[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / bflo / film / imouto / lippe / magali / pdfs / plyn / vg ]

/christian/ - Christian Discussion and Fellowship

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
Email
Comment *
File
Password (Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.


The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom shall I fear? the Lord is the strength of my life; of whom shall I be afraid?

File: 76f78d8d70ea19f⋯.jpg (112.27 KB, 1330x1558, 35:41, school-shooting-santa-fe-t….jpg)

df2f81 No.649726

http://time.com/5282754/santa-fe-shooting-suspect-dimitrios-pagourtzis/

>Who is the suspect in the Santa Fe High School shooting?

>Pagourtzis was a student at Santa Fe High School and played junior varsity football.

<He also participated in his local Greek Orthodox church, according to the AP, and danced in an annual festival for the church last fall.

Seriously though, is this the first ever Orthodox school shooter? Sounds like someone took 'Death to the World' a little too seriously.

f870e4 No.649728

File: 5f97e7ba0861b1f⋯.jpg (65.98 KB, 1280x720, 16:9, 5f9.jpg)

>greek goes to orthodox church


8ab8e1 No.649730

This unrelated to OP's shitpost, but is it true that Greek Orthodox churches tend to be more liberal than Russian Orthodox? What are the differences between all the Orthodox variants anyway?


d2008f No.649736

>>649730

From my experience the Greeks are the most liberal out of all the Orthodox but still leagues more conservative than the average church outside Orthodoxy. Russians and Serbs tend to be the most conservative. Bulgarians tend of keep to themselves. Antiochians probably have the most western converts out of anybody else from what I've seen, I'm not sure why though. I don't have much experience with Romanians or Georgians.


d09b4c No.649737

>>649736

> Romanians

moonshiners

>Georgians

see serbians


1df0bd No.649738

It'd be unfair and extremely uncharitable to attribute anything of this crime to the Orthodox or its teaching.

I hope they do not get attacked over this from MSM.


a4dfa7 No.649739

>>649730

Serbian Church, Church of Greece, and ROCOR tend to be the "conservative" ones (schismatics have no grace, Jews are behind everything evil in the world, preparation to communion must be strict).

The rest of the churches are just neutral, except for some bishops here and there who are super conservative.

I have never seen an Orthodox parish be what you'd consider "liberal" by the standards of Christendom.

>>649726

The Orthodox are winnie the pooh hypocrites, what do you expect?

>Sounds like someone took 'Death to the World' a little too seriously.

You mean like all those Orthodox who kill their unborn children in Russia? Or those Greek Orthodox bishops in America who are fine with abortion if the (((doctors))) say the woman's in danger? Or those bishops in Cyprus who allowed Orthodox women to abort if they were raped by Turks?

The Orthodox are guilty of countless crimes already, one more Orthodox murderer isn't a remarkable event.


19dada No.649740

File: 66c012f7c1908f4⋯.jpg (11.48 KB, 225x225, 1:1, download (25).jpg)

>>649730

There is no difference theologically, they all hold the same Traditions.

As for the rituals and what to use, those traditions are up to the Church (example, in some Slavic Orthodox Churches, for Palm Sunday, they will give out pussywillows (pic related) instead of palms (because palms dont grow out near Carpathia)


d09b4c No.649741

>>649739

you know you can insert any branch and related country and get the same thing right?


a4dfa7 No.649747

>>649740

>there is no difference theologically

lmao

Orthodox are as theologically diverse as Anglicans.

Is there original sin, or are we all born immaculate?

Is the essence-energy distinction a dogma?

Is a second marriage sacramental or not? Does a divorce actually terminate a marriage?

Are schismatic sacraments valid? Do schismatics have any grace at all? Must Catholics and Oriental Orthodox be rebaptized?

Is there an eternal relation between the Son and the Holy Spirit?

How many sacraments are there?

All of those are essential questions, yet they all have a spectrum of responses within Orthodoxy. At this point the Orthodox are indistinguishable from Protestants because they're so all over the place.

>>649741

All the Christian confessions of faith have their hands bathed in blood, and I don't know which is the most clean one. Not that it matters anyway, correct doctrine is more important.


d2008f No.649748

>>649747

>Orthodox are as theologically diverse as the Church Fathers

fixed


a4dfa7 No.649749

>>649748

And yet Augustine, Fulgentius of Ruspe, etc. are completely shunned and their theology is treated as heretical even if they themselves are saints. Which isn't a problem in itself (saints don't have to be perfect theologians) but shows the xenophobia against Latin theology that plagues the Orthodox Church. The only solid teaching is "we're definitely not like the Catholics," everything else is theologoumenon. What hypocrites.


