No.86491
A true classic or pretentious garbage?
Discuss!
No.86493
it was pretty good
thot got bullied a lot; series got a lot better after they introduced cosplay girl
No.86496
Just don't read the sequel or the spinoff.
No.86497
As much as I've read, I enjoyed it. I would consider it a classic though I need to actually finish it.
No.86499
How did the harem arc ended?
No.86517
Reminder: MC settles down with one of the girls only, on the day she gives birth to his child, he runs from the hospital to fuck the trap from series 2 thats now a transvestite.
This series is the longest prelude to NTR you could waste your time on. Now i saved you all those hours.
No.86518
>>86517
This can't be real…
No.86521
>>86518
Imagine reading this series for years, growing to love all the characters and seeing the MC literally run from his wife, sweaty and bleeding out and in pain as she births his child, only to run into the "so kawaii uguu" trap whos now a literal transvestite whore that cheats on his girlfriend -whos so emotionally abused because she used to be the token fat girl and slimmed up but fears nobody else wanting her- who learns that he wants to fuck his post dilation puss hole that used to be his dick and he smirks and pulls him into bed and gets fucked by him as he cries. Years of characters you love destroyed in one chapter out of nowhere.
To this day i don't think another scan team has picked it up after the ones up to that point dropped it in disgust.
1 year later i am still mad.
No.86523
>>86521
The urge to corrupt and ruin something beautiful is too powerful for some people. Holy shit that's bad.
No.86525
>>86521
Is that the former trap of his wife?
No.86526
>>86525
>Is that the former trap of his wife?
*or his wife.
No.86527
>>86525
the trap. His wife is currently exhausted in the hospital after a 40 hour labour of his child and he ran away because its just like in his BL doujin games xDDDDDDDD
No.86535
>>86527
Wait, so he's not a newhalf but a complete cutoff-dick tranny?
What a complete pile of waste.
No.86536
>>86535
This series started in 2002. This shit happened in 2017. Fifteen years to get to this.
No.86540
The first series was a very elaborate literal trap to you follow the story to a hell of fujoshis and fag propaganda and a deeper level of hell that is the spin-off.
No.86545
>>86521
The trap cut the pee pee?
No.86547
>>86545
And the poor former fat girl is her dilation "pay pig".
No.86548
This series turned to shit as soon as it became fujo focused. Once again Fujo's ruin everything.
No.86549
>>86547
The only thing that would be remotely interesting and they went with the surgery route.
Fuck this world.
Who is the MC's wife? Who won the nerdbowl?
Also, I thought the MC was the guy who joined the Genshiken club in the first chaper.
No.86553
>>86549
I'm pretty sure Madarame was the authors self insert so once genshiken had run its course he defaulted to MC.
No.86554
>>86491
Started a classic, ended not pretentious, just garbage. The sequel Spotted Flower really drives the point home, the author is a faggot and pussied out giving Madarame the girl, going against the realism he always attempted to portrait, he tries to walk that back making Madarame fuck the trap while Saki was nursing their newborn made me utterly disgusted by Madarame.
It`s kinda amazing the author managed to ruin a 300 running series with a spin off, unofficial sequel and only using two chapters. Proof that mangakas are autistic degenerates.
No.86558
>>86554
what what what!? That sounds fucking awful. I thought the spin off was supposed to be non canon?
No.86560
>>86554
Wait, Spotted Flower is a sequel? the story of a nerd and his pregnant woman?
No.86562
>>86560
>>86549
>Also, I thought the MC was the guy who joined the Genshiken club in the first chaper.
You are thinking Genshiken, the series changes to a fujo cast on Nidaime and Madarame takes the center stage, from that I am sure you can figure things out
>>86521
The tone deafness of it all really made me sad, up to this point Mada really idealizes Saki, he changes his whole lifestyle for her, abandon the otaku life for the slim chance she will see him see him as a worthy mate. You would think she is enough of a reward for him but apparently he isn`t above a petty attempt to get back at her for the years wasted with Chadotaku, on her most vulnerable moment. Just what the fuck men what was the author thinking? I really believe he resents otakus being a family men and all.
Honestly where were you faggots when this first came out? I tried making /a/ threads and it either got deleted or people ignored it. If I ever go to Comiket I will look for the author and call him an asshole.
>>86558
>>86560
It`s obviously a sequel and canon, author never denied that
No.86563
>>86562
Not using that authoritarian shithole ran by a transvestite thats where.
No.86565
I don't see why would anyone even bother discussing this. As soon as I read in this thread that this has an honest to god tranny with butchered genitals I lost any interest, NTR or not.
No.86566
>>86565
Read the thread again you faggot, it`s a 15 year old running story that gets killed in two chapters, that`s worthy of a discussion. Also it`s a pre-op tranny not that it makes that much difference.
