012b51 No.16314728
Why did Grand Theft Auto shift away from 4's tone in favor of GTA Online nonsense? If I wanted flying cars and orbital cannons I would play fucking Saints Row.
012b51 No.16314741
>>16314734
It was dreary and bleak. Not every Grand Theft Auto game has to be some wacky zany San Andreas game with copious use of the word "nigga" and fucking jetpacks.
96a1f3 No.16314747
>>16314734
It was pretty good. Needed more shit to actually do but the framework was there if Rockstar had gave a shit beyond making a bare bones next gen GTA to abandon. The DLC made some minor efforts toward that but ultimately were disappointing as well.
56529b No.16314752
GTA 4 had a lot of small things that made it a good game and GTA 5 had a lot of big things that made it a better game.
012b51 No.16314755
>>16314752
>GTA 5 had a lot of big things that made it a better game.
Such as?
>dumbed down driving and car damage model
>dumbed down melee combat
>enemies not as reactive to gunfire
>far less enterable interiors
56529b No.16314762
>>16314755
Superior missions, carplay and gunplay that was't shit, a less dreary feel overall. The fuck plays GTA for the melee combat?
012b51 No.16314769
>>16314762
>Superior missions
You complain so much about the drive A to B missions in 4, but 5 has plenty of those and the only thing it added were missions that were practically on rails and "cinematic".
>gunplay that was't shit
But the gunplay in 4 was better. Peds/cops reacted more to gunfire.
012b51 No.16314772
>>16314762
>The fuck plays GTA for the melee combat?
Not an excuse to axe features they could have easily carried over. I liked it.
96a1f3 No.16314779
>>16314752
Post-purchase cope right there. No one would legitimately believe such a thing. I'm glad I didn't play it so I never have to lie to myself like this.
012b51 No.16314784
>>16314782
>making it fun
>games needs zany, wacky, RANDEM antics to be considered fun
Go play Saints Row so you can have fun with you stupid dildo weapons.
96a1f3 No.16314787
>>16314782
I don't know what the fuck Get Shorty is, I just play video games lil guy. Calm down.
012b51 No.16314791
>>16314785
>4 was flat as supermarket cola
The base game and TLAD were kino. TBoGT was a small taste of what was to come in GTA 5, and it tastes like shit.
012b51 No.16314796
>>16314794
Imagine your fee fees being hurt this badly by words.
96a1f3 No.16314797
>>16314792
No I wanted a GTA game, I got one, it was okay. Calm down.
012b51 No.16314799
>>16314797
b-but how can it be a GTA game if it doesn't have jetpacks, totally epic ufo easter eggs and the military at five stars??!
96a1f3 No.16314805
>>16314799
It's like they aren't old enough to remember the relatively basic gritty plot, gameplay and setting of 3.
>>16314802
Are you always this much of an impotent flailing spastic?
1985d3 No.16314822
>>16314741
GTA IV received a lot of flak for being 'too serious' and not being like San Andreas. That backslash forced Rockstar to make V more similar to SA in tone. IV wasn't that well received which is a shame because I really like its more grounded approach to storytelling.
56529b No.16314842
>>16314779
I got GTA 5 as a gift, m8
917b1f No.16314847
>>16314842
>>16314845
<I got HIV/AIDS as a gift and took it proudly
<At least I can regift it!
96a1f3 No.16314877
>>16314843
Project some more, little man.
96a1f3 No.16314916
>>16314897
Highly unlikely, but I'd switch tactics and call him a lanklet. I'm way ahead of you fuckers.
96a1f3 No.16314932
>>16314925
What if God were one of us? He is. I'm him.
f87d09 No.16314935
GTA IV and V are both shit. They, and RDR2, feel like they've been written by some fat, alcoholic cuck going through midlife crisis and being sad he can't get up his dick anymore.
They're the textbook definition of soy-fueled centrist nihilism and cuckery.