2f8f16 No.649750

>>649736

>Antiochians probably have the most western converts out of anybody else from what I've seen

They're the most aggressive with proselytizing and the least insular of the branches of the Church, at least here in the US. They're also very open about being Christians in their daily lives, which draws in a lot folks who feel increasingly repressed in the current cultural climate. I'd recommend anyone in the US who is interested in Orthodoxy look to them as they have the most experience with conversion here.


1ca9f1 No.649751

He has a Baphomet decoration on his trenchcoat, his parents are Orthodox but Dimitrios' personal allegiance is to Satan.

I'm Catholic btw just saiyan.


a4dfa7 No.649752

>>649750

I went to two Antiochian parishes in the US. One was really, really good. The other was Western rite, it was garbage and somebody harassed my girlfriend.


d2008f No.649756

>>649749

It's not "xenophobia" to disagree with double procession or essence/energy or infallibility or any other western doctrine.

You're being uncharitable.


2f8f16 No.649757

>>649749

This is a rather Latin-centric way of looking at the issue. What of the Latin's xenophobia of eastern theology that plagues the Roman Church? And are you sure you really want to throw around accusations of hypocrisy? Your organization is rife with atheists wearing vestments.


a4dfa7 No.649760

>>649756

"We have diverse doctrines like the Church Fathers… except the Latin fathers, what they taught was absolutely wrong and is under anathema." That is xenophobia.

In fact, the Byzantines came to embrace or at least tolerate aspects of Latin theology such as the Pope deciding what councils are ecumenical (during the 9th century iconclasm), the filioque (per Maximus the Confessor, during the monothelite controversy), original sin (again, per Maximus), but the Byzantine success with the council at Constantinople of 879-880 and the period of estrangement between East and West during the pornocracy were sufficient for the Byzantines to completely reject any bits of Latin theology. 11th-15th centuries are just the Orthodox anathematizing the Catholics without caring to know what the Latin fathers may have written, and 15th-21st centuries are just the Orthodox acknowledging what the Latin fathers taught but rejecting that it may be legite theological ideas because the Catholics already teach them.

>>649757

>What of the Latin's xenophobia of eastern theology that plagues the Roman Church?

What xenophobia of Eastern theology? Only actual differences I find with the Catholics, besides papal supremacy, are the essence-energy distinction (but it's post-schism, Catholics have no obligation to recognize it), the idea of praying people out of Hades (which isn't hard to reconcile with Purgatory), and… I believe that's it.

The three holy hierarchs are doctors of the Catholic Church, aren't they? And Fr Francis Dvornik has made Catholics like Photius.

>Your organization is rife with atheists wearing vestments.

I am Orthodox, so you are correct. I probably won't be Orthodox for much longer now.


a4dfa7 No.649761

>>649760

The Catholic Church says "We are the Church of Christ, and this is what we teach and have always taught."

The Orthodox Church says "We are the Church of Christ, ask 3 bishops the same question about doctrine and you'll get 3 answers that are in contradiction, but what we can say is that we definitely don't teach what the Catholics teach."

Sounds familiar, doesn't it? Sounds like every group that separated from the Catholic Church.


d2008f No.649762

>>649760

>"We have diverse doctrines like the Church Fathers… except the Latin fathers, what they taught was absolutely wrong and is under anathema."

Ok piggy, you're not getting any more pearls from me.


43a2da No.649763

File: 77dfabd60c4f77b⋯.png (82.34 KB, 239x229, 239:229, 1525774795305.png)

>>649747

>Are schismatic sacraments valid? Do schismatics have any grace at all? Must Catholics and Oriental Orthodox be rebaptized?

>Don't know wether grace outside church

>Be recieved into Orthodox Church without Baptism


a4dfa7 No.649765

>>649763

The school of thought that says that non-Orthodox have no sacraments or grace also says that if somebody who wasn't sacramentally baptized isn't baptized upon entering the Church, the sacrament of chrismation "covers" the baptism that wasn't done. So there's no actual fear of somebody not actually being part of the Body of Christ.

Although I've heard of Athonite monasteries rebaptizing you if you weren't originally baptized in the Orthodox Church.


1ca9f1 No.649766

>>649762

Is that a charitable thing to say?


2f8f16 No.649768

>>649752

>The other was Western rite, it was garbage and somebody harassed my girlfriend.

Harassed how? There are only about 20 or so of those in the US, most of them in the midwest, so I've never attended one.

>>649760

>Only actual differences I find with the Catholics, besides papal supremacy, are the essence-energy distinction (but it's post-schism, Catholics have no obligation to recognize it), the idea of praying people out of Hades (which isn't hard to reconcile with Purgatory), and… I believe that's it.

The theological differences run far deeper than just that. You barely have to glance at their catechisms to see it. If Roman Catholicism still looks appealing after having read theirs, then you probably aren't equipped to even properly compare the two.

I also don't actually believe you're Orthodox, or ever were. You reek of deceit.


d2008f No.649769

>>649766

Telling the truth is always charitable.

If he's simply going to misrepresent the Orthodox position, especially when he should know better since he supposedly is one, and make a claim that all the Latin Fathers are anathema even when we honor them saints, then he's a pig. And we know as Christians that our Lord teaches us not to cast our pearls before these people.


a0e128 No.649770

>>649761

>claims Orthodox Church contradicts itself

>doesn't realize Vatican 2 is full of contradictions


a4dfa7 No.649771

File: fb7c1f8f412bcc5⋯.jpg (3.37 MB, 4608x3456, 4:3, 1.JPG)

File: 73b227585fa5217⋯.jpg (3.4 MB, 4608x3456, 4:3, 8.JPG)

File: 75688aa353f8be7⋯.jpg (3.41 MB, 4608x3456, 4:3, 7.JPG)

File: fd548ee6a9a01f7⋯.jpg (3.38 MB, 4608x3456, 4:3, 6.JPG)

>>649768

Some weird dude kept hitting on her in the most sad way possible.

It's unfortunate, the parish is close to where she lives so she could've gone there.

Here's a couple pictures of the church if you're curious.

>The theological differences run far deeper than just that.

What are you going to say? Original sin? Most Orthodox profess it. Filioque? Like half of the Orthodox believe in it. Azymes? Be serious, now.

The real differences are of course the role of the Pope and his role's origins, the relationship between God's essence, his grace conveyed to creation, and creation itself, and whether the Latin Catholic Trinitarian schema is an acceptable expression of the faith.

>>649769

I never said the Latin fathers are anathema.

However, a lot of Augustine's theology is anathema (his pneumatology and his proto-Calvinism). Similarly, Fulgentius of Ruspe's pneumatology is completely anathema.

The doctrine of papal supremacy of Leo and many other popes is also anathema, obviously.

It's perfectly fine for saints to teach things that end up being anathematized later. A saint isn't somebody who is a perfect theologian during their life, but somebody who has led a holy life and died in Christ.

>>649770

Are you a sedevancatist? They're hard to take seriously.


76ac1f No.649773

>>649760

>little baby met a few bad priests so now he wants to leave the church

you're from an Orthodox-majority country aren't you? You're so angered by the imperfections of the Orthodox yet you probably don't know a thing about the Catholics and Protestants.

With the exception of fringe traditionalist churches, Western denominations are in decline. Go to the average post-Vatican II Catholic mass and you'll get nothing but a feel-good guitar mass that teach nothing but empty platitudes. The majority of Catholics in the West support anti-tradition progressive causes like gay "marriage" and abortion. The Catholic clergy are filled with progressives and pedophiles. Whatever you see in the Catholic Church, it's a shadow of what it once was.


3a36a5 No.649775

>>649771

It doesn't matter as someone like (you) will only slander it. One doesn't need to be Catholic to see the glaring flaws of the Church™

Besides this anon >>649773 covers what I would have said anyway.


ba3693 No.649776

>some dude whose family is Orthodox turned out to be a real jerk

Is that all Catholics?


a4dfa7 No.649777

>>649773

I've only met two… strange priests, to say the least.

My issue is with every bishop and seminary teacher teaching his own flavor of Christianity, and this reflecting upon what laypeople say online.

I'm in France, and I go to Catholic Mass often since my priest lets me… Catholic Mass is perfectly fine, it's just really short compared to the Divine Liturgy. But it's really beautiful.

I only hear horror stories from America and Belgium, but there are liturgical abuses in the Orthodox Church too.

>The majority of Catholics in the West support anti-tradition progressive causes like gay "marriage" and abortion.

Don't surveys show that Orthodox are nearly identical to Catholics in the West in that aspect?


2f8f16 No.649779

>>649771

>What are you going to say?

Their concept of "The Human Communion" and the gnostic quagmire they've made of the Trinity would be my first concern. That they slyly attempt to demote God and elevate humanity through a doctrine of "oneness of spirit" is nothing short of sacrilege. These ideas are root of their corruption and decay because taken to their extreme they are atheistic. Magisterial infallibility and the Pope are minor issues compared to this.


a4dfa7 No.649780

>Their concept of "The Human Communion" and the gnostic quagmire they've made of the Trinity would be my first concern

Please elaborate (with sources if you can). I'm not being aggressive, I just am really unsure of what you have in mind here.


2f8f16 No.649782

>>649777

>Don't surveys show that Orthodox are nearly identical to Catholics in the West in that aspect?

The Pew studies did. But there are so many issues with how that study was conducted that there isn't much reason to trust their numbers at all for any group. I've covered the issues with it before in another thread but they're so numerous that they'd make up a thread on their own. In short there are catastrophically bad errors in their sampling that lead to some virtually impossible numbers with regards to Orthodoxy in particular within that study. And I wouldn't trust it for other denominations either.


3232ea No.649784

>>649728

This.

I honestly haven't a clue what you're expecting from this, OP. He's just another of the thousands of kids who are "forced" by their parents to participate in their ethnic community center church activities regardless of the kid's actual personal beliefs.

What the heck do you even want us to say? This is a stupid thread.


1791c7 No.649785

>>649726

>He also participated in his local Greek Orthodox church, according to the AP, and danced in an annual festival for the church last fall.

OP, we know you're trolling. Everybody with an iota of common sense knows he's not truly of the Eastern Orthodox faith.


2f8f16 No.649786

>>649780

Read their catechism. There's an entire chapter called "The Human Communion" and if you really think through the arguments within you'll see what I mean. Catholics have weakened the distinctions between the separate aspects of the Trinity and then tried to insert humanity into the equation. I was actually appalled when I read their catechism back when I was studying the different churches. I later found out that I wasn't the only one to object to this part of Roman Catholic theology. Dostoyevsky came to very similar conclusions.


ba3693 No.649787

>>649779

Why is it like every time something is made to be purely spiritual then it's some kind of Gnostic heresy to those who merely have Aristotelean affections?


807c76 No.649788

>>649738

You know this is exactly what's going to happen. Their going to use this to paint us as violent psychos.


0f6a86 No.649789

>>649787

Concupiscence and lack of clarity of thought.


2f8f16 No.649790

>>649787

It's not an accusation I throw out lightly. Them elevating humanity in such a way is gnostic in nature. It is atheistic, and it contradicts the Final Judgment by implying a collectivized soul for humanity.


ba3693 No.649792

It literally says in Acts 4:32 "They were of one heart and one mind".


2f8f16 No.649794

>>649792

So you should understand the problem with attempting this without direct divine intervention. Look around. Notice how it always ends in tragedy? This is what I mean when I say that these ideas are the root of their corruption. Keep reading through Acts and see what happens when someone attempts to profane a gift from God with base human nature.


ce2f68 No.649796

>>649730

I've only read reports that some Orthodox priests in America have extremely watered down their faith and practically they are just Catholics or Protestands with Byzantine rite, they tend to be the most liberal. Greek Orthodox church in Greece is still very strict. I've also heard about some monasteries in America who are still in line with true Orthodoxy.


75e28a No.649803

>>649796

>>649790

>let me tell you where and when the gates of hell prevailed on your Church

absolutely_orthoprot.jpg


75e28a No.649804


f291ce No.649820

>>649739

>You mean like all those Orthodox who kill their unborn children in Russia?

You can say that about any historically catholic country in Europe where people call themselves 'catholic'.

>Or those Greek Orthodox bishops in America who are fine with abortion if the (((doctors))) say the woman's in danger?

When a woman is in severe danger (e.g. ovarian pregnancy) and nothing else can be done it is permissible to abort the child.

It is also morally sound to choose the life of the woman over that of the child if labour and delivery can seriously mean the death of the mother.


c35af4 No.649841

>>649751

Don't forget the bi-sexual and communist pins too


fb9261 No.649859

In news sources he's identified as atheist.

/thread.


3a36a5 No.649892

>>649859

Lmao, OP and salty Catholics BTFO


6c7483 No.649914

>>649859

I don't think this is actually good news for us.

The (((media))) is getting mad at Putin for butting heads with Israel in Syria and I think they'll star mass attacks at Orthodoxy by proxy.


fb9261 No.649923

>>649914

I've read multiple articles/sources about him, and in every single one, the primary emphasis is on his "Born to Kill" T-Shirt, and Nazi Iron Cross (and other non-Christian symbols) on his duster. His involvement with an Orthodox dance group is treated as a brief insignificant footnote. Heck, there's been more emphasis on his involvement on the football team.


6c7483 No.649943

>>649923

I'm not talking about this case. But the bigger picture.

As Russia keeps butting with Israel, (((they))) will keep twisting and turning the truth in the (((news))) to attack us.


df2f81 No.649950

>>649785

>OP, we know you're trolling. Everybody with an iota of common sense knows he's not truly of the Eastern Orthodox faith.

No true orthodoxman, huh?


a0e128 No.649973

File: 8ca0231435762c4⋯.png (3.5 KB, 211x239, 211:239, 1508523232954.png)

>>649950

>Jesus tells you to obey God

>God tells you to not murder

>schoolshooting.exe

>looks like he didn't Obey God

<muh no true scotsman fallacy

<durrrr stoopid orthoprot


f291ce No.649978

>>649973

>Jesus tells you to obey God

>God tells you to not [instert any sin]

>sinning.exe

>looks like he didn't obey God

Well fugg, guess nobody's a christian.


4bc980 No.649983

>>649820

>When a woman is in severe danger (e.g. ovarian pregnancy) and nothing else can be done it is permissible to abort the child.

>It is also morally sound to choose the life of the woman over that of the child if labour and delivery can seriously mean the death of the mother.

Yes, that's what I said. You are pro-abortion devils.

In Catholicism it is absolutely never permissible to abort a child under any circumstances.


800bfd No.649984

Is it time for #NotAllOrthodox?


a0e128 No.649985

>>649978

This must explain why the Catholic church hasn't defrocked the sodomite and pedophile preists infesting thier clergy.


f291ce No.649987

>>649983

>Yes, that's what I said. You are pro-abortion devils.

>In Catholicism it is absolutely never permissible to abort a child under any circumstances.

You're speaking to a catholic here.

http://www.ewtn.com/v/experts/showmessage.asp?number=417376

https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/abortion-and-double-effect


dfdb7d No.649988

>>649985

Oh God please pardon me, somehow in my the long years of my life I never realized that Protestants literally never sin.


2f8f16 No.649990

>>649950

>wearing an iron cross, hammer and sickle, rising sun, Baphomet, and Cthulhu pin

>parents have criminal records a mile long

>skipped his anti-psychotics

>identifies as an athiest

>attended a church community outreach event once

>none of them even lay members of the Church

Certainly this is the work of the Orthodox Church…. somehow….


cb34e1 No.649993

>>649988

>>649985

You are both beautiful. How about this new meme:

Catholics are still sodomite enabling, pedophile protecting, modernists

Orthodox are now edgy school shooters.

And Prots are still prots.

Can we all just get along now and realize the shooter in the OP is not a Christian?


1df0bd No.649994

>>649993

how about this

>protestants deny that Christ died for all sins


0425d5 No.649996

>>649994

>doesn't understand Protestant theology

Dude, you aren't helping anything or anyone, just stop.


2b8818 No.649997

>>649747

>Orthodox are as theologically diverse as Anglicans.

>All of those are essential questions, yet they all have a spectrum of responses within Orthodoxy. At this point the Orthodox are indistinguishable from Protestants because they're so all over the place.

wewlad. You fell for the meme. All Orthodox in full communion share the same theology. Ease off the memes and open a few more books.


1df0bd No.649998

>>649996

>protestant theology

teehee!

Listen, either Christ died for homosexuals or He did not die a death for all sins. Either we can all repent through the pure and just sacrifice of Our Lord, or we cannot (thus, rendering the sacrifice imperfect).

Which is it?


4bc980 No.650003

>>649997

I assume you're a recent convert? Because that is not true. There are many theological traditions in Orthodoxy. There isn't necessarily a single answer for everything. Which is one of the reasons it's so hard to have some kind of universal catechism.

>>649987

>https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/abortion-and-double-effect

I think you haven't read this carefully enough. Re-read it.

It is not acceptable to directly kill the child.


