its next target, you will be accused of being a pessimistic whiner making baseless accusations against a poor mega-corporation who's done nothing to deserve your skepticism. It doesn't matter how many times a company has fucked its customers over in the past, they will always be given the benefit of the doubt by the shill.
Mods Did Nothing Wrong
>oh whats that you were banned for toxicity? GOOD
Modern video gaymers lack the capacity to tolerate anything mildly upsetting in-game, and so they will approve of the most egregious, intrusive, community-breaking censorship practices as long as they no longer get called a "fuck tard" for being a bad player. This is by no means limited to video gaymes, however, for instance this very website is plagued by the most pathetic sorts of mod-dicksucking imaginable. Shills can't imagine that companies would ever abuse their power. It is inconceivable to them.
Thank you, EA!
When a company massively fucks over its users for years on end, and then throws them scraps, the shills are incredibly quick to engage in fawning praise. I say "Thank you, EA!" because EA shills are particularly prone to this. Brittbottles will fumble over themselves to praise EA for releasing a new FIFA promo pack for them to by, only minutes after raging at the game for being a piece of shit (it is). It's not only EA though. A recent example would be Star Citizen who tried to actually force people to pay 50 bucks to watch their yearly shillcon. All they had to do was apologize and the whales at /r/starcitizen showed them with praise.
Add you own! Shills are everywhere…even if this very thread! Be careful!
a6cf5f No.15924740
>>15924723
I can think for myself, faggot
bd85b5 No.15924746
>>15924740
why are you mad ??
bd85b5 No.15924781
>>15924760
>criticize company on the largest platform available for discussing said company
>its the company forums - owned by the company
>its the subreddit - owned by the company
>internet cops (mods) called
>get banned for "trolling"
5057b3 No.15924785
Who cares if the games suck anyway. Just play and discuss old GOOD games, then you avoid shilling entirely.
dc0e5e No.15924802
>>15924760
Yes?
This is the lolice
bd85b5 No.15924817
>>15924791
>>15924785
i dont even play these video gaymes i just like following the drama
star citizen/ea/wow shit will always be funny
bc687d No.15924818
We do have to be careful about company shills worming their way into fan made communities and moderator positions within those communities. Companies do know how to internet and they can and will plant artificial toxicity in communities that criticize them. I've talked to former friends that had seen smaller fan forums die this way. Only a few niche old JRPG sites remained until Square Enix rebooted the series to kill them. At that point instead of selling the domain and passing on the forum hosting to a new person who may or may not be a corporate shill they closed the site down. The fan Wikias are up, but Wikis are ruined half the time by shill revisionist cancer anyway. I'm glad Lufia forums chose to die gracefully.
5152e2 No.15924834
>I want a refund
<Um sweetie you have signed the ToS and it clearly states you don't get refunds :)
>The ToS is completely powerless. My country's and bank's laws will always be above it. I want a refund, and I can get a refund through my bank.
<Wow what the fuck man, you're entitled asshole, the devs worked so hard for this game and wen you're bored of it you refund it >:(
Tarkov forums lads. The mods and shills in there will scream at anybody who requests a refund, mentioning that the ToS doesn't allow refunds, and when you tell them that the game's ToS is irrelevant, they call you names and ban you from the forums for 3 months minimum.
869f74 No.15924856
>>15924834
Hopefully those laws will be reformed to make your country more business-friendly.
46805a No.15924857
>The Shill-22
This one is valid. You don't have to get kicked in the balls to criticize it as a bad thing. It's obviously painful to anyone watching. However, you can't act like your criticism matters more than someone who Has been kicked in the balls. They experienced it firsthand and can criticize it better than someone who hasn't been kicked.
If you tell someone you don't like Fallout 76 without playing it, you can't itemize its problems better than someone who did suffer through its frustrations. If you attack someone shilling a game they like (let's face it, there no "paid" shills on /v/; just unpaid anons recommending their shit tastes onto others), they Can discard your opinions if you haven't even played the damn thing yourself. I mean, what would you know? You're only regurgitating what someone else who hated it said, but unlike you, they DID play it.
5152e2 No.15924868
>>15924856
Absolutely correct my fellow anonymous forum poster, companies need to independent and not regulated by any government ever. The free market will most certainly balance itself, no need for rules
bd85b5 No.15924879
>>15924857
video gayme journalists play the games they review, so i take their word for it :) they know best
guess i better spent 60 buck on ur shit game
46805a No.15924899
>>15924879
Oh, I didn't realize I was dealing with a retard here. Bottom Line:
"People who hated a game and did play it", are able to criticize it better than "people who hated a game but didn't play it".
bd85b5 No.15924912
>>15924899
What about people who become completely addicted and beholden to a game? Should their views be treated with respect?
Many modern video games use extremely exploitative psychological techniques to make their fans addicts. FIFA with its FUT game mode is a perfect example (turning kids into gambling addicts etc.). One side effect is that many of the people who play these games the most are the least able to view them objectively.
11edf3 No.15924918
>>15924723
>>if you don't like "X", don't buy/use/play "X"
>>you don't even own/use/play "X", why do you care?
funnily enough, the "take it or fuck off" thing is a fallacious argument: argumentum ergo decedo AKA traitorous critic fallacy.
Basically, turning a deaf ear to your fans and telling them to 'go play something else' after they dare voice some criticism is a bullshit position.
0cfb48 No.15924930
>>15924723
>The Tinfoil Hat
I agree with this but it never hurts to source your claim, especially if you're doing a throwaway "this game/dev are SJWs!"
bd85b5 No.15924936
>>15924930
Yeah but the thing is the person asking for the source is almost doing it disingenuously (especially on a site like reddit), and their standard of evidence is such that you could never meet it.
e1426c No.15924946
>>15924918
Oh yeah? Well your post is an ipso facto mangus hocus pocus argumentum ad faggotum.
24b1c0 No.15924956
>critisize game
>"You havent played the game"
>"you havent played the game long enough"
>"you played the game for too long how can you say its bad"
>"you are just bad at the game!"
>"you are just a contratian/troll/Bait!!"
>"You have a low rank in the game!"
>"nuh uh the game is fun/good and you just suck :)"
>*anime Raction image* "its japanese so its good"
>*literall shill image* "its a western game so its good!"
Did i miss any?
bd85b5 No.15924967
>>15924956
>uhhh, asshole, there's a difference between CONSTRUCTIVE criticism and just plain bashing!
6777a6 No.15924971
I don't understand op, why do you hate free market capitalism so much?
bd85b5 No.15924999
>>15924971
Isn't it weird how these erstwhile Leftists transform into the most vile sort of libertarian extremist when it comes to stuff like this?
24b1c0 No.15925004
>>15924971
>Capitalism
Another word for judaism
8d42b8 No.15925007
>>15924956
>*jewish/slav image* "it's a European game so it's good!"
11edf3 No.15925011
>>15924946
i'm not the one arguing against logic here, ergo no u.
>>15924956
>"it's good, you just can't appreciate it!"
>"it's good, it's just meant for people with different tastes!"
>"it's good, you just can't accept/don't like change!"
>"you aren't a real fan because you don't like $THING"
>"you're not part of the game's intended demographic anyway"
etc.
24b1c0 No.15925012
>>15925007
>jews and slavs
>european
Does europe even make games anymore?
91e65f No.15925013
>>15924956
>If you don't like it just don't play it!
>The devs worked hard and need to be paid!
>[food analogy]
>>15925004
Ideally capitalism would exist without usury and the free market would thrive, while still allowing for some socialist handouts for those truly in hard times (eg illness or injury through no fault of their own)
A more adjusted opinion would be that any political and social system is inherently flawed when taken to an extreme and distorted by handwringing happy merchants
8d42b8 No.15925021
>>15925012
yeah they made the smash hit pirate game for the xbox one i forgot the name of. also stalker. same people, literally.
0d7ac7 No.15925063
>>15924834
the russian voice only makes it even funnier
63477e No.15925066
>say a positive thing about anything
>this is considered shilling
5152e2 No.15925070
>>15925066
>complementing objectively terrible games made by leftists isn't shilling
dc0e5e No.15925083
<<15925066
<i am the thread designated attentionwhoring (You)-slut,please feed me (You)s
Fuck(You)
fe5958 No.15925105
While I'm sure there are actual shills here, their numbers are exaggerated. I'm of the opinion that the average /v/ user is just that stupid these days.
c46100 No.15925126
>>15924971
>>Capitalism
>Another word for judaism
>>15925004
Capitalism and Communism were literally allied in destroying Europe in WW2. All the bullshit about the Cold War was just a tactic to keep us caged: the elites in both East and West were the same.
bd85b5 No.15925146
>>15925105
Oh yeah most shills aren't paid. They do it for free like this guy >>15925066
4dae30 No.15925225
I think a lot of "shilling" is probably just retards blindly siding with corporations. People are brainwashed into uncritical consumption their whole lives through PR departments. Things like catchy jingles in commercials, "nice" public figures interacting on social media, "funny" ads. People get sucked into all this shit and don't even notice their ass is getting raped vigorously. Consumer skepticism should be a key value taught to everyone but hardly gets mentioned unless some serious shit goes down.
bd85b5 No.15925566
>>15925225
yep, pretty much
f64f5c No.15925698
>Modern video gaymers lack the capacity to tolerate anything mildly upsetting in-game
I think it's more that the devs/pubs/mods are trying to create a certain type of community. Like how the commies wanted to great a New Soviet Man
dd72ea No.15926658
>>15924723
>thread about a new videogame, with a subject title of the name of the new videogame
>magnet is listed and brief description of the game
it's a shill, i don't know why but playing videogames, not my ordeal.
86ff15 No.15926811
Let me tell about one of the most effective shill tactics of all time: /vg/
>start with a board about video games
>some series are larger and more popular than others, essentially there's always an active thread discussing things like WoW, Final Fantasy, Zelda, etc.
>these threads dominate the board, crowding out smaller, faster-moving topics
>ok, let's make a board for these giant dedicated threads
>this isn't a great idea because after a few thousand posts, what else is there to talk about regarding any game series ever
>smaller generals start appearing for more niche titles
>oh, some appeared for games still in development, that's a little weird
>some people who are totally average anons and not the developers make threads about an upcoming indie game
>some anons who are totally not the devs' friends show up to make it seem like there's genuine interest
>these threads last forever, getting bumped back up when they drop too far down, this is totally normal after all, general threads are meant to last a long time
>eventually sucker real anons into supporting their scam and shit out generic, derivative pixel trash
And that's why Starbound exists.
e268ff No.15927028
>>15926651
>Business must never be free. All businesses must bow to the will of the consumers.
>Regulate everything. Always.
If only that was how regulations worked. Although (((they))) would figure out how to manipulate the popular vote even if it was up to the consumer to decide, rather than a higher authority that most likely doesn't even represent that consumer.
d07132 No.15928849
>>15927274
> With regulations, companies are kept in check.
But who watches the watchmen?
eae167 No.15928913
>>15927274
>Any discussion of current or yet-to-be-released games is shilling. All threads about those must be banned.
If they will give torrent link or download link with spoilered password in OP, so bot crawlers won't find it and nuke it afterwards then I don't mind threads for current year games being here.
>>15926811
Shouldn't it be somehow mitigated by setting limit to number of posts before threads receive bumplock.
aa68a2 No.15929197
Hello regular users, please tell me about how awesome GAME is
>shill OP creates thread asking shit along the lines of "I just got GAME, what am I in for?" or "Redpill me on GAME, is it any good?"
>Fellow shills come in (Or the same OP, if they can't even try to be subtle) and start to plug the game.
Popular on cuckchan and you'll see those threads here on occasion too. It's much more effective to paint a picture that a large amount of people genuinely like a game than to just shill outright in thread openings.
757bd6 No.15929453
>>15925066
>somebody says something objectively false
>correct him
>fuck off shill
30adb2 No.15929492
Ctrl+F influencer
0 results found
This thread missing the biggest point. No wonder it didn't get anchored.
cac858 No.15929749
>>15924781
I love it when even the dicksuckers get banned because the company are paranoid fucks who see
>Maybe this can be improved
as unacceptable.
8415ef No.15929779
>>15924723
>political shill tactics
disrupting all discussion of video games
84ca6c No.15929795
>>15929760
The alternative, however, is thinking that a company's going to go under because of one flop, because the flop is "too big to recover from". This can be summarized as "wishful thinking", or "having unrealistically high expectations of normalfags".
If Nintendo could recover from having three out of seven of their home consoles be flops, Bethesda and EA isn't going under just because of one fucking game. Can they go under? Sure, and let's fucking hope they do, but JUST Fallout 76 and JUST Battlefield isn't enough. I don't expect them to, either. Normalcattle have the memories of fucking goldfish, and the moment they see Skyrim 2, they'll buy it five times again, unfortunately. Even if 76 destroys Fallout as a franchise, they'd need to fuck up with Elder Scrolls separately, which of course can happen, but I'm doubtful.
Hell, aside for Blizzard being dissolved into Activision, the only big company I see potentially going under within the next ten years (barring some big miracle incident) is Valve. As "too big to fail" as they seem, Tencent playing their cards right with the Epic store could fuck them over. And Tencent taking sneezes worth more than Valve's entire company certainly helps. They probably wouldn't mind investing a billion or two to potentially take the fucking market over. For as shit as Valve is, it's scary to think about.
8415ef No.15929817
>>15929795
>This can be summarized as
the mentality that enables clickbait
8415ef No.15929934
>>15929927
>/v/ is, and always will be, /pol/.
lol, you cycle through users so fast. go invite more redditors
8415ef No.15929949
>>15929939
your willingness to defend that which poisons the entirety of 8chan for a temporary boost in activity says everything about your nature. youve absolutely sacked /pol/ and its nothing but reddit and twitter now. you should be ashamed.
a16d6d No.15929956
Every modern video company shills today, in fact thats the job their pr department not just damage control when a scandal breaks out, i could say thats their main job. As for retards that defend corporations ive long suspected that they project their lack of a father figure on the corporations. Think about it a lot of these kids are growing up in a single mother household, in their eyes they can do no wrong.
1fc1fd No.15929984
>>15929949
>not wanting /v/ to turn into corporate marketing like the rest of the fucking internet
>poison to 8chan
8415ef No.15930001
>>15929986
>hes given up defending it because he cant and its eating away at him
f1569d No.15930012
>>15929492
OP here. To be honest I have no idea why this wasn't anchored. In my experience the mods of this board are among lowest piece of sub-human shit on 8chan and that's saying something. I almost always get banned when I post here and that's very occasionally, almost always for stuff like this.
I think you may be on to something though. I must have missed something big haha
f1569d No.15930016
Also, ever notice how Leftists have become the biggest corporate dicksucks of them all?
I mean this thread isn't necessarily partisan but the only people who are gonna complain when you call out shilling are Leftists. Because they support the corporations doing the shilling.
65cea3 No.15930021
>>15929717
>"Correcting" without any proof is also shilling.
Sure thing. You'll get called a shill if you dare point out that 20,000 consistent users on Steam after a few weeks doesn't mean a blunder of the century.
84ca6c No.15930024
>>15929927
>a company as hated as Tencent
Most people don't know what it is. Who really hates Tencent? Hell, most people only know them as the companies they own - Epic, Riot and all that - and not them themselves. Can you really tell me that if you asked a hundred normalfags, more than one would know Tencent? I don't believe that. Seems just like a case of believing that /v/ is an active representation of real life.
>Yes, they can go under just because of one single flop. What happened in past years doesn't apply anymore. There is a massive spread of information whenever a new game flops, preventing people from wasting money on it. There is also the increasingly high costs of making current games, with also (((marketing))) draining all money. A single product that cost too much to be made and marketed can bring down a whole company when it flops.
The difference is that most companies are not dependent on one game, really. If by some miracle an R* game flopped, yes, they could be at risk, though GTA5 being one of the best selling games of all time means even they could support a flop. But I don't think some shitty rushed spinoff is going to kill Bethesda. If it was TES6 that failed, that would be far more significant. Battlefield 5 means more for EA, but even they could downsize, "restructure" as companies do and just keep shitting out mobile games and sportsball to keep afloat for a while longer while chasing trends with whatever spare shekels they have.
8415ef No.15930030
>>15930016
well see, your problem is that you think everyone is just like you, 100% politically motivated, so you only call out shilling when you think its a product aimed at the "left".
the fact that you buy into the left vs right propaganda shows that maybe you have some inner shills you need to sort out.
f1569d No.15930092
>>15930030
What makes you think I'm opposed to calling out shilling aimed at the right? I really don't care what sort of shilling it is as long as it is interesting/funny/curious. That's the purpose of this thread. So we can compile shilling in all its forms. I'd be very interested in any examples you have friend.
8415ef No.15930093
>>15930065
well this is a thread about marketing, and you sure are doing your best to sell something using emotions and dishonest tactics. you cannot be taken seriously by anyone outside of your niche because you are so damn far off track its amazing, so you have to try to drive away the users on other top boards. id like to say youre a dnc agent, but im pretty sure youre just that disconnected from reality.
f1569d No.15930100
>>15930065
You see I'm not sure that influencers are "easy" to spot, at least for normal people. They seem to fall for that shit. I mean the biggest advertisers for a given game aren't usually paid directly by a corporation, but they make money by playing the game created by said corporation so they have an indirect motivation to defend said company.
What's interesting to me is when it gets to the point where a company is so reviled that these influencers have to engage in a sort of balancing act between appearing "genuine" (which requires criticizing the company) and shilling (so they can keep the golden goose going).
f1569d No.15930106
>>15930093
No he's just a sperglord who came into this thread looking to have an argument and post walls of text. That's not shilling - it's just typical 8channer behavior.
