Islam & Race Mixing عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 10:49:37 087008 No. 18209
While I know that Islam at its heart discourages racism and looking down on others because of their race (despite the fact that racism isn't unknown in the Muslim world), I often have trouble with how many modern Muslims talk about this issue.
On the one hand, you have the modern, progressive Muslims who condemn racism and tribalism as say Islam came to get rid of these things (but often make exceptions in this case for non-whites who are allowed to revel in their unique cultural heritages). You then have the political Islamists who want to replace all national, tribal and racial distinctions with a globalizing "Ummah". But both of these understandings to me seem at odds with historical fact and present reality and at times feel biased against whites or white Europeans in such a way that makes me feel there's a kernel of truth to some of /pol/'s sterotypes
I'm mixed myself and I don't want anyone to think I'm a crossboarder from /pol/ or that I'm biased towards any one race or nationality, but my understanding is that while Islam may permit race mixing by emphasizing the individual's piety more than anything else, because Islam also sanctified the "tribe" with its particular system of family values that gave authority to patriarchs and emphasized self-sufficiency, it also tempered this license with a certain assurance that individual tribes would continue to be able to maintain a healthy measure of autonomy from one another even as they may have mixed for political reasons.
If all the white Germans tomorrow, for example, suddenly converted to Islam, wouldn't Muslims be obliged to respect their wishes if the male elders of all those white German families decided they wanted to be Muslim yet stay white and not be forced to mix with others except to the degree they feel most comfortable with? After all, most Muslims in the Middle East and other parts of the Islamic world continue to just marry within their own nationalities and language blocks, despite the "there's no racism in Islam" slogans.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 15:03:37 087008 No. 18212
{
The Prophet said, “O people, your Lord is one and your father Adam is one. There is no virtue of an Arab over a foreigner nor a foreigner over an Arab, and neither white skin over black skin nor black skin over white skin, except by righteousness. Have I not delivered the message?”
}
You can still have preferences for marriage that's for sure. it's not haram to have so.
to be honest I don't understand your point that much.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 16:01:24 087008 No. 18214
>>18209
If you choose not to race mix, that's up to you. I'm white and I married a white woman and we have white children. That was my choice. However, that is not a choice I made in order to "preserve my race".
In Islam there is only one race. There is no "preservation of race". Frankly, I don't really understand your point either. Islam doesn't force people to "race mix" it merely removes the idea of race.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 17:26:58 087008 No. 18216
>>18209
Modern multiculturalism has nothing to do with Islam.
Maybe you want a pat on your back every day for managing to not be racist?
Well multiculturalism does that, and makes you feel good about yourself while you do nothing to actually improve the lives of people who need it.
It's a way of eliminating class conciousness and is the partner of neoliberalism.
It's a political distraction tool, muticulturalists and conservatives fight while capitalists enrich themselves.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 20:43:29 087008 No. 18222
>>18212
>to be honest I don't understand your point that much.
Well, my point is that it is very popular among modern Muslims who have by and large subscribed to much of the modern liberal and leftist views on race to try to style Islam as somehow being the ideal religion for the anti-racist, multiculturalist views many progressives in the West believe in.
But while Islam said that no person is better in the eyes of God for their skin color, only their piety, at the same time the patriarchal and tribal social structure remained mostly intact, with only some adjustments, in many ways it was strengthened by Islam's conception of the family and patriarchal authority. If you look throughout the Islamic world, even in the most culturally mixed regions, there isn't really a whole lot of mixing. It is true that you have some regions where a multitude of tribes are united by a common language or ancestry, but even here, there are many distinctions between individual tribes and their unique ethnic character within that common cultural tapestry that when these people are outside their homelands, they'll say "I'm Arab," or "I'm Iranian" but within their countries they're able to say "I'm this or that tribe and these are my people and traditions". And tribes which at some point in the past due to intermarriage or conquest became mixed have more or less opted to continue marrying mostly within their respective tribe from that point on to maintain that new racial character and their independence.