63d6ad No.16314953
>>16314728
It's likely because of Saints Row. Around the time of GTAIV's release, Saint's Row II was released, and it marketed itself as a wacky and zany alternative to GTAIV's bleak atmosphere. Needless to say, Saint's Row was a huge success, and Cockstar took notice. Not only that, but Cockstar has always tried to thrive on manufactured controversy surrounding their games, and they likely realized that, with the coming of age of the meme generation, they could get even more shekels by trying to appeal to their kind of humor. This kills two birds with one stone, because they're dealing with what they believe to be their main competition and appealing to a huge demographic in the process.
2d59c2 No.16314963
>>16314953
To me that doesn't make much sense considering how successful IV was, more so than Saints Row 2. I just think shortly after IV the talent that was left in Rockstar left.
24493e No.16314973
>>16314728
Just don't play online.
96a1f3 No.16314977
>>16314941
What if me god, me lanklet ? ? ? ?
17a273 No.16315474
6b9f24 No.16315647
Money money money.
>>16314822
Too bad GTA V hit a shitty spot where it neither has the level of detail of IV nor the fun factor of SA. Like, driving in SA was unrealistic but fun, in GTA V it just feels like nothing, all cars handle the same.
>>16314784
The dildo in SA was funny because it was a hidden weapon in places like police showers and it was well, a dildo. The shit in SR3 was unfunny because they made a huge deal out of LMAO LOOK HOW HILARIOUS IT IS A GIANT DILDO BAT WITH JIGGLE PHYSICS.
35763c No.16315671
>GTAIV online
>entire server fucking around in the airport having fun
>GTAV
>get penalised for blowing up someone elses car, fags take it too seriously
dfd5b1 No.16315684
>>16314762
<superior missions
>towing a fucking car
>yoga
>lifting cargo
>dude weed lmao
>lackluster heists
Most of the acceptable missions are a direct rip off from San Andreas, the only one that isn't is the one where SWAT swarms Michael's house. One genuinely fun mission in the entire "game".
>carplay
Every car feels the same.
>and gunplay that wasn't shit
Shitter than in Max Payne 3 or Red Dead Redemption, same with the gore and ragdoll effects. The guns selection is awful too, and what's with locking away the desert eagle behind a pre order bonus but selling Max Paynes 3's collectors edition guns as DLC later on? Greedy cockstar bullshit without any consistency.
d407b1 No.16316060
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>16314728
Probably current-year effect but they lost more than their tone, the whole system has degraded significantly.
68f4dd No.16316443
>>16314728
I really hated how you couldn't have fist fights with the npcs in gta 5
0aea2a No.16316536
Too many people criticized GTA 4 on release for being to serious and praised Saints Row 3 for being "wacky" and "fun". Saints Row 3 was a mistake, Saints Row 2 was better because it was as grounded GTA SA/VC/3. GTA 4 was a fine follow up, where it's still kind of goofy but the goofiness works because its serious. Same with its satire. When everything is goofy nothing is. When everything is satire nothing is.
dfd5b1 No.16316606
>>16316554
>crowbcats video shows cop behavior, a better hand to hand combat system, crash physics, climbing mechanics (shimming), ped reaction to damage, all core elements of the game
>this vid shows some gay little details that no one cares about like swimming or cutting leaves with helicopter blades
you sure showed him
7dcee4 No.16316611
SA > IV > VC > III > V
my taste
a57cc0 No.16316628
>>16314935
>They, and RDR2, feel like they've been written by some fat, alcoholic cuck going through midlife crisis and being sad he can't get up his dick anymore.
Yeah, the Hauser Brothers.
838c2a No.16316732
>>16316554
All of this shit is really irrelevant when main mechanics suck ass compared to 4. Downgraded gunplay is the biggest crime kikestar commuted when they developed 5, with cops blatantly cheating coming after that. Good gunplay makes 4 one of the best games and I wish we had more dedicated developers who put some efforts into making proper gunplay in shooters. I will never get tired from killing everything with a pistol in 4.
6b9f24 No.16316738
>>16316732
Everything regarding physics in IV is fun. I had a great time pushing people around and throwing them off a certain ridge (near one Burger Shot), it felt so satisfying. The physics in V got a downgrade (deliberate, since it's the same engine) and everyone fucking dies instantly.
