[–]▶ 80d4c8 (1) No.11404>>11410 >>11482 >>11487 [Watch Thread][Show All Posts]
I'm re-watching DS9 and I just finished The Assignment, in which Kuntko is taken over by some entity that makes her take her true form -- total fucking cunt sociopath piece of shit. Obrien cucks out as usual rather than allowing Kuntko to kill their elliott rodger loli and itself.
I really hate everything about Kuntko and her full-force shrill awful cuntiness and total disregard for obrien as a man is ruining any of the enjoytment i should be getting out of watching the chief onscreen.
I am asking fellow haters to post autistic rants for everyone's enjoyment.
▶ 11c0dd (1) No.11410
>>11404 (OP)
Fun fact: the actress who played Keiko is married to the guy who voiced Kain in the Legacy of Kain series.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11413
Irishmen are meant to have terrible wives. Why do you think they drink so much?
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11414>>11439 >>11505
>I am asking fellow haters to post autistic rants for everyone's enjoyment.
I feel more for O'brien tbh. He's an actual working man in the Feds galactic machine. He's fought in actual wars that the Feds like to sanitize or memory hole. He does his job and duty diligently without any pretension or grand soliloquys. Fedfucking faggots who wants to inject all types of shit diversity will call O'brien cis normalfag. I know some of you fucks probably does too.
But you know what, he's that normalfag who'd help you out when you're in a jam and you don't know a bottle of yamak sauce from a bucket of self sealing stembolts. He's that normalfaggot who just wants to have a pub night out with his BFF Bashir, build autistic but harmless holosuite legos. He's got some lingering issues from the cardies war that the Feds barely acknowledge, but he soldiers the fuck on. Even when life and circumstances gives him an opportunity to break away from his shrew wife. He still remains faithful to his vows and his word as a man, the guy still genuinely tries to love his wife and cares for his daughter.
Chance are you know someone like O'brien in your life, and you didn't even realize it. He might be your co-worker, your neighbor, your twice removed uncle. Next time you see him on the transporter room, or repairing a jeffreys tube or a food replicator, give him a pat on the back and a "thanks for your hard work chief". A little appreciation goes a long way for a working man like O'brien. The forgotten man, the downtrodden man, the man who fixes things and get the hard shit done no matter what.
▶ cfb5a4 (1) No.11431
>Driving a man to the depths of hell while he is still living
Truly a cunt of unimaginable proportions.
▶ 7b1ff8 (5) No.11439>>11445 >>11454 >>11489
>>11414
O'Brien's suffering is a little understated. DS9 is a goddamned clusterfuck of awful ancient Cardie technology, ramshackled together with Federation tech in a constant state of failure and self-destructive incompatibility. This was probably even by design, because the Cardassians were such dicks that they probably littered the whole place with intentional faults and failure points just so the place would never be fully usable by anyone who took it over after them.
…And O'Brien kept that shit running for 7 fucking years, with nothing but a couple of Ferengi retards for helpers.
▶ f8c740 (7) No.11445
▶ 235dc4 (1) No.11447>>11458
Keiko was one of the few ST characters that I consistently disliked, the others being Kes (way too smug), Rom (too JarJar Binks), and literally everyone in Discovery except for that cute robot-looking chick who hasn't spoken yet.
▶ 1929bb (5) No.11454>>11456
>>11439
Chief Petty Officer Miles Edward O'Brien.
>Given the least glamorous posting Star Fleet could find him.
>After years spent as a glorified deck hand on the Enterprise this was meant to be his step up.
>He's now responsible for a technological abortion of a station (that the spoonheads intentionally sabotaged).
>His work crews are primarily feckless bajoran natives rather than experienced or even trained engineers.
>Still manages to keep things running.
>His wife is pretty much emotional abuse personified, giving him every reason for a divorce or even just to throw himself into his work and forget he has a family.
>Still comes home every nigh with a smile and does his best to be a good father to his child even as she starts to pick up her mothers bullshit.
>Dominion war breaks out, large numbers of green Junior Officers start salivating about 'muh glory' like some drunken Klingon.
>The veteran Chief (who saw some shit during the first Cardassian War) doesn't flip out but keeps his calm and does his job following these dumb kids.
>Repeatedly tortured in every possible way the writers could think of (they literally sat down and asked "How can we make Chief suffer next?")
>Literally stands up against and shouts down an evil deity (Episode 'The Story Teller')
>Doesn't punch Bashir in the face
>Has every reason to seek and be granted a medical discharge, or even just a period of leave to recuperate.
>Doesn't matter. The Chief still did his god damned job, and raised his kid, no matter what.
O'Brien deserved better.
Keiko must suffer.
▶ f8c740 (7) No.11456>>11459
>>11454
Is O'Brien the most virtuous character in all of Star Trek?
▶ 5156b3 (3) No.11458>>11467 >>16427
>>11447
>Kes
how can you possibly hate this face?
▶ 1929bb (5) No.11459>>11480
>>11456
I honestly can't help but admire him and I can't think of any other ST character, from any series no, not even Porthos, who serves as such a strong example of the stoic ideal of virtue.
If I ever become a father my kids will sit down and watch DS:9, whether they like it or not, and they will learn from the example of the Chief.
Because, at the end of the day
Chief gets shit done, no matter what
▶ f8c740 (7) No.11467
>>11458
Indeed. It's a shame.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11470>>11478
Keiko was the Federation's secret weapon in case of Dominion invasion.
▶ 5e4eef (2) No.11478>>11509
>>11470
Aye, because no Changeling could possibly turn into her and fully emulate her bitchiness.
▶ 7b1ff8 (5) No.11480>>11485 >>18278
>>11459
I remember reading an interview where they talked about using characters like Miles O'Brien to have some real, grounded humanity in the series after every character on the main TNG cast came out looking God-like and infallible. This manifested with them making him suffer in every possible way, but because he wasn't some high and mighty paragon of enlightenment and willpower, it made his character far more admirable and likable.
