4c1a23 No.16177458
Any good FPS games where you beat the shit out of everything with your fists? I tried condemned and it was kind of medicore. Felt like the combat never really evolved. Mirror's Edge is more of a platformer so I guess the only other one I know of is Dying Light.
273edb No.16177474
Zeno Clash 1/2 and Dark Messiah
771c85 No.16177482
Breakdown on Xbox. Expect to get your ass beat.
75b494 No.16177499
What about beating the shit out of everything with your foot? If that's fine with you, Dark Messiah.
6d940a No.16177503
d0b84b No.16177507
I really wish Kingdom Come had a better unarmed system instead of using your fists solely for bar fights. I know it wanted realism, but it's always fun going kenshiro on armed enemies.
01ea0d No.16177529
>>16177458
Yakuza. Nioh also has some meme builds that can make hand to hand viable.
>>16177488
I don't care if you're being ironic or not, fuck you. I've even tried to make barehanded viable and fun in skyrim and it's even harder than making the sex mods work right. It's fucking garbage and I hate you for even reminding me of it.
06c42e No.16177535
01ea0d No.16177537
>>16177529
oh wait nevermind OP said FPS.
273edb No.16177548
Almost forgot
Crysis, at least the first 75℅ of the game
273edb No.16177551
fd0512 No.16177632
>first-person punches
>good
You can't even tell the distance of your throws without 3rd person or VR.
9c43ad No.16177657
>>16177632
You must be part of the genetically inferior race of humans that can't first-person platform.
273edb No.16177668
fd0512 No.16177687
>>16177657
You need depth perception via two points of view or alternate point of view to be able to tell distance properly. Imagine Exanima in first person, it would be twice harder than it already is. The best plain first person can do is that cuhrayzee one-punch man gameplay in DOOM webm above.
79ad45 No.16177704
>>16177458
Resident Evil 7.
In the End of Zoe dlc, it's ALL about punching monsters to death. No guns because those are for pussies. Only your cold hard fists.
08b150 No.16177708
91eba7 No.16177710
>>16177521
Dying Light's okay, aside from the crafting shit and fucking AWFUL final boss it's a solid 6/10 game.
Wish they focused more on the verticality aspect of the parkour system.
3b1628 No.16177712
>>16177668
he certainly types like he has a thick chinese accent
see
>>16177687
>it would be twice harder
>>16177458
fallout games
elder scrolls games except skyrim
273edb No.16177718
>>16177687
>Imagine Exanima in first person
It's called Tresspasser
d0b84b No.16177726
I remember a game where you played as a knight that punched shit in an old school dungeon crawler setting. Anyone know what I'm talking about?
91eba7 No.16177727
>>16177712
>3D fallout games
>Good
God no, the melee combat especially in Bethesda's games is fucking terrible.
fd0512 No.16177729
>>16177718
That's not even a melee combat game, how is it related to the topic?
26928e No.16177736
Would God Hand work if it was in first person?
9c43ad No.16177751
>>16177710
>a solid 6/10 game.
>>16177727
All the combat is terrible.
>>16177687
Grenades and grenade launchers in first-person require a judgement of depth that people have coped with, melee is hardly so different.
fd0512 No.16177780
>>16177751
>Grenades and grenade launchers in first-person require a judgement of depth that people have coped with
True.
>melee is hardly so different
Wrong, you need your punch to be delivered at exactly the right momentum and at exactly the right range… unless combat is so shit it doesn't account for any of that. Throwing grenades only requires getting used to the default projectile arc in the game.
d0b84b No.16177810
Since we're on the topic of melee, what game does it right? The only game that I can think of that has a pretty realistic fighting system is Soul Calibur. You had the ability to duck oncoming blows as well as angle in, counter, and parry.
273edb No.16177812
>>16177780
>you need your punch to be delivered at exactly the right momentum and at exactly the right range… unless combat is so shit it doesn't account for any of that.
It's called Mount&Blade, how ignorant are you?
273edb No.16177819
>>16177810
>The only game that I can think of that has a pretty realistic fighting system is Soul Calibur.
fd0512 No.16177822
>>16177812
That game doesn't track collision force, also it's shit. It literally fires invisible beams to detect a hit. Like all weapons in Fallout 3 are just projectile spells.
b408e7 No.16177825
>>16177810
Unironically For Honor.
fd0512 No.16177834
>>16177825
It's not too bad, but it's third person.
273edb No.16177849
>>16177822
>It doesn't track collision force
It literally calculates it based on your momentum you dumb fucker
Not only that but you also moved the goalposts.
If you lack 3D perception that's your own uneducated impaired brains fault.
>>16177825
>>16177834
For Honor is a shit game with shit combat
Get fucking bent Ubishitter shills
fd0512 No.16177877
>>16177849
You're trying too hard.
>literally calculates
It literally doesn't. It just has different damage numbers for different weapon frames. If opponent was moving away from you at full speed and your weapon happened to touch him from behind it would still deal full damage just because it touched him even though there was no force delivered.
05f0ad No.16177910
Fight Knight when it's out and Xeno Clash.
87ab22 No.16177915
The Riddick and Condemned games.
If weapons are okay too, that expands to Maken X, Mount & Blade, Kingdom Come, Chivalry, Red Steel, and Pirates vs. Knights.
>>16177474
This
>>16177482
And this
d51bd0 No.16177926
FIGHT KNIGHT definitely counts.
You can also do the same in the early game of dead island when the zombies arent that tough.
d0b84b No.16177943
>>16177926
>You can also do the same in the early game of dead island when the zombies arent that tough
I can't stand when this happens. Here you are enjoying a certain play style, when suddenly they way you play is either grossly outclassed or phased out completely.