No.86567
>>86566
Anon in >>86521 said:
>wants to fuck his post dilation puss hole
Whom should I believe? And how does it getting killed change the fact that readers were ok with a tranny? Unless it's just a trap on hormones, this isn't just a case of "piss ate shit".
No.86568
>>86567
>this isn't just a case
this is just a case*
No.86569
>>86568
>>86567
So you have no idea about what is being discussed? Genshiken is entry entry tier shit, it`s the type of show people first watch after shonens and shit how come you never head of it. You either retarded or underaged kys either way.
No.86570
>>86567
He specifically has scenes talking about his breast implants and how they turn hard in the cold. It was creepy.
No.86571
>>86562
>where were you faggots when this first came out?
probably banned for missing a fullstop.
No.86572
>>86569
I don't see how not watching tranny shit makes me a newfag, what a queer.
>>86570
So he couldn't even let them grow via hormones? This is some kind of double tranny.
No.86573
>>86571
or saying slightly negative things about that ghoul manga the mods erp as characters from.
No.86575
>>86570
And it is implied he doesn`t want to cut his dick off and prefers to stay as a walking fetish. I could go on a rant about Raku`s character really, how he is a emotional manipulator, petty, fails at being both a men and a women and is the kind of character that would be the antagonist in any other series. Revisiting all this it really feels like an accurate portrait of a tranny honestly.
>>86572
AGAIN YOU ARE NOT READING YOU GOD DAMN NIGGER
It WASN`T tranny shit when it started more than a decade ago, it became so after much time passed, to this degree only a few years ago. Kill yourself
No.86576
>>86575
>It WASN`T tranny shit when it started more than a decade ago, it became so after much time passed, to this degree only a few years ago
Well, you should have said so from the start instead of being such a passive-agressive little shit.
No.86577
>>86575
Remember when he was just a cute, shy trap who wanted to make friends and wasn't a plastic titted manslut who wanted to break up families for a night of anal buggery?
No.86580
>>86577
I said it before but Fujo's ruin everything. It's really not hard to point out where the series went wrong when you start pandering to fujo's, fujo shit inevitably turns it into absolute garbage.
No.86582
>>86576
I am directly saying you should kill yourself because you have no idea about what is being discussed because you never read the series, there`s nothing passive about it. I think you should kill yourself.
>>86577
I wonder if the author hates what otaku has become and this is just his commentary on everything
No.86609
>>86562
>Honestly where were you faggots when this first came out? I tried making /a/ threads and it either got deleted or people ignored it.
For all its faults Genshiken did try to provide commentary on real world otaku, and discussing anything that relates to the real world was literally against the rules of /a/ in the past (no idea if that has been relaxed since). If you literally are not allowed to discuss real world traps or fujoshi that makes it impossible to discuss anything deeper than WHO WILL WIN DA MADABOWL XD
t. vaguely remembers having posts deleted and banned at least once in Nidaime manga threads
>>86577
That's reality for traps. They have earlier expiration dates than even women do. They can't go back to being regular men after they've tasted that forbidden fruit, it's either cling to your fading youthful androgyny for as long as possible, go full troon, or suicide.
>>86582
Didn't the author get married to a fujoshit manga artist? It might be a combination of her influencing him and him thinking he's above regular otaku now that he has something resembling a normal adult life.
No.86614
>>86562
I just thought they were OTHER nerds and faggots.
No.86615
I only remember the hot chick with a beauty mark that had a fetish for bald dudes, she was adorable. Didn't know about this shit.
No.86624
It was good until they introduced the faggot and started catering to fujoshits.
No.86655
>>86624
Considering the OFF INTO FUCKING SPACE tanget the series took, and the shit the mangaka has done since– I got to wonder if the guy has a massive faggot cripple editor at Afternoon. Normally Editors keep a fuckwit creator in check..
No.86664
>>86547
>her
>>86563
>/a/'s BO is a tranny
I guess that's why /a/ feels a lot like /leftypol/. Not even into /pol/ much, I just find /leftypol/ unbearably cringey.
No.86668
>>86664
>I just find /leftypol/ unbearably cringey
As does any sane person. /x/ seems more coherent than leftypol users.
No.86684
>read up to S2
>cut losses
>find this thread
Impressive, this author had one last pang of disgust to provide.
On the 'Why would you do that?' front I remember the guest pages at the end of S2 I remember one pointing out Genshiken's author capacity to take unattractive concepts and running them in an ugly morbid manner (akin to the expression 'watching a trainwreck' maybe).
No.86685
>>86562
>Comiket I will look for the author and call him an asshole.
The author legit needs bleach.
No.86704
i already forgot the characters.
who is madarame and who is saki again?
No.86729
>>86704
Madarame was the skinny radical otaku from Genshiken and Saki was the cunt
No.86737
One of my favorite series, even the tranny show and fujo shit that made up the bulk of series 2 didn't ruin it for me. The ending was too unrealistic and more wish-fulfilment than anything else.