▶ 3b8774 (1) No.11482
▶ 5084de (1) No.11485>>11496
>>11480
>This manifested with them making him suffer in every possible way
▶ fa7058 (10) No.11487>>11511
>>11404 (OP)
Nope, she was alright. She had an actual career and wanted to do it.
▶ fa7058 (10) No.11489>>11652
>>11439
>Ferengi retards for helpers.
Nog had little education but experience. And yet, he did quite well.
▶ 1929bb (5) No.11496
>>11485
Jesus, tittyfucking, christ. Just look at his face. This is a man who knows he's just made the worst decision he could ever possibly make in any possible universe. Credit to him, he's holding back the screaming and pleas for mercy as best he can, but just … just look at his eyes. That is a man facing his firing squad and trying to put on a good show for the last few seconds of his life.
▶ 19b868 (1) No.11505>>11510
>>11414
STD should have been about the Chief in one of those wars.
▶ 7cdb43 (3) No.11509
>>11478
>evil Bajoran spirit from the Fire Caves takes over Keiko in a DS9 episode, she becomes a horrible abusive demon
>her actress acts exactly the same
▶ 1929bb (5) No.11510
>>11505
That would probably have been a bit too grim for strek.
▶ 5156b3 (3) No.11511>>11515
>>11487
>abloo abloo i grow plants in a post-materialistic society, totally a career
▶ 12226d (1) No.11512>>11515
>modern trek
>o’brien gets accused of rape by the cardassian engineer lady
>keiko turns on him, publicly damns him
>wife testimony seals his fate
>he is killed and resurrected endlessly
>at the end of the hour Odo proves he’s innocent
>goes back to living with keiko
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11515>>11517 >>11523
>>11511
Yeah botany seems tricky in the TNG and DS9 portrayal. Technically you have food replicators, though there are more than a few hints that real non replicated food from non replicated ingredients still tastes better. But that didn't get explored further until meh Voyager. There might be an opportunity for world building if botany was treated as part of say terraforming and colonization efforts. But it seemed to be shown in the series as one of the low priority divisions in their timeline.
>>11512
>modern trek
>o’brien gets accused of rape by the cardassian engineer lady
Don't forget
>The writers constantly tweets "we're just trying to start a conversation!"
>When some viewers correctly pointed out the rape accusation was not only false but came after Obrien turned down her advances. Those viewers are accused of victim blaming.
▶ 1929bb (5) No.11517>>11519 >>18295
>>11515
>it seemed to be shown in the series as one of the low priority divisions
From what I could see in DS:9 it was basically Keikos hobby, that she treated like a real job that mattered.
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11519>>11628
>>11517
>From what I could see in DS:9 it was basically Keikos hobby, that she treated like a real job that mattered.
Yeah it's a bit fucked up. Botany could be treated as a serious thing. NASA wants plants in space. Terraforming can involve botany. Astrobotany, xenobotany, the possibilities of treating it as a serious thing is there imo. But even if the show does that, would the character still treat botany as if she's the manager of a flowershop in a galactic cruise ship or formerly cardie military space station.
▶ b3307a (7) No.11523>>11533 >>11552 >>11557
>>11515
>When some viewers correctly pointed out the rape accusation was not only false but came after Obrien turned down her advances. Those viewers are accused of victim blaming
You mean kinda like how Ira reacts to people pointing out causality rate flaws with the Bajoran Occupation?
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11533
>>11523
>You mean kinda like how Ira reacts to people pointing out causality rate flaws with the Bajoran Occupation?
Is his vagina still sandy about that.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11544
>Be Mirror O'Brien
>Work each day as a slave in ore processing trying to stop shit from exploding or being executed
>Get bullied by other Terrans, keep getting called Smiley a name you hate
>Eventually get dragged forcefully along into a Terran rebellion that you never asked for
>Spend every day fighting against tyranny and for your very survival
>Eventually become a leadership figure in the Terran Rebellion as one of the few rational people in a universe full of hotheads
>Suddenly under constant pressure to not just keep yourself alive but everyone around you
>Still at least not married to Keiko
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11552>>11559
>>11523
>people pointing out causality rate flaws with the Bajoran Occupation?
>MFW Lower annual per capita mortality rate than influenza in Canada.
▶ fa7058 (10) No.11557
>>11523
You mean someone actually brought that up to him?
▶ 0fd495 (1) No.11559>>11565 >>11629
>>11552
Not to detract from the shitposting, but typically disease kills more people than war. The 1918 influenza epidemic easily killed more people than World War I
▶ f5b176 (2) No.11565
>>11559
Yes, but that was an epidemic. We're talking typical rates in a first world country with first world healthcare and first world sanitation.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11628>>11638
>>11519
Pretty much, you've got exploratory missions bringing back xenoflora samples on a daily basis (before the dominion war at least) and Bajor going through pretty much constant agricultural crises - both things that could use a botanists skill - and Keiko just starts building a glorified flower garden on DS:9.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11629>>11635
>>11559
Oh yeah, epidemics and plagues are very scary things indeed. But the mortality rate of the Cardassian Occupation of Bajor (15 million total deaths claimed, from a population of approximately 3.8 billion, over a span of 50 years) gives us a lower death rate than a simple, standard issue, non-epidemic, respiratory infection in a first world nation regularly praised for the quality of its healthcare.
Running those numbers the Cardassian occupation killed 7.89 Bajorans per 100'000 every year. Kiras claim that every Bajoran survivor knew someone who had been killed is clearly exaggerated (unless Bajoran society was more close knit and integrated than seems possible, especially given the highly rural population of the world). We're never given a precise breakdown of the 15 million figure, so we don't know how many of those were killed by Bajoran terrorist activity, or the food/medication shortages caused by Bajorans targeting the storage/production facilities as part of their terror campaign against their Cardassian conquerors.
We know, at least, that these figures won't have been bloated by battle casualties during the initial invasion
>"How can there be war crimes when there hasn't been a war? I can understand your wish that there had been a war, your need to indulge some pathetic fantasy of Bajoran soldiers marching to honourable defeat, but in fact you and I know Major there was no war, no glory. Bajor didn't resist, it surrendered."
