Are there any game franchises whose success has you dumbfounded? Games which you might see why they are somewhat liked but not nearly good enough for them to have a fanatical following. This two come to mind.
The first Uncharted was a sort of tech demo, maybe, but it was really shitty, the second was better, with some good set pieces, but the gameplay itself was shit. They were cinematic experiences first, games second, maybe even third.
And following that line of thought is this fucking hack's game, not of his game are good, but he keeps making them, and they keep giving him more money too. It's probably Sony trying to push the interactive movie, but how people can defend his shit is surprising.