Despite the constant lefty shit on JJJ, Tom Tilley isn't actually that bad. He does examine both sides, doesn't interject and try to shut anyone down, instead asks them questions to justify their thoughts and gives roughly 50/50 airtime to both sides of callers.
Hell, he gave 30 minutes to anti-abortion callers in an hour segment, which would be unheard of on any other major news program in this country.
If that guy LARPing as a Jew to prove a point was put on The Project, they'd be cheering him on from the audience and giving him all the airtime he wanted.