While that may seem like an exaggerated statement, but consider that Kira doesn't correct or challenge it in any way.
▶ 578f79 (1) No.11635>>11641 >>11649
>>11629
If you consider the death toll was only from direct actions of Cardassian (skirmishes, concentration camps), living in modern Brazil would still be significantly more dangerous than the occupation. My theory is that Bajorans consider being a productive member of the society a form of induced atrocity.
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11638>>11641 >>11647
>>11628
>and Bajor going through pretty much constant agricultural crises - both things that could use a botanists skill - and Keiko just starts building a glorified flower garden on DS:9.
If DS9 is a futuristic version of a frontier re-settling type of story, a Western basically. With O'Brien as the guy the Feds sent because he's the type of nuts and bolts meat and potatoes just FUCKING FIXIT NO MATTER WHAT kind of guy. The type of people you need around to keep a formerly Cardie space fort and transport hub running. Keiko would be that character who thinks opening a school to teach the native ridgenose children the finer points of table setting in high society 19th century Earth is just as important.
>Keiko, some of these kids would be lucky to have 3 bajoran potatoes a day this week, between the bad seismic events interfering with the yields, the questionable governance and the military tensions right now I doubt having 3 types of salad forks is important to the-
<THIS IS IMPORTANT MILES WHY WON'T YOU SUPPORT ME
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11641>>11644
>>11635
>Bajorans consider being a productive member of the society a form of induced atrocity
I'm pretty sure they've got a message from the wormhole aliens they interpret as a prophecy telling them that becoming a productive member of society is Superoppressionrapemurderabuse.
>>11638
She even starts a pissing match with the local religious leaders.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11642>>11657
I just figured that there is someone who suffers as much as O'Brien
>Be Kurn
>Born to a Noble House
>Be a real fucking Klingon
>Skilled squadron Commander who inspires the loyalty of others
>Family is virtually destroyed
>Can't really do much cause your older brother is Worf who is obsessed over his "Federation" and "Muh Honor"
>Despite this eventually get to build up House from scratch by siding with Gowron against Duras and Worf fucks off back to Federation leaving you alone
>Begin to prosper
>Gain a seat on the High Council
>Respected heavily by friends and feared by enemies
>Talk of one day becoming Chancellor of the Klingon Empire
>All this is taken away one day cause Worf once again is retarded and decides to go "Muh honor" and "Muh Federation"
>Suffer humilation of being ejected from High Council, having all your property seized and becoming an outcast while Worf sits comfy in Federation
>Have no way to stop it cause you are the younger brother and don't get a say
>Get denied honorable death and suicide cause of the Federation and Worf
>Only way out is to be surgicially altered and have your memory erased
Still at least not married to Keiko
▶ f8c740 (7) No.11644
>>11641
The wormhole aliens are a bunch of sheltered babbies that quite literally live outside normal time and space. They are sheltered spoiled brats. Of course they think hard work is bad. They don't have to lift a finger. This shit has gone to their heads and they think they are some kind of authority. "Oh noes! Orange creature wants to make a profit! Devolve it because profit is stupid!" Fuck those wormhole aliens.
▶ 405bd8 (2) No.11647>>11664
>>11638
Schools actually are important for occupying powers.
Its not about actually teaching them anything, thats secondary. Its mostly about keeping an eye on what propaganda and ideals the kids are growing up on.
▶ 405bd8 (2) No.11649>>11662
>>11635
It had a super rigid caste system before, one so bad that it forbade their membership into the Federation.
▶ 7b1ff8 (5) No.11652
>>11489
Nog and Rom were actually good engineers, but they were more bumbling liabilities for most episodes that focused on them. I don't hate them, but I can't pretend that they didn't cause more problems than not for O'Brien
▶ b3307a (7) No.11657>>11660
>>11642
Worf did nothing right.
▶ 7b1ff8 (5) No.11660>>11661
>>11657
And he still ended up as Emperor of the Klingons
▶ 7b1ff8 (5) No.11661
>>11660
Sorry. Chancellor, because Clone Klingon Jesus is Emperor.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11662>>11668 >>12049
>>11649
What if the Cardassian "Occupation" was a Federation ploy to get a third party to destablize the caste system of the Bajorans so that it would pave the way for Bajoran membership to the Federation?
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11664>>11673
>>11647
>Schools actually are important for occupying powers.
>Its not about actually teaching them anything, thats secondary. Its mostly about keeping an eye on what propaganda and ideals the kids are growing up on.
That's a true point. Hmm, thinking about the episodes I might have to review it closer to see if I need to revise my impression on whether the character was trying to teach some practical things as well. I thought the big stink that got kicked off was over the "calling wormhole aliens vs calling them The Prophets", Keiko was not in the wrong if she was trying to say it in the scientific context.
It's been a while but heh, I completely forgot another episode.
http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Keiko_O%27Brien
http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Time%27s_Orphan_(episode)
>Keiko had to deal with the loss of Molly who, while on a picnic on Golana, fell through a time portal three hundred years into the past. Molly returned as an eighteen-year-old who had grown up in a prehistoric era and could not adjust to the modern era. After attempts to rehabilitate her failed, Keiko and Miles let Molly return through the portal, where the older Molly found her younger self and returned young Molly to her parents. (DS9: "Time's Orphan")
That was a weird episode.
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11668>>11693
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>11662
That'd be some Section31 level cloak and dagger. Then again it's not completely implausible, the official story is of course the Feds just wants to help the Bajorans, and have them join into Club Fed. The more cynical take is the strategic value of the stable wormhole is what the Feds or at least section 31 really wants.
▶ a091e2 (1) No.11673>>11680
>>11664
>Keiko was not in the wrong if she was trying to say it in the scientific context.
Keiko was being a cunt. There is such a thing as age appropriate teaching. You don’t need to do lessons on prolapsed anuses with elementary schoolchildren, you can hold off on telling them the Prophets are called Wormhole Aliens.
