>>14083628
Quake and UT work pretty well for what they are, since they weren't trying to base themselves too hard off of any existing IP's. Don't get me wrong, AVP1 is still pretty good, but it lacks that thick atmosphere of Alien and Aliens.
And yeah, Aliens WAS HURF DURF MUHREEN ACSHUN with horror elements (which is fine, it's a great film), but you can still do better with the franchise in general. Aliens was the peak of its quality.
I'm saying I wish a game could do more than just "sorta get it". Alien: Isolation was pretty good, and captured the feel of Alien, but it's more of an Amnesia clone with a nostalgic kick. At least they got atmosphere and tone down pretty well, but still.