I'm fairly new to the anime game, but I've enjoyed it thus far. I've only completed 4 series though.
My first anime was Madoka Magica which I went in to see what exactly these here "anime's" are all about. Wound up loving it which surprised me. Mami and Madoka are both my waifus. The rest of the cast was great as well. Wonderful OST, wonderful visuals here and there with the witches labyrinths. Cool fight scenes, lots of drama. All in all, enjoyable stuff.
And thus began my journey into the horrid land of japanes animation.
Second up was Jewelpets Tinkle witch I picked up solely for the cuteness factor of tiny plush animals dancing on the screen for 20 minuets. Had some decent character moments here and there and for what it was, was fairly enjoyable. About 50 episodes in it actually started to take itself seriously and I couldn't get into it at that point so then I dropped it.
Third was Kaiba which was ok. It started off great. Had a cool world, a very intriguing premise, lots of great character moments and locations. Felt like a sort of cosmic anthology series with each episode focusing on a different world. But then it started to really begin focusing on its main cast about half way in and I just couldn't invest myself into it as much. It just felt jarring to change focus like that. The lead was great for the set up of having to have new places explained to him, but to actually rely on him and his interactions with others to be engaging? Just didn't do it for me.
Fith was Baccano! which was great. Issac is my husbando. Jacuzzi was great as well. I can't remember any of the other character's names, but I remember them all being great regardless.
And now I'm about 20 episodes through Azumanga Daioh which I was referred to as a classic. And I pretty much adore this one as well. I love the relationships all the characters have amongst each other, I love the themes it presents, it has wonderful comedic timing and generally keeps me laughing throughout. Osaka is my waifu and may be the most relatible protagonist I've ever encountered in any media. So yeah. Good stuff.
and that's my list. hope you all enjoyed my [spoilers]personal blog[/spoilers]