>>13786763
>Have you played this game
Yeah
>why is this game liked outside of its setting
Well some of the bandit hideouts are fun to complete, but that's only in multiplayer mode where each camp has like four times the amount of enemies who can swarm you from every direction and who seem to deal more damage. Fortunately, you can just skip the single player all together and go into a local LAN private lobby and complete all the bandit hideouts yourself. To be clear, I am not suggesting that the mechanics are deep or engaging, just that it can be fun to kill some of the enemies. However, the appeal of this quickly vanishes as it becomes apparent just how repetitive it is, and what you're left with is another empty, albeit beautiful, open world with collect-a-thon objectives and some side-missions that do a decent job of creating some atmosphere.
>I played on hard with no auto-aim and the game is piss easy
Yeah, well it's your basic third person cover-based shooter with bullet time and-shoot-at-whack-a-mole-esque enemy patterns, what'd you expect?
>it shocks me that the gunplay is so bad when it's something I hear most people praise
Yeah, well, it's pretty shit in the sense that the guns are not realistic, but then again the game is more of an arcade styled shooter, it wasn't meant to be a simulator. Whoever you talked to misled you if you expected this game to feature an in-depth and extensive firearm combat subsystem.
>The horse controls are shit
Eh, they're not that bad, though I guess it can be annoying to force your horse to gallop by constantly tapping the X/A button over and over again. It's not like you're really expected to do anything else while on horseback
Anyway, yeah, it's a pretty par-for-the-course AAA third person shooter. The gameplay is merely a vehicle that facilitates the setting, story and atmosphere. This is yet another 'cinematic' game that wants to be deep and mature and artsy and all that bullshit. The game manages to deliver on this front to some extent, so I have to ask again, "What the fuck were you expecting?"