No.82744
Anyone want to give this a shot? My idea: it's too small to vote so we can just have everyone add one thing to each category (so it would take 20 people which sounds right to me- and I guess if we don't have 20 people we could just add more). So the categories could be:
>popular but good, and for the rest of the categories we would avoid putting anything that's really famous so most of the list is sort of different stuff- if we needed a threshold we could say like the 100 (or 200) most popular things on MAL
>scifi
>fantasy
>slice of life
>action
>drama
>movies
Thoughts? Different categories?
No.82748
This could be fun and so if we all vote will a graphic be made?
No.82750
>>82748
Yeah- the other thing would be that when you vote you've got to include pictures and they'd all have to be the same size (maybe 200x200?)
No.82753
>>82750
Sounds pretty rad,
No.82756
>>82753
Cool. I'd like to give it a day or 2 to see if people feel strongly about genres. Then I'll start it if people are interested.
No.82759
>>82756
I'll look for my personal picks and come back. But I think you should add Horror, Romance and cooking.
No.82761
>>82759
Sounds good to me.
No.82763
>>82744
>scifi
kaiba
>fantasy
shingeki no bahamut
>slice of life
silver spoon
>action
hellsing ultimate
>drama
gankutsuou
>movies
gantz: O
koe no katachi
No.82764
>>82763
Want to get some 200x200 pictures Anon?
>>82759
Want to add any of these?
No.82765
>>82759
>Horror
zombieland saga
>Romance
jitsu wa watashi wa
>cooking
yakitate japan
No.82770
>>82764
sounds tedious, I'll work on it some time tomorrow if more people get interested
do you need multiple of each show or one for each show
No.82776
>>82770
>sounds tedious
But think of how pretty the graphic will be at the end.
>quantity
Just one per. Preferably with the name of the show as the filename so I don't have to guess.
No.82784
>scifi
Last Exile
>fantasy
Isekai Shokudou
(also counts as Cooking)
>slice of life
Binchou-tan
>drama
Uchouten Kazoku
(Doesn't really belong in this category, but whatever. Season 1 is better than season 2)
>movies
Vampire Hunter D - Bloodlust
Got nothing for action, it's not a genre I enjoy much. I've seen Hellsing Ultimate but didn't like it enough that I would recommend it along with the others here.
No.82798
Alright, looks fun, I'll give my two cents. I don't know how popular these are but I enjoyed them and don't see them talked about too much.
>scifi
Planetes
>Fantasy
Now and Then, Here and There
>slice of life
Usagi Drop
>action
Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom
>drama
Koi Kaze
>movies
Patema Inverted
You should also add a category for mystery for which I would recommend:
>mystery
Shinreigari
No.82805
>>82798
>Usagi Drop
You will incur the hatred of many a "daughterfu" amerilard with that one.
Daichi did nothing wrong, I would've fucked her too if I was in his shoes
>>82744
For Scifi I the mecha hipster nominate Zegapain, Argento Soma or Gasaraki. Maybe even Zaion I Wish You Were Here but I only like that series because it had biomechanical power armors like the Guyver and drones.
No.82808
>sci-fi
Gundam Wing
>fantasy
Death Note
>slice of life
School days
>action
Boku no pico
>drama
Sword Art Online
>movies
Yugioh the movie
No.82815
>>82744
Let's not do an /animu/ recommneds chart. Most of these charts always end up with the most generic trash and flavor of the month bullshit recommended by the biggest shiteaters that spam the thread.
No.82817
>>82744
The better option is to have a number of smaller charts. That way you don't have wars between older sci fi and newer sci fi, or having to choose between two really good SOLs. You can just have a post-2003 sci fi chart and a pre-2003 sci fi chart, and include multiple shows on each. And you can sort them by more useful tiers "start here", "if you like cyberpunk", "if you like spaceships", etc.
Even if we were to stay with one, I would strongly suggest different categories. Movies being its own category is absolutely retarded, either include movies with TV shows or do separate TV and movie charts. There should be separate categories for isekai and fantasy, and there should also be a comedy category. There are probably more I can't think of as well.
No.82822
>sci-fi
power rangers
>fantasy
avatar the last airbender
>slice of life
clarissa
>action
xiao xiao
>drama
bible black
>movies
emergence live action
No.82841
>>82815
Seems easy enough to spot them so far.
No.82887
>>82805
Why would he get hatred for Usagi Drop? Also obviously Daikichi did nothing wrong, he was great the whole time
No.82888
>>82887
Daikichi did nothing wrong
>they were not blood related
>he never signed adoption papers
>they only fugged when she was of legal age
You all hating on Daikichi over nothing.
No.82890
Can we add a post apocalyptic category?
No.82891
>>82805
I just finished Zegapain. It was really good but holy shit was there a lot of exposition.
No.82895
>>82888
Really? Did that spoiler happen in the manga? So ojisan didn't fug the girl?
No.82898
>>82895
Yep. It comes to a time when the only thing holding them from doing it is that they are supposedly related. But then her whore of a fucking mother comes out with the truth: She got pregnant, and the old man allowed her to take the baby to his home to care for her, and later when she decided to disavow the child - while still keeping her job as a maid - he decided to "adopt" her by claiming fatherhood so as to not give the baby a complete dumpster fire of a background
No.82902
Composition of every guide ever:
75% same shit that everybody knows, but none have actually watched
25% personal taste pushed through authority, with asspull reasons
I studied cinema. Then I worked with a famous critic and woke up. Theory only exists to put order in history, while new stuff is always received a-critically through bias and convenience.
No.82906
>>82902
>I studied cinema
I'm sorry to hear that, anon. My thoughts and prayers.
No.82911
>>82890
Sure. If we don't get a bunch of them I'm just going to put it in with scifi though.