Glad I never read Spottet Flower, it would have tainted the series for me.
No.86753
>>86737
Tough shit. It exists, the traps a mutilated whore who treats the fat girl like his literal bitch, lures in madarame to cheat on the other girl as she gives birth. Fucking welcome to the true mans world.
No.86763
>>86521
Yeah. I definitively regret opening this thread now.
No.86783
wait is this saki? the thot that banged the guy on the left for like 2 seasons?
how did SHE end up with the glasses nerd???
No.86804
>>86783
They don't in the official timeline. Spotted Flower is a "what if" spinoff to "satisfy" Madarame x Saki fans.
No.86807
>>86804
The author confirmed its canon when asked if a genshiken 3 will ever happen.
No.86808
>>86804
Welp, guess they got shat on.
No.86890
No.86892
>>86517
>>86521
I think mada was traumatized by the sudden realisation that he was now a betabuxx and forced into raising sakis and her exboyfriends child
No.86896
>>86892
Wait it's not even madrame's kid? Jesus fuck this keeps getting worse.
No.86914
>>86892
>he was now a betabuxx and forced into raising sakis and her exboyfriends child
This thread keeps getting progressively more disgusting.
No.86916
Fucking hell, It's like the author relentlessly lurked day and night on imageboards to distill the perfect pozz filled manga.
No.86918
>>86916
I'm sure if you look up the manga that came out post scanners dropping it and walking away one of the guys turns out to be a bugchaser.
No.86919
>>86918
At this point I wouldn't be surprised
>>86491
>A true classic or pretentious garbage?
Neither, it's just garbage. I haven't even seen it and I already know.
No.86921
>>86521
>read all that
You know, i read Oh My Goddess back in the day and got mad with the whole double NTR simulation, but I guess other anons had it worse than me.
No.86922
>>86914
>>86896
>>86916
>>86918
Calm down the anon was just joking around, there`s no indication the baby isn`t his.
>>86919
Why anons that insist on having opinions about something they never read, you SHOULD check out the first season, it`s like a time capsule of how things were for a japanease otaku on late 90s and early 20s, the character development is top notch before things went south too.
I still don`t get why so many people never heard of this series, Genshiken is the kind of shit your faggot high school friends suggest you watch as your first anime.
No.86923
>>86922
Actually there is some suggestions that it is the exes baby and he knows but saki never told him.
No.86924
>>86922
>I still don`t get why so many people never heard of this series, Genshiken is the kind of shit your faggot high school friends suggest you watch as your first anime.
My friends made me watch CPUButtobi, photon and a lot of ghibli movies.
No.86926
>>86922
People born 2000 are now 18.
No.86935
>>86923
I looked for raws of further chapters to see if we get anything besides ambiguous suggestions, I found some itallian translations and I regret deeply, the cucking has escalated and Maradame somehow became more unlikeable.
I don`t care about this shit anymore can a mod mercy kill this thread so we can never talk about it again.
No.86940
>>86935
>>86923
>>86892
S2 in manga ended with Madarame and Sucy together, giving up on the rest in one fell swoop except Saki who tricks him into not being a stupid faggot; what the fuck are you people talking about?
Was it so horrifyingly bad my brain decided to replace S2 with something more bearable?
No.86952
>>86940
sucy is the autist or the big tittied slut? I can't remember.
No.86954
>>86952
Sucy is the younger gal, that lost much of her speech after being in contact with the untold horrors of fujoshism.
No.86982
>>86954
Not anymore she ain't, in spotted flower shes a tall tittymonster that fled japan because madarame cheated on her with saki the moment he could and only comes back for comiket.
Legal loli? i don't think bloody abe allows it!
No.86984
>>86982
You're the same guy that keeps coming in and saying stuff that just keeps pouring gasoline on the fire right? Are you being legit? Can you post some pages?
No.86987
No.86988
>>86987
I really am not going to read this shit. Someone already tricked me into reading that shitty manga about that bitch who forces her way in to living rent free with some beta. I definitely value my time more highly than that.
No.86989
>>86987
>chapter 29.5 uploaded 2hrs ago
OH NO NO NO NO
No.87087
>>86921
>double NTR simulation
No.87088
>>86922
>Genshiken is the kind of shit your faggot high school friends suggest you watch as your first anime.
This is exactly how i got to watch it
No.87090
>>87088 (checked)
>be young hitler
>get recomended Genshiken by a joo
So this is how WWII happened
No.87096
>>87090
getting to part 3 was why he killed himself.
No.87630
>>86562
>where were you
pic related
No.94674
No.94807
>>86491
>genshiken thread
>most of it is people still reeling over the infidelity
Spotted Flower was my first foray into the world of Genshiken unfortunately. Thought it was going to be a comfy story of an Otaku husband and his normal wife. Instead got a massive faggot of a husband and his wife just desperate for the dick. I'm still mad but at least the original series helped wash away the shame.