90d4ca No.15930130
>>15924956
>>critisize game
>>"You havent played the game"
>>"you havent played the game long enough"
Well to actually make a valid critical review of a game you do have to know it as a player who has experience the whole thing.
a84fe4 No.15930139
>>15930130
If a game is so bad that I didn't want to finish it, that doesn't somehow convert into me being unable to criticize it.
4c3f65 No.15930143
here's some shilling, check my boards out
>>>/eerie/
>>>/garrett/
f1569d No.15930152
>>15930143
Mind describing them a bit? Looks interesting man.
>>15930130
>you cant know if our game is bad until you spend 60 bucks on it goy
f64f5c No.15930153
>>15930139
You don't understand, the last 10 minutes are wonderful.
Oh, you didn't like them either? Then why did you play the entire game?
8415ef No.15930154
>>15930130
clarity and thoroughness are always desirable for sure, but depending on what kind of game it is you may not need to have a complete understanding of the games nuances to be able to tell whether or not it feels like crap.
there are certainly different levels to enjoy a game at, where someone might hate it at a basic level while someone else might appreciate some often ignored deeper aspect enough to overlook other problems. so that can be confusing.
90d4ca No.15930170
>>15930152
>you cant know if our game is bad until you spend 60 bucks on it goy
You can pirate it. Or you can just state your reasoning for not playing it. But you can't produce a critical review of it. Merely stating your reason is much more easy to dismiss when it comes to criticisms. If your goal is convince others of your point than the more informed your criticism is the more undeniable it would be. Take MisterCaption for instance. He made hour long videos completely ripping apart shitrim and fo4. Nobody can argue with it and the only way to actually dismiss it is to ignore it and then we go into the territory of calling out of malicious intent.
>>15930139
You can fully criticize the part that you played, that can well be enough of a representation of the game. But its still leaves room for "well it gets better". To thoroughly criticize and shit on everything on a game you first would have had to experience it all
f1569d No.15930188
>>15930170
I might take your position seriously weren't we in a situation where leading game journalists produce reviews without actually really playing the games in question. In fact in many cases they are directly paid to do so.
So you are describing a problem that doesn't exist. Or rather, the opposite problem exists. Which really makes me wonder….
90d4ca No.15930196
>>15930188
Hey, I was just referencing in objectivity, not the shitshow corruption. And of course Its about you doing so, because they can product paid off reviews, but if you thoroughly produce a review the right way then a person faced with both can't really dismiss you unless as I said they purposefully choose ignorance.
90d4ca No.15930201
>>15930196
Also a review isnt about you justifying why you did something. It is to be viewed by other to convince them of your point.
f1569d No.15930217
>>15930201
>>15930196
I honestly don't see the issue with lying about gameplay in order to slander a company's game. Given our current situation it seems downright moral, in fact.
f1569d No.15930219
>>15930215
What if you buy "X", based on the false premises of the company that produced it? Because that's almost always the case.
Companies get away with lying blatantly about their product, and then when people buy it and are disappointed they get told
>WELL WHY DID YOU BUY IT THEN????
893b2a No.15930223
>>15924723
I feel like you missed the
They care about your best interests, goy
bargain.
f1569d No.15930229
>>15930224
Yeah man it's the consumer's fault. They should be expected to see through corporate lies.
Corporations should face no consequences for lying though!
90d4ca No.15930230
>>15930217
Because if a lie is revealed you will be instantly discredited and will only provide an avenue to dismiss real criticisms.
f1569d No.15930241
>>15930230
Yeah I get that. And I think that's why so many critics always couch their criticism in effusive praise (see: WoW for perfect example).
90d4ca No.15930252
>>15930241
Well thats just a trick to make themselves seem objective whiles technically dismissing the issues they brought up by downplaying them.
65cea3 No.15930254
>>15930241
It's not necessarily critics. Fake outrage that gives the game more exposure with complaints about shit no one would care about can be dumped straight onto the public, too. Remember how the greatest complaints one could conceivably have about Cyberpunk was that it didn't look like vaporwave and that there were no flying cars? And anyone who names some other problem with it is just grasping for more straws after the public was smart enough to see through complaints about the sun.
b4ea85 No.15930259
>>15924723
>companies exist to make money
>you're all just a bunch of entitled crybabies
>get hype
>passive aggressive mockery of valid concerns
>perpetuation of corporate loyalty
>etc
Shills are characterized by a general unwillingness to see the truth about a situation or product, usually in an attempt to disregard, downplay, or otherwise deny the existence of a problem or complaint. You must be careful, because not everyone who isn't ready to take up arms for YOUR SPECIFIC GRIEVANCES is a shill. No, the shill is a slimy cretinous beast that works hard to sow discord and derision. The shill will actively attempt to dissolve any conversation that they believe may be damaging to their corporate master's reputation or well being. In the event that this is not possible, the shill will resort to smokescreens, jumps in logic, emotional outbursts, and a variety of other tricks to either destroy conversation or sow doubt.
As a secondary objective, the shill is tasked with keeping the product or idea relevant in the minds of the general population, and can use what appear to be honesty and integrity to attempt to direct discussion in a specific direction.
>New Game Product™ will release soon
>Forum users may be averse to the product in question
<So, let's talk about older titles in the series, to keep the franchise primed in the minds of the forum's userbase
The thread can then be used as a pretense to gauge attitudes about the franchise in question, and to give the franchise as a whole some publicity, which in turn may generate discussion about the newer title. However, simply because this tactic can be used to maintain a product's relevancy, this does not mean that every thread will be used for this purpose. It is entirely possible that a forum user genuinely wants to discuss older entries in the franchise, and this is why accusations of SHILL are generally impotent, unless there is some substantial evidence that can be used to prove that "we're being raided" or that some third party is creating threads for this express purpose.
This is but a brief description of how shills operate, and is not exhaustive. There are many online platforms, such as Resetera, GameFAQs, any publisher's official forums, Steam forums, and reddit that are rife with these kinds of people, so they provide an invaluable resource for examining these corporate cocksuckers.
f1569d No.15930266
>>15930252
Yeah I often think it's used by e-celebs to distinguish themselves from "those people" (ie irredeemable trolls). As in, their criticism is somehow more acceptable because they don't want to harm the company they are criticizing.
>>15930254
This is fucking true man, really fucking true. I seen it all time with FIFA. FIFA "influencers" will make videos like "EA we need to talk" and it's all criticizing irrelevant bullshit. It just serves to advertise the game.
f1569d No.15930270
>>15930259
You are spot on with your analysis. And I'm glad you mentioned Resetera, which to me is almost the pinnacle of corporate dicksucking as it intersects with modern political concerns.
65cea3 No.15930288
>>15930259
<So, let's talk about older titles in the series, to keep the franchise primed in the minds of the forum's userbase
This one is especially obvious after the negative response to DMC5, since its threads quietly morphed into general DMC threads to minimize the damage. Though its threads are a showcase of so many marketing tactics that it's ridiculous, like how microtransactions are a "retard tax" that a true hardcore player doesn't have to use, while at the same time a true fan will be happy to "support the developer™" by paying extra for cut content and using real money to "skip the grind". Or trying to remind you how no one ever complained about how they tacked microtransactions onto a 7 years old game before (which isn't even true), which means that shoving them into the series is now acceptable, and how it's exactly the same as developing a game with microtransactions in mind from the ground up.
802ae2 No.15930306
I'm a fan of Pol Pot so I generally hate private companies. but that would also mean no vidya so a compromise must be made.
f1569d No.15930311
>>15930306
>i like the worst sort of communists and also the worst sort of capitalists
wow so based and epic
90d4ca No.15930427
>>15930415
What the fuck are you talking about you limp-dick faggot?
a2c35e No.15930452
d72971 No.15930863
>>15930306
he'd fuckin kill you four eyes
a0c646 No.15930890
>>15930415
>Video Game is a Right-wing hobby.
Your talking shit you faggot. Just because we don't like faggots, jews, feminists and niggers it does not mean we are right wing. Faggots, jews, feminists and niggers have spread the myth that only the far right hates them. We used to live and let live until faggots, jews, feminists and niggers started to interfere with our hobby. We are the TRUE left, we used to think everyone should enjoy vidya. If they left us well enough alone we would have left them the fuck alone but those dumb fucks kicked over a hornets nest what they did not understand was it was the biggest motherfucking hornets nest around. Thats why we do not like any of that lot. They made a foe of us for no real fucking reason.
3235aa No.15930943
>>15930100
Like bethesdas paid promoters. People excuse their actions, despite it being obvious they're beholden to bethesda due to them being the reason they can pay the bills and bethesda gives them memorabilia and toys.
