1d5913 No.15623044
Just finished Shining Force 2 and want another srpg. Which one is better? Which one is more fun and has more replay value?
I'm a big fan of black and white morality, right and wrong, and from what I've seen of Tactics Ogre it seems to push the post-modern "everything is grey and all your choices are gonna suck" morality instead of having good guys vs bad guys. Is this true?
5c709a No.15623053
Fire Emblem games are mostly vapid trash. I think you'll have more fun with tactics ogre. Try out Rondo of Swords on the DS as well, and also games like Final Fantasy Tactics.
adfb1b No.15623060
1d5913 No.15623071
>>15623060
oh! actually this reminds me I need to finish Jean D'arc first, half way through it. Not sure why this reminded me of JD….
But after I finish that I want to do Tactics Ogre or FE A…
af6c19 No.15623109
>Comparing LUCT to Awakening at all
LUCT is the most mechanically complex of the two by a long shot and it has an actual non-braindead plot, with superior waifus to boot. It does deal in grey morality because every faction is doing its own thing instead of having one definitive bad guy fucking everything up and even then you have Lanselot Tartaros fucking everything up throughout the game. The choices in the story deal in how you would solve the problem and whether you believe that the ends do justify the means.
a48581 No.15623139
>>15623109
>The choices in the story deal in how you would solve the problem and whether you believe that the ends do justify the means.
I believe in actual morality, not "the ends justify the means" nonsense. I don't think a game should force you to pick poorly amongst the lesser evils, or w/e. That's unrealistic and dumb. YOu can have complexity without forcing the player down evil paths
e92387 No.15623143
>>15623044
not so fast; you're not done with Shining Force yet
all 3 scenarios of Shining Force 3 have been translated and it runs fine in SSF
8ccb0f No.15623146
>>15623044
>srpg
it's called Tactical Role Playing Game. For fuck sake's the games are about Tactics, even one of the games you featured in the OP is called "Tactics Oger". The strategy is the big picture overall objective whereas tactics are the specific actions in an encounter.
a48581 No.15623148
8ccb0f No.15623160
**I'm really tempted to get the HD remake of Disgaea on switch but I still don't want to support Nisa
>>15623143
Shining Force: The Sword of Hajya is also worth playing.
>>15623148
I don't really care, ogre can be spelled both ways.
8dceff No.15623166
>>15623139
Then you just go the Chaotic route instead of the Lawful one in the first fork, but by no means it's a bullshit "end justify the means situation" in the game.
b7ceac No.15623168
If you wanted to play Fire Emblem. There are much better games than Awakening which is decent at best. FE 4, 5, 7, 9, and 10 are all much better games. I would recommend 7 if you want the most replay value.
If you want a TRPG with a stupid amount of replay value and depth, then get Disgaea 5 for PC. Pirate the demo and use the patch found in the pastebin below to unlock the full game and get a better version than a pirated version of the Steam version. https://pastebin.com/XyuTLRD9
If you want a TRPG with a good story and gameplay then there's Utawerumono Mask of Deception/Truth. Gameplay is a combination of Shining Force and Fire Emblem. However, due to it being a VN, it has a ton of reading and plot.
Want a challenge? Then try out Natural Doctrine and Trapper Knight, Sharpshooter Princess. ND is known as the "Dark Souls of TRPGs" but it's actually hard unlike Dark Souls. Trapper Knight is just like Fire Emblem but much tougher.
>>15623053
Would also recommend Rondo of Swords. It's a pretty good SRPG for the DS.
>>15623160
Don't bother. It's just updated sprites which they just ripped from D2. It's not worth it. No quality of life features that you see in 4 or 5. You're better off emulating the PSP version of 1.
