/sw/ - Star Wars★

>>4384 (OP)

t. ahsoka masturbater

>>4384 (OP)

Ahsoka was only created by Lucas for the sake of having someone the kids could relate to, and it resulted in a mediocre performance for Clone Wars' pilot/movie. Hell Ahsoka only managed to garner fans when she finally matured and had that fanservice episode. And that episode where she started questioning the Republic was great, up until Lucas went and forced the staff to write Dooku as a one-dimensional villain instead of the complicated Republic-hater from the comics. Anyway, the series could've gone the same, or better off, without her. I used to like Filoni for actually trying to add some of the more obscure lore into Clone Wars and trying to make Lucas's ideas more bearable, but then he just went full greedy bastard on us when Disney hired him for Rebels. I mean, honestly, when I saw his pitch for that "Endor" idea of his, I knew he lost it.

>>4384 (OP)

Oh god I am now remembering the huge butt hurt the mando fags produced after those episodes in The clone Wars

>jailbait

Can we just agree that a society that literally baits people into prison with hot asses they know everyone wants is cancer and deserves to not exist anymore?

>>4390

Seriously Clone Wars at its worst is better than Rebels. Filoni is getting that sweet sweet Disney money and he went lazy with Rebels. However him being the apprentice of Lucas he managed to add in some dumb shit too.

I know people are split on the whole chips in the clone troopers brains but I honestly think that entire thing was done so people would think "Clone Troopers are gud boys they didnt do nuffin they were forced!!! des right the Empire and Storm Troopers are the evil ones!!"

This goes even deeper when its revealed popular Clone Troopers like Rex,Woffle, and Gregor are all left the Republic at the rise of the empire and join the Rebels.

>>4392

Mando fags are dumb asses anyway the mandolore episodes were the absolute best of the show

>>4392

Not even a mandofag, but turning the Mandalorians into Naboo 2.0 was fucking retarded and against all the lore.

>>4394

To me, it made much more sense for Order 66 to have been a voluntary order. It makes the Clones more human, and also allows for the popular 'good' Clone troops to have refused to carry out the order out of their own free will, not because they got rid of some chip in their brains.

>>4384 (OP)

>Ashoka dying by Vaders hand shows you how far Anakin has fallen when he became Darth Vader killing the last piece of his old life

>Uh actually shes alive guys

>>4394

>Seriously Clone Wars at its worst is better than Rebels.

Never said it wasn't. Clone Wars was a 50/50 experience for me. Half good, half bad. The clone stuff and them being humanized into gud boys with the chips shit irked me, but that episode where they all rebelled against that douchey jedi was practically worth it and surprisingly, the clones ended up being the best part of the show. Also, that one trooper with amnesia who was left behind was awesome. It wasn't until Maul showed up again and that Dathomir bullshit sprung up that I was truly tempted to drop the series.

>>4400

but the Maul stuff was good though

>>4397

The creator of the mando lore was a faggoty bitch and sperg, but if you never read her terrible stories, then the mando culture would actually sound appealing and interesting without all her awful stories accompanying them. The language, the oaths, the banners, the clans, it all had its appeal until you actually read her tumblr-tier shit. The author was basically the Wendig of her time, but still, the elements she introduced were neat and usable especially when used by better authors. Neo-Crusader Mandos were a neat shit.

>>4397

If they really wanted to do a different thing with the mandos in CW, they could've at least tried to not make them a second Naboo with blocky architecture.

>>4401

Until the Dathomir stuff. Spidercyborg Maul was awesome, but he was cooler without a brother. But the fight between him, his brother and Palpatine was some great shit.

>>4402

How do you tell if a character is mandolorian?

Look to see if their dick is covered in Karen Travis's lipstick…

>>4384 (OP)

Who drew that? Did they make more of these?

>>4404

Pretty much.

>Mary Sue Ahsoka

How many people here actually think this? She's certainly very talented, but she ends up needing Anakin to pull her cute hiney out of the fire more than a few times, she's not that knowledgeable about the large-scale political goings-on, and she's not treated anything like Rey by the rest of the characters.

The only people who defend Ahsoka and thinks she's legitimately good are waifu fags

>>4408

I don't think she's a mary sue, just a shitty character in the first 3 seasons. It wasn't until around the 4th that she started growing on me. But bringing her back in Rebels was unneeded. The character herself would've honestly worked a lot better if she wasn't Anakin's apprentice.

>>4407

this is nothing new, everytime new shit comes out the user count grows, and especially with the film being the mess that it is, we've grown a bit more solid in our regular posters. i just hope we don't keep too many sithposters.

>>4414

hey /tv/

Compared to what Disney did, Filoni is a saint.

>>4487

Fair enough.

>>4394

The chips pissed me off since it goes against Battlefront 2 (the original) and the whole moral struggle the clones went through in executing order 66.

>>4384 (OP)

I thought Filoni wore a cowboy duster not a fedora?

>>4404

lol. Last I heard she went on to write some novels for the new Halo games and they are awful and the Halo fandom now hates her. That and there was some GI Joe thing she wrote.

I always had this feeling that the only reason why Filoni was so praised was because he relied on a lot of already established EU lore and just did his own thing with them. Basically, he took toys someone else made and just played in their sandbox passing it off as his own.

>>4580

You mean that GI Joe comic with the really gay cover, which resulted in the cancellation of GI Joe in IDW, was her doing?

>>4607

No that was Aubrey Sitterson. I know she did some comic about Scarlett. Don't know how it panned out.

>>4394

> Filoni is getting that sweet sweet Disney money and he went lazy with Rebels.