24b1c0 No.15931007
>call out an obvious shill attempt
>endless replies about "HURR YOU DONT WANT TO TALK ABOUT GAMES? THIS IS /v/ DURR"
>same filenames and posts as the previous thread
>get banned an hour later
Remider that anyone that posts le todd howard le buy skyrim is also a bethesda shill
90d4ca No.15931019
>>15931007
BUY MY GAME FAGGOT
8415ef No.15931021
>>15930890
try not to buy into the left vs right too much. its meaningless now that everything has been exaggerated to hell and back for the sake of making people feel like the group that theyre unwittingly now a part of is constantly under attack.
you say they made a foe of us for no reason? the reason is to force people to become irrational since groups 1 and 2 both blame eachother for everything since indeed everything ever falls into either category 1 or 2.
its much easier to manipulate and distract people when theyre already fighting someone else, especially when its infighting, and double especially when youve already made up their minds for them.
d72971 No.15932328
>>15931007
criticizing video games is trolling bro :)
unless you dicksuck the game you are a vile troll
491e5a No.15932348
>>15924723
Taking advantage of a culture of irony where people will defend corporations against criticism for the hell of it.
14b6d3 No.15932478
>>15930130
How do you know getting shot in the foot will hurt? Have YOU ever shot yourself in the foot? Therefore you cannot have an opinion on it. No, poking yourself with the bullet really hard does not count. You did not experience the while thing nor as intended.
491e5a No.15932521
>>15932478
Good line from Confucius about that
"Man has three ways of acting wisely. First, on meditation; that is the noblest. Secondly, on imitation; that is the easiest. Thirdly, on experience; that is the bitterest."
86d0c6 No.15932552
>corporate memes
All joke websites are filled with em. Marketing via attempts at cheap laughs.
It's incredibly effective on normalfags.
90d4ca No.15932579
>>15932478
The fact that people who don't make the mental connection between "gun" and "hurt" exist doesnt help your extreme comparison.
ac9a51 No.15932667
>>15932478
He's not entirely wrong, but since so many games play the same whether you're 2 or 20 hours in you don't even need to finish them to be able to tell whether you'll like them or not.
And because so many of them now fall into these distinct "types" you don't even need to play them.
6b8ef6 No.15932670
Slippery Slope Fallacy Fallacy
This is one I've seen here more times than I can remember. It's when people point out a clear pattern of increasingly shitty behavior in an individual, company, government, or whatever, and the shill responds to that by saying "That's a slippery slope fallacy. We have no indication that they're planning to do anything worse." We don't need indication when we see it every fucking day, and that slope can actually be really fucking slippery. Anyone using this tactic is an obvious shill trying to stifle discussion.
Example: When SJWs started censoring niche games, I expressed concern that this set a bad precedent, but I was told it was an isolated incident that nobody cared about anyway. Then, Omega Labyrinth Z was outright banned outside of Japan, and I pointed out that things were getting worse and what a horrific precedent had been set. I was told I was using a slippery slope fallacy to overreact to an isolated incident that nobody cared about. Now, Sony is literally having its SJW branches harass Japanese game developers during the development of new titles.
Only pedos defend that
Seen this one more times than there are stars in the galaxy. This is when the shill states that anyone criticizing censorship of a certain game is a pedophile. They don't stop at actual loli games, either. I've seen them go after Senran Kagura, even specifically mentioning members of the cast that are over 20 years old.
Examples: check any thread about Steam censorship or the Omega Labyrinth Z ban. They're chock full of shills saying anyone who defends the games in question must be a pedo.
a4ba5d No.15932811
The greatest corporate shill tactics has little to do with corporations and more to do with common "knowledge" that everyone parrots but no one actually understands.
=Muh free speech only means the government can't censor you=
Free speech is a concept, and there's been a case where that's been ruled false: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_v._Alabama
This is why you should never base your understanding of the law on what random brainlets on the internet parrot.
=Muh slippery slope fallacy=
Slippery slope is the most retarded fallacy in that whether or not it's a fallacy is dependent on whether or not the conclusion is correct. It might not even be a fallacy. This makes it the most misused fallacy on the internet due to brainlets incorrectly using it to try and point out a flaw in the inherent logic of the argument. This is not a fallacy that can be applied to the logical structure of an argument, it's only a fallacy when the conclusion is incorrect, which also makes it the most pointless fallacy ever.
=Muh unregulated free market=
This is the most retarded shit gamergate and the libertarian right has ever fallen for. The unregulated free market does not result in the highest quality in the long run, and it will eventually stifle all competition. Businesses don't become successful by having the best product, they become successful by having the best business and marketing practices. And in the long run, all unregulated free markets end up becoming a monopoly, because someone will eventually win. Or businesses realize cooperation is easier than competition. If you see an anarcho-capitalist do the world a favor and give him a free helicopter ride.
=Muh censorship=
So long as we live in a society, censorship has and always will exist, even if it's only self-censorship. People have been getting fired or worse for having retarded opinions long before SJWs were a thing. The problem isn't that people get fired for publicly expressing retarded opinions, it's that SJWs aren't getting fired for their retarded opinions, and people are getting fired for retarded reasons. This is the most devastating shit gamergate and the libertarian right has ever fallen for, and one of the major reasons they will never be able to get SJWs out of the industry.
=Muh democracy=
Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting for what to eat for dinner. It's the preferred government type (or republic) because of its checks and balances (not that it'll matter for long due to election fraud), but notice how virtually every other aspect of society is either a dictatorship or an oligarchy? There's a reason for that.
=Muh bad tactics=
There's a game theory concept called the Prisoner's Dilemma. Two players can either choose to cooperate or backstab. If both players cooperate, they both benefit. If both players backstab, they both lose. However, if one of them cooperates and the other one backstabs, the backstabber gains more than if they both cooperated, and the cooperator loses more than if they both backstabbed. What happens when you've been conditioned into always refusing to use "bad tactics"? You get completely and utterly fucked by those who are willing.
24b1c0 No.15932882
>>15932670
slippery slope is the biggest meme, and the worst part is people always fall for it.
>Niggers are people too!
>who cares if they get equal rights?
>de-segregation doesnt sound that bad!
>its not fair that niggers get all the cool seats at the back of the bus!!
Same shit with horse armour and hidden unlockable content in games
581d4c No.15932895
>>15932882
I know that darkened one is just supposed to be mona lisa blacked, but all I see is ALIENS
24b1c0 No.15932939
>>15932521
>chink philosophy
b53e36 No.15932953
>"i hate [company] as much as the next guy, but…"
>"i'm not a [company] shill, but…"
>"say all you want about [company], but…"
Seeing Valvedrones using this soft shilling to fit in and shill steam is always funny to see, and somehow it always works with you plebs.
6b8ef6 No.15932967
>>15932882
>horse armor
Holy fuck, this is one of my big I told you sos. From the instant that shit was announced, I said it was setting the precedent that you could release a game without all of its content and nickle and dime people for the rest of it after release. Now, we get like 1/2 to 1/3 of a game on release and have to pay $20 a pop for god knows how many DLC packs and season passes for multiple seasons for the rest. I'll give you two guesses at which particular fallacy people said I had used back then, but you'll only need one.
24b1c0 No.15933000
>>15932967
>1/2 to 1/3 of a game on release
You'd be lucky to find a game thats even 1/10 finished nowadays
dcc404 No.15933549
>>15932670
>>15932811
great posts thank you
dcc404 No.15933552
>>15932953
le enlightened reddit centrism
you see this as the top comment on almost any thread critical of a corporate game on reddit
3c96e2 No.15933787
>>15924834
>windows 10
smh tbh fam
1fe645 No.15933834
>>15933752
>/v/ is /pol/
People who say /v/ is /pol/ just want an excuse to derail every thread with politics, fuck off TORfag.
41cab2 No.15934005
>>15933834
/v/ is full of the same retarded kiddos as /pol/ idk who you are kidding bud
48925b No.15934020
>>15932521
This is the first time ive ever seen someone quote Confucius here.
7432a9 No.15934541
>>15924723
>>15924857
<hurr you need to get stabbed in the gut in order for your opinion to be valid, that way you know what it's like to be stabbed in the gut, because if you weren't your opinions don't matter in any significant way :^)
>muh real life experience validation :^)
nice try you fucking corporate spook, you say shit like that but it's okay when your boss does it huh? well fuck you I can do what I want and there's nothing you can do about it wanker
>>15924912
>using psychological techniques
shit like this should be the kind of subversive business tactics that should be made fucking illegal
>>15924723
I think you should add Real Life Experience Validation on their list of psyop argumentations, along with the But without copyright the companies WILL SUFFER and they can't make any money in their games n shit, therefore, piracy is bad!!1 insipid semantical bullshit, and then there's that Copypasting content in the internet is stealing man, it doesn't matter how you put it, IT"S JUST STEALING. PERIOD.