The Federation just wanted to fedora tip.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11679
>Look up Mirror Universe Keiko
>She enters a relationship with Broca
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11680>>11713
>>11673
>Keiko was being a cunt. There is such a thing as age appropriate teaching.
Hmm, there might be a complication on that one unless my memory is wrong. The class she was teaching was mixed age wasn't it? Closer to a one room schoolhouse type of deal. The oldest kids was Jake and Nog, but there might have been younger ones. Jake and Nog can understand the different context, while much younger ones might not understand yet.
>You don’t need to do lessons on prolapsed anuses with elementary schoolchildren, you can hold off on telling them the Prophets are called Wormhole Aliens.
But prolapsed anuses are great scientific analogy to the wormhole itself. :^) Yes I keeed.
>The Federation just wanted to fedora tip.
For all the shit that the Feds have encountered throughout the galaxies, weird anomalies and basically godlike beings. It really does hang on to the fedora way too hard at times.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11693>>11694
>>11668
Wouldn't that mean Section 31 were aware of the stable wormhole before it was officially discovered? I'm not saying that's impossible, but it's a story I would love to see.
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11694>>11701
>>11693
>Wouldn't that mean Section 31 were aware of the stable wormhole before it was officially discovered? I'm not saying that's impossible, but it's a story I would love to see.
Yeah it's definitely not impossible. The only story concern would be making section 31 too powerful and 31 steps ahead of everyone. That shit can get boring fast. But space CIA level with network of spies that rivals the rest of the factions like tal shiar obsidian order etc. Yeah gimme a bit more of that cloak and dagger storylines.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11701>>11806
>>11694
Still maintain DS9 missed out a golden opportunity to have Garak take on Section 31.
▶ 7b5c19 (1) No.11705>>11711 >>12050
I kinda don’t like Section 31. Not because I dislike the idea that the Federation does questionable shit, but because they were too powerful and effective.
The Federation having a secret police that can BTFO the Tal Shiar or Obsidian Order is just not very believable.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11711>>11714
>>11705
>The Federation having a secret police that can BTFO the Tal Shiar or Obsidian Order is just not very believable.
I always thought that was the point of Section 31
>Civilised people sleep softly in their beds at night only because they know that rough men stand ready to visit violence upon those who would harm them.
Star Fleet, and the Federation in general, are only non ridiculous if there is an underhanded space CIA doing the job of the Obsidian Order for them while also protecting them from the underhanded bastards working for the other powers in the sector.
▶ 13aefa (2) No.11713
>>11680
>The class she was teaching was mixed age wasn't it?
Not only mixed age, but also mixed species. Only the Bajoran students would give a shit about whether they were called prophets or aliens.
▶ 0d8a20 (1) No.11714>>11728 >>11730 >>11747
>>11711
IMO it doesn’t work that way. “Open” societies have historically awful intelligence services. The CIA is barely competent.
>Civilised people sleep softly in their beds at night only because they know that rough men stand ready to visit violence upon those who would harm them
I don’t put much stock in this quote. It is generally the justification for lobbing cruise missiles at tents while beaners flood over the border.
▶ b3307a (7) No.11728>>11730
>>11714
It had a bit more stock 50+ years ago, not so much now. Even so, your modern interpretation of the quote would still be quite in line with what we see the Feds doing on air. And keep in mind, we also only see Section 31 really coming into its own after both the Obsidian Order and the Tal Shiar were simultaneously ruined. In the OO's case rather permanently by the looks of it. Any event, Klingon Intelligence seems to be rather limited out of the other competition, so S31 gets a freer hand after that.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11730>>11731
>>11714
>“Open” societies have historically awful intelligence services
Because the Federation is an "Open" society.
>The CIA is barely competent.
Didn't stop them setting up literal RWDS in El Salvador, or aiding/creating hard right governments all over South America (most likely strengthening the modern left in these countries for decades to come), training 3rd world dictators pet psychopaths in the finer side of torture, Warrant/charge-less arrests and imprisonment (i.e. illegal state sponsored abduction and confinement), conducted illegal human experimentation (Church Committee, Rockefeller Commission), carried out international campaigns of assassination since the end of WW2, and christ knows what else that hasn't been declassified/leaked yet.
Consider what would happen to Star Fleet and the Feddies without something like S31 working for them. How long would it be before the entire Federation Counsel was subverted by the Tal Shiar?
>>11728
>Klingon Intelligence seems to be rather limited
<I AM GORKON, SON OF TOQ, OF THE HOUSE OF MAKOK, SERVING THE EMPIRE WITHIN THE RANKS OF THE KLINGON IMPERIAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY!
<I MEAN THAT I AM A COMPLETELY UNREMARKABLE ANDORIAN GRAIN TRADER.
<NOTE HOW MY SKIN IS PAINTED BLUE.
<SAY, FELLOW HONOURLESS MERCHANTS, HAVE YOU HEARD ANY MILITARY SECRETS LATELY?
Yeah, the Klingons are kinda out of their depth in anything that doesn't involve a Bat'leth or a disruptor
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11731>>11733 >>11735 >>11915
>>11730
Klingons find espionage dishonruble although seem to weirldy be very well informed most of the time about things going on in galactic affairs as well internal politic of other powers
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11733>>11735 >>11742
>>11731
To be entirely fair to the Klingons, while they may suck at infiltration, can you imagine anyone being better at interrogation? The process might not be as elegant as the Tal Shiar, or as cold as the Obsidian Order, but it would definitely work.
▶ 8fe93c (5) No.11735
>>11731
>>11733
>Klingons suck at infiltration
Ah, but you forget: without those tribbles on K-7, Sherman's Planet would have literally starved to death. The Klingon's mission went off without a hitch until that moment. And then there's how well General Chang pulled off his subterfuge in ST6. Klingons can do subtlety, and arguably are all the more dangerous for that fact not being common knowledge.