I think he has less power on Rebels than during TCW.

As for the "Disney money", given the quality of the textures, models and animations, I bet that it costs way less than an episode of TCW.

>>4414

Well, at least she's not Sabine or Aladdin Bridger.

>>4399

>Uh actually shes alive guys

Brilliant move there Rebels.

>>4576

I think you mean Episode IIIs novelization since according to Cody there were a bunch of other Orders the clones had

>>4649

Order 4: "In the event of the Supreme Commander (Chancellor) being incapacitated, overall GAR command shall fall to the vice chair of the Senate until a successor is appointed or alternative authority identified as outlined in Section 6 (iv)."

Order 5: "In the event of the Supreme Commander (Chancellor) being declared unfit to issue orders, as defined in Section 6 (ii), the Chief of the Defense Staff shall assume GAR command and form a strategic cell of senior officers (see page 1173, para 4) until a successor is appointed or alternative authority identified."

Order 37: Capture of a single wanted individual through the mass arrest and threatened execution of a civilian population. Follow-up directives include scenarios for body disposal of civilian casualties and suppression of communications.

Order 65: "In the event of either (i) a majority in the Senate declaring the Supreme Commander (Chancellor) to be unfit to issue orders, or (ii) the Security Council declaring him or her to be unfit to issue orders, and an authenticated order being received by the GAR, commanders shall be authorized to detain the Supreme Commander, with lethal force if necessary, and command of the GAR shall fall to the acting Chancellor until a successor is appointed or alternative authority identified as outlined in Section 6 (iv)."

Order 66: "In the event of Jedi officers acting against the interests of the Republic, and after receiving specific orders verified as coming directly from the Supreme Commander (Chancellor), GAR commanders will remove those officers by lethal force, and command of the GAR will revert to the Supreme Commander (Chancellor) until a new command structure is established."

>>5228

>we are that fucked

I think we are beyond fucked actually. We have been for the last 4 years. I think a more fitting term would be that we have been given testicular torsion.

>>4407

Where can I get that beanbag?

>>4394

>Clone Wars at its worst is better than Rebels

George was heavily involved with Clone Wars.

He had no involvement with Rebels.

>>4384 (OP)

Disney is giving them hardly any production money, so I'd argue it was Disney.

>>4399

waifufaggotry strikes

>>4398

is that tourbillon? fuck that guy for perpetuating this shitty character's popularity

>>4390

>Fanservice

in the episode that ripped off its own comic tie-in?

that's a new one. and they couldn't even get that right, because they toned down ashoka's slave outfit.

>>10666

Yep. The episode was even less lore friendly than the comic and the slave costume even less sexy and revealing for the most part.

>>10638

>>10655

>>10656

>>10659

Going to quote these posts here because that discussion is for this thread instead.

>>10667

The reason for them toning down her slave outfit was articulated in the lewd thread:

>It's because of feminist jealousy of younger, more attractive girls. That's why they raised the age of consent and it's why they're now contemplating raising it even more. Mad bitches are already calling guys over 24 or so who date 18-year-olds pedos. They don't care about the Dr. Who age gap because the Dr. Who girls aren't in that 14-16 sweet spot that they're most jealous of.

Then there's also this bit about whether Ahsoka would be attracted to Anakin, thus also engendering jealousy:

>He's got his face plastered all over the galactic media as the Hero With No Fear. You've seen how teenage girls feel about guys like Bieber. How much more intense would it be if he was a general? Now imagine that you're one of these girls and you get to be the apprentice to this guy, who's only a handful of years older than you, and you've heard all the stories about how amazingly skilled he is and seen his handsome face that's made him a rock star, and you start spending time around him and find out that not only are all those stories true, but he's incredibly loyal to the people close to him. The idea that she wouldn't fall in love with him defies any reasonable characterization.

>>10671

Wait a minute, why are they jealous of that particular age range? Isn't that before most curves and desirable features?

>>10672

No, it's actually right about when curves and other desirable features appear. It's the freshest possible version of them. Plus teen girls are less bitchy than grown women. This thread is supposed to be about Ahsoka specifically instead of about some political debate, but you can't deny these motivations had a hand in certain story decisions.

There's also this from >>10655 regarding Lux Bonteri:

>He acted like a dick most of the time and only seemed to be there so the feminists wouldn't throw a fit about the Anakin/Ahsoka shippers because of their age gap and they have to throw a fit about nonexistent abuse because they know teenage girls are sexier than they are. I'm surprised Anakin didn't strangle the little bastard after learning that he got her kidnapped by Mandalorians.

>>10673

Okay, that's when they _start_ appearing, but that's hardly the ideal developed state. Not everyone is into teens, anon.

>>10674

Fair enough, but a lot of people are. Political concerns getting in the way of writing is nothing new, even for Star Wars. I've actually heard tales that the prequels were supposed to be ten times as redpilled as they were about government and corporate corruption, but George Lucas' original script was rejected by the suits.

>>10675

Lucas was the suit though, no? He was CEO of Lucasfilm as well as the director of the prequel episodes.

>>10676

20th Century Fox were the suits. Lucas didn't own them.

Why do people dislike Ahsoka? She’s kinda cute and not really a feminist cunt or anything. It does seem like a lot of the episodes focused on her as opposed to Anakin or Obi-Wan but my guess is Lucas wanted that so there was less character development of them outside the films.

>>10687

Personally, when she first appeared I didn't like her but I grew to like her as she became a better character over the seasons.

>>4576

Not necessarily. The clones' narration was as if they were speaking from the future.