49f9fe No.16612761
>>16612752
>Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts
No.
44e784 No.16612765
It looks like a pretty good entry level list for pre-2007 game, but even then there are some odd omissions. Like why leave out RE3? It's at least as good as Code Veronica.
cbf512 No.16612772
>should /v/e make our own?
fuck no, because every single time someone has tried to do this - and without exaggerating we're probably talking at least thirty times - it ends up being stillborn because everybody just blasts shitty entries, people remove them because opinions, original poster puts them back, the guy responsible for the whole mess checks out after two weeks because it's too much work, and the website/wiki/list falls apart and never gets referenced again
22e7cf No.16612778
>>16612752
>no EYE Divine Cybermancy
Plebs who read this book are going to be stuck in their cycles of guilt forever
0d4412 No.16612791
>Bioshock infinite
>A mobile game
>F.E.A.R 2
>Braid
<No Red Alert 2
<No SMT games outside of persona
<No VTM:Bloodlines
Like everyone other list that tries to give a "definitive video game canon" it missed a bunch of essential titles and puts in a bunch of questionable shit. Hell even the /v/ list is garbage with how it lists MGS3 as a fucking third person shooter and how the inclusion of some titles is extremely questionable.
44e784 No.16612806
>Star Control 3 but no Star Control 1 or 2
What the fuck?
04bb04 No.16612817
>fallout 1 but not 2
>fallout 3
>MGS 4 and Portable ops but no Ghost Babel or Revengeance
>Heavy Rain
>Bioshock Infinite
Man this just makes me tired
6d5c6f No.16612837
I remember leafing through that in a bookstore once, it had a lot of shit.
8385d8 No.16612838
>>16612806
>Edge magazine editor
>peter molyneux
41059b No.16612849
>>16612752
>should /v/e make our own?
No, because every time someone tries to, they just give up because it's too much work. The closest thing /v/ has is the /v/ recommended games wiki, which was stormed by redditors and has little to nothing to do with /v/ anymore. Just make do with the charts we currently have. I'll dump some.
42acbb No.16612874
>>16612752
>DJ Hero
I had fun playing it, but seriously? Guitar Hero or Rockband is probably more important.
>No Mega Man
>No Kirby
41059b No.16612877
That's all I'm posting. Have fun, /v/irgins.
51f8cc No.16612879
>>16612752
>Acecombat 6
<not 4,5 or 0
ca3a73 No.16612880
They really padded that list, didn't they?
000000 No.16612881
>>16612849
You know you can just check older versions of each page so you can avoid all of reddit's input, right?
3127c0 No.16612882
>Journey
>Dark Souls
>Shadow of the Colossus
I'm surprised they don't have Gone Homo.
41059b No.16612884
>>16612880
>all that jarpig garbage
Doesn't surprise me that Peter Molyneux had a part in this book.
7bd7f1 No.16612885
>>16612752
>has morrowind and not oblivion or skyrim
I'd say the list has some merit.
16153d No.16612886
>>16612882
>I'm surprised they don't have Gone Homo.
The list was last updated in 20-
>Gone Home was 6 years ago
41059b No.16612888
>>16612881
Yeah, but this board really didn't need a wiki in the first place. The charts were fine and did a good job at filtering the trash from the good shit.
e7bc72 No.16612890
>>16612772
I mean just use the /v/ guide for each type of console. That will get you a decent amount. My only take is that this list didn't have Golden Sun: Lost age. ???
218ba9 No.16612901
He who controls the money, controls gaming history.
A loser with a few thousand bucks, to keep the website running indefinitely for the next 30 ~40 years could completely shape the history of gaming to their whim. Granted that casuals and kotaku/polygon faggots don't fag it up by threatening to call you a misogonerd rapist for not including their favorite walking sims.
ca3a73 No.16612907
> Four Mario Kart games, but not Double Dash
> Feature Pokemon, but only Gen 3 and Gen 4
> Rock Band 1 and 2, but not 3, the objectively best entry that allowed you to play with real instruments
> Only 3 Sonic games, including Sonic Adventure 1, but leaving out the magnum opus of the series, Sonic 3 & Knuckles
> Including Yoshi Touch and Go, a bare-bones tech demo
There's a shit load wrong here.
192fe2 No.16613052
Yes and no. Lists like these are good for the person just starting into vidya to jump right in. But when you got over 500 games to somehow fill a list, you'll inevitably start choosing shit just to fill. Also the quality will naturally go down when you already chosen the "best" 100 games ago.
f5e9a4 No.16613094
>no Warioland games
Complete trash.
