>>14596480
Superman's angst and inner conflict is that he has the personality of a regular guy, but the powers, and thus responsibilities of a god. And not just physically, but socially. He's not actually the most powerful thing around, every issue he fights another thing that is legitimately challenging for him, another villain that's more powerful or cunning than him, but he knows that everyone looks to him to save the day. Meanwhile, he'd probably prefer to just go home and listen to music or something, but you gotta do what you gotta do.
People think of Batman as the everyman superhero because he doesn't have superpowers, but personality-wise, he's very far from the everyman. Superman is the everyman. He's just some guy who grew up on a farm and got an okay job at a newspaper. Batman and Green Arrow and even Blue Beetle are billionaires, Flash and Green Lantern are cops, Captain Marvel is a kid, Hawkman is Indiana Jones, but Superman is a straight up middle of the road most regular guy you can think of, who just so happens to have superpowers and the whole world, including all the other superheroes, look up to him as a god.
>>14596587
Superman has worked with angst many times. But when you talk about optimism, the thing is that that's at the end of the story. Superman can work in dark worlds and can have great inner angst, but he overcomes it. Because that's what a story is. Superman lives in a world with tons of darkness. 9/11 was barely made the news in the DCU because the headlines were stolen by the universe being destroyed by Imperiex. And his plan hinged on infinite universes being killed only a few years earlier by the Anti-Monitor. And Imperiex isn't even considered a real "Crisis" in the DCU. It was nothing compared to what happens there every couple of years, which is about every year or two in-universe. Superhero universes are inherently dark because they involve insane amounts of battle and carnage. But the key is that they don't feel that dark because the protagonists overcome them, which Superman does. He just needs to overcome his inner conflicts as well, and feel optimistic himself. Which again, he usually does, except for in crap adaptations like new movies and Injustice.
As for angst, there are many great Superman stories that show his angst at the responsibility I mentioned, about being adopted and his heritage being wiped out, about various failures like not being able to restore Kandor. We relate to angst, and when Superman feels it and overcomes it, it gives us hope that we can as well.
>>14596607
>That's the issue though, there's only so many stories about "Superman is a good guy" and "Superman punches hard" you can tell before you run out of novel ideas. He works well enough if all you're trying to do is write a story about a strong guy in some whacky universe were crazy shit happens, but if you place him into a continuity how long can you keep inventing new plots before they all blur together?
The continuity helps, because it forms a much more complex reality that allows you to do much more complex stories. The problem is that you have to have 12th level autism to understand them. The mind bending shit that goes on with the multiverse, or Superman battling abstract concepts, or Superman being an abstract concept, is something that has never been adapted properly, and thus casuals don't know about it, but it's great, and much more meaningful than the stuff the casuals do know about.
Then again, you can just keep doing all sorts of crazy sci-fi as well. The character is very versatile. When you really look into it, Superman hasn't punched Brainiac as many times as you think. And you can always change Brainiac into another form again. Plus, most Superman stories aren't even about punching. Villains come up with issues that can't be solved by punching, hence Superman is still at a disadvantage.
>>14596936
Removing Superman from the DCU would remove him from most of his best stories. These long running characters have the multiverse built into them. How many Superman stories do people care about from before he first teamed up with Batman in the mid '50s? Very few, and most of those are from his first two or three years of publication.
Superman has cool concepts and characters that are intrinsically his, but there are so many more that involve DCU stuff that you're basically cutting off at least half of your good Superman stories without them.