56d7c0 No.650004

>>649998

Jesus died for everyone dingus, it's still up to the sodomites to repent from their sinful behavior. Doesn't mean we should (((tolerate))) them and their destructive behavior like what the Catholic Church is notorious for


9c9a05 No.650005


67cd88 No.650027

File: 80b7cb3b47590de⋯.gif (2.11 MB, 200x150, 4:3, king.gif)

>>649749

>xenophobia


2b8818 No.650034

>>650003

>There are many theological traditions in Orthodoxy

Then what are those theological traditions? Orthodoxy is set apart in that it has no large overhead bureaucracy like the Roman Catholics issuing down orders. The churches are separate yet in agreement on the major aspects of theology that determine what it means to profess the Christian faith. If not then they would all be in schism with one another. Ecumenical councils are not in the habit of passing down issues of dogma unless needing to speak out on heretical beliefs.

> Which is one of the reasons it's so hard to have some kind of universal catechism.

If you would actually read the various Orthodox catechisms you would find that they very much say the same thing.


4bc980 No.650045

>>650034

>Then what are those theological traditions?

As I said above

>Is there original sin, or are we all born immaculate?

>Is the essence-energy distinction a dogma?

>Is a second marriage sacramental or not? Does a divorce actually terminate a marriage?

>Are schismatic sacraments valid? Do schismatics have any grace at all? Must Catholics and Oriental Orthodox be rebaptized?

>Is there an eternal relation between the Son and the Holy Spirit?

>How many sacraments are there?

Just for a few examples of things that get different and contradicting answers in Orthodoxy.

>The churches are separate yet in agreement on the major aspects of theology that determine what it means to profess the Christian faith.

The only thing that really unites the Orthodox Churches are the 7 ecumenical councils and the liturgies. Everything else is fair game.

There are no schisms simply because nobody is addressing those issues yet. There are schisms over politics every few years though, so that's not much better. Antioch and Jerusalem aren't even in communion right now, and the EP is doing nothing.

>If you would actually read the various Orthodox catechisms you would find that they very much say the same thing.

Something tells me you haven't read several catechisms yourself.

I have read the Living God catechism, part of the Philaret catechism, and the Russian church's "The Basis of the Social Concept." More importantly, I have talked with several priests.


ba3693 No.650053

>>649794

No, I don't see the problem. We were made in God's image and the malady of sin obstructs us from realizing the significance of this. That doesn't demote God in any way. And I don't know where you're getting this idea that we reach thesis on our own terms. The believers in Acts were of one heart and one mind through the Holy Spirit.


ba3693 No.650055

>>650004

I think that dude literally thinks Andersonism and Protestantism are the same thing


e64e30 No.650066

>>649726

Going to church once a year does not make you a believer.

>>649739

> Or those bishops in Cyprus who allowed Orthodox women to abort if they were raped by Turks?

I don't see anything wrong with that. You have a cuck fetish.


f291ce No.650081

>>650003

>I think you haven't read this carefully enough. Re-read it.

>It is not acceptable to directly kill the child.

I know, but it remains an abortion when the child is killed even if it's not meant to kill it.


2f3886 No.651001

>>649790

>>649779

Compliance with God's exaltation of you is entirely different to the self-exaltation of a gnostic. It is diametrically opposed to gnosticism.


df2f81 No.651005

>>650066

>I don't see anything wrong with that. You have a cuck fetish.

Is abortion murder? And if so, is it okay to murder a guy because his dad was an asshole?


2f8f16 No.651012

>>651001

That difference is lost in translating the doctrine into praxis as I would argue is evident throughout that chapter. Roman Catholics seem to put the cart before the horse in this matter and end up susceptible to exalting the creation rather than the creator. I think this is part of the reason why Orthodox theology diverged since the essence-energy distinction almost seems to be an answer to this issue.

I actually wanted to make a thread talking about this since I hear a lot of folks here downplay the theological differences between the two sides of the schism and I would really like to hear both sides of the argument and, in particular, a deeper examination of their catechisms. The differences seem to be much larger than many here give credit.

But I haven't made a thread in 12 years of imageboard lurking and I don't intend to start now.


d0976f No.651065

File: 4ddfc9066d975e2⋯.jpg (78.08 KB, 600x489, 200:163, tabernacle.jpg)

>>651005

>And if so, is it okay to murder a guy because his dad was an asshole?