86200b No.16613099
>>16612752
>Is this a good list?
No
>Should /v/e make our own?
No.
Every single chart/list that tries to even categorize best Worthwhile games by platform is always packed with shit or outright erroneous information. Charts only work as primers for specific franchises or doing shit like modding games or hardware. See also this: >>16612772
>v/e
Fuck off >>>/cuckchan/
What would you put on it?
I would throw this and every single GREATEST GAMES OF ALL TIME LIST in the trash where it belongs.
>>16612791
That the list even has the term subjective in its title as a back handed defense to knowing it's a worthless chart cobbled together by autists who want to have some stamp on the board's taste is proof of its uselessness.
>>16612849
>The closest thing /v/ has is the /v/ recommended games wiki, which was stormed by redditors and has little to nothing to do with /v/ anymore
<posts charts filled with shit games and shit ports
You're one to talk nigger. That you posted the cuckchan wii chart with Other M is proof you don't actually look at these other than to post them.
16153d No.16613131
>>16613099
>make a pun
>HOW DARE YOU, GO BACK TO CUCKCHAN
17f508 No.16613139
>>16612907
>Feature Pokemon, but only Gen 3 and Gen 4
And not even HG / SS I assume?
>>16612752
>Should /v/e make our own? What would you put on it?
Limit the entries to 100 games for one, to lessen the chance of crap getting in.
2e57b8 No.16613200
>>16612752
>published in October 2010
>Mollyjew and some fag from Edge™
>wikipedia page
>Skyrim makes the cut
<Mountain Blade doesn't
ba4c95 No.16613313
>Morrowind instead of Gothic
confirmed trash list
e9ff1d No.16613371
>>16612817
>Man this just makes me tired
It's all so tiresome.
8a474c No.16613386
>>16612752
>no StarTropics
>Star Control 3 but not 2
>Ultima 1 and 7, but not 4, 5, or 6
>only the first two Professor Layton games. no Unwound Future
>APB
>Ace Combat 6 but not 4, 5, or 0
I can't figure out this mustplay list; it keeps dipping between listing great games, overlooking great games and listing so-so to shit to actually unplayable games. Is this a list of great games or a list of games we'll be forced to play after we die?
636910 No.16613407
>>16613200
>Oblivion, Skyrim, and FO3 made the list
Did Todd himself ghostwrite this list?
02de19 No.16613439
>>16613313
>not morrowind and gothic
The nigger had 1001 slots to work with, I can't even name 1001 games worth playing, let alone 1001 must-plays
34e71e No.16613440
>Suikoden III
>not II
Fuck a dick
01bfd9 No.16613467
>>16613426
>All that
>Not the /v/ quadrilogy of E.Y.E, Stalker, New vegas, and V:tMB
1faf36 No.16613475
>>16613386
>>16612791
I think /v/ should just make a board-wide effort to make our own proper list.
Basically every anon would post up to 100 games (or fewer) that they consider top-tier and whatever had the most votes would go to the top.
It would probably be the most fair and accurate list compared with all of the others which are just guesses at best.
But that's too much work probably.
7367ad No.16613484
>>16613467
How could anyone forget the holy trinity of shit v core games?
685165 No.16613488
>>16613426
>Half-Life 2 rated higher than Half-Life
Even with it being what I assume to be a shitpost, that still made my blood pressure spike.
7367ad No.16613491
>>16613488
the list isnt a shitpost, its what cuck /v/ voted for
b3c3c8 No.16613497
>no contra: hard corps
>no any wario land game
What a shit fucking list.
ecb13c No.16613512
>>16612880
Every single vidya list is padded, especially when it's a "mainstream" list in which case the entire list feels like the dumbasses making them went "what came out this year with a 10 million+ marketing budget?"