07374f No.16316789
>>16314728
GTA 4 is the worst GTA game
f39c83 No.16317667
>>16316789
That dildo is sitting extra-tight in your ass, yes?
35763c No.16317701
>>16316536
i dont get why people shit on GTAIV for being serious when every GTA game is serious, except for V, trevor is reddit personified, just like electro swing
aa9268 No.16317737
GTA IV sold well and got good reviews, but there were also a lot of people not happy with it. Some of its shortcomings may have been also due to engine limitations. I liked IV a lot but can see why people didn't like it. Perhaps they were trying to do some 2deep4u social commentary about modern crime or they originally intended for IV to be much more like a sim.
c29461 No.16317743
Because GTA Online made and still makes an absurd, retarded amount of money off of Shark card addicts.
657804 No.16317744
>>16316789
This, GTA4 is horrendous.
090649 No.16317797
>>16316606
>cherry picking is okay when its details I think are important
Aside from hand to hand, those are all gay details as well. The physics in IV sucked ass, everything felt like it had a gun safe strapped to it.
000000 No.16317933
>>16314728
Money and normalfags.
012b51 No.16324719
You DO use the Claude outfit, right?
012b51 No.16325968
I don't remember the blood spray looking this shitty.
3ee053 No.16325983
>>16325968
I don't either, not on PS3 anyway
c4fd75 No.16325995
>>16314728
>2008 era /v/
>"Why did Grand Theft Auto shift away from San Andreas's wacky fun? If I wanted dreary depressive bullshit I'd go outside"
3ba90c No.16326014
>>16325995
This was basically the consensus leading up to V. I guess we didn't realize how good we had it.
bf6da8 No.16327441
GTA 2 was the one that nailed tone and style.
The feel of the OP video was done far better in The Warriors.
f5e0f3 No.16327589
>>16316536
same I enjoyed saints row 1 and 2 and after that didn't like the rest of them also everything post gta4 is cuckstar and GTA5 is an overall downgrade in every imaginable manner compared to it's predecessor.
GTA5
>worse driving
>worse shooting
>worse physics
>smaller city
>gigantic outback of forests with nothing in them
>shit motorcycle and motorcycle physics
>Shittier and easier shooting mechanics
>Rewards are locked behind ingame paywalls HAHAHAHAHAH
f5e0f3 No.16327593
>>16325968
Those effects are better than the non effects in GTA5
You hear that booming gunfire? The fucking bass. The cracks? It actually sounds like a gun going off as opposed to 5 where every gun just shoots like an airsoft toy.
78b8ce No.16327802
>>16325995
Some people just turned 18.
dfd5b1 No.16327839
>>16317797
core mechanics of the game aren't details retard, it's the entire game, it's what you're playing, the game play
dfd5b1 No.16327856
>>16327839
to add to that, cops behaving differently isn't a detail, cops were a core element of all GTA games and yet they made them obnoxiously unfun in five, why did they regress with movement, the climbing? shouldn't they be adding more stuff to it?
d8cdfd No.16333820
>>16314728
>you've lived long enough to see /v/ decide it likes GTA IV now that V is popular
So what 2023 when GTA VI comes out we all like V?
333e1f No.16333840
>>16325995
The lighthearted style of comedy in San Andreas is different than the ironic post-modernism bullshit of GTAV
333e1f No.16333844
>>16333820
This happens with every Zelda game so I'm not surprised.
37b132 No.16333878
>>16315465
>rocket bikes
I thought you'd be kidding here until i checked it out, the online game seems to be literally the griefers wet dream even more so than APB ever was.
d8cdfd No.16333920
>>16333844
Zelda hasn't been good since it was 2D.