30673a No.15623258
KEK
Never played Tactics Ogre(though i plan to at some point) but i can almost assure you that its better; its very well regarded by many anons
Awakening by comparison and in general is disappointing dogshit that is all style and no substance (and no fun either after the beginning)
472c5d No.15623304
>>15623044
>Shining Force
Braindead easy gameplay.
e92387 No.15623320
>>15623304
>hating on Shining Force
>because its gameplay is too easy
It doesn't need to be an Idea Fuck game for it to be good
a48581 No.15623341
>>15623304
>too easy
Despite it being easy, it was still a fun adventure to go on because there are things to enjoy in games than difficulty.
6f8b89 No.15623352
>>15623139
>game is literally based on the Yugoslav wars
>the ones that actually happened and the only thing most people can name about them are where they happened (because it's in the name), "genocide" and "warcrimes"
>claims having to pick the lesser evil is unrealistic
a48581 No.15623375
>>15623352
>fighting muslim subversion and rebellion
>"grey morality"
>"having to pick lesser of two evils"
No.
6f8b89 No.15623384
>>15623375
The mudslimes deserved it, but last I checked there was plenty of Serb v. Croat genocide/warcrimes.
46c106 No.15623432
>>15623160
>ogre can be spelled both ways
If you're a brainlet, sure.
952204 No.15623561
>>15623044
Vandal Hearts 2. You won't regret it.
c0a948 No.15623576
>>15623160
>I don't really care, ogre can be spelled both ways.
No it can't. Any spellcheck will tell you otherwise.
0c9f15 No.15624001
Awakening is so fucking terrible that literally any choice is better. Try Der Langrisser, I hear that's pretty fun.
6cebf7 No.15624204
Anons will shit on it but Awakening has insane replay value
de7b88 No.15624276
>>15624204
But why bother when the game is an unbalanced mess? It's not even a good unbalanced mess where everything is broken but many mechanics don't make sense. Outside of healing, there is no reason not to pair up because the game is designed around that idea that 1 strong unit is more optimal than 2 weaker units. And pairing turns 2 good units into 1 god tier unit. Map design is horrible and the story is garbage with just a few characters being entertaining. The game revolves around the idea that the player can grind for levels or money so they don't give a shit about weapon durability or proper enemy scaling. In fact endgame enemies will have maxed out forged silver weapons that rival legendary weapons because that's they only way they can counter pairing.
The replay value mainly comes down to making broken units with absurd skill combination and pairing people to make the best master race children. It doesn't even have a ranking system like FE7 that actually adds replay value.
e0bc18 No.15624397
>>15623044
Play a Fire Emblem game that isn't Awakening. Any of the others will do. If you're looking for black/white morality, Fire Emblem Binding Blade is a good choice.
96814d No.15624450
>>15624397
Binding Blade was my least favorite fire emblem game after Fates/Awakening
It was so fucking boring, the story was hot garbage, the characters were overall bland and unimpressive, the maps had numerous problems (unique and fun-looking designs on the surface but fundamental problems with the game mechanics and balance seriously hampered their abilities to be fun), the lack of objective variety certainly didn't help things either
The "Black/white" morality in that game might as well have not been existent because the storytelling is nonexistent. How can you have a true black/white morality when you barely know anything of what's going on for most of the game?
>Zephiel randomly kills or wounds a character
>Zephiel appears to be evil offscreen
>Uh oh, Zephiel is conquering yet again!
The true final villain isn't even an inherently evil one, and the one before that is some sort of strange thing that just hates humanity
Narcian is one of the few villains I would classify as both vile and getting enough screentime to easily classify as black morality, and he was just a high-ranking henchman
26e75a No.15624451
>>15624001
About Langrisser, the SNES version of the game is Der Langrisser and the Genesis version is Langrisser II. Langrisser II is the harder of the two because in DL you can abuse the class change system The music also blows the SNES version out of the water in my objective opinion
02e34c No.15624461
>>15623160
>Shining Force: The Sword of Hajya is also worth playing.