7432a9 No.15934549
>>15933834
>>15934005
<kidding bud
>t. trannypol
both of you niggers clearly don't belong here
>>>/leftypol/
117800 No.15934636
>>15925011
>>"it's good, you just can't accept/don't like change!"
this one's valid depending who you're talking to. mate of mine gets all his "opinions" from cuckchan, complete with spouting the latest memes why game X is bad (ofc while never playing them) while playing shit like lol and overwatch.
bonus points for getting pissy when I won't play the latest streamer shit with him
>>15932670
> thread about Steam censorship
good lord, that was such a shitshow
>>15932811
>one of the major reasons they will never be able to get SJWs out of the industry.
they don't need to cause that shit will take care of itself. a companies first interest is money, SJW shit means less money for the company so they gonna cull those retards at one point eventually.
it's also a byproduct of a cushy society that allows that shit in the first place, it's only a matter of time now till economy or ecology starts crashing down and people won't have the time and money to spout or even listen to retarded shit on social media.
and even in the unlikely case everything will keep working somehow, history being cyclical means a shift will happen inevitably and they'll learn being "on the right side of history" is relative (implying they know shit about history to begin with), pushing shit harder just means an equal reaction.
the main problem is that shit happening can take a while, so right now we're simply fucked.
e2ad9e No.15934685
>>15934541
>But without copyright the companies WILL SUFFER and they can't make any money in their games n shit, therefore, piracy is bad!!1
And that isn't true because?
11edf3 No.15935080
>>15934685
>And that isn't true because?
you think books, art, and music didn't exist before 1710, nigger?
do you even know the costs of the shitty copyright system? the current system is so wasteful: BILLIONS of tax dollars wasted every year and money wasted on lawyers and licensing costs. I think artists would make more money if all that money went towards paying them instead of litigating the shit out of each other.
The only reason goyim are willing to put up with the current system's awful shit is because they've been convinced that's the only way they'll get to gulp down the AAAbortions shat out by the industry. However, deep down, noone likes copyright (DRM, orphan works, impedes research, facilitates vendor lock-in, etc.), only kikes (lawyers, publishers) do. This especially true if you ask anyone who's had to clear rights (finding (actual) right holders, delays pushing your deadlines, dealing with lawyers, licensing fees, draconian terms, refusals, etc.).
e2ad9e No.15935106
>>15935080
Okay, forget all that. If everyone pirates, then the devs don't get any money and can't develop games. Isn't that right?
4189f9 No.15935241
11edf3 No.15935259
>>15935106
>then the devs don't get any money and can't develop games. Isn't that right?
what part about the billions in tax money (in the US alone might I add) that are used on copyright cases could go to artists instead don't you understand?
moreover, selling non-excludable, non-rivalrous goods (e.g. games, music, art), is self-evidently a terrible business model. there are other ways to earn money (with differing viability): subscriptions (games are under continuous development these days), crowdfunding, commissions, contracting (common with software), merchandise, etc. Hell, some people have talked about a monthly tax or levies on blank media destined to artists.
11edf3 No.15935271
>>15935259
>subscriptions
as in, subscriptions for updates and the latest version and updates a la Red Hat Linux, not to launch and play the game. file hosting isn't free you know.
117800 No.15935317
>>15935259
>some people have talked about a monthly tax or levies on blank media destined to artists.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_copying_levy
1917ed No.15938161
>>15933752
Kill yourself, huemonkey.
>>15932670
>>15932811
>>15932882
I never even knew slippery slope arguments were "fallacies" until I started using the internet. Now it seems like any argument that one event leads to another is called out with muh slippery slope fallacy even if the conclusion is obviously correct and supported by evidence.
ec46e1 No.15938281
Anyone who criticizes piracy is unironically a shill.
e05fb1 No.15938301
I would shill the game I like, to share the joy of playing it, but I don't remember the last time I did so, I wish there was a game which I could shill without remorse.
b10ff0 No.15938308
Remember when Gearbox kept on spamming Borderlands on 4chink's /v/? It was impossible to post anything without it being deleted instantly by their spam.
a2c35e No.15938315
>hey x is good
>ARE YOU TRYING TO SELL ME SOMETHING YOU ANTI SEMITE xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxdddddddddddddddddddddddddd
check my dubs
a872cf No.15938338
>>15938281
Downloading of unauthorized copies shouldn't even be called "piracy", honestly. We don't murder or hold people hostage, among other things.
ec46e1 No.15938357
>>15938292
He explicitly says that these autists can and do exist, shill. Try reading the OP.
ec46e1 No.15938360
>>15938315
>turkroach
>shill
like pottery
81d05b No.15938364
>>15938315
>YOU ANTI SEMITE
>While calling out jewish shills
Makes no sense but I suppose thats to be expected from a roach.
b10ff0 No.15938376
>/pol/ shitposting in the last bit of the thread
Fucking nuke this board and string Mark up from a noose, this place can't get any worse.
a2c35e No.15938378
>>15938360
>>15938364
sheeeittt, you found me goy
893b2a No.15938386
>>15938357
>/v/
>reading the op
70c98e No.15938456
>>15924723
>The Shill-22
I fucking hate this. The problem those two arguments, is that they're really only made by disingenuous niggers or sub 80 IQ retards that don't want to argue, but just take snipes. That's what it is, really, a gotcha. It's not addressing your points, but putting into question your credibility, which is harder to defend and easier to attack. The best course of action is to simply call it out for the goal-post moving, bullshit that it is and move on.
My most despised type of shilling isn't some archetype of argumentation or clear-as-day fallacy. It's something way more abstract. Think of some obese neckbeard that lurks on reddit the whole day and gets into serious discussions about the most trivial of matters. This blog of a human will write out 12 paragraphs ranting about you're 2 sentence post. This creature will sit behind his monitor all day doing nothing but wait for you to respond, just so he can epicly pwn you 10 minutes later. He doesn't really make arguments or tries to refute yours. He just goes on and on about everything and eventually tires you down. You have to have talked with one of these fucking ogres to know what I'm talking about. I'm sure a few anons have been in this situations before multiple times. You know exactly what I'm referring to.
>>15929984
Welcome to /v/ circa 2009.
4d7fb4 No.15938471
>>15937269
No it isn't
No they aren't
And repeating it over and over won't make it so, torpedo.
acbb6b No.15938513
>>15924723
>Mods Did Nothing Wrong
/v/ is extremely guilty of this.
acbb6b No.15938568
>>15932811
>whether or not it's a fallacy is dependent on whether or not the conclusion is correct.
You either don't understand slippery slope or you don't understand fallacies. Fallacies are errors in the reasoning process, they're assertions made with the premise of being 100% infallible when they actually aren't. The result doesn't matter; you can probably end up with at least one high quality sculpture if you randomly hit rocks for millions of years without any rhyme or reason. It doesn't make it a good process
Pattern-pointing being a fallacious statement depends on the conviction you have when calling it. Clearly it isn't a 100% certainty, you're merely making a guess, and you'd be wrong if you were 100% sure of your convictions for the mere fact that you think it's an infallible 2+2=4 reality. It isn't something that you can prove mathematically.
However, you're absolutely right in pointing out a pattern and stating you're making an educated guess. There's nothing wrong with that. There's certainly cases when people misuse the fallacy when calling out on criticisms; that happens when they talk under the presumption that you're saying the pattern is a fact and not just an educated guess. In that case, it's not a fallacy
60b82f No.15938795
Undercover marketing/astroturfing firms absolutely do exist though. Anyone remember that Duke Nukem Forever debacle? The company that worked for them still exists and still attempts to viral for publishers on video game forums.
http://therednergroup.com/
NeoGAF was literally full of industry propagandists for ages.
60b82f No.15938810
>>15932811
>Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting for what to eat for dinner. It's the preferred government type (or republic) because of its checks and balances (not that it'll matter for long due to election fraud), but notice how virtually every other aspect of society is either a dictatorship or an oligarchy? There's a reason for that.
Actual democracy never referred to electoral politics. Real democracy is making decisions by citizen referenda. In fact that ancient Greeces who literally invented the word referred to systems where people ran for office and were elected by vote as oligarchy. Why? Even a few millennia ago people were able to correctly notice the tendency for electoral politics to insert people who were already wealthy enough to have the free time and resources to run for office into positions of power where they would further defend their own class interests. In Athens they didn't elect officials at all; they had an elaborate system of sortition where people put themselves in a pool for public service positions and then where chosen through a randomization device.
9df52f No.15939053
Oh joy, the "I can't articulate as to why I dislike or like a game so I'll call the anon with the differing opinion a shill because I'm a nigger" bible.
Man up and whip your opinions out there like your dick. If you're such shit tier faggot you can't even defend why you like or hate a game and have to call the other guy a doo doo head then what the fuck are you even doing on this board?
60b82f No.15939104
>>15939053
>If you're such shit tier faggot you can't even defend why you like or hate a game and have to call the other guy a doo doo head then what the fuck are you even doing on this board?
Sitting in good company? Better question is what are they even doing on anonymous image boards.