▶ 7d813b (4) No.11742>>11744 >>11746
>>11733
>Those guys with the cloaking ships and shit sure must suck at sneaking into places…
I also doubt they'd be particularly good at torture. Its not exactly honourable to gouge a defenceless prisoners eyes out after all.
The real trick to klingon intelligence work though, is to understand the klingon concept of honour. For example, they have assassins, corrupt politics, backstabbing and cloaking devices on all their warships **or nearly all* and consider civilians perfectly acceptable targets.
This would seem to suggest they likely don't consider sneaking up on an unsuspecting enemy, lying and such dishonourable.
It seems that the klingon concept of honour, if anything, has more in common with the likes of IRL pragmatic warrior societies where victory at any cost and loyalty are just about the only virtues you had to live up to.
▶ 7d813b (4) No.11744>>11746
>>11742 continued
Forgot to point out, in practical terms, torture is a highly ineffecient means of gathering intelligence, since a skilled torturer can make a victim say anything, and theres no easy way to tell the difference between someone who is still holding out and feeding your false in formation, and someone who will say anything to make you stop.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11746
>>11744
>>11742
I was thinking more intimidation than torture, although that probably shares many of the same problems.
▶ 7cdb43 (3) No.11747>>11766
>>11714
>“Open” societies have historically awful intelligence services.
not to start an argument, but there are some exceptions to that rule. MI6 was a powerhouse during WW2, while the Abwehr was a joke.
also the CIA is pretty decent at what it does, the problem is "what is does" is not "what it should be doing."
▶ b4dd4e (1) No.11766>>11767 >>11784 >>11785 >>11806 >>11948
>>11747
>not to start an argument, but there are some exceptions to that rule. MI6 was a powerhouse during WW2, while the Abwehr was a joke.
The Germans were honorable. MI6 and the OSS were communist sympathizing orgs with ties to the NKVD.
>also the CIA is pretty decent at what it does, the problem is "what is does" is not "what it should be doing."
The CIA is full of retards. They wanted to use a goddamn umbrella to kill Castro. The KGB ran circles around them.
▶ 8fe93c (5) No.11767>>11768 >>11774 >>11784
>>11766
>The Germans were honorable. MI6 and the OSS were communist sympathizing orgs with ties to the NKVD.
Irrelevant. Honor does not mean effective.
Incidentally, I love how the designated Keiko Hate Thread became an appraisal and discussion of intelligence agencies fictional and real.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.11768
>>11767
You should wait till it devolves into burger posting.
▶ 990a6d (1) No.11774
>>11767
>Honor does not mean effective
They were not a closed society is my point. They were a healthy society which sought to be free of the Jew.
>Incidentally, I love how the designated Keiko Hate Thread became an appraisal and discussion of intelligence agencies fictional and real.
I think we all agree Keiko is horrible.
▶ b3307a (7) No.11784
>>11766
>The Germans were honorable. MI6 and the OSS were communist sympathizing orgs with ties to the NKVD.
Yeah, and? That's like saying the Dominion are bad spies because they'll nuke your civilization the moment you politely tell them they are a little out of line. They're assholes, but that won't stop them from doing a number on you behind the scenes. The Klinks found that out the hard way.
>The CIA is full of retards. They wanted to use a goddamn umbrella to kill Castro. The KGB ran circles around them.
The CIA's pretty bad when it comes to protecting the US, that's pretty obvious, but it's quite effective when it wants to do something actively harmful to it or at least out of pure self-interest.
>>11767
>Incidentally, I love how the designated Keiko Hate Thread became an appraisal and discussion of intelligence agencies fictional and real.
Outside of writing haikus about how much Keiko sucks, there's only so much you can say when you have a despicable character like that. Or someone similar like, say, Wesley. Wonder if Rosalind is as much of a bitch in real life as her fictional counterpart was, given the co-relation between Wil and Wesley.
▶ e045ed (1) No.11785
>>11766
Germans were retarded you mean?
▶ a9b77f (10) No.11806>>11809 >>11815
>>11766
>The CIA is full of retards. They wanted to use a goddamn umbrella to kill Castro.
The CIA can stay in Section31, for entertainment sake alone they are worth it. Soviet era level talent can of course find a home in Section 31 as well, any of earth's historical cloak and dagger agencies really.
Sheeit, maybe they have old grudges that flare up from time to time to keep Sec31 not too boringly overpowered story wise, since that type of backstabbing is not unheard of in any organization. Let alone a super sekrit space spy agency.
>>11701
>Still maintain DS9 missed out a golden opportunity to have Garak take on Section 31.
That could have easily been a 3 parter that I'd watch.
▶ 8fe93c (5) No.11809
>>11806
Worth noting is that the current Russian intelligence service killed a man by sticking him with a pollonium-tipped umbrella. Not nearly as silly as it sounds.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11815
>>11806
>maybe they have old grudges that flare up from time to time to keep Sec31 not too boringly overpowered story wise
Have it actively encouraged by S31 command. Have them slowly give each cell the impression that other S31 cells around them are suspect, or even potentially rogue, and have them start to investigate each other. Have Sloane or his bosses talk about how that 'helps keep them sharp' or something similar.
▶ 13aefa (2) No.11844>>11845 >>11866
>Chao's parents were instrumental in her decision to pursue acting;[4] she began at the age of five in a California-based Peking opera traveling company at the instigation of her parents who were already heavily involved, and during the summers they sent her to Taiwan to further develop her acting
I think I understand now why she's so bitchy, she had pushy asian parents who never showed her any love.
I also found this picture which gives some insight as to why O'Brien put up with her for so long.
▶ 7afb5f (1) No.11845
>>11844
I don’t think the actress is actually a bitch. Kain wouldn’t be married to her.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11866>>11880
>>11844
>Body of an ugly 12 year old
>Literally Keiko
>There is no excuse
▶ f5b176 (2) No.11880>>11881 >>11886
>>11866
>Body of an ugly 12 year old
Either your hate has blinded you, or you've seen some twelve year olds that are ridiculously curvy for their age.
