0da764 No.536278
Don't switch the track. The train time table will be effected. That's no good. Also, if those people didn't want to be ran over by a train, they wouldn't be on the track.
710b89 No.536280
>>536277
We've had this thread many times and the answer never changes.
MULTITRACKDRIFTING
U
L
T
I
T
R
A
C
K
D
R
I
F
T
I
N
G
efb221 No.536281
7a8bad No.536284
The train isn't even moving you retard.
93dc70 No.536285
Yell out asking which are christians. Change accordingly to avoid killing the brethern.
Totally this >>536280 though if it's an option.
710b89 No.536301
>>536277
One has to wonder what sins these people may have committed to land themselves as "victims" in this scenario.
Should we do evil that good may come of it?
In the current world it seems like about 1/6 people are "good" (just going by catholic population). Thus the probability is that the 5 on the original track are unrepentant atheists, protestants or demon worshippers thus God is merely enacting his holy judgment upon them and lessen their damage to his creation. Who am I to thwart the God's intentions and murder potentially a "good" catholic man who can help the world. When it comes to salvation it is quality not quantity that matters. And I shall let he who is without sin pull the first lever
597e26 No.536324
>>536277
Hit the larger group with the train
Finish off the survivor
4a0c2f No.536326
>>536301
But bad things happen to good people all of the time. It’s awfully presumptuous to just assume so that they deserve it
c0e5dd No.536332
>>536301
>Judging entire population
How high is your equestrian, anon?
Also, the last part is a literal Pilate tier act.
ba7c01 No.536333
>>536326
It's also awfully presumptuous to assume that they don't deserve it, knowing the current state of the world
710b89 No.536345
>>536326
>bad things happen to good people meme
Bad things happen because of the shared sin of the entire human race for which we all share culpability. And often bad things happen to people most of the time because of sins they are committing and accumulating unwittingly
"My ma died of cancer. Why do bad things happen to good people" whilst ma was consuming carcinogens a bad diet and had an unhealthy lifestyle.
710b89 No.536347
>>536332
How is that Pilate tier? Pilate condemned an innocent man to death and said "lol not my fault". I would refuse to condemn a man to death.
No good can come from doing evil.
Would you shoot a man if you knew it would mean 5 men condemned to death would live?
d24081 No.536353
>>536277
It's funny.
But in all seriousness, the fewer deaths the better, though this may depend on who's on the track.
What if they are all terrorists for instance? Yeah, it really makes you think.
e954a1 No.536416
>actually trying to answer this
You shame me, famalams.
The correct answer is that the world is fallen and there's no right choice here. Whichever way you chose, you'll have something that haunts you and you'll have a good reason for doing so.
7a8bad No.536439
If the train is moving and I have my hand on the lever, am I complicit in murder if I let the train mow down those 5 people?
c92d33 No.536459
*running in the 90s starts playing*
5ead6f No.536486
6d7141 No.536821
Pull the lever. The one guy on the upper track has bad taste in shoes. He deserves to die.
425f0b No.536828
>>536285
>>536301
Isn't it better to purposefully kill the brethren and then convert the atheists that live? Brethren won't mind they're in heaven.
8c92bb No.536831
>>536486
OP just wanted trolley track memes.
e519ce No.536861
Nothing, let the Lord move the train>>536277
4651a4 No.536898
>>536828
Negative. The atheists are unrepentant (as evidenced by the fact that they are atheist at the moment if their death as no one has an excuse to not come to God as God makes himself known to all before death). The brethren could live to proselytise and convert many more as opposed to the atheists living in destructive sin.
d24081 No.536987
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>536828
More alive brethrens can convert even more atheists in the long run.
(also, atheists you saved probably wouldn't convert if they knew you'd throw them under the trolley when atheists need saving….)
710b89 No.537111
>>536862
Schrödinger's multitrackdrifting
422089 No.537120
>>536831
And this time there are some good ones, at least
c3304b No.537123
422089 No.537126
>>536416
>The correct answer is that the world is fallen and there's no right choice here. Whichever way you chose, you'll have something that haunts you and you'll have a good reason for doing so.
this guy gets it
7cadc0 No.537193
>>536277
Leave it be. To do anything would be to make yourself a murderer. Let God sort out His own.
You might kill (ah, see? you are now a murderer) less people by switching the track, but what if the majority were evil and the one on the other track was saintly? What says you are right to decide their fate?
359700 No.538332
Switch the lever half-way causing the train to do multi-track drifting; train subsequently tearing itself apart as it goes forward on ever-diverging rails until it inevitably stops due to it's own sturdy construction or falls apart completely due to poor assembly – thus, saving everyone and destroying the Meme Train Menace and binary system once and for all.
0cf479 No.538439
>>538332
>moral choices are too hard for me the post
50ab9b No.538777
Some one post christ chan webm
b9afa1 No.538977
>>537304
You didn't set up the scenario (presumably), your choice to get involved makes you responsible for the death. A (presumably) innocent person's blood will be on your hands.
<Conclusion: pulling the lever is murder.
2263f3 No.539009
6a889a No.539010
>>538779
God knows his own. Don't switch.
d24081 No.539017
274d40 No.539028
My philosophy is that decisive inaction is in fact an action. By having your hand on the lever while being fully aware that you have the power to save the lives of the five people that are about to be run over you are responsible for their lives. If you allow them to die you have committed murder. However if you pull the lever you have also committed murder, but have also just saved the lives of five. It is intrinsically better to be the saviour of five and murderer of one than to be the saviour of none and murderer of five.
9b21d6 No.539046
>>538977
>your choice to get involved makes you responsible for the death
272c3b No.539047
>>538977
>your choice to get involved makes you responsible for the death
<Oh look, that guy's getting mugged on the street, better stay out of it so I don't have to sin by punching the criminal
b9afa1 No.539078
>>539047
Get on my level, Anglo-consequentialist.
d8d319 No.539130
>>539028
Refusing the potential of doing good is not doing evil. There is a potential for a great amount of good and evil at any point in time, by doing nothing am I made to carry the burden of countless possible sins? I think the logical conclusion with your approach is antinatalism.
5ca60f No.539134
>>536277
don't interfere with god