In light of this, I think it's wrong for Muslims to try to sell Islam as a vehicle of modern multiculturalism. There's nothing in Islam that says it's obligatory for any race to mix with another race or any tribe to mix with another tribe if they don't want to. so why should it be a problem if white European countries want to remain white & European like they have for nearly thousands of years? Couldn't they even convert to Islam and still choose to remain as such while having peaceful relations with other Muslim racial and ethnic groups?
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 20:45:48 087008 No. 18223
>>18209
Islam is not going to force your white daughter to marry Tyrone Jamal just because both of them are muslim. It really comes down to what the parents and the girl want. But parents usually look at his piety, job stability, wealth, personality, family, ect. Not just his skin color.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 20:49:38 087008 No. 18224
>>18222
>so why should it be a problem if white European countries want to remain white & European like they have for nearly thousands of years?
You're implying that most white people are afraid of 'racemixing' and want to preserve their race.
It's already common in the arab world with lebanese and syrian families that don't want to marry outside their ethnic group. And nobody gives a [foul language].
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 20:51:36 087008 No. 18225
>>18214
>In Islam there is only one race. There is no "preservation of race". Frankly, I don't really understand your point either. Islam doesn't force people to "race mix" it merely removes the idea of race.
The problem is this seems very wrong in light of the Qur'an
>O mankind, indeed We have created you from male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may know one another. Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Acquainted.
At least at first glance, verses such as these seem to imply that God himself has created and sanctified the diversity among people.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 20:58:59 087008 No. 18227
>>18225
Allah made us and loves all of us. Creation has great diversity and it always will. However, there is nothing wrong with a white woman marrying a black man. The mix just adds to the diversity.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 21:34:49 087008 No. 18248
>>18223
>Islam is not going to force your white daughter to marry Tyrone Jamal just because both of them are muslim.
Well, that exactly what I'm trying to say Islam doesn't force, but the problem I find is that there are a number of modern muslims, especially in the West who want to sell Islam in a way that makes it sound like it does, and they think they are doing Islam a great service, but I think they doing it a great disservice and also deceiving those they sell Islam to.
>It really comes down to what the parents and the girl want. But parents usually look at his piety, job stability, wealth, personality, family, ect. Not just his skin color.
And I think that's the most important thing. In traditional societies, which includes the Islamic countries, marriage is still very much a kind of business affair that involves not just the two individuals getting married but also involves the wider family networks of both parties. In these societies, it is usually preferred that the children marry certain people within a particular network or circle of trust. This helps keep wealth & property mostly within that circle and also gives the tribal network a greater freedom to determine their own cultural character for themselves. In the modern West, marriage is a purely individual affair and at times children are encouraged to completely disregard the "narrow minded" opinions of their parents.
>>18224
>You're implying that most white people are afraid of 'racemixing' and want to preserve their race.
"afraid" isn't the word I would use. I don't think the majority of whites are afraid of race mixing, but I do think the majority of whites have no actual conscious interest in race mixing, regardless of whether they object to it or not, and generally prefer to be with those of their own race and/or nationality, with those who are most familiar to themselves, and so naturally gravitate to those people, even if they aren't consciously choosing to stay within their race. The people who are motivated by some sort of fetishism or ideological need to marry outside of their race to prove something to themselves I don't think are very sincere.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 21:42:49 087008 No. 18250
>>18248
I think some of the problem is the differentiation between "race" and "nationality". We are all one race with multiple nationalities.
People may choose to stay within their own familiar nationality, but it is literally impossible to "race mix" since we're all the same race.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 21:44:40 087008 No. 18251
>>18227
>The mix just adds to the diversity.
Not when it is motivated by an ideology that is telling people that the only way to eliminate racism is for everyone to agree to become a colorless mush.
I'm not against race-mixing in principle at all, but I think Islam's approach to this issue is very different from the way many modern people approach it. I think in Islam, whether races mix or not is ultimately irrelevant and so the result of this historically has been a society where there are plenty of mixed and non-mixed ethnic groupings united by common religion. It doesn't see these distinctions as merely social constructs to be destroyed.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 21:49:23 087008 No. 18252
>>18248
>and generally prefer to be with those of their own race and/or nationality, with those who are most familiar to themselves, and so naturally gravitate to those people
I guess you could say that, for example I prefer moroccan girls but If I find a woman with better character then race does not count very much.