▶ 5b9e15 (1) No.11881
>>11880
On a chan no woman rates above a 3, but an obvious boy in a wig is 14/10 OMIGAWD BOIPUCCI
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11886>>11892
>>11880
>Either your hate has blinded you
Are you trying to imply that there is such a thing as 'too much hate for Keiko'? That doesn't make any kind of sense and you know it.
▶ f8c740 (7) No.11892>>11893
>>11886
The two are not mutually exclusive.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11893>>11898
>>11892
Keep telling yourself that
▶ f8c740 (7) No.11898>>11899
>>11893
I'm secure in my hatred. Are you?
▶ f8c740 (7) No.11899
>>11898
This is the picture I meant to post, but the bebop one actually works better.
▶ bb7d24 (14) No.11915
>>11731
>(Klingons) seem to weirldy be very well informed most of the time about things going on in galactic affairs as well internal politic of other powers
Maybe it's less about intelligence gathering and more about the Klingons just assuming that everyone is going to act according to character.
>You know the Federation is going to meddle while pretending to keep their hands clean.
>You know the Cardassians are going to want to keep to themselves and just try to run their authoritarian society as efficiently as they can.
>You know the Romulans are going to do everything they can to be underhanded, manipulative, bastards on every level possible.
>You know the Vulcans are going to make Starfleet do all the heavy lifting so they can sit in their temples and jerk off about how logical they are.
>You know the Orion Syndicate are going to run organised crime everywhere and make a shit load of money.
>You also know, as a Klingon, that they're all out to get you, and that they don't have the balls to run at you bellowing as they wave a sharp piece of metal.
▶ d4c00f (1) No.11945>>11949
I think Klingons as dumb warriors is largely subverted by the shows. In TOS they were quite underhanded, to the point they doctored a Klingon to appear human to poison grain.
Klingons obviously have good engineers and good spies. I think they carefully keep these two groups out of sight of aliens so they see the Klingons as brutish and dumb, when in fact they always have advanced ships and seem to be pretty good at knowing what’s going on in the quadrant.
▶ fa7058 (10) No.11948>>11975
>>11766
>The CIA is full of retards. They wanted to use a goddamn umbrella to kill Castro
If they were serious about being pissy with a Communist Cuba, they would have invaded and reinstalled a puppet regime.
▶ fa7058 (10) No.11949
>>11945
Yes, its excellent propaganda. They have merchants as well, that aren't bullied too hard or often, and they have the concept of civilians.
▶ b3307a (7) No.11975>>11977 >>12051
>>11948
>If they were serious about being pissy with a Communist Cuba, they would have invaded and reinstalled a puppet regime
There was the Bay Of Pigs, but Kennedy called that off. Didn't win him friends with the Cuban anti-communists in Florida nor the CIA. Actually Kennedy was really good at making people upset in retrospect, those two groups were one of many. One of those many might have done something about it, too.
▶ 4a3297 (1) No.11977>>11984 >>12001 >>12039 >>12051
>>11975
>but Kennedy called that off.
No, he didn’t. He let it go ahead and it was a massive failure. The CIA went on old reconnaissance data and made the amphibious landing at the site of a naval base. It was a massive disaster.
▶ 7d813b (4) No.11984>>12001
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>11977
Kennedy let it go ahead with some changes to the plan, like landing in an out of the way place instead of in trinidad, which meant that the nearest mountains, which where supposed to be a fallback position from where the troops could fight a guerilla campaign, where over 80 miles away through swarmps, instead of right next to the landing area.
Mind you, the reason Kennedy wanted the plan changed was to make it less obvious the US was behind, to limit the amount of support the Soviets would send, since an open american invasion of Cuba would likely have resulted in Soviet intervention and thus WWIII.
Since the fiasco of the invasion DID lead to the Soviets sending military support to Cuba, including nuclear missiles, it DID lead more or less directly to the cuban missile crisis. So its not like this was a baseless concern for Kennedy.
▶ b3307a (7) No.12001
>>11977
He let the Cuban spearhead go through, but he called off the final means that would have ensured success: direct military intervention. Afterwards he allowed the CIA to do all the retarded shit people were talking about a few posts ago in Operation Mongoose. In any event, he blinked.
>>11984
The USSR would have sent nukes over anyway eventually, the failure of the operation merely hastened their deployment. Castro was already in line with the general ideology; not quite to the extent that Che was perhaps but he was a true believer. Plus there's also a practical concern in that, you are only 90 miles away from a country that does not like you very much and has a much larger military than you do. It would have been foolish for him not to have allowed the Russians to do whatever they wanted in exchange for protection. But again, BoP just made an inevitable concern all the more pressing.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.12028
You know there are times I have to double check that I am on /strek/ and not on /k/ this board is really /k/omfy
▶ 190299 (2) No.12039
>>11977
>He let it go ahead and it was a massive failure.
That's because the CIA didn't disclose the fact that the Russians already knew about the invasion plan for the Bay of Pigs. The CIA was trying to force Kennedy to invade Cuba, and, when he refuse to use their plan, they didn't disclose the info and set it up to fail.
http://the-puzzle-palace.com/files/crimesoimmense.pdf
▶ fa7058 (10) No.12049>>12080
>>11662
Didn't the occupation of Bajor happen concurrently with the Federation-Cardassian War? As in, Cardassia was already occupying Bajor went they had their war with the Federation?
Yeah. It had to, because Cardassia was still occupying Bajor during a large portion of TNG, and O'brien wasn't that old in TNG, and Bajor was Cardassian territory for decades right?
No, when the Cardassian-Federation War that O'Brien fought in prior to TNG occured, that whole area was heavily disputed, partially because Cardassia occupied Bajor and the Federation already had some settlers on the otherside of Bajor and were getting mixed up with Cardassian settlers.
I think the Federation-Cardassian treaty may have included a secret clause about the scheduled withdrawal from Bajor, leaving the station there and intact, in exchange for de facto Cardassian sovereignty over the disputed territories that would become the Maquis areas.
