Is the MLP comic worth reading?

Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File	Select/drop/paste files here
* = required field	[▶ Show post options & limits] Confused? See the FAQ.

[–]

▶Anonymous 10/30/17 (Mon) 05:43:38 76512d (1) No.299245>>299255 >>299259 >>299265 >>299295 >>299297 [Watch Thread][Show All Posts]

Is the MLP comic worth reading?

▶Anonymous 10/30/17 (Mon) 07:15:40 45aedf (2) No.299255

>>299245 (OP)

most of the first ones were ok, but now most of them are trash, specially those written by katie cook

▶Anonymous 10/30/17 (Mon) 11:44:38 95b814 (1) No.299257>>299301

Sometimes they're serviceable, but a lot of issues are shit, like the one with the BLM dragons.

Anything drawn by Fosgitt is instant trash.

I don't think I've read any of the comics and that they were better than the show.

So I'd say don't bother, but if you really want to read them for the few okay stories, just read them online. Don't spend anything on them.

▶Anonymous 10/30/17 (Mon) 13:30:08 1d1110 (1) No.299259

>>299245 (OP)

Some are good. Some are not. It's like show episodes. The old Cook/Price/Breckel stuff was the best.

▶Anonymous 10/30/17 (Mon) 17:38:53 249bd4 (1) No.299263

File (hide): 8c35315f6b8741f⋯.png (119.52 KB, 330x324, 55:54, 1469391786362.png) (h) (u)

I've read several of the first ones of the main series, issue 1-16 I think, and in my opinion they ranged from ok to great.

▶Anonymous 10/30/17 (Mon) 18:07:32 92698f (1) No.299265

>>299245 (OP)

Not anymore

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 01:48:05 d33143 (1) No.299295

>>299245 (OP)

SHE IS THE LAW

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 02:16:03 248831 (2) No.299297>>299309

>>299245 (OP)

The Friendship Forever side series is actually more fun in my opinion. Or whatever they called the non-main series.

The early issues of the main comics where good like 1-10 or so but by the time you get into the 20's it nice to see the art but the stories suck.

What is this 'deviations' shit? is it the new FF?

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 04:25:23 3fa8a9 (3) No.299301>>299302 >>299328

File (hide): fa98bd20127d951⋯.png (381.54 KB, 720x720, 1:1, laughter stops.png) (h) (u)

>>299257

Fosgitt is an extra special kind of garbage. Some of the other artists are not great, but he really takes a shit on the cake.

Basic anatomy? Backgrounds? Not obviously copy/pasting? Doing basic research about character designs or plot of the fucking comic you're drawing? Who cares, it's just MLP!

What's funny/enraging is seeing retards on Derpibooru leap to his defense, mods deleting wrongthink comments/posts, etc

Wait a second

Weren't there Ponko lewds in this thread just before?

Where the heck did they go? Am I in the Berenstein universe now?

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 04:41:44 45aedf (2) No.299302>>299305

>>299301

>Weren't there Ponko lewds in this thread just before?

eh? no that i remember

>Fosgitt

is that the guy that draws the ponies like swans and with no basic horse anatomy?

And i though that Tony Fleecs was bad, but at least the guy tries to git gud a little bit.

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 05:13:42 3fa8a9 (3) No.299305

File (hide): 2efee3d694b7995⋯.png (1.63 MB, 1391x1401, 1391:1401, on model.png) (h) (u)

File (hide): 77c933c58f5d205⋯.png (288.35 KB, 496x397, 496:397, on model 2.png) (h) (u)

File (hide): 7e748f6bfc201e9⋯.jpeg (112.04 KB, 662x156, 331:78, photoshop mastery.jpeg) (h) (u)

File (hide): 96936ce4a050a0e⋯.png (94.81 KB, 450x142, 225:71, derpi.png) (h) (u)

>>299302

Less like swans, more like Porky Pig.

For real, you can count his quadrupedal ponies on one hand

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 05:14:49 3fa8a9 (3) No.299306

File (hide): b6003223e48c3e0⋯.png (99.08 KB, 409x682, 409:682, i'm cia.png) (h) (u)

Forgot to post the best one

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 05:56:20 58390b (2) No.299309>>299311 >>299314 >>299325

>>299297

The Micro series was pretty solid. The Rarity Micro is probably the best pony comic there is. The first few main arcs were good as well. Friends Forever was good most of the time.

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 07:52:29 f0c5ff (1) No.299311>>299312

File (hide): 42636892ea7e989⋯.jpeg (203.87 KB, 586x833, 586:833, 1565519.jpeg) (h) (u)

File (hide): f47ccab7e3b74da⋯.jpeg (335.73 KB, 900x1200, 3:4, 286023.jpeg) (h) (u)

>>299309

I particularly liked the Cadence FF 30,only because her dynamic there, is a little more different than her boring indifference during the episodes of the show.

And pic related has become somewhat relevant recently

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 07:55:33 58390b (2) No.299312

>>299311

It must be difficult to make Cadence any weaker than she is in the show. And yeah, Nightmarity is fucking hot. She rocks that shit way better than Luna ever did.

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 09:29:45 248831 (2) No.299314

>>299309

I haven't read the comic series in a while do they still make the friends forever micro series and is yayponies still got the latest one if so?

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 21:47:38 9fa992 (1) No.299325

File (hide): c9d85580228716e⋯.png (447.19 KB, 793x465, 793:465, serveimage_003.png) (h) (u)

>>299309

From all the fiendship is magic comics i liked the first one, it gave me feels, its a shame that the same writer shitted the bed when he got an opportunity to continue that story in the main comics.

▶Anonymous 10/31/17 (Tue) 23:24:53 f1a468 (1) No.299328

>>299301

There there anon, I removed them as not to derail the thread. Now just sit and relax with you Bearenstien Bears books and listen to some Leonard Bernstain…

/pone/ - My Little Pony★

General

WebM

Theme

User JS

Do not paste code here unless you absolutely trust the source or have read it yourself!

Favorites

Customize Formatting

Filters