No.82912
>>82911
It's pretty much a genre unto itself.
No.82913
>>82911
Recommending Jinrui wa Suitai Shimashita for post apocalyptic.
No.82928
>>82888
>>82887
Hmmm, weird I remember back in 2011 /a/ hated the ending to Usagi Drop's manga so much it became an EBIC MAYMAY to post an image of the girl saying
I want to have Daikichi's baby
But I guess people here have gotten so conservative over the years that "child grooming" doesn't feel like a crime to them at all. To which I have to agree, raising a child to be your wife isn't really a bad thing. Not gonna lie if shitskins do it to races worth a fuck I do rage however.
No.82929
>>82891
>it was really good
The animation was shit, tbh I only watched Zegapain because of the plot twists. Also that depressing OP really got stuck in my head.
No.82930
>>82929
I'd have to agree. You shouldn't watch Zegapain for the fights. They're tertiary.
No.82992
>>82898
Really? Huh I'm not against loli romances but in the case of Usagi Drop it seems wrong to me, it's too sweet and wholesome to be sexual even if they weren't blood related and Daikichi was just a non blood adoptive father that would have been fine by me honestly. So does Daikichi fuck her in the end?
>>82928
That rage you feel should probably apply to everyone who does it irl.
I don't want to derail the thread with politics so if you disagree with my stance I won't argue back but I don't mind hearing you out. But I think that being conservative to the point where you by and large have the same set of ideals as a muslim, yet hate them just because they're shitskins makes you stupid. I see a lot of anons who do think this way and I just don't understand it.
No.83004
r8 my selection, /animu/
>>82744
>scifi
I can't think of anything that isn't popular, so I guess Cowboy Bebop
>fantasy
Likewise the only one I can think of that I'd recommend is Berserk
>slice of life
Saint Young Men is about Jesus and Buddha being wholesome and enlightened while hiding their power levels
>drama
Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatteiru was something I had no expectations for and was pleasantly surprised with how good it was
>movies
Royal Space Force: The Wings of Honnêamise is a damn good film with a damn good soundtrack with comfy, wholesome, and tension. It's a visual a gold standard too
I think comedy would be a good category for a list like this, mainly so I can shill Space Dandy.
>>82784
>Vampire Hunter D - Bloodlust
I see you're a man of culture
No.83011
>>82992
Women were made to fuck, make babbies and be a man's partner, there's nothing wrong in raising a child to grow up to fuck you, rear your children and be your partner. The reason why shitskins piss me off is because their grooming gangs blatantly abuse children through rape, and are used as a spearhead to spread their shitty genetics plus religion of "peace". There's a world of difference between raising and grooming someone so they can be your future partner, and another one in order to use them for sexual depravity plus political goals. If you fail to understand this, you're lost and a feminized cuck.
No.83017
>>83011
>fucking tik tok meme
Don't do that.
No.83024
>>83004
Yeah comedy makes sense as a categpry, let's add that.
No.83033
>usagi drop
if its just the anime then fine, the big plot twist was from the mango and never even hinted at.
electra complex is pretty common in girls and getting over the electra complex is a huge part of their maturation (also why girls who don't have father figures are generally so fucked up).
>>83004
>oregairu
s2 had a completely different tone from s1, and I think it'd fit more as a comedy (s1) or a romance (s2) or as a tragedy overall. the stakes were never high enough to be called a drama in my opinion.
>berserk
as an anime? can't agree
haven't watched the rest
>space dandy
was more scifi than comedy btw
No.83106
>>83033
Are you high? Dandy was balls out comedy.
No.83107
>certain anons upset at Usagi Drop for the millionth time
>steer people away from the manga, the creator's intents don't matter if they make me uncomfortable
Anons being eternally assravaged about this series for pushing a socially unacceptable romance at the end reminds me that even in places as far-removed as this there are still the same kind of faggots that infest every other corner of western anime fandom.
No.83151
>>83107
Anon no one is ass ravaged, the closest one to having a negative opinion about it is >>83033 and that's pretty tame. I guess the second closest would be me where I said
>I'm not against loli romances but in the case of Usagi Drop it seems wrong to me, it's too sweet and wholesome to be sexual
I'm probably going to read the manga anyway but the tonal shift from paternal to sexual is a big one and not liking it in this context doesn't mean you hate it all the time.
I get you want to feel like a superior faggot but you're trying really hard
No.83197
>Action
Motherfucking Karas
It's an over-the-top action OVA that uses CGI for the action scenes only, heavily inspired by old toku shows. It's pretty great, if you haven't checked it yet, look it up.
Here are the first few minutes of the first episode. I thought about editing in only the fight scenes, but it would mess with the music.
>anon those physics make no sense, what the hell is that
Shut up! Action scenes run entirely on rule of cool. It's as logical as it needs to be to look good.
>why is a brick wall exploding
Everything was made of nitroglycerin in old toku shows.
No.83210
I watch more films than shows and OVAs, so this don't reflect my taste very well.
>scifi
Kaiba
>fantasy
The Vision of Escaflowne
>slice of life
*Barely watched any of this. RahXephon is more weird slice of life than mecha so I'll put it here.
>action
Mezzo Forte
>drama
The Sensualist
>movies
Night on the Galactic Railroad
Pics related are some of the better guides I've found.
No.83230
>>83210
That 20th century anime chart made me think. What would a 21st century chart look like? I mean there's gotta be good animu post-2007 r-right?
No.83233
>>83197
Well with Karas you don't need a reason for defying physics. It's fucking magic.
No.83239
>>83230
We're nearly eight decades too early to find out.
No.83250
No.83255
>>83239
We've had almost two decades of content where more and more almost anyone can produce a show. I think the hard part of making such a guide would be the quality, not quantity