You're better off playing the SEGA CD version, Sword of Hajya is just part 2 of that one, and SEGA never published part one for god knows what reason. There's also a 3rd part that's been fan translated, but it doesn't have anything in common with the other two, it's more a prequel for 2
129e3d No.15624850
>>15624451
genesis music usually shits on snes music. The snes had shitty sampling overall, its just that the music had to be competent on the genesis or it sounded like niggas having a bowel movement
b56c6b No.15626486
>>15623109
>LUCT is mechanically complex
compared to stuff like FFT and early Shining force, sure
>>15624451
AI in Lang 2 genesis is also better (so I hear)
OP, Front Mission series is very fun. Only FM2 is kinda "morally grey", but not really
e4cb3e No.15626527
>>15623044
Nigger what are you doing?
If you're gonna play a 3ds fire emblem play this instead.
c477fe No.15627559
The warlock class in Tactics Ogre LUCT is pretty weak and probably the worst class there is in the game
>Can't use offensive magic like the wizard, valkyrie, ninja and some knight classes can
>Can't use status-inflicting magic like witches can
>Can't use healing magic like clerics/exorcists can
>Can only use magic that amplifies elemental magic attacks of other magic users, which can be useful at times but not enough to warrant a spot on your team since witches can also do that
>Shit defense and shit offense so he's neither a physical tank and damage-dealer like a knight (which is to be expected), nor a physical glass cannon like a ninja. I already mentioned how he has no magical spells for defense or offense (just relatively useless buffs another class that can inflict status ailments in addition to that can also do)
Did a warlock cuck one of the battle programmers or something? I never have seen a non-joke class be so gimped and so shit that it's basically worthless. It's like the game designers just wanted to include the warlock for the sake of completing the roster, but forgot to make it useful.
86864a No.15627613
>>15627559
Original or remake?
Only played original and I couldn't complete the last dungeon. Too grindy. Did you really need to hit up training to close the level gaps every mission? And those stat up cards, was farming them necessary?
c477fe No.15627648
>>15627613
Original.
I usually train every 2-3 battles because that's usually how long it takes to for the enemies to gain another level and I make sure I get overlevelled a bit in order to not worry as much about my more fragile witch and ninja units.
About the stat cards, I almost never pick them up unless the enemies are mostly dead or at least the biggest threats on the field are dead and the remaining portion of the enemies are just regular soldiers/amazons. But by that time, most of my units are already closing in on the leader or the last enemy, so I don't bother with it, but I have a feeling that will bite me in the ass later.
86864a No.15627745
>>15627648
I feel like you can get good stats and classes early on by farming random encounters. But I never put the time into it. I always did the training mode trick where you have two unarmed clerics punch each other up to level 50
Also I'd usually make Denim become whatever class just unlocked to try it out and see what it was like, so my army had a bunch of soldiers and really awful multiclassed things going on
e0bc18 No.15628461
>>15624450
Well done, anon, you managed to have shit taste.
a63c83 No.15628621
>>15628461
So much for an actual argument.
Its pretty fucking shitty, and you have nothing to argue with otherwise from what it looks to me.
e0bc18 No.15628756
>>15628621
I don't care to argue with you, faggot. You have invariably shit taste. Just know that.
a0441e No.15629011
>>15623044
I'm not sure if you can really compare FE games to LUCT but all I can say is tactics ogre is an amazing game and after 200 hours of play time I still can do much more
fe3ed0 No.15629307
>>15628756
>believing someone who can't even be assed to defend a game he cares about
Why should I do this?
Are you some kind of redditor? You can't even state why you think the game is good? Why come to a board about video games if you're not willing to talk about them?
cb1f25 No.15630298
>>15627745
I feel like it really isn't worth it to farm random encounters (other than for money really) because you can get the same experience through a decent amount of training and do so more reliably. DOing that would make the game more tedious than it actually is.
As for Denim, I always wait until the Knight or Berserker classes are unlocked because I'm willing to sacrifice some speed for more defense since most of the time I have 2+ Ninjas and Canopus, so the sacrifice is worth it. Plus, I like the design for the Dragoon and Terror Knight in the original and would be damned if I didn't at least have one of each
2a264e No.15638040
>>15628488
How good are the Super Robot Wars games on the whole?
a2f9e0 No.15638066
>Grid.
