/islam/ - 8ch Masjid

He's a fedoratard. Can you summarize the "bukhari" vid? Can't stand to listen to his voice.

>>23671

I would like to see a refutation

>>23772

The arguments are copy pasted from islamophobes and not academic in nature. You see his manner as well, it's meant to be mockery and not an intellectual discussion. But with that said these are points that have been refuted anyway.

>>23795

link pls

>>23796

I dunno if someone has made a refutation for that vid specifically seeing as how it's mostly just insults and such atheists are dime a dozen on youtube. But if you mean specific points then that's a different matter. Try for example the books written by Jonathan AC Brown on the topic, one titled "The Canonization of al-Bukhārī and Muslim: The Formation and Function of the Sunnī Ḥadīth Canon" and the other "Hadith: Muhammad's Legacy in the Medieval and Modern World".

>>23798

thanks

>>23800

"Arab". They like to call themselves something else like phoenician or something kek just to get away from anything that has to do with Islam.

>>23808

>>23808

Neo-shuubiya is so lulzy. You're not a phoenician or assyrian or whatever until you stop speaking arabic and start speaking phoenician or whatever larp language you claim to be.