fc5f58 No.16613530
>>16612877
>punch and run
damn that's actually accurate especially for older beat em ups
2e57b8 No.16613554
>>16613426
>>16613484
>cuckchan infographs
>post MMXIV A.D
crossposters like you belong on a cross >>>/back/ in the cuckshed
7367ad No.16613564
>>16613554
>MUH CROSSPOSTER
<REEEEEEEEE
Everytime lol
2e57b8 No.16613572
>>16613564
<DICKSUCKER AND PROUD
274213 No.16613574
>>16613572
someone is le trying to hard to fit in xD
7367ad No.16613587
>>16613572
>cuckchan filename
>near the end of 2015
>calling anyone out as a crossposter
People who are the most vocal about something usually partake in it themselves behind closed doors
1ae834 No.16613597
>>16613587
>newfag doesn't know that's well within the time perios 8chan still used that style of unix timestamp for filenames
7367ad No.16613612
>>16613597
how convienient for you
2e57b8 No.16613631
>>16613612
>get called out
<DOUBLE DOWN
>get called out again
<TRIPLE DOWN
9d2333 No.16613633
>>16612752
>MGS Twin Snakes
>No Ys games
>Donkey Kong 3 but not 2
>no Crash Bandicoot
>Bioshock Infinite
I could go on, but basically this list is shit. It does at least have one Monster Hunter game on it so that's a miracle.
1ae834 No.16613639
>>16613612
>conveniently ignores the -3 at the end of the filename noting that it was from a multi-image post
>something cuckchan never had
Oh gee look at this filesize, what a cuckchan filesize for a cuckchan filename right?
7367ad No.16613644
>>16613631
Make that a
<QUADRUPLE DOWN
>>16613639
I hate dogs
eaeb89 No.16613647
>>16613644
>8ch premium
What are we just going to pull out all the classics at once?
49599a No.16613649
will you glowniggers shut up already?
7367ad No.16613656
>>16613647
No, let us stop and go our seperate ways.
41059b No.16613674
>>16613099
See the little salt icon, retard? That means that it's meant to be taken with a grain of salt and not a serious, legitimate rec. If anybody needs to go back to cuckchan, it's you.
121ca8 No.16613886
>>16613475
I really like the idea, anon.
d41a40 No.16614151
>>16612884
>jarpig
What is this meme?
40f9e1 No.16614178
>>16614151
>JRPG
>Jay ar pee gee
>Jar puh guh
>Jarpig
It's like calling an MMO a muhmorpuhgur.
3fcd7b No.16614186
>>16614178
STOP IT
BE RIGHT BACK GONNA GO PLAY MY FIPS.
MAYBE ILL GO PPAY A SARPEEG
093155 No.16614194
>>16612849
Aren't these still relevant as well?
7f2709 No.16614209
>>16613475
A bot could be easily written to collect the votes, if you could get anons to all post in a certain format, say:
>Contra
>The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
>Pokemon Heart Gold / Soul Silver
One game per line, full title.
7f2709 No.16614213
>>16613484
doom 1 should be at the center
19fc11 No.16614214
>>16614186
Wanna play some shamups?
3fcd7b No.16614219
>>16614214
Sure and after some shakeups let's get the board together and play some forks like civ 4
697cda No.16614262
>>16614213
Seconded. Duke Nukem shat all over DOOM, no contest.
40f9e1 No.16614271
>>16614219
Auroraforks is the best forks if you're autistic enough
Also I wish rutee-es weren't dead
688a36 No.16614400
>>16612752
Wait a minute that card…
201b46 No.16615043
<No Donkey Kong Country 2
<No TMNT Turtles in Time
<No NES Castlevania
<No Klonoa
<No Alien Hominid
<No Jazz jackrabbit
<No SW Battlefront 2 (2005)
<No Conker's bad fur day
<No Shovel Knight
<No Zelda II
<No Meat boy
Yeah, this is shit.
7b9a70 No.16615059
>>16615043
Zelda 2, conker, jazz jackoff, meat boy and alien hominid are shit.
49218c No.16615083
>>16612752
<No Star Ocean
Shit
5e354b No.16615086
>>16614262
Both are good in their ways. Brutal Doom today is amazing, and Duke Nukem maps are just _amaze_ me every time with amount of action. They both do tbh. Recommending both.
8501d5 No.16615091
>>16614262
And Blood shits all over every Build engine game.
8385d8 No.16615111
>>16613633
Why would you want a game you like on this list?
1f1445 No.16615130
>>16615107
Shovel knight is a pretty good platformer if you ignore the devs and the shitty development. It looks good and plays nice.
aec012 No.16615146
>>16615130
I could at least try if it wasn't baked into the game itself.
c51067 No.16615187
>Ace Combat 6
>Not Ace Combat 4,5, or even 0
that is the shittiest shit list that ever shat.