85813d No.15939123
You're missing a key element of understanding this situation.
The hole left when all tradition was stripped away were filled with this culture of jingle recital and product review groupthink. These are all thralls. Kept alive to toil and slave fed only bare minimum to breath but not to think. There are not many free people any where. The only portion of reality that is free is found in the nomadic styles of liars who host shame and tragedy in their breast. They know who they are and what they want but do not give up on seeking it for they want it badly. That is the last flame
85813d No.15939132
Know not the names of your overlords, thrall-kun?
Self-sustianing horror is one
Hydra by the common tongue
ec46e1 No.15939687
>>15938513
Yes. In that regards it is extremely similar to reddit.
>>15938456
I know exactly what you mean. It's actually an incredibly effective argumentative tactic if your goal is just to drive away your opponent.
>>15938795
Yeah no doubt but I do think the majority of people who appear to be shills are just fucking retarded bugmen who dicksuck for free.
1917ed No.15941014
>>15938456
>This blog of a human will write out 12 paragraphs ranting about you're 2 sentence post.
This reminds me of another shitty tactic: you made a spelling error so your entire post is wrong.
8b44dc No.15941951
>>15941014
Yes, and shills will often try and coax you into typing out walls of text ("well why don't you PROVE 'x' company is doing bad things" etc.) so they can pick out one minor error and harp on it to "disprove" your argument.
24b1c0 No.15942130
>"ITS JUST A BETA!"
>"THEY'LL FIX EVERYTHING AT RELEASE/ IN UPDATES!"
aa6090 No.15946640
>>15942130
>beta is coming out in 2020 the game is ON TRACK
star citizen fan boys actually believe this
acbb6b No.15950702
>>15950641
Are you ever going to give out your address or any meeting place so someone can go and beat the shit out of you for being the most annoying fuckwad in the entire site?
6e922b No.15953254
Sound like teenage capitalists identifying with corporate owners, lots of economic cucks like that everywhere.
5859fa No.15953279
This irony of OP's pic+post is more than likely completely lost on him.
901a21 No.15955818
>>15953254
Nice try, Conan O'Brien. No one wants to watch your shitty show anymore.
0a0c96 No.15956034
>>15938513
Actual posters don't say that. Mark and his volunteers do pretending to not be anons.
0a0c96 No.15956054
>>15938456
Yes but some times it's quite obvious. You sometimes see posts that are nearly word for word what the devs said or posted on other sites word for word. Take the Star Control controversy currently happening. There are posts in our thread that are the near exact same posts with the exact same images being posted both here and on cuckchan on top of the devs themselves on their twitter saying the exact same shit as well. You combine this with the fact that it's known some of the devs browse here and it's a good legitimate case for shilling.
Another great example would be the people from GOG who would make the exact same threads every day on cuckchan and /v/ about how GOG is great and Steam is shit while the devs themselves were shown to browse these sites. Is it really hard to believe people will defend and shill their products here when they browse here?
890aa8 No.15956985
>>15956054
Reminds me of that Mechwarrior SJW game. They shilled it on cuckchan relentlessly, but when they decided to come here, turned out it was one ID doing the majority of the damage control.
54999a No.15957346
>>15957319
Such an incredibly lazy false flag. Can we please ban torposters already? They contribute nothing of value.
a21c24 No.15957356
>>15957338
Kikes are the ones that bring politics into fucking things like Puyo Puyo.
>>15957346
This torposters are fags that got banned.
a21c24 No.15957388
Before anyone replies to the TORFAG. Behold his true SOYBASED form >>15956424
Thinks Agents of Mayhem is good. Thats all you need to know about this fag.
eb6190 No.15957408
>>15924723
>posting 3 times in a row
wow behold indubitably we are triggered
eb6190 No.15957423
You have autism nigga lmao go jerk off to robo-wombs.
9ad4ca No.15957458
>shill
>they literally do it for free
"Shilling" without any personal gain isn't called shilling, it's called enjoying talking about something.
Some people actually like vidya and will praise their favorites, the reason you think these people are shilling is because you don't like the games they like.
Here are 4 examples of games I like and how "shill" would generally be applied:
I love Carrier Command '88, not that '12 trash, this would generally be consider not a shill as the game is over 30 years old, unknown and there is no money to be made.
I love BeamNG Drive, this game is still a pretty small indie title so it could be claimed I'm a dev or people could point out there isn't any gameplay there isn't but I love the handling and see a lot of future potential.
I love the KSP 1.6 update, this could be considered a shill because it's a recent addition to a popular game and may draw DLC sales for Squad.
I love Fallout 76, this would most likely be called a shill as it's a game from a huge studio that has seen public backlash. While it is entirely possible I just like the game. I don't, I just can't think of a AAA from the last 2 years I actually like
6b14fa No.15957460
>>15957448
I don't get it, why does the fake donald trump picture make people depressed ?
c89b4e No.15957482
Companies are getting better at making reddit meme their games for them.
Right now, there's a new meme called "this how mafia work" which is literally just ads for some shitty facebook game. Some ad company was apparently able to turn their ad into a "popular" reddit meme by pure "coincidence"'
eb6190 No.15957485
>>15957438
Not an argument.
81d05b No.15957508
>>15957458
>You cant be a shill unless you're paid
Yes you can, you're just a fucking retarded shill.
1d3bbb No.15957717
>>15938795
Reddit is too. Also we had a shill in the fighting game thread trying to defend Street Fighter V. Everyone told him to fuck off while he tried to use (((echoes))) (wrongfully mind you) and saying nigger to try and fit in. These people can't sound like genuine fans even if you begged them to.
>>15957485
Just filter TOR autists and move on. The faggot is probably just trying to derail the thread into another /pol/ thread.
8809a9 No.15958264
>>15957460
>that pic
TONIGHT on Top Gear:
9f5890 No.15958275
>>15957458
Oh hey it's a shill.
>>15957482
Gaymers are fucking idiots so its easy to trick them into shilling for shit.
6051aa No.15958362
>>15957388
Checking these criminally unHeile'd dubs o/
cc5131 No.15958442
>It's in alpha, of course there's no story elements yet
<but the game is supposed to be out in 3 months, why aren't they talking about the story?
>a l p h a
>>15924956
>"I'm going to buy 2 copies of the game just to piss you off"
>>15930130
>"The game gets better 7 hours in"
44846c No.15958820
>>15958770
>tor poster knows what fallacies are
60b82f No.15959230
>>15958995
Damn son, you are one autistic ideologue.
1d3bbb No.15959315
>>15958442
>"The game gets better 7 hours in"
This can be true in some cases. Many roguelikes won't be fun until you take the time to learn the game. Same with some fighting games. It does not excuse games like FF13 where the game "opens up" or actually allows you to form your own party. Difference here is that the first 2 genres have all the depth right in front of you and the only reason you didn't enjoy it as much is because you didn't understand how it worked. Meanwhile FF13 keeps important mechanics from you to force a narrative. And when you do finally get more freedom, the game is still shallow and doesn't allow for much creativity to team/character builds.
84fe02 No.15960002
A WILD FAGGOT APPEARS
>>15932953
>"i hate [company] as much as the next guy, but…"
>implying that's an invalid starter for a devils advocate argument
Or even without being a devils advocate it can be a valid statement.
>I hate shills as much as the next guy, but some of the arguments in the thread are fucking awful, holy shit.
>>15930229
No, you as a person should know better. And if you want to perform some sort of activism based on the situation you've posed in your previous post, then you are totally justified in doing that. However I'm skeptical in you being able to do that seeing you misdirecting your actions due to how hard you are projecting.
>>15959315
>Many roguelikes won't be fun until you take the time
>Difference here is that the first 2 genres have all the depth right in front of you
That's not how roguelikes work.
First, you get horrid ui and barely serviceable manuals that most of the time don't explain any of the mechanics (bonus points for mechanical inconsistencies due to games being unfinished projects most of the time).
Second, you get artificial difficulty in a form of hand crafted situations that are either puzzle game difficulty tight or have requirements that are outside of your knowledge prior to entering such situation (bonus points if it's also unclear from game mechanics and game design what are the requirements for solving the situation even after encountering it several times).
Third, before you master the game and get a hang on all of its quirks and bugs features that would allow you to complete it literally naked, you'll probably make use of some meta and builds, which are usually reliant on specific items spawning at specific points in time, and since games usually don't have a prebuilt meta (i.e. fixed drops, weighted rng) you'll likely spend some time failing sub-optimal runs, rolling for optimal runs (instead of playing) and failing optimal runs.
That's just a few points why you'd spend a ton of time on a roguelike without having fun, and how it's not your fault as a player.
>>15930012
>I almost always get banned when I post here and that's very occasionally, almost always for stuff like this.
Maybe it's because instead of talking about vidya you talk about policies, being a massive faggot while at it? I don't see any other explanation, since I am an attention seeking faggot and I barely ever get banned. And I shit up threads all the time.
