[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / animu / arepa / asmr / ausneets / pawsru / sonyeon / vg / wx ]

/christian/ - Christian Discussion and Fellowship

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
Email
Comment *
File
Password (Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.


The Lord is my light and my salvation; whom shall I fear? the Lord is the strength of my life; of whom shall I be afraid?

File: 3133a3c72e71bab⋯.jpg (122.46 KB, 992x577, 992:577, Aristotle-usury.jpg)

3d9a6b  No.699095

Since usury is viewed as evil by many Christians, how do you counter the claim that usury is vital to an economy, that it's necessary for an economy to grow?

7c39da  No.699098

The economy is evil, and should be escaped.

t. early church


6116c0  No.699100

>>699095

The economy should serve humanity and not the other way around.

In this age, economy and money are both idols that we worship as gods.


e13aab  No.699107

>>699095

>usury is vital to an economy

For a modern, unsustainable economy you mean. We were just fine in the Middle Ages. Progress was slower, but we were not worshipping technology and destroying the planet.


89d0c7  No.699115

>usury is vital to an economy, that it's necessary for an economy to grow?

>"if we dont sin, then how can we make lots of money?"

Uh, don't sin and be poor like God wants.


519544  No.699119

Economic growth doesn't supersede morality, growth for the sake of growth is not what we should pursue, but instead center our society around God and the logos. It's better to be poor and save your soul than to be rich and lose it


d50a66  No.699134

File: 2ed1c097b95413b⋯.jpg (13.78 KB, 481x499, 481:499, 2ed1c097b95413bb8e3ab39c8c….jpg)

>>699095

Maybe economic growth isn't the meaning of life?


5e54ee  No.699142

Why are you not a prostitute?


040d5e  No.699143

>>699095

Just become something is efficient doesn't mean it's moral. Usury is an efficient means to gain wealth, but so is slavery. That doesn't mean it's ok.


040d5e  No.699144

>>699134

That picture still gives me feels. I just wish Christ was saying "It's all I need" instead. Don't know why, just sounds better.


bba8dd  No.699145

>>699100

This. Economy used to serve trading between us but now we've come to the point of worshiping the free market as God.

Remember that EU commisioner who said that "the free market will teach Italy to not vote the right wing"? This guy gave me the chills. We're trully heading back to the pagan dark ages.


d50a66  No.699147

>>699144

I love it. Amazing how such a simple, cartoon image sums up the entire Christian faith. God truly is merciful.


6116c0  No.699149

>>699144

Well God does want you.

He may or may not need you, but he definitely wants you.


040d5e  No.699150

>>699149

I thought of it more as "All you need to give me for me to let you in is your heart. It's all I need from you."


6116c0  No.699153

>>699145

>pagan dark ages

I wish we were going back there, at least pagans had laws against unfair dealings, what we are doing now is darker and more evil than anything we've seen before.


a1ef46  No.699154

>>699153

>pagans

Hahahahahaha


5072cc  No.699302

>>699095

>how do you counter the claim that usury is vital to an economy, that it's necessary for an economy to grow?

Why would it be? Money is there to be exchanged for goods or services, it only exists because hauling carts full of whatever you produce is inefficient. Economies grow through work and production, not by magically making money out of thing.


e161f5  No.699320


e161f5  No.699321

>>699142

This is an interesting analogy. Missy likely poster would make more money as a prostitute.

Unrelated; one of the evil fruits of usury: (which I take to be compounding interest. A reasonable return on a financial investment, especially to a venture and not to someone in need, I don't take to be usury or a sin. )

Usury leads to the compounding inflation of prices, especially of real estate. Riding house prices are not good, though they benefit some, but an evil. They prevent their modest families from buying a home, as God intends, without taking on a heavy burden of debt. It's a vicious cycle which leads to the sorry state of servitude we all operate under today, in the West.


19b5c6  No.699340

>>699095

Usury is just bad business. There's no reason to need a guaranteed profit on a loan unless you expect that the business funded by the loan will fail. Investment is licit for this reason, you're buying a real stake in something that you presumably think will succeed, if it goes down then you bear the responsibility. If you don't think it will succeed, you shouldn't be investing in it.

There may be some cases where usurious loans resulted in the funding of something worthwhile which otherwise couldn't have been bankrolled, but this is more than counterbalanced by the immense amount of guaranteed loans which are just designed to knowingly profit off of the shortsightedness of irresponsible people. So much of the economic system being based on an incredible amount of debt which which will inevitably be defaulted upon being treated as a bank's assets is a recipe for the plentiful economic disasters we've had throughout the last century.

Usury could have as easily set us back decades as quickened economic growth or technological progress, to pretend to know for certain either way is just conjecture. What isn't conjecture is the great mass of wealth accumulation in the hands of (((you know who))) and the attendant mass of human suffering which is the result of usury.

>>699321

Investment, that is buying stake in something which may or may not return a profit, is not a sin. All loans for consumption (like how money is "consumed" through being spent) whose sum is personally guaranteed plus interest, is usury and thus morally illicit. The only licit loans for consumption are those given out of a sense of charity, no profit can licitly be made through them. look up zippy catholic's usury faq if you want to know more.


d5a1dc  No.699448

>>699095

Usury, do you mean money-lending as a whole, or at excessive interest? Interest rates should be decided by the market. Pegged too low, you encourage malinvestment, overextension, pegged too high, you dry up credit for new ventures. And if you don't have interest at all, it becomes unprofitable due to there being no remuneration for the time-value of money.

See: School of Salamanca, Ludwig von Mises


9a7398  No.699892

>Usury is necessary for an economy to grow.

First usurious debts that are not backed by anything often trigger an economic crisis.

Second if people do not have money thanks to usury they cannot spend it.

Third it is not necessary for economy.

Fourth it is an evil and rightfully so - seeing the fruits of usury is enough for you to know why God forbids it.


ea483d  No.699968

>>699448

Usury is collecting any interest merely from owning capital.


e385de  No.699990

>>699095

The economy causes white genocide, but communism does too. The old Christians were right. It should all be done away with. Where’s that cap about Anatolia where Christianity was successful and prosperous because it retained its whites while Islam did not. Not to trigger any mutts, but it makes sense God would reserve the top-tier genes for His own flock.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / animu / arepa / asmr / ausneets / pawsru / sonyeon / vg / wx ]