Deuteronomy is very clear that the punishment for rape is death. Since the child was conceived of this capital sin and isn't baptized yet, it too is to die. Same is the case with adultery in Leviticus 20:10:

>And the man that committeth adultery with another man's wife, even he that committeth adultery with his neighbour's wife, the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death.

Clearly it will often happen that as a result of adultery a child in conceived in the woman's womb, yet God doesn't care, he commands the abortion of child and woman. In the case of rape where the woman hasn't sinned, she is thus spared.

Stop watching cuck porn and obey God instead.


df2f81 No.651074

>>651065

>Deuteronomy is very clear that the punishment for rape is death.

Sure, I have no problem with that.

>Since the child was conceived of this capital sin and isn't baptized yet, it too is to die.

Uh.. no, that doesn't follow at all.

>Same is the case with adultery in Leviticus 20:10:

>And the man that committeth adultery with another man's wife, even he that committeth adultery with his neighbour's wife, the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death.

>Clearly it will often happen that as a result of adultery a child in conceived in the woman's womb, yet God doesn't care, he commands the abortion of child and woman.

Okay, fair enough, a fetus could die when an adulterous woman was executed. An unfortunate but unavoidable consequence of executing the woman.

>In the case of rape where the woman hasn't sinned, she is thus spared.

Right.. Therefore the fetus also lives. We don't punish children for their father's crimes.

>Stop watching cuck porn and obey God instead.

I don't do that, stop bearing false witness. I've actually met someone who was a product of rape and also was a beautiful person and a Christian. I'm glad her mom didn't murder her.


d0976f No.651088

File: d97419f1032297a⋯.jpg (24.05 KB, 300x218, 150:109, humanism.jpg)

>>651074

>Uh.. no, that doesn't follow at all.

>Okay, fair enough, a fetus could die when an adulterous woman was executed.

Do you have the attention span of a goldfish or what? God commands killing of the fetus conceived of adultery, because adultery is a capital sin. If God wanted to spare the fetus he'd say "Wait until the woman has given birth, then execute her". Since rape is a capital sin too, the fetus conceived of that sin is to be killed as well.

I don't care if you met a rape-child who became a Christian, if her mother had aborted her she would have given birth to another Christian child instead. Stop worshipping human life, it is Un-Christian and leads to humanism, secularism, and satanism.


df2f81 No.651104

>>651088

>Do you have the attention span of a goldfish or what? God commands killing of the fetus conceived of adultery, because adultery is a capital sin. If God wanted to spare the fetus he'd say "Wait until the woman has given birth, then execute her". Since rape is a capital sin too, the fetus conceived of that sin is to be killed as well.

The fetus is not specifically punished in the case of adultery, it's a side effect. And as for why they didn't wait 9 months till the baby was born, then execute the mother? That would just not be practical in ancient Israel. They didn't maintain prisons and no one is going to voluntarily wait around 9 months to be executed. Justice was executed immediately.


d0976f No.651111

>>651104

>The fetus is not specifically punished in the case of adultery, it's a side effect.

God doesn't kill people out of side-effects, everything he does is righteous and of a grand design. You have much to learn, read the Bible and lurk more.


351563 No.651147

File: a02b7811258f3c8⋯.jpeg (7.7 KB, 185x273, 185:273, images (47).jpeg)

>>649786

>inserting humanity into the Trinity

oh no somebody stop them


9b50c3 No.651183

>>651111

>unironically defending abortion using a complete non-sequitur based on your interpretation of a single verse from the OT

Wow so this is the power of orthoprotestantism


0f1dad No.651202

>>649726

>Death to the world!

<Lol, message received.


0f1dad No.651205

>>649749

Augustine isn't a saint in the Ortho church, they call him "Blessed Augustine."

Many still read and believe much of his theology but they believe he was mislead on the trinity.


d0976f No.651274

>>651183

I am not defending abortion, I am defending abortion in case of rape. Plus, there nothing to interpret about the verse.


309eae No.651296

>>651205

How so? (He asks, looking up from his copy of Augustine's De Trinitate)

>>651274

Read that as "I am not defending murder, I am defending murder in case of rape." and you'll understand why you shouldn't. It's a heavy cross, but it's one that needs to be borne.


d0976f No.651299

>>651296

>"I am not defending murder, I am defending murder in case of rape." and you'll understand why you shouldn't.

Are you daft? God explicitly commands killing for all sorts of reasons, how exactly do you think that labeling something as "murder" should deter anyone? Go read the Bible kiddo, from cover to cover, and come back no sooner.