069760 No.16333924
>>16314822
>GTA IV received a lot of flak for being 'too serious'
It looked like shit, had a shitty soundtrack, had shitty driving and shitty physics. I hated the story but that's mainly because I hated the characters. The entire thing wasn't "too serious", it was that it was just nonstop from start to finish dreary, grey and brown garbage. I've heard people say that that was on purpose to "highlight the state of the organized crime world to immigrants" and other such and maybe it's true, I don't know or care. I do know that it made for a boring game that had virtually zero standout properties. The Euphoria engine was neat if buggy and that's the only thing I can really remember enjoying
6747d4 No.16333967
>>16316789
Pretty much, good thing it turned me off from the series entirely. Rockstar of david went to shit anyway
350bd2 No.16334068
GTA online isnt canon you retard
0439ff No.16334072
>>16333924
>shitty physics
you shut your whore mouth
9209c4 No.16334246
>>16314728
>"When did the series go from being like the last game in the series to being like the newest game in the series?"
Are you retarded?
7cb9cf No.16334254
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>16333840
It really wasn't that's just nostalgia. Grand Theft Auto has always been post modern and has always had a slight liberal slant. GTA San Andreas only benefited from being set in 1992 so things like the LA Riots and Rampart Scandal which were huge news pieces back in the 90s were just seen as novelties by 2004 and most people today have no idea they even happened. We only really see them as jokes in movies. In 20 years most of GTA 5's politics will just be see as comedic.
588523 No.16334262
>>16334254
>>16333840
Also GTA 5 is just shit compared to its predecessors. Even 4 probably had a more notable liberal leaning, but it was far more entertaining.
c9eaf1 No.16344078
I want another GTA like Vice City, one based around a movie parody. Shit, even a GTA set in China parodying Kung Pow and Jackie Chan Movies or something would be funny.
297276 No.16344116
GTA5 is literally the zoomer GTA. It's over.
896592 No.16344158
>>16344078
>Shit, even a GTA set in China parodying Kung Pow and Jackie Chan Movies or something would be funny.
Go play Sleeping Dogs not the definite edition just go pirate the original
35763c No.16344247
>>16344166
>hard work
Yeah real hard making the most boring city ever with less depth and life to it than a game from 2004.
If only they made LS as similar to what its like IRL, methzombies, gay AIDS ridden sex pool parties, numales and jews everywhere
1eb5ce No.16344275
43055a No.16346398
Chinatown Wars is the best GTA.
Change my mind.
a5ae3f No.16346413
GTAIV decided the best way to tell a serious story, was to remove features people liked like aircraft, because "too silly". Yeah, nah. Fuck that pretentious game.
7913f2 No.16346477
>>16314755
Far FEWER interiors.
24a4ae No.16351599
>>16314728
So in terms of storyline, gameplay and meta is GTA5 bad or not bad?
012b51 No.16351614
>>16346413
>was to remove features people liked like aircraft, because "too silly"
What would have been the point of flying a big jet around a map as small as Liberty City? You could still fly helicopters.
80fb74 No.16351616
>>16351599
>Story
Trash
>Gameplay
It gets old after awhile like every single Rockstar open world but its a lot better than IVs and whoever says otherwise is just lying to themselves
012b51 No.16351621
>>16351616
>shoot someone in the foot
>they immediately bleed out and clutch their abdomen like that's where they were shot
>everyone is knocked out with one counter and punch
>"it's a lot better than IV's"
80fb74 No.16351627
>>16351621
>IV
>No planes
>No offroading
>no vehicle customization
>You cant rob convenience stores
>Better gameplay
>implying
<"B-but the AI acts marginally different!"
naw
6b4251 No.16351684
The one thing that made me pissed about GTA IV was the lack of purpose in getting money. Once you got a few suits and bought decent guns from the alleyshops there was no purpose in doing any missions. The story revolves around how you're poor and need money to live the high life but the only things you can buy are 100$ resprays, 1$ hotdogs/sammiches, and 2000$ suits.
And then in GTA V you finally get to buy some businesses but get ZERO access to the interiors even though one literally had a scripted interior you used in a random event. The lack of purchasing houses unless you're doing the gay GTA online bs. Whoever comes up with Rockstars game economy is retarded.