>Endless Tactics Clones.
Play Ogre Battle instead.
d85927 No.15638231
Is Telepath Tactics any good?
ac50d6 No.15638259
>>15626527
ya this looks interesting I need to try it
and Stella Glow! ?
Stella Glow good right?
ac50d6 No.15638261
>>15638040
very fun
too much long-winded dialogue scenes (but you can skip them)
and the one I played was pretty easy at the start….not sure how the difficulty goes later on
e0bc18 No.15638272
>>15629307
>are you some kind of redditor
Ebin. I don't need to defend my taste to you, as you have proven your taste is shit and you as an individual are not worth having a discussion with.
b93da6 No.15638411
>>15623044 (Checked)
>>15623109
What about Knight of Lodis, the sequel to LuCT?
24437f No.15638772
>>15638411
>Knight of Lodis
Wasn't that the prequel which explains why Lans Tartare is a complete cunt?
96814d No.15638779
>>15638272
>I don't need to defend my taste
>you have already proven your taste is shit by disliking and criticizing a game I like
Guess this just proves there's more redditors among the binding blade fanbase than I expected. Thanks for proving absolutely nothing to nobody outside of the game being bland, forgettable, overly drawn out, grossly imbalanced, tedious and trash
26369b No.15638809
87824f No.15639322
I tried getting into LuCT a few times, but never could get far. The battle system feels just so tedious compared to other TRPGs, or maybe a better way of putting it is that the flow of combat feels off. I also dislike how much grinding was needed to keep up with enemy levels, and the grinding itself being so boring. I think the first time I quit was on a mission where I had to rescue some chick that started off in the opposite corner of the map from my team and she'd keep getting gang-banged before I could get halfway across the map. The first time I was assaulting a castle and I remember there being dragons. Does the gameplay get better later on? Is the story really that good and worth getting into? I love FFT and I really like VH2, but LuCT just feels so… wrong.
36a84a No.15639353
>>15623044
As a massive Fire Emblem fan, I'll tell you Awakening is complete trash and not worth playing at all. I haven't played Tactics Ogre, but I'm 100% sure it's better.
8f9498 No.15639357
>>15626486
What do you compare LUCT to that makes it seem mechanically not complex? Because it was a pretty damn complex game even back on its SNES release.
e0bc18 No.15639424
>>15638779
Sorry you aren't good enough to figure out the Rescue command, anon. I know you're very mad that your taste is being mocked, but it will be okay. Go play other games, like FE7 and 8. They're more to your taste, since they're easie-"more balanced."
e4cb3e No.15639655
>>15638259
I don't know, it looks like weebshit to me.
I played all 3 of the 3ds fire emblems and out of all 3 of them I only managed to enjoy Echoes. Got bored of awakening and couldnt even finish it, I forced myself to play fates but couldnt even finish it, I was so heavily invested in Echoes that I made my army into a batallion of fucking tanks and trampled all over chapter 4. With a bit of difficulty still remaining
I didn't even just enjoy it, its now one of my top 5 games on the 3ds.
In Echoes theres no waifushit, no fucktarded story, no bloat mechanics, no localization fuckery, but there is DLC but you can just get the .cia files for them anyways if you have cfw on your 3ds.
8f9498 No.15640062
>>15639655
Echoes is a remake of an older title, though, so don't expect more of it. unless they're more remakes.
ee5425 No.15640119
>>15639322
Looks like you listened to some hipster faggot and played the snes version, there's your problem. Play PSP version instead.
b1f4a7 No.15640142
>>15639424
You retard. I said "imbalanced' in the context of it being too easy because magic steamrolls fucking everything you dumbfuck.
It easily rapes everything, has no weapon weight so no speed penalties, the plentiful statboosters and general growth and stats of mages make them powerful enough to steamroll through the game and its just an overall shitshow, and it has incredible accuracy and is not affected by the weapon triangle.