309eae No.651303

>>651299

Do you want to know which Biblical figures never command infanticide? God. Do you want to know which ones do? Herod and Pharaoh. I am shocked beyond words.


4320fb No.651610

>>651303

Abortion is not infanticide. Stop lying.


4841b0 No.651613

>>651205

Are you dumb? An ecumenical council recognized the sainthood of Augustine. He's on every calendar. Even theologians who think all of Augustine should be rejected, like Rommanides, don't doubt his sainthood.

Augustine is called "blessed" in the Russian tradition but that doesn't mean he's not canonized already.


309eae No.651614

>>651610

You're right, it's even worse. Not even Herod and Pharaoh would command it.


4841b0 No.651615

>>651610

Don't be stupid, abortion is recognized as infanticide in both Orthodoxy and Catholicism.


4320fb No.651639

>>651614

>Not even Herod and Pharaoh would command it.

Yet God does when he commands the killing of the adulteress with child.

>>651615

>abortion is recognized as infanticide in both Orthodoxy and Catholicism.

No it's not. It's recognized as abortion. Can you all stop lying please?


309eae No.651659

>>651639

And yet YOU command abortion even when capital punishment for rape victims is a part of fulfilled Jewish law, for no other reason than he was "conceived of sin." Matthew 15 makes it clear that ritual purity was of no importance to Jesus while spiritual purity was of the utmost importance. If he want to protect an adulteress, someone who was actually responsible for their defilement, from capital punishment, then I imagine he would like to protect the unborn as well.


4320fb No.651664

>>651659

>Matthew 15 makes it clear that ritual purity was of no importance to Jesus

You know there's a difference between moral and ceremonial law?

>If he want to protect an adulteress

He doesn't. He only protected the adulteress so that he himself does not break the Roman law. It clearly says "This they said, tempting him, that they might have to accuse him.".


309eae No.651665

>>651664

>You know there's a difference between moral and ceremonial law?

I do and given that executing rape victims is blatantly immoral and and justified as a matter of purity, which is fine under the Law, then it is clearly in the latter category.

>He only protected the adulteress so that he himself does not break the Roman law.

Is that why he used the occasion to put forth one of his most famous moral statements and THE definitive moral statement on hypocrisy?


4320fb No.651670

>>651665

>and justified as a matter of purity, which is fine under the Law

You don't know what you're talking about, Deuteronomy 22 says explicitly that rape victims are not to be punished.

>one of his most famous moral statements and THE definitive moral statement on hypocrisy

If people acted according to this the world would be in total chaos, because no courts or punishment could exist. However, we know from Romans 13 that earthly courts are just, so what Jesus said to save the adulteress cannot be a commandment.


dd6285 No.651684

Just another of the staged events that are ramping up lately.


58b340 No.651697

Hmm


4841b0 No.651784

File: 54192f7ecc8e4b1⋯.jpg (79.61 KB, 742x960, 371:480, orthodox hypocrites.jpg)

>>651639

>No it's not. It's recognized as abortion. Can you all stop lying please?

What the winnie the pooh is your point? That an unborn fetus is not considered a child? Liar. But this wouldn't be the first time an Orthodox justifies murder.


61496a No.652310

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.


1ac58e No.652336

File: 3482c758e857a73⋯.jpg (451.67 KB, 1072x1200, 67:75, Foster_Bible_Pictures_0074….jpg)

What the Winnie even is this thread anymore?


c2e38f No.652341

>>649771

>>649771

Is that parish in Texas by chance? It looks familiar


dab3c9 No.652342

>>652336

It has apparently become a couple of anons vs. a lukewarm ortho who wants to twist scripture to justify infanticide. Your pic is related.


1ac58e No.652351

>>652342

I'm just baffled by what the thread started as vs what it is now.


a0e128 No.652358

>>652351

Thats why there needs to be a cath v ortho general, aswell as an apostolics v prots general as well.


6d965d No.652364

File: 0d1001e41d0400d⋯.jpg (35.89 KB, 280x289, 280:289, thread-derailed.jpg)


79be70 No.652462

>>651784

My point is that while abortion is in almost all cases unjustified (except rape, genetic deformities, or health reasons), it is not THE SAME as murder, just as executing a capital punishment is not the same as murder. And now go and repent for using foul language.


b4d432 No.652477

>>649726

>someone took 'Death to the World' a little too seriously.

kek




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / bflo / film / imouto / lippe / magali / pdfs / plyn / vg ]