>5 halo games
>like 10 final fantasy games
>ratchet and clank: size matters
This list is clearly made to make people upset
47c75e No.16615373
>>16612752
>no wizardry
>only might and magic game is a shitty DS game
>only mainline ultimas are 1 and 7 but no age of enlightenment trilogy
what the actual fuck
942e57 No.16615419
>>16612791
>Timeshift
Who the fuck would put this anywhere near the best first person shooters? It isn't awful but at best it's an overlooked mediocre game.
bda84e No.16615531
>>16613426
I got GRIDS just looking at that. Can we do humanity a favor and not try making any more lists ever?
0e05a5 No.16615585
>>16615043
>>16615059
alien hominid tries to be metal slug but with a quarter of the frames with even less that effort into the art.
4720d7 No.16615699
>>16612849
>The closest thing /v/ has is the /v/ recommended games wiki, which was stormed by redditors and has little to nothing to do with /v/ anymore.
There's an 8chan specific vidya recommendation wiki that's been around for years now. Not like many know of it at this point, nor does it get new additions either.
3ad3ad No.16615749
>>16613426
Where's x-com?
fucking nintendobabies
bda84e No.16615784
>>16615749
God Hand barely made that abortion of a list. It's possibly the worst thing /v/ has ever assembled, including the tone-deaf sing-a-longs redditors love.
ee5320 No.16615820
What if we just play video games we like?
3fb442 No.16615831
>>16612761
Disappointment or not, Nuts & Bolts is a unique game that should be included.
>>16612791
If we ever make another list I want to propose that nothing from the past few years be eligible, and no game from the past 10 years without unanimous approval.
There's some obvious flavour of the month that snuck into that chart.
0b2ba3 No.16615843
>>16612752
It's a fucking normalfag-kosher bullshit list, and the choices are suspect or fucking shit
c2d680 No.16615956
>>16613484
>who only like these games to conform and fit in with v
Are anons not allowed to recommend games they like now?
775516 No.16616324
>>16612752
>Is this a good list?
>wikipedia
Answer's no.
>Should /v/e make our own?
Lurk for two fucking years and then post, faggot.
0e49d6 No.16616373
>>16612838
>webm
My fucking sides
5e354b No.16616628
6ceb49 No.16617122
>>16613426
Why is everyone so upset with this list.
Granted, its got a lot of questionable rankings and is missing a lot of my personal top 100, but overall most of the games on there are good.
25f578 No.16617344
>>16612791
>Grand strategy
>Hearts of Iron 3 missing
>2 versions of Total Meme
This is a shit list.
25f578 No.16617350
>>16613475
This could work. Those meme lists are gay as shit.
769aa8 No.16643579
>>16613484
Having played 4/5 of those games at release, some before /v/ existed, it is difficult to take you seriously anon. You are full of shit.
6b2a8e No.16643839
>Fallout 3
<No Fallout 2 or New Vegas
niggers I swear
c42b42 No.16643876
These lists always tend to assume some semblance of a hivemind. And while the book in OP is just made for retarded normalfags, the /v/ recommendation lists are legitimately terrible, considering they might convince anons to waste tens of thousands of hours on hundreds of questionable at best games instead of finding what they like on their own. Especially considering that most anons here drool over objectively shit, broken and unfinished games like Wind Waker, Mario Sunshine and STALKER.
>>16613475
Why bother with something so complicated? Just list the entire SNES library, every Gamecube exclusive, every Fromsoft game, STALKER and Fallout New Vegas and you're done.
>>16612907
>magnup opus of Sonic
<not Sonic 2, the only Sonic game that actually encourages going fast
b5aa6b No.16643916
>>16615820
What if we just fuck your mom that we like?
7b415d No.16643935
>>16612752
>not even a single 2hu
76149c No.16644141
>STALKER Clear Sky instead of Call of Prypiat
>no terraria
>no EYE
>no Mount and Blade
>all those gay sports games
80b88c No.16644166
>>16643935
Touhou fags are the most obnoxious fucking retards in the world.
cd03e7 No.16644179
>>16613475
/v/ shouldn't do anything.
The people in this board are as useless and unproductive as they are petty, dumb and pedantic.
07cd8d No.16644186
>>16644166
sage niggerated
982f41 No.16644230
>The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
3be6fc No.16644252
>paying money to read some dude's backlog
fucking lol
33b29b No.16644307
>>16612752
>bioshock infinite plotholes
I am not even going to read the rest of the list. The only redeemable thing here is that this list serves as a decoy to keep faggots away from good games.