>>15925225
Clear example of your point is denuvo discussions on steam forums.
>>15925070
>objectively terrible games
',:^)
>made by leftists
It's a rare case when there is a shilling thread about a game made by literal leftists.
>>15924956
Some points might be rightfully addressing flaws in your arguments (except for ad hominems), the question is are they doing that in bad or good faith? And while at it you also must answer the question "is hostility towards your criticism within a natural degree for someone taking a defensive state or is it exaggerated?".
>>15924723
>Muh Private Company
If you are able to pinpoint objective flaws that can't be refuted by examples mentioned, then there are 2 problems
1. Your actions are completely misdirected, you are trying to argue things that should be handled somewhere besides vidya game forums where rarely ever anything of consequence gets done;
2. You are engaging in a battle on an enemy territory. Don't. Unless your goal is outside of just discussing vidya and you know that at face value you will lose the argument (your posts will get overwhelmingly shilled on and you'll likely get banned).
>The Tinfoil Hat
What do you actually expect from a fan forum? Just imagine strategically why and how such forums hold up. If skepticism was as easy to spread then they would be in ruins in no time. You are engaging with people of a different mindset and you don't take that into account, that's what they are telling you when replying in such way.
>Mods Did Nothing Wrong
No, that's not how it works you fucking retard. Most people in general are not aware about issues we are talking about and they also subscribe to a social behavior concept which also brings preconceived notions about hierarchy to the table. It's not normalfags that get occasionally confused as shills, it's shills that wear mask of a normalfag.
Basically you are underestimating how stupid people are, you don't correct your actions based on a situation, and you have a pretty horrible assessment ability for someone who loves to criticize.
722bc0 No.15960833
>>15960002
I'm having a hard time coming up with roguelikes that meet your issues. Can you name an example?
24b1c0 No.15960863
>"hey guys i found this game"
>"not shilling but…"
>"the game is fun and good!"
>*multiple threads on the game with similar OPs and loads of 1ID posts
>every criticism is deflected as bait or trolling
FUCK DUSK! and the other games that do this
cebdd0 No.15961285
>this thread
Jesus, this explains so fucking much. You people legitimately don't know what the word shill means. That's why you spout it at every fucking corner.
If they aren't being paid, they aren't shills. I shouldn't have to be explaining this to you.
68cb1c No.15961467
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasocial_interaction
These people believe that these corporations are their friends and this is why people love gossiping about stocks and games tanking. I don't see the appeal of it because it's just another fucking company. It's like gossiping about how the gas station down the road open up a new station in town and how the local Citgo is in trouble. Like who gives a shit. I don't work for these companies or even manage them.
4ab546 No.15961671
>>15961285
>(1) and done retard
>makes idiotic sweeping wrong generalizing statement how this informative thread is stupid
Butthurt shill?
84fe02 No.15962817
>>15960833
It would be easier to name that don't - Desktop dungeons.
Most other games in the genre that I've played or looked at feature everything that I've described in one way or the other, featuring all of them or being only partially affected. That doesn't mean that roguelikes are bad per se, it means that there are natural and obvious drawbacks to passion projects about (procedurally generated) rpgs with a console like interface made in ones life backyard. People that love roguelikes often times confuse depth with fairness, being completely oblivious to the irony of the situation. "It's possible to complete 'game' on your first playthrough!", "All the tools are in front of you, you just need to pay attention.", "It's not artificial difficulty, it's exploration!" and so on.
>>15960863
No one's stopping you from shitting the thread up with criticisms that shills and retards would fail to address. Their resistance only makes, well, you know the rest.
>>15961671
>(1) and done retard
>makes idiotic sweeping wrong generalizing statement
The irony.
69d143 No.15963150
nt tec.com is a great company to work for
cebdd0 No.15963240
>>15961671
>literally only two posts had been made since mine, one was a shitpost
>"he didn't think either of the two were worth responding to, must be a (1) and done!"
How do you function being this retarded? Not that I'm remotely surprised by yet another display of cognitive failure in this thread.
722bc0 No.15963369
>>15962817
Okay? I would recommend you Unreal World, which has no dungeons, is open world but has meaningful randomization and interaction, a manual and a tutorial that teaches you all the necessities but leaves you to enjoy the game at your own pace. It also has a user interface that conveys all the information to the player.
There are others that might suit your standards like Elona, but the genre just isn't for everyone. I personally like the bullshit rng and permadeath difficulty and the minimal UI with ASCII tilesets. They suck and most often than not are excuses for lazy and bad game design, but like I said, it appeals to some and not everyone.
24b1c0 No.15963422
>>15962817
>No one's stopping you from shitting the thread up with criticisms that shills and retards would fail to address.
but thats the point, if i give a detailed reason on why the game sux people just go "nuh uh its good i bet you play COD lmao" or call me a troll and if i give a brief reason on why the game sux its contrarian nitpicking, best thing to do is call them faggot nostalgiababies, shills respond to shitflinging better than they do actual facts, thats why writting like a passive aggressive female works best when combating the shill menace
03944c No.15963435
>>15924723
>Why do you think gaymers are so susceptible to shilling?
Most of the targets of this are children or teenagers, who are retarded and don't know any better.
Places like Steam forums are completely useless because they're full of both retarded teenagers and the shills who shepherd them.
Some exceptions would be forums for older games that have a small, older demographic.
84fe02 No.15963438
>>15963369
Well, the point was that
>Difference here is that the first 2 genres have all the depth right in front of you
was a wrong statement, simple as that (and since it's wrong the whole post about comparison falls apart). I don't think that's the reason to condemn an entire genre, but as you've said the fact that there are people enjoying a niche doesn't excuse objective faults of that niche. Which's the point since the thread is about shitty arguments.
As of the actual games, Unreal World wasn't my thing and I really fucking hate the tax collection feature in Elona. I'm more into a roguelitelikeroguelikes like :^) DoomRL, Prospector and Cogmind, but they still feature staples of the genre.
>>15963150
Ironic shillposting is still a shillposting.
>>15963240
You could just let me deal with him.
>>15963422
Use their weapon against them, if they are only able to counter you with shitty arguments, then enable them in doing so. If a thread is full of autists arguing, where people in support of a game can barely string two sentences together, then that's hardly a shilling, since conversation in such atmosphere is impossible, and fans of the game are outed as fucking retards.
ad8362 No.15963615
>>15960002
jesus christ this shillwall of text
shilling for mods, corporations, AND fanboys all in one post
truly a shilling masterclass
ad8362 No.15963623
>>15963422
This guy gets it. Anyone who actually tries to reason with a shill is a fucking fool.
84fe02 No.15963667
>>15963615
For the off chance, where between reddit spacing and no sentence punctuation, you are being serious - me pointing out that battling shills and fanboys on their grounds on their terms is obviously a completely losing situation and not being able to recognize that is a sign of a retard, has nothing to do with me being shill or not, except if you want to subscribe to an idea that "everyone who disagrees with views that I support - opposes me".
Unless of course you are being ironic, then it's likely lost on a public since the thread features actual retards that could think that.
>>15963623
No one argues for reasoning with shills.
0443b3 No.15963676
ad8362 No.15963753
>>15963676
lol
>>15963667
>muh reddit spacing
you post on /v/ dude this place is fuckin 8gag reddit
3d9ef0 No.15966829
>>15966728
Businessmen have zero knowledge of what makes a game good and therefore have no confidence in their ability to predict whether or not a game will sell. Instead, they look at a companies' track record but even the best developer will have a few misses in with their hits, often the hits are breakout hits with little investor involvement, and therefore, little investor profit, and the misses that come later drop investor huge bucks because of it. This means that the vidya market is prone bearish stock flights and one big failure can mean the end of a company's ability to produce AAA titles, if they lack a reliable source of income other than sales, which is just another reason why they keep trying to push the "games as a service" meme. They want to escape market volatility.
TL;DR t-selected yids can't into vidya. Burn in hell, kikes
606a2b No.15967040
>>15966728
>>15966727
good shit brotha, fuck on these faggot mods
fab0f8 No.15967052
>attacking the free market
OP this is a cleverly worded defence of leftism. Although I detest leftism in all forms I for one will defend your right to free speech on /v/. I might not like what you have to say, but I will die defending your right to say it.
234ccf No.15967066
>>15967052
It's pretty funny how libertarians manage to convince themselves that free trade, open borders, inalienable rights, materialism and plutocracy are right-wing ideals.
fc2c15 No.15967690
>>15932670
This is an all-around excellent post. Especially the "Why do you care about a niche you don't belong in?" part. It's something many non-shills make a mistake with, not banding together against horrible precedents because it isn't hurting their hobby yet.
fab0f8 No.15968646
>>15967066
I never said this. Although I believe libertarians are the true champions of free speech there are some sensible leftists haven't abandoned this cause. In fact, championing free speech used to be a cause predominantly fought for by leftists back when it was all bible thumpers rulinng society. Leftists like Dave Rubin, Sam Harris, Noam Chomsky or the late great Christopher Hitchens champion free speech.