I steamrolled the game with Lilina, one of the few characters I liked from that shitheap of a game.
24437f No.15640261
>>15640119
>>15639322
The rescue missions are usually pretty bad, you usually need to trick the AI by sending your birdman buttnaked to entice the enemies to attack him instead of all gangbanging the stupid spear wielding slut and healing her up so the rest of your army can make it and engage them.
This happens both in the SNES and PSP version, suicidal NPCs you HAVE to save are always a pain in the ass, you can just pick to let her get butchered when the mission starts at least so you don't instantly lose if she gets her dumb ass murdered.
475f3f No.15640279
>>15640142
No anon, if you criticize my favorite game that obviously means you're just bad at it and need to git gud.
>>15640119
The PSP version is better, but the whole "class levels instead of character levels" thing takes some getting used to. It can be pretty annoying to recruit a new character and have them be completely useless until you've spent the requisite time and effort grinding them back up to the level they were trying to kill you at. But that's what cheats are for.
49ccae No.15640654
>>15623044
Those 2 are both garbage but for different reasons. Fire Emblem is poorly written weeb pandering garbage, and Tactics Ogre is a grinding/micro management sim.
You're gonna be really disappointed after coming off Shining Force 2 which is fantastic. Maybe try Langrisser 2 or something.
ed1441 No.15640943
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.
>>15623044
It's a really weird hybrid, but I really enjoyed SNES's Bahamut Lagoon. The conceit is each "unit" on your strategy map is actually a party of 4 characters, and attacking an enemy unit brings you to a more standard JRPG combat screen, where each side gets one turn, before kicking you back out to the strategy map. When you start the game, each party has 4 characters of the same "class," but you can mix and match and put any character in any leader's party from the main menu before battle, customizing your units based on what you need that party to do.
Each of your "party" units is also accompanied by an AI-controlled "dragon" unit, which operates similarly, but is just a very powerful single creature, which you can feed and evolve throughout the game into new forms with new powers, abilities, and elemental affinities. Also, units have map abilities they can use depending on class or dragon type on their turn, rather than going into the JRPG fight screen.
I won't ruin the plot, but I will say that even though some enemies are redeemed, and even though some turn out to have a greater purpose to their evil actions, there's still your typical JRPG big bad evil power at the end.
9cb7ba No.15641322
>>15640943
I really liked this game but the NTR near the end got me mad and confused as fuck.
3e64d4 No.15641330
>>15641322
The worst part is there isn't any story decision you can make earlier on to change it. All it does is give you another reason to act like a dick to Yoyo early in game if you know about it beforehand.
8ccb0f No.15641342
>>15623168
I don't like the PSP version because of the screen crunch and awkward controls. The PS2 version is the only version I played through. That said, I sorta am still tempted to get HD remake because it's on a handed.
<<15641264
>OC
nothing original about that ebin cuckchan meme.
9cb7ba No.15641356
>>15641330
To top it off that gay wizard geezer keeps hitting on you. At least it was fun bullying him though.
ada633 No.15641578
eca12a No.15641656
>>15641264
Think you're missing an "artist" in there, unless you're just trying to call Urushihara "the greatest pervert alive."
a5307b No.15641662
ed1441 No.15642359
>>15641322
>>15641330
It's only NTR if you ever gave a fuck about air-for-brains Princess Thot. Compared to Lukia, Diana or (especially) Jeanne, she is literal trash.
d34dc1 No.15652751
>>15638040
As long as you don't mind playing the same easy game with mild graphical upgrades and the occasional formation mix up over and over and over because you really love mecha and fanservice plots of wildly uneven quality.
e0bc18 No.15658128
>>15640142
>magic steamrolls everything
Yeah, if you play slowly and poorly, but that's the case in every single Fire Emblem game you dumb fuck.
>Lilina is good
You're a casual, it's really clear now. Try to play with even a modicum of speed and you will see that Lilina is a shit tier unit and that you are a noob. I was right all along, you are awful.