2a7123 No.16177947
>>16177810
Movie Battles II. Sabre vs sabre combat pacing is actually pretty fucking close to IRL swordfighting, minus some of the cheesy bullshit you can do (like insta-counters with some styles).
d51bd0 No.16177959
>>16177943
And thats one of the reasons why Dead Island is a shit game.
273edb No.16177966
>>16177877
>If opponent was moving away from you at full speed and your weapon happened to touch him from behind it would still deal full damage
Wrong, it's momentum based and walking into someones sword is instadeath or very close to it while doing something like you stated is around half to a quarter of your healthbar gone, you're a retard that has never played the game.
273edb No.16177980
>>16177959
But muh realism in muh janky zombie game.
Dead Island was such a shitshow, and yet normalniggers bought it in droves for their 7th Gen bricks.
87ab22 No.16177982
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>16177947
DF/JK lightsaber fencing really isn't designed to work in 1st-person. At that point, you might as well start rec'ing stuff like Rune & DBtS. Or, for punchers, Oni & Overgrowth.
273edb No.16177996
>>16177982
There's also Severance: Blade of Darkness
fd0512 No.16178036
>>16177966
Looks like that's indeed the case since the second game. Well, thanks for proving my point anyway. It's a third person game.
fd0512 No.16178049
Oh, and, I confused Mount&Blade with Chivalry when I spoke about invisible beams to track collision. Probably because Chivalry is an actual first person game relevant to the discussion and Mount&Blade isn't.
273edb No.16178058
>>16178036
>>16178049
>Since the second
It's always been the case and there's only one game, Warband is a glorified Expansion Pack/Definitive Edition made with Paradoxes money instead of self funding until the last stretch of development like the original.
The game features a First Person View mod and the melee works well with it.
You literally don't know shit, stop fucking posting and talking out of your ass because said ass is going to get handed to you.
You haven't even played the game you shit for brains retard.
273edb No.16178068
>>16178058
>mod
*Mode
It was already in the full release of the game, just specifying that so that you don't come out with your pretentious babble on how a fanmade mod somehow doesn't count.
fd0512 No.16178071
>>16178058
>You literally don't know shit
>still hasn't posted a single goo first person melee combat game with functioning physics to prove me wrong
273edb No.16178105
>>16178071
Your original point was that one can't make good first person combat and you got proven wrong only to spiral down into a wave of schizo tier denial and mental gymnastics
Eat shit and die faggot
>>16177632
fd0512 No.16178108
>>16178105
>got proven wrong
Where?
273edb No.16178134
>>16178108
>>16178071
>>16178105
>>16178058
>>16178036
>>16177966
>>16177877
>>16177849
>>16177822
>>16177812
>>16177780
Right here
Stay buttblasted that some rando proved you wrong on an anonymous mongolian basket weaving forum, this was fun but I'm off.
fd0512 No.16178154
>>16178134
>buttblasted
>so mad he references every post
What did you prove, you peanut brain? Mount&Blade isn't first person.
05f0ad No.16178167
What about Shadow Warrior? The most satisfying weapon of the game was Lo Wang's fists.
87ab22 No.16178176
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>16177996
Yes, that was #7 in the video I linked.
bebbb3 No.16178677
>>16177915
riddick is great. haven't played the expanded game (dlc or whatever) but the combat and stealth are top notch.
OP you would like the prison fight club in riddick
d4911f No.16179177
>>16177458
Zeno Clash is pretty great, Gahoole.
ed96df No.16179315
>>16177474
>>16179177
Whenever I think of that game, I'm always reminded about the man chicken things with teeth, I don't know why I find them so disturbing… and I've watched a lot of things I'm not proud of but that image is fucking carved in my brain. Maybe a chicken man fucked me in a previous lifetime?
28b47f No.16180043
>>16177458
Fuck first person. The government should make a game of killing e-celebrities in real life.
2337c6 No.16195193
>>16177458
Though it's pretty forgettable.
4e7e54 No.16205827
>>16177698
Mystical Ninja Goemon on N64 was the shit.
228590 No.16205870
Invidious embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>16177726
>I remember a game where you played as a knight that punched shit in an old school dungeon crawler setting. Anyone know what I'm talking about?
Fight Knight. The art style and presentation make me think it's reddit meme trash, but the enemy interactions in the trailer look cool so maybe it'll be nice.
>>16177877
>different damage numbers for different weapon frames
Unlike your favourite game, Jedi Outcast, which has momentum, which makes it the best, because it has momentum and no other melee games have momentum, except for Jedi Outcast, because it has momentum in the movement physics of each frame and no other melee games have momentum or movement physics in frames.
>>16178154
It has first person and third person options.
Your next post will be: "if the game has both things, then it has neither thing.
887f78 No.16205901
>>16195193
Yeah it's pretty shit.
>>16205870
fight knight could be fun and silly but I'm really leaning towards what you said, reddit meme trash. I'm not confident but I'll be happy to be surprised.
6a0c62 No.16206028
>>16205870
I get bad vibes from that trailer. Like I'm looking at something degenerate.
fa18b7 No.16206031
>>16205870
It's got that Unity floatiness so I know for certain I'd only be able to play it for 3 hours before having to shut it down and restart it. I'd really want to like it but I'm not getting my hopes up.
a421d3 No.16208009
nobody gonna post a serious reply huh?
619577 No.16208036
>>16208009
Just before Beltanzippers was a real meme. I miss it.