234ccf No.15968680
>>15968646
>Although I believe libertarians are the true champions of free speech there are some sensible leftists haven't abandoned this cause. In fact, championing free speech used to be a cause predominantly fought for by leftists back when it was all bible thumpers rulinng society.
Well, yeah. Revolutionary ideologies love free speech since it lets them promulgate their doctrine - and then very quickly learn to hate it once they seize power since they know full well how unregulated speech could unseat them, and besides, they have no need of it in power because they can ensure speech that favors them is always free.
2fe009 No.15968720
>>15966727
>/v/ is /pol/
More like /v/ is >>>/cow/, with the way you're sperging.
1fe645 No.15968736
>>15966727
It's the same TORposter that virtues signals about how "BASED AND REDPILLED" he is, he already got banned in this thread, he just can't let go of his autism.
5fa318 No.15968768
>>15967690
Martin is faggot
acbb6b No.15968792
>>15968736
You can't ban a single torposter without banning all of them. That's the issue.
You either ban every single torposter, just because of this dumb asshole, or ban none of them and just delete his posts. Either way you take, it's a pretty annoying situation.
ca0ff2 No.15970440
>>15968646
Leftists were never pro-free speech for anyone but themselves dumbfuck.
>>15968840
Oh hey its a shill.
7a3689 No.15972573
>>15963438
>I'm more into a roguelitelikeroguelikes
>They appeal to normalfaggots like me
a4e8dd No.15975184
Liking anything is shilling. Never forget that.
acbb6b No.15975203
>>15968840
The outrage from banning tor users on /v/ would be so massive that it's understandable that Mark would prefer to just delete this particular faggot's posts rather than banning him and every other tor user altogether.
For him, deleting his posts is a mild annoyance compared to the shitstorm that would come from banning all tor users. People would never stop bitching about it.
fe4719 No.15975212
>>15975203
Not to mention that it's only relatively recently that tor was used almost exclusively as another vector for spamming and shitposting. I don't think it's a (((coincidence))) that it happened almost simultaneously with Lawson's spergout and I think that getting tor banned is one of his objectives.
f34fa8 No.15976077
>>15975212
>>15975203
The problem isn't with TOR but with the remaining fanbase of /v/, which is made up of mentally retarded sycophants who think shitposting is "bad".
e124be No.15976241
>>15976077
>who think shitposting is "bad".
When it would be only thing remaining, why even bother to post anything here?
a9b69f No.15976284
>>15976077
Don't forget people (and mods) who label anything which goes against the grain as "spamming" or "shitposting/derailing"
2a61e1 No.15986405
>>15976284
Yeah it's convenient isn't it. That's basically the number one rule of internet moderation - label shit you don't like "X", delete it, and then claim it was against the rules.
Most users, being low IQ retards, fall for these sorts of shenanigans.
f2f774 No.15986444
f2f774 No.15986453
>>15986405
If you have a problem with it, go make your own dead board so you can bitch about it. If people had issues with the way the board was run, then they wouldn't be posting here, they would use the features of 8chan to go someplace where they can circlejerk about how hard it is to follow a few simple rules.
0a3330 No.15991019
>>15986453
>>15986444
Oh hey it's a butthurt mod, or one of their IRC dicksucks.
99bbef No.15991035
>>15991019
Prove it, faggot.
fea329 No.15991054
603942 No.15991069
8c5c84 No.15991286
>>15976077
Torpedo is not shitposting, at least not in his eyes
This is what you fail to understand
He's being honest, genuine and serious in the dumb fucking shit he's saying, and believes it strongly.
6b96ac No.15992274
>who cares if the ceo and investors are jews
>what do you mean robert altman was a scandalous fiend that's in the past
Actually heard that 2nd one, was probably a jew but it was still disgusting.
>>15924971
It sells my Nation's vital interests to foreigners, converts the economy to service model, lacks serious regulation of major anti-consumer practices and underage gambling, and turns society into capital oriented materialistic whores. It's a corporate plutocracy.
>>15925225
Whenever groups would go on strike those who crossed their picket were considered to be shills. When someone violates your boycott they are fanboys or paid shills.
>>15930217
Unless you are also a slimy parasite, your weapon is and must always be the truth.
>>15960863
I legit made a Dusk thread after pirating the game and didn't know the publishers were communists and the devs an SJW. No one explained it to me so I figured it out, didn't like being called a shill by you niggers.
>>15968646
All the people you mentioned are subhuman degenerates. Chomsky fucking wrote Rules For Radicals you absolute mongoloid. They never fought for free speech, and "muh bible thumpers" were never the problem, just a distraction.
>>15976077
>boo hoo (((tor))) dindu nuffin goyim
Daily reminder that jews have been involved in the development of Tor and probable have backdoors.
9ff9ec No.15993595
7d5bc8 No.15997770
463da3 No.15997779
>posting the exact same thing in every single thread I visit is just voicing my opinion, guys
7d5bc8 No.15998984
OP here delete this thread already you queers. I realized this thread is way, way too good for /v/. No idea why it hasn't been nuked yet. Mods here are reddit tier cancer.
179e44 No.15998992
>>15924723
One of the issues about this list is that people actually unironically do what you're saying, and shills just join in en masse to reinforce the idea.
Basically, the only way to combat a shill effectively is to post your own opinions about things without worrying about entering any of these conversational categories, because shills are stupid. Any sort of reasonable opinion you make outdoes whatever they do because they operate under an objective and you don't.
48ac70 No.15999058
>>15998984
I agree 100%, this thread is attracting all the faggots who do nothing but discuss drama and shills while accusing others of being shills in a nice containment thread. We should have these more often.
b5d347 No.16002174
>>15925011
>post
>HEH LOGIC
People who post fallacies as a "Gotcha" are massive faggots who should be shot.
ae01a2 No.16002196
>>15924723
>It'd be like if you posted on /r/TacoBell and complained about a new fucking taco or some shit and they said "WELL TACO BELL HAS THE LEGAL RIGHT TO PRODUCE THIS TACO AS THEY SEE FIT" etc etc. (actually rebbitors probably do say this).
that's exactly how reddit acts
fuck shills though
079d85 No.16008641
>>16002160
good stuff brotha, thanks for sharing
1db734 No.16009101
I just hate how people can't accept that the game they play is a downgrade compared the the previous games in the installment. I MHW, GtaV/RDR2 etc
07939e No.16018988
>>15924723
OP you forgot:
>You can't say that this game is shit without playing it first, i haven't played it myself yet but i am sure is going to be a masterpiece! GOTY contender for sure!
<Someone says something bad about a game or how they aren't interested in slightest.
>You are going to buy it anyway like everyone else hahahaha!
98c041 No.16019017
>>16018988
>You can't say that this game is shit without playing it first, i haven't played it myself yet but i am sure is going to be a masterpiece! GOTY contender for sure!
Who even says that? I don't think I've ever seen it.
The most annoying shilling tactic is the "You're just too poor!" shtick. No, I just don't care about your shitty game / console / service / whatever.
07939e No.16019069
>>16019017
I saw it often on the jewtube comment section of game trailers, these faggots are all typing the same shit like "omg hype this game is going to be a masterpiece!" "GOTY of current year!" "10 out of 10 confirmed! muh hype!" before the game is even out, and then when someone makes a negative comment they bitch and moan saying that they can't judge the game without playing it first while they are doing the same exact shit themselves, basically:
>Only positive feedback is allowed in this comment section
Another shilling tactic is:
>First you BUY IT and play it goy, then you may say that is bad (rubs hands together and grins)
e349e8 No.16019144
>>16019069
Fan boys think they are the only ones with any right to criticize. And they always begin their criticism with a paragraph of dicksucking
>Although I LOVE THIS GAME and spend HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS and have played it for YEARS and it is MY LIFE etc. etc.
You have to coat even the mildest criticism in effusive praise otherwise these braindead fanboys will rage.
94ffe3 No.16019183
>>16018988
>You are going to buy it anyway like everyone else hahahaha!
That does happen, even here on /v/. Anons will talk shit but on release day a lot of them will cough up the cash and play the latest AAA release like they always do.
d2d9a0 No.16033115
>>16019183
>paying money for games
lol
d8b514 No.16033163
>>15924760
>post on twitter
>banned from game
>banned from reddit
>banned from school
>banned from youtube
>banned from patreon
>banned from online payment processors
>banned from physical banks
At least you can learn to eat bugs.
53b305 No.16033504
>Pirate game
>Play game
>Like game
>Want's to talk about the game
>"Fuck off shill"
>Thread gets derailed
GODFUCKING DAMMIT I JUST WANT TO TALK ABOUT VIDYA JUST PIRATE THAT SHIT I DON'T WANT TO SELL ANYTHING YOU RETARDED FAGGOTS