Arguments against sedevacantism?

Email
Comment *
File	Select/drop/paste files here
Password	(Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field	[▶ Show post options & limits] Confused? See the FAQ.

Embed	(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options	Do not bump (you can also write sage in the email field) Spoiler images (this replaces the thumbnails of your images with question marks)
Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf Max filesize is 16 MB. Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000. You may upload 5 per post.

Arguments against sedevacantism? Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 17:33:08 779cdc No.741722

Is it the only choice for a sincere practicing Catholic, or is it autism? Shouldn't Catholics trust that whoever is in the seat of Peter is there because God allowed it for reasons beyond our immediate understanding, the gates of hell haven't prevailed against the church right?

Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 17:51:48 66e92d No.741725

>>741722

Depends, do you agree with the heresies of Vatican II and the fruits it bore?

Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 17:53:17 5f302c No.741726

We once had a pope who exhumed the corpse of his predecessor in order to condemn him as an invalid pope because of dumb rules about dioceses that were considered tradition at the time. They chopped off his fingers and flung him in a river, and the guy had to appear from heaven just to get a proper burial. All of this to say that the people who think that the VII popes are somehow invalid in comparison to THAT, not to even mention the Avignion or the Borgia popes, are just silly.

Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 20:19:45 2f43b4 No.741748

>>741722

Sedevacabtism is just more private interpretation/judgement bs

Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 21:48:23 e8dc0f No.741785

>>741726

sedevacantism is historical illiteracy

Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 23:18:22 be8500 No.741810

>>741726

Top kek. What pope btw?

Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 23:23:25 59a856 No.741814

>>741810

Cadaver synod, one example on why papal infallibility is bs.

Christanon 12/15/18 (Sat) 23:36:52 be8500 No.741824

>>741814

Do you understand what papal infallibility is or are you just baiting? If the pope says that you are a retard that doesn't make it true.

Christanon 12/16/18 (Sun) 09:35:08 149703 No.742074

>>741722

>or is it autism?

Pure schismatic autism. You don't proclaim yourself obedient to the Church until you aren't.

>Shouldn't Catholics trust that whoever is in the seat of Peter is there because God allowed it

Not every Pope is a "good" Pope, but when we receive a "bad" Pope, we trust in God and pray for clemency, that His Will be done.

Christanon 12/16/18 (Sun) 10:40:42 53f75d No.742094

>>742074

>Pure schismatic autism. You don't proclaim yourself obedient to the Church until you aren't.

Fine, explain then why Popes haven't publicly spoken heresy or prayed with heretics while all post V2 Popes have

Christanon 12/16/18 (Sun) 11:01:01 be8500 No.742097

>>742094

>Popes haven't publicly spoken heresy

When did that happen after Vatican II?

Oh I think you mean they said something you don't agree with

>prayed with heretics while all post V2 Popes have

Lol winnie the pooh heretics you want to know more about the Church? Get away from me smelly prots we don't want to convince you to join the church.