Some real bastardry there, but theoretically understandable if the Federation was concerned about appearing to be just another expansionist, imperialist power, that in fact WAS subverting and adjusting aliens cultures as necessary for future admission into the Federation, minimizing future threats and increasing its strength. Which it most likely WAS, but being obvious about it is detrimental, and would provoke a lot of bad blood from its neighbors if they became aware.
Its likely the Klingons hated them for this very reason, and its half the reason the Romulans are so paranoid. That bald Lt who became Maquis? He was right.
No, I'd assume the majority of Section 31 isn't mad supervillain shit, but just long term cultural subversion and adjustment to prepare potential enemies to become allies, working alongside or even as diplomats in some cases, and small nudge cloak and dagger, rumors and blackmail type shit.
Basically, NATO.
▶ fa7058 (10) No.12050>>12061
>>11705
>The Federation having a secret police that can BTFO the Tal Shiar or Obsidian Order is just not very believable
The Klingon one is even more effective.
▶ fa7058 (10) No.12051
>>11977
>>11975
No, that was a pathetic excuse of an attempt.
I mean as the Revolution is happening, openly invade with American forces and support Batista.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.12061>>12069 >>12082
>>12050
Klingon secret service is so secret nobody knows about it.
▶ 190299 (2) No.12069>>12074 >>12075 >>12082
>>12061
Not even the Klingons.
▶ b3307a (7) No.12074>>12075 >>12082
>>12069
Not even even the Chancellor.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.12075>>12082
>>12074
>>12069
I feel a meme coming along
▶ fa7058 (10) No.12082>>12083
>>12075
>>12074
>>12069
>>12061
They claim they just order random soldiers to go find out something within a certain timeframe, and expect the said Klingon to be competent and able to do so.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.12083>>12085 >>12422
>>12082
Come to think of it, anyone notice the talking Targs? :^)
▶ 06838e (1) No.12085
>>12083
Talking Targs? What I want to know is why is nobody talking about the chemicals in the water that's turning the fricking Gagh gay?!
▶ 3cc69e (1) No.12209>>12498
>>12091
Is that Keiko shitting out her human side?
▶ 7bdd63 (1) No.12422>>12456
>>12083
>Be Fed shot down on hostile world
>Half a sector fleet is sent to come find me
>Spend only an hour before being rescued
>My rescue is front page news
>Get treated as a hero of the Federation
>Have dinner with the President
>Get exclusive holonovel deal about my traumatic experience
>Be Klingon shot down on hostile world
>Have a nice time camping in the woods for an hour before a Targ with a Ketha Province accent asks if I need help.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.12456>>18284
>>12422
Is that the joke about how the US rescue downed pilots vs UK from Yugoslavian War?
▶ 501d84 (18) No.12494>>13028
>rewatch DS9
>Sisko asks Martok if he was able to decode Maquis transmission that not even the Federation or Cardassians were ever able to break
>Martok just taps his datapad and shows Sisko the transmission
Holy shit the Klingons really are good at intel gathering.
▶ 5e4eef (2) No.12498
>>12209
She lost that long, long ago
▶ 46e742 (3) No.13001
>>12091
>First two pics
Ah, keiko in pain, a beautiful sight if ever there was one.
>third pic
After that she unhinges her jaw and attempts to swallow O'Brien whole, doesn't she.
▶ fa7058 (10) No.13028>>13030 >>13063 >>13071
>>12494
And it nevers clicks. The memetic perception of Klingons as dumb brutes is just too ingrained. Amazing isn't it?
Fun Fact:Ferengi and Klingons are closely related, possibly from the same original homeworld.
▶ 6d060a (1) No.13030>>13040
>>13028
> Fun Fact:Ferengi and Klingons are closely related, possibly from the same original homeworld.
Say what!?
Is this some meta-level shipping going on now? Which Start Trek races are related.
First Vulcan-slash-Romulan, now Klingon-slash-Ferengi. Keep an eye out in your fave fanfic archive.
▶ 7d813b (4) No.13040
>>13030
I've never heard about links between klingons and Ferengi, but there was that rat like lizard fucker they said was a distant cousin of the Ferengi.
Not sure if the writers understood the implications of that though, since the idea was that since quark was naturally immune to Betazoid telepathy so was the other guy.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.13063
>>13028
>Fun Fact:Ferengi and Klingons are closely related, possibly from the same original homeworld.
Excuse me what peta'q?
▶ 46e742 (3) No.13071
>>13028
>Klingons and Ferengi are related.
no
▶ 5156b3 (3) No.13072>>13073 >>13088
rewatching ds9 right now and i just got finished with that episode where obrian is on trial
> O'Brien informs Kovat he loved his parents, and when Kovat suggests spousal abuse on Keiko's part, he indignantly describes her as "the most wonderful, supportive person I've ever known."
i'm starting to think o'brian really might have been the terrorist
▶ 46e742 (3) No.13073
>>13072
>Not recognising Stockholm Syndrome
▶ 501d84 (18) No.13088>>13089
>>13072
I think he was trying to plea insanity.
▶ 8fe93c (5) No.13089>>13094 >>13101 >>13197
>>13088
WHY DO YOU STEAL DUBS?
▶ 448dad (1) No.13094
>>13089
This board is slow. If you can’t get the planet killer going it’s pretty damn sad.
▶ 501d84 (18) No.13101
>>13089
Why do you fail with the Planet Killer?
▶ bd176b (1) No.13197
>>13089
Why did you lose the Planet Killer?
▶ 8f5f55 (1) No.16399
After Wesley dies in all universes we need to kill Keiko in all universes.
▶ c38605 (1) No.16402
>Checking catalog for several hours
>Apparently this thread was bumped 2 hrs ago
>Did not see it on front page till just 5 minutes ago
Did /strek/ meme temporal anomalies into reality?
▶ bcdb71 (1) No.16427
>>11458
It's not the face, it what comes out of her fucking mouth.
▶ 98a526 (1) No.18272
Don't forget that she brought her noisy crying baby into Ten Forward to ruin everyone's off hours.
What a cunt.
