[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / alto / builders / cyber / eerie / htg / resetera / strek / x ]

/christian/ - Christian Discussion and Fellowship

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
Email
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Flag
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.


Christchan is back up after maintenance! The flood errors should now be resolved. Thank you to everyone who submitted a bug report!

File: b3f3679111fbc0b⋯.jpg (6.6 MB, 4752x3168, 3:2, 00.jpg)

cca1f1 No.544193

Why do you ask that mass be in Latin?

If you were serious, very serious about this, you would ask a faithful to give you Mass in the language of angels, which is what Angels and the Trinity use to actually speak when they are in heaven.

f280f7 No.544194

Seems like greek or hebrew would make the most sense since that's the word of God was written in.


cca1f1 No.544197

File: 3e44b8db78f8732⋯.jpg (54.75 KB, 408x495, 136:165, 1427681092075.jpg)

>>544194

Nope, its still whatever is the heavenly language, whatever it may be.

Try to think of it for a minute,

He had to write his words in greek and hebrew since that's what people had at the time, so those languages are only by happenstance. If God has a language used in heaven, you'd speak that language when you were holding mass for him.


c50302 No.544200

It isn't so much the latin as it is the form of the Mass.

I'd totally be down for a Tridentine Mass that's translated to the vernacular, but that being the only change.


ab1b66 No.544201

>>544197

So English?


cca1f1 No.544203

>>544201

>They speak english in heaven guys

>That's what angels were taught

>Trust me

Good joke

The bible makes it abundantly clear that there is a language of angels and languages of man.


f280f7 No.544204

>>544197

Hebrew probably is God's language and what Adam and Eve spoke.

>>544201

also this


f280f7 No.544206

>>544203

Verse? And can you show me the verse saying it's latin.


cca1f1 No.544207

>>544206

Its softly implied in verses such as 1 Corinthians 13 which deliberately mention them being separate

1 Corinthians 13 : If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal


f280f7 No.544208

>>544207

So where does it say latin? And were you implying latin wasn't a language men came up eith and spoke?


cca1f1 No.544209

>>544208

Re-read my posts, I am implying Tridentine mass should not be Latin.


209655 No.544210

How about Jesus' original language : Aramaic.

One of the reasons why there are countless versions of the bible is because the original language was not preserved.

Centuries of being mistranslated and mistransliterated resulted in a lot of deviations and contradictions. And of course, there might be numerous who added their own personal or political agenda into the texts over the years.

>>544204

>Hebrew

Perhaps God is above language, no?

(USER WAS WARNED FOR DENYING SCRIPTURE IS PRESERVED)

80db89 No.544211

>>544209

well i agree in this day and age since catholic schools no longer teach latin accept for a few


cca1f1 No.544212

File: 859cc3ed00ee982⋯.jpg (91.55 KB, 571x800, 571:800, 859cc3ed00ee9825cc55bb8903….jpg)

>>544211

You realize that if my plan went through, only people with the gift of tongues would be able to understand mass, since nobody but those gifted with the power of tongues can speak it?


ab1b66 No.544213

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

de94c1 No.544214

>>544194

i gotchu fam

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=esmKkuLZI-I

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyAWQDqzggk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FnXcKYNOsAw

>>544200

Check out the Anglican Ordinariate masses. It's closer to the Tridentine mass in the vernacular than the OF.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_VkfON4DAh4

Alternatively, Western Rite Orthodoxy often is the EF in the vernacular.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trMWaBgOGQg


11af74 No.544267

>Why do you ask that mass be in Latin?

For Church is Roman. Not in sense that protestant use it though.

For Church is universal. And it should have universal language in its rites so no can boast about it. All great languages of liturgy, Latin, Old Greek, Hebrew, Churchslavonic etc etc are detached from now and ranscendent in sense.

For Christ sanctfied it by word of His mouth and by work of His Cross.

>If you were serious, very serious about this, you would ask a faithful to give you Mass in the language of angels, which is what Angels and the Trinity use to actually speak when they are in heaven.

Angels' language are pure thought for surprise, they have no tongues. Closest thing would be mass for deaf for sign language are more about concepts than about words. But it's impossible for to Mass to be there have to be Consecration and you cannot do it without words.

Second of all, God speaks in all languages that were and are and will be and never been. We could have mass in badger and it would be as Trinitarian as Latin or English or any other language.

Also, Mass is not for God, but from God for us. Litugry literally means "work for people"


17a6aa No.544272

>>544193

>Why do you ask that mass be in Latin?

because it's a dead language

/thread


fa405f No.544275

Latin is the language of God


80db89 No.544277


666e69 No.544287

File: c01ce0ef507c486⋯.jpg (14.64 KB, 240x240, 1:1, sE2FkYwv_400x400.jpg)

>>544275

LinGuA LAtInA EsT LiNgUa DEi


dd859c No.544334

>>544210

I'm all for Latin but this. I never understand why Aramaic/Syriac gets thrown under the bus yet was the language the gospels were first spoken and recorded.


49abca No.544347

>>544334

It wasn't sanctified by Cross.


ed9e54 No.544392

>>544275

*greek


50fbc4 No.544412

>>544193

>Because Latin was the language Western Christianity spoke.

>Because Latin is a dead language, therefore the meaning of its words doesn't change.

>Because Latin is a very precise language.

>Because it sounds really good.


7fc550 No.544414

>>544412

>Because Latin is a dead language, therefore the meaning of its words doesn't change.

that's actually a good argument


5f2a6b No.544462

>>544210

Mohammadens are so easy to spot. Regurgitating the same things over and over again. They truly are a "copy paste" nation.


2f709d No.544672

>>544210

>muslim says Bible not preserved

A sheep ate part of the Koran and it's lost forever now, you have no room to talk.


11ca89 No.544702

>>544462

>They truly are a "copy paste" nation.

<says the board that constantly spews "muh Romans 8" and "muh 1 Corinthians" over and over and over




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / alto / builders / cyber / eerie / htg / resetera / strek / x ]