>>63150
>Asspull plot twists without foreshadowing are in fact shit, and that makes retcons by extension shit.
Not all retcons are completely without foreshadowing. Even if the continuity they are retroactively adding was not originally intended, they could be built up for quite some time before the reveal. It could be argued that this is the case with Piccolo and Kami's origins, where Toriyama claims he was intending to foreshadow that they were aliens when they spoke to each other at the tournament. Though I agree that's flimsy at best.
Also, some retcons can cleverly allude to details from previous stories which may not have been intended to tie together and imply the retroactive continuity, but can still fit well anyway. That's not to say that certain retcons don't do these things and still suck for other reasons, but they don't suck purely for being retcons. A good example would be Grant Morrison's run on Batman, where the gimmick was essentially taking minor background characters from decades of stories who happened to look similar and saying they were all the same guy, then explaining how his individual roles from those past stories all tied together to form a master plan that culminates in modern day. He retroactively inserted a villain and plot into past stories, but in an interesting and effective way.
>Not only is it meant to write a writer out of the hole they made
Not necessarily. They might just have had a new idea that they wanted to use. And even if it is to write your way out of a previous hole, sometimes that can be done effectively and make for a good story. DC's multiverse was created because The Flash was rebooted, but both the original and the rebooted version of The Flash had met characters like Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman, who had never been rebooted. While the explanation is the most autistic thing to have ever been written, it has resulted in many of the most beloved superhero comics ever, including the initial one that created the multiverse, Flash of Two Worlds. And before you go shitting on superheroes, remember we're in a Dragon Ball thread.
>it's also signs that a story is being made up as it goes along.
Again not inherently a bad thing. There are different styles that work for different things. When comics were invented (I know I'll get crucified for this on this board, but manga is comics), each issue contained many standalone stories, and some were successful enough to get sequels. Eventually some series of sequels were successful enough that they felt confident enough in their continued success to begin introducing cliffhangers, resulting in multi-part stories. Over time this became the norm and now people view the entire series as one long story, but I also wouldn't begrudge them doing shorter stories with sequels, as if that's inherently a bad thing. Dragon Ball consists of multi-part stories, but each arc is essentially its own story and then the next one is a sequel. There's nothing inherently wrong with that.
>No, it's not a stretch to say that the god of the world created a wish granting mcguffin at all.
I agree. It's not a stretch. It's still a retcon. Which is my point. Retcons are not inherently bad.
>What is a stretch is suddenly deciding he's actually an ancient AYYY LMAO who suddenly became religious enough to want to become the god of earth.
It's more like he was an ancient alien who developed great martial arts skills, and martial arts are largely spiritual (or at least they were still treated as such by this point in the series) so his journey eventually lead him to training with God and succeeding him. It's almost exactly what happened with Goku (even before we learned Goku was an alien) except Goku didn't want to actually succeed God after he trained with him.
>but not him NOT being mutated by demon energies, or the fact all of his children came out mutated due to demon energies.
He clearly chose their forms, which may have been an ability he had due to being a demon. The retcon is only that laying eggs is actually an alien ability, not a demon ability.
Do they ever say Piccolo is from the Warrior Tribe? I mean yeah he looks like Nail and is a great warrior, but Kami was a great warrior too and apparently looked just like Piccolo (and therefore Nail) in his youth. If they do say Piccolo is part of the Warrior tribe then yeah they fucked up.