▶ 0e980f (1) No.18278>>18284
>>11480
>Miles O'Brien
>not having godlike will power
He had not only stayed married to Keiko but tried to be a good husband, I bet not even fucking Picard could do that shit. I bet he would have offed himself the first few days.
▶ aca70c (5) No.18284
>>12456
Sounds like a story, do you have a greentext?
>>18278
>I bet he would have offed himself the first few days.
Picard would have been driven into a Klingon tier murder frenzy half way through the foreplay on their wedding night.
▶ a352d2 (2) No.18295>>18296 >>18300
>>11517
>it was basically Keikos hobby, that she treated like a real job that mattered.
To be fair; nobody in the Federation is getting paid, so all their jobs are just hobbies. They supposedly do it because they like it, but then it makes no sense that there are any shit posts. Like everybody acts like it's super important for them to have a job, but it's not to support themselves or their families; it's just because every single person somehow has a boner for dumb shit like cleaning waste extraction units when they could be spending all day every day in a holodeck simulation because of glorious space communism that totally works, gais.
Man that shit really phase-shifts my navigational deflector.
▶ 881802 (2) No.18296>>18300 >>18324
>>18295
And the writers don't even try to pretend that all the jobs are honorobru and glorious duties necessary to protect the Federation motherland, and that all the menial shit has been eliminated with automation or whatever. There's a fucking barber on the Enterprise-D. The best barber in Starfleet, apparently, who takes great pride in his work of chopping the ends of hair. This is your brain on communism.
▶ aca70c (5) No.18300>>18329
>>18295
I'm assuming Star Fleet personnel are paid (presumably in latinum) as Quark is unlikely to take 'job satisfaction' as payment for his wares and services.
>>18296
Was there a "society depends on the sacrifice of the turd-wranglers, comrade" moment? Or maybe a non-ironic "Dude, I fucking LOVE waste-processing!" character? Or even just someone who acknowledges that their job is kinda shitty but someone has to do it?
▶ 101df5 (3) No.18304>>18306 >>18342 >>18443
I like it when Keiko gets hurt.
▶ e19df6 (1) No.18306>>18338
>>18304
I thought she was just projecting her bitchyness there
▶ 1d849a (2) No.18324>>18329 >>18337
>>18296
>who takes great pride in his work of chopping the ends of hair.
There is nothing actually wrong with that.
▶ 101df5 (3) No.18329>>18337 >>18342
>>18300
>I'm assuming Star Fleet personnel are paid
Federation credits are a thing. They're no brought up too often because they don't have much use in the Federation due to replicators being common as fuck, but credits are a thing (they were mentioned in TNG).
>Was there a "society depends on the sacrifice of the turd-wranglers, comrade" moment?
Not really but kinda. Rom had to stand all night waist deep in shit to fix a sewage system on DS9 and it was clear that no one wants to do that and that everyone understands it's a shitty job but it needs to be done.
>>18324
I second this comment. There's nothing wrong with taking pride in what you do.
▶ 881802 (2) No.18337>>18341 >>18363
>>18324
>>18329
No, there's nothing wrong with it at all. I'm just saying that expecting personal pride to be an appropriate substitute for the standard of exchange that currency provides is retarded communist bullshit.
▶ 2d67b1 (1) No.18338
▶ 101df5 (3) No.18341
>>18337
Picard is from earth. There's no money on earth. No crime. No overpopulation. No struggle to survive. His views on what all of humanity do, hell even just Starfleet, is skewerd by that. The rest of the Federation operates different to earth. Especially on their colonies.
The Federation has the Federation Credit, still in use during TNG. I think the DS9 officers got paid by Starfleet in Gold-Pressed Latinum which probably required some currency exchanging. They might've exchanged their credits for latinum on station, I can't recall.
▶ aca70c (5) No.18342
>>18304
>This isn't even my final form, Miles!
>>18329
>Federation credits are a thing
True, thanks for pointing that out. I'm also sure that the friendly neighbourhood bartender on DS9 would happily exchange FedCreds for gold pressed latinum at a *very* reasonable exchange rate and handling fee.
>it's a shitty job but it needs to be done.
Not quite what I was going for there. Without the need to fund their lives/pay the bills the average Federation citizen has no incentive to be anything other than a NEET unless he has some kind of driving passion in his life (protip: most people don't have one of those). I'd quite like to see what sort of imageboard analogues they'd have created by then. Would they be planetary or federation wide via subspace?
▶ 1d849a (2) No.18363>>18440
>>18337
Fair enough, but everything is taken care of as far as needs are concerned, so the main motivation would be socializing with other sentients and having something to do with your life.
▶ a352d2 (2) No.18440>>18442
>>18363
>I take orders from surly commanding officers and swim around in the mixed waist-deep feces of dozens of species because how else am I going to have hobbies or a social life?
▶ aca70c (5) No.18442
>>18440
People do some crazy things if you raise them to think a certain way.
▶ 70ab39 (1) No.18443
>>18304
>sheev_shows_mercy_to_obrien.gif
▶ cff25b (1) No.18566>>18604
Does anyone think that Keiko's bitchiness could collapse the wormhole?
▶ 0d2a4f (1) No.18604>>18615
>>18566
Her bitchiness and the sheer force of hot hair she blows is probably what keeps it stable in the first place.
▶ 1c1035 (1) No.18615>>18620
>>18604
wew. I could imagine her as the Federation superweapon.
▶ aca70c (5) No.18620
>>18615
>Director Sloane, I wasn't expecting an inspection!
>Yes sir, 'Project: Hen Peck' is exceeding all our expectations.
>The initial units should be ready for deployment in about 5 weeks.
>Sir, there's just one thing that's been … troubling me.
>Subject One sir, CPO O'Brien, I know why he was selected and that he's probably one of maybe a dozen humans who could take this without breaking
>But sir, he's had enough, he's already lived through more than any man should have to.
>I lost three research assistants just to watching the footage!
>Yes sir, I understand, it's for the good of the Federation.
>Can we at least arrange something nice for him as a reward when we terminate the primary test unit?