80fb74 No.16351696
>>16351684
>The lack of purchasing houses unless you're doing the gay GTA online bs.
That's the biggest thing I miss from GTA SA and IV lacked it too. Whoever thought it was a good idea to get rid of houses needs to go fuck themselves. I don't want to have to chose between Trevors trash trailer, Franks Beverly Hills Mansion or Micheal and his annoying ass family. I want to buy a normal fucking house for my character. That shit does piss me off.
24a4ae No.16351731
>>16351627
>story is trash
>mediocre gameplay
Naturally, going by how they write stories they suck at it, and putting libshit, 'muh realism', and ugly ass character designs on their game doesn't make it any better, not to mention not being able to purchase houses, I get that it's 'for muh plot' and all, however that doesn't excuse them from not implementing it, damn shame really.
80fb74 No.16351738
>>16351731
Most Rockstar games have shit story and mediocre gameplay. V is still better than IV though.
215f08 No.16351744
f0f80a No.16351749
>>16333967
> Rockstar of david went to shit anyway
You think GTA 5 was bad? RDR 2 was packed to the brim with angry leftist passive aggressiveness. I waited until it was 20 dollars and grabbed it for the gameplay but my god. Every Native is a saint, every black is a saint, every other women is strong and empowered. All the southerners and people who fought for the south in the civil war are imbred rednecks to be killed and in a mission you literally do burn ones house to the ground
80fb74 No.16351769
>>16351749
Also
>Read Dead Redemption 2
Just want an excuse to post this file with this filename
5b10c5 No.16351795
>>16314755
>>16314762
>>16314769
>>16314779
>>16314842
GTA V sp was an excuse for the online component. Remember SA?
>See a dam.
>Know there will be a mission featuring it.
And GTA V:
>See a prison.
>Assume you'll go there eventually
<Never fucking happens.
Shit game.
24a4ae No.16351816
>>16351795
Sounds to me Rockstar is in need of some major overhaul, including the upper management.
215f08 No.16351823
5b10c5 No.16351829
>>16351816
Not gonna happen since microtransaction profits are actually through the roof.
012b51 No.16351832
>>16351749
>can't even name your horse "Hoarse" because it contains the word "arse"
Jesus Christ, this is a whole new level of nanny state fuckery.
012b51 No.16351835
>>16351627
Why would Niko want to rice out cars? Go play Saint's Row.
dad696 No.16351937
>>16351829
>since microtransaction profits are actually through the roof.
Is Rockstar games' well off in this current year or not?
3eaf0e No.16352011
>>16314728
yeah, well that's what's good about online. people WANT Saints Row online, people WANT Just Cause online.
I hope the next GTA game is dedicated online, because single player is garbage in comparison. no I don't care about video game story lines anymore.
e9c35c No.16352022
>>16314755
>>dumbed down driving and car damage model
I will never forgive Cuckstar for this.
There were already six million mods fixing the issues of GTA IV's somewhat boaty albeit still enjoyable driving model, yet (((they))) had to turn GTA V into some kind of lobotomized Mario kart clone where Patriots can ram other cars out of the way at high speeds without losing any grip but hitting a small rock at 40km/h makes them flip over.
24a4ae No.16352036
>>16352022
>mods
Are there mods for GTA5 that 'mostly' fixes said issues apart from the storyline because that would take a long time to unfuck even with the necessary resources (which also includes non-shit VAs).
e9c35c No.16352046
>>16351627
>no procedurally generated 500x500km map
>no Facebook integration
>no MMO multiplayer component
>no smartphone companion app
>no Instagram integration
>no microtransactions to support children in afrochina
>no real-life marketing tie ins
>no crafting system
>no spotify radio integration
>no Islamic integration
>have to play the game before watching a cutscene
>no support for women's rights
At least it had GFWL.
>>16352036
There are/were a bunch of driving physics mods but they're probably all dead thanks to Rockstar's love of breaking mod compatibility with every GTAO update.
5b10c5 No.16352423
>>16351937
I don't know but GTAV gave them billions. They're not going to revert back to single-player even if new games fail.