[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / abap / alto / bbbb / brains / shame / startrek / tijuana ]

/christian/ - Christian Discussion and Fellowship

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
Email
Comment *
File
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Flag
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options
Password (For file and post deletion.)

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.


Christchan is back up after maintenance! The flood errors should now be resolved. Thank you to everyone who submitted a bug report!

File: d06fa84a747a501⋯.jpg (20.72 KB, 340x319, 340:319, quiles_ismael.jpg)

be821d No.540471

Fellas is it haram to go to a therapist? My trad friends say they're all a bunch of communist jews, but I need help dealing with some aspects of my life.

What do?

6b34e5 No.540474

>>540471

Nope.

IIRC Hierotheos Vlachos has nice books about this subject.


8f5e0d No.540480

>>540471

Have you tried talking to your priest?


9b3d88 No.540630

There are plenty of Christian therapists, you should try to find one if you think it will help you. Had multiple therapists in the past and none helped significantly until i had a Christian one. He understood my motivations for most things, and helped me in realizing why some of what I wanted to do was hurting me.


8f5e0d No.540646

>>540630

>He understood my motivations for most things

Great point. I can't imagine a Jewish therapist being able to understand a Christian's motivation in the slightest.


11b05a No.540709

>>540471

I've benefited from therapy a lot. You just need a good therapist. There is a lot of power in talking things through, but for multiple reasons your friends and family aren't good targets for unloading piles of childhood trauma.


3f4f5c No.540731

>>540474

>>540480

>>540630

>>540646

>>540709

Thank you. I'll seek therapy and make sure he's not Jewish.


44691d No.540857

File: b02741ce3e34d5c⋯.jpeg (12.05 KB, 192x263, 192:263, images-5.jpeg)

>>540471

Most psychotherapy views serious theism as a mental disorder.

See your spiritual father instead, one with some age and experience behind him.


e2f390 No.540883

>>540471

>they're all a bunch of communist jews

95% are; then there are a few good Christian ones…but very few. My mom knows a couple of them, but I always refused other people's help.

If you can find a good Christian one, then consider asking him/her for help: but like >>540857 suggested, ask your spiritual father.


be41c3 No.541010

>>540857

Or better yet, find a therapist who's a believer.


be6bcc No.541064

>>541010

Yeah, like he said a spiritual father not a jewish quack with a college degree in post-modernism


5c5e32 No.541288

Did Pastor Peale not say, "When one finds themselves sick, it behooves them to send for their preist as they send for their doctor?".


40ac02 No.543497

>>540857

>Most psychotherapy views serious theism as a mental disorder.

True, I've been talking to a girl I met at driving school who's getting a Psychology degree, she eventually asked about my faith and said Christian Orthodoxy was "too quickly destructive" because it inspired too much fervor and strictness. She's a Kardecist and says God doesn't punish and no eternal life exists outside of reincarnation.

Psychologists are Aristotelian by nature; to them, a happy life can only be achieved through moderation, that includes "moderate beliefs" and, if possible, complete unattachment of the spirtitual world and the Christian concept of God.


be41c3 No.543560

>>543497

It's a psychology degree. It tells you how the mind works, not how faith works.

Why can't psychologists understand that?


40ac02 No.543569

File: 1f04b4e78343940⋯.jpg (122.77 KB, 1000x1042, 500:521, kosnichyov-a-monk.jpg)

>>543560

Psychology was created in order to try and fill the nihilistic void that was made up in the 19th century. If you read the Philokalia as a Christian, it feels like a self-help book written by various "psychologists", since Christians are aware that the state of a man's mind is 100% related to his acts of staying true to God.

Atheists and agnostics have nothing to stay true to other than themselves, hence the whole lay study of the mind is a narcissistic exercise with its roots in emptiness of spirit. It will always be better to talk to elders or good spiritual fathers about the issues within your soul as a Christian, for Psychologists are no more than godless scientists - and those will always use their granted expertise to push false godless explanations towards their object of study.


86799c No.543575

Go for spiritual counseling with your priest.


cd0c77 No.543609

>>540471

>>540857

>>543497

>>543569

>>543575

Ok fine I'll post. I'm diagnosed with depression and have been going to therapy for 2 years.

Psychology is a useful science. There are patterns of human behavior and pathology that merit study, and solutions exist to many practical woes of self-sabotage people have today. I've been watching a bunch of Jordan Peterson's lectures and they are very edifying.

It's true that there are problems with the discipline. Going to a psychology for homosexual issues is likely to cause you more damage than help; they'll incite you to jump headfirst into your depravity.

Likewise, a priest can be incompetent in non-spiritual matters.

My recommendation? Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's; and to God the things that are God's.

Therapy for psychological issues, priests for spiritual ones.


40ac02 No.543617

>>543609

I've been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, been to a ward already as well as several therapists. Back then it wasn't my choice given that I was a minor, but in my experience no talk session or medicine ever seemed to have any effect on me like God's truth has.

I stick to my belief that any non-physical issue that one hasn't been dealing with ever since birth is a spiritual one and can be solved with nothing but spiritual exercise, I'm not saying it will be an easy process - it's not - but you can do it.


4fdc46 No.543643

>>540471

Go to an ayahuasca ceremony, I met god and it cured my depression


cd0c77 No.543647

>>543617

>any non-physical issue that one hasn't been dealing with ever since birth is a spiritual one and can be solved with nothing but spiritual exercise

This sounds like it could be true, I don't know. I don't want OP to dismiss something that could help him.


50b975 No.543649

What about a Christian psychologist?


86799c No.543650

>>543609

I'm with depression too. I use anti-depressants to deal with it and don't go full suicidal mode.

I just have to cut the root of my problem now. Do you know what is causing your depression?


cd0c77 No.543655

>>543650

> Do you know what is causing your depression?

phew… that's a difficult question.

My therapist says I don't love myself and choose to be a "thing" that doesn't really live. She's not wrong. Unfortunate mistakes in my parenting and some bad early experiences gave me a tendency for vicious self-criticism and pessimistic viewpoints. As the years piled on these attitudes shaped me in the wrong way, conditioning me into a pathological state of mind. Without motivation to overcome my flaws time passed me by while I did nothing. Sabotaging my own efforts, insulting myself in my mind for it, comparing myself to everyone who was doing better, it served as a vicious cycle that kept spiraling myself further into misery. Even now with an understanding of what is happening to me, change is very difficult. Layers built over many years can't be destroyed immediately.

The key is to achieve things. Keeping myself well kept, sleeping at the right hours, losing weight and working on launching my business. It's not easy since my demons are always there, but little by little I'm getting better.


4fdc46 No.544246

>>543655

Just take some ayahuasca or some mushrooms, or you can't take some pharmajewticals instead if you like instead of God's plants


b75897 No.544320

File: 983f632deadefd6⋯.jpg (57.56 KB, 500x500, 1:1, sleep-selection-of-shamefu….jpg)

>>540471

>Fellas is it haram to go to a therapist? My trad friends say they're all a bunch of communist jews, but I need help dealing with some aspects of my life.

There are Christian psychs around. Try one of them. If ANY of your issues are going to touch on or revolve around your faith or your relationship with the Lord, you really cannot go to some liberal Manhattan jew from a Woody Allen film – and let's be honest, no /pol/ here, but most psychs do seem to stem from a very specific ethnic group – and expect them to be at all sympathetic, much less helpful to you or your faith regardless any "ethical standards" they allegedly follow.

I am … well, I do regularly sigh when I see this thread regularly come up, not because it isn't a good question, or that therapy is haram, but that there is a learning from all the banter here that the world is haram and that using anything from it is therefore haram. It's all very well to meme this, but we've gotta be clear that some peoples are sufficiently messed-up in the head that some help is required in untangling the mess. And, sometimes that can just be an experienced spiritual father – and what I wouldn't give for them to have a minimum in psych training – but sometimes it takes a medic with experience unravelling human psychology.

So, let's be REAL clear when we say this:

>Psychologists are Aristotelian by nature >>543497

>Most psychotherapy views serious theism as a mental disorder. >>540857

Most PEOPLE on this planet view serious Christian commitment as a mental disorder. And most PEOPLE have worldviews that are completely alien to ours. We cannot expect ANYONE of the world to be sympathetic to our ways or our beliefs. BUT, just as there are Christian bricklayers who look to their work of building homes for the homeless, there are Christian Psych's who honour the Lord and want to use their skills to build-up the faithful who, for whatever reasons, have been broken down by this world and its trials. No, this was not possible in the first century, but then people of the first century weren't living in OUR world where the enemies are far more insidious and the environment far more innately toxic. (Though, certainly less physically dangerous.)

I just find this attitude >>543569 somewhat contemptible when compared to people with these >>543609 >>543617 >>543650 issues

>>544246

Get lost heretic


a99486 No.544322

>>540471

>Fellas is it haram to go to a therapist?

No. Though it's interesting you use the word "haram". The oldest psychiatric hospital in the world was built by Muslims in the early 700s with the belief that the mentally ill should be treated with dignity.

>they're all a bunch of communist jews

If your friends can only argue using /pol/ buzzwords, then you need to 1) find better friends and 2) disregard the argument.


cd0c77 No.544338

>>544320

well put


d33fa0 No.544369

>>540731

Make sure you don't mention your pathological obsession with Jews though. It may give off a bad impression as to your sanity.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / abap / alto / bbbb / brains / shame / startrek / tijuana ]