>>15492109
Don't know about OP, but I based my opinion on my own experience.
I've tried Crusader Kings, Europa Universalis, Medieval Total War, CIV 4, 5 and 6, Endless Legend\Space, and many others.
You'll probably argue that "most of those are 4X, not GSG" but that's a moot point when we are talking about unpredictability or the complexity of it's gameplay, where any 4X trumps CK easily.
MTW doesn't do a very good job with it's economy, TBH. I found it too simple and boring, same for the politics. Even CK and EU do those fields better, but that's obvious since it's focus are on the battles themselves, so if that's what anyone is looking for, no reason to try CK instead of any Total War game, even the shitty ones are better at this.
In terms of unpredictability, you simply can't beat 4X games since the environment you are in is a new one every match and it's the environment that shapes your economy and your relationships with your neighbors.
Even when it comes to complexity, Endless Space \ Legend have so many different avenues of attack and so many layers just to get an economy strong enough to deal with your oponents, plus the changing seasons, that it makes CK seem like children stuff. It's not complex, it just looks that way.
Even when it comes to intrigue, I've had more tense games of CIV4 with it's spies, or any CIV game with the AI itself and their multiple personalities.
Meanwhile in CK everyone seemed to act the same way when they were under the same circunstances, reduced mostly to their traits.
I tried that game expecting a lot more from it and instead what I got was a blob building game with time gated diplomacy that barely did anything anyway. The only thing you have to worry in diplomacy is making heirs and that's it, everything else is optional.
And then I went to the threads here and the feedback I got discussing this was that "yep, that's what the game is all about, which is why half of it is trying to slow down your blob building efforts".
I get the LARPing aspect, but lets not pretend that's the only thing that actually keeps players interested in those games.