9cb7ba No.15658138
>>15642359
The MC still got NTR'd even if the player didn't
37889f No.15658166
>>15641264
>Dies when killed
>Never dies, even when killed…
>Changes classes a minimum of five times per game
>Enemies actually know how not to get killed
>No level skip code. Forced to play levels in order the developers intended
This meme is funnier than it deserves to be.
fe3ed0 No.15658218
>>15658128
What are you, retarded?
As soon as you get boots on her (they're available pretty damn early on) she has excellent and moves the same as a paladin, and she's a single fucking unit that can nuke and survive pretty much everything thrown at her; she also has incredible staff powers later on and makes any and every other unit better as a result of being able to warp and rescue them incredible distances. Have 1 or 2 other magic-wielders for utility and healing in the interim between then and it works out fine.
You could effectively put her either alone or with one other unit on any map that would require 2 or more sides being defended and not have to worry about the side she's on. I had no problems with speed as far for almost all of the maps I used her on. For the other units I used, they were mainly mounted characters that could keep up with her and mainly just dealt with shit such as side objectives, rescue-chaining, and general map movement and unclogging and that was all that necessary.
9cb7ba No.15658928
>>15658218
>Joins lv1 with horrible bases at chapter 8
>Needs extreme babying to get up to par and even then she could get speed screwed, needing further babying with speedwings
>not giving the boots to someone who can actually use them for something useful, like a flier
>good
Anon, I love Lilina and I always use her, but she's bad. It's okay to like bad units, but that doesn't make them good. You can make anyone OP in fire emblem if you feed them enough kills.
f958eb No.15658974
>Game based on the Yugoslav wars
>No option to genocide the other ethnic groups
I can let the Galgastani off with a light cleansing but the Bakram and Lodissians deserve to wiped from the face of the earth.
fe3ed0 No.15659060
>>15658928
I don't know the odds of her getting speedscrewed, but mine did not. Her availability is good enough and she gets plenty of opportunities for fed kills without sacrificing much.
>not giving the boots to someone better
Well no shit I could do that, but I liked Lilina and felt like ensuring she could keep up with all my mounted units without having to be rescued too often.
>You can make anyone OP in fire emblem if you feed them enough kills.
Well no shit, there's obviously better units than her, namely the mounted and flying ones, but I consider her to be a fine non-mounted unit.
She's an Est who comes in early on, she's decent and viable enough and after promotion really doesn't have any problems with survivability. She's also permanently a 1-2 range unit who targets what is generally the weakest enemy stat in the game. Magic users always have some sort of value and increase in value and usefulness as you go further on in the game and I felt like she was good for the role of my main magic nuke and boss-killer.
e0083b No.15659091
>>15658138
He still ended up comparatively better off, being eternal bros with Bahamut.
While on the other hand, princess ends up forever alone for her bullshit, since the empire citizens butchered the dude as a scapegoat for all the bullshit that went down.
As far as old square shit goes, Oersted was a far worse case of NTR.
9cb7ba No.15659201
>>15659091
I agree with everything you said
>>15659060
Most of what you said is just your opinion based on your personal experience though, which does nothing for judging if a unit is objectively good or not. I'll give you that FE6 has a lot of trash units that are worse than her (Sophia is just a worse Lilina for example), still doesn't make her _good_. It's nearly the same thing going with Amelia in FE8, another big contender for bad unit favoritism which I'm also guilty of
e0bc18 No.15661763
>>15659060
Boots should always go on fliers, anon. Get with it. Lilina is utter garbage, especially on Hard Mode. I was giving you the benefit of the doubt and assumed that was the difficulty you chose, but that's clearly not the case if Lilina was doubling and consistently surviving enemies.
Niime can do what Lilina can do regarding warp, but with only one staff rank to level as opposed to fucking 5. Saul is also a much better warper because his base staff rank is so good. None of the mages are good at combat, but it isn't like you need a mage or "balanced team" in Fire Emblem (especially GBA) since you can just use Paladins and Fliers to shit all over the game.