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 21:57:40 087008 No. 18253
>>18252
>moroccan girls
pffff
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 22:06:12 087008 No. 18255
>>18253
>"What?….You hate moroccan girls?" *cries*
عبد الله 11/27/16 (Sun) 22:09:19 087008 No. 18256
>>18250
race is a tricky term, especially since americans got a hold of it. before, race was more or less a synonym for tribe. Thus Britains, Irish and Italians were all seen as part of separate "races."
But I do think there is a correlation between a society having a firm sense of cultural and national identity and a certain degree of homogeneity in terms of the gene pool. Egypt is probably a good example. Most of the people of the modern day Egypt are homogeneous in that they pretty much all descend from the same Ancient Egyptian people. While there are some people who are mixed with the blood of Greek, Arab and Nubian groups, these groups have mostly assimilated by now into the broader Arabic-Egyptian culture so as to reduce conflict while still hanging on to a few individual traditions.
I feel like there are many white Europeans who have a bad image of Islam because they have been led to believe that Islam is to be associated with a kind of invasion of migrant peoples But a lot of these same people could easily be attracted to Islam if it was given to them with a guarantee that their independence and autonomy to decide what sort of nation they want to be remained intact.
عبد الله 11/29/16 (Tue) 11:22:11 087008 No. 18319
>>18317
>can't even sage properly.
k
عبد الله 11/29/16 (Tue) 22:26:08 087008 No. 18326
>>18319
We should raid /christian/. Enough is enough.
عبد الله 11/29/16 (Tue) 22:39:28 087008 No. 18327
>>18326
Let's not "punish" an entire demographic for the actions of a few,ok?
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 00:13:22 087008 No. 18328
>>18326
This is /b/ or /pol/ behaviour, not /christian/
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 00:21:44 087008 No. 18329
>>18326
We don't raid. If you want to do it, you're on your own.
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 01:47:55 087008 No. 18330
>>18328
maybe its /judaism/
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 05:16:31 087008 No. 18333
>>18330
It's possible, remember that American jew that pretends to be an Australian jihadist?
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 06:30:27 087008 No. 18334
>>18333
I'm pretty sure that guy's in prison.
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 07:32:57 087008 No. 18337
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 09:53:15 087008 No. 18339
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 20:02:12 087008 No. 18344
>>18339
hahaha this is so jewish lmao
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 22:11:55 087008 No. 18346
>>18344
Racist caricatures are not allowed on this board.
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 22:22:42 087008 No. 18348
>>18344
was this a picture of the mechant guy ? lol
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 22:59:51 087008 No. 18350
>>18346
How about this one?
عبد الله 11/30/16 (Wed) 23:16:38 087008 No. 18353
>>18350
Racist caricatures are not allowed on this board.
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 00:23:41 087008 No. 18355
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 01:17:23 087008 No. 18358
>>18355
The "le happy merchant" is a racist caricature of Jewish people and I have never allowed racist caricatures on this board, ever. This falls under the umbrella of "/pol/-like behavior".
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 01:39:34 087008 No. 18360
>>18358
So jews are a race now?
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 01:41:51 087008 No. 18361
>>18360
Judaism is a religion.
Jewish is a cultural identity.
Whether you agree with that or not makes no difference at all.
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 02:10:57 087008 No. 18363
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 02:33:06 087008 No. 18365
>>18363
It's sort of like being Muslim. Obviously "Muslim" is not a race, but we do all share a uniquely distinct culture with each other. Islam is our religion, but Muslim is our cultural identity.
The primary reason for not allowing them is because I want this to be a discussion board, not a "who wins at insults" board. Just imagine the response to every post you make being a picture of Justin Trudeau as a sign of invalidation. That no matter what you say or how sound your argument, that Canadian flag there renders you nothing more than a caricature of your nation. Not that I think we have any Jewish people here, but it has to be consistent across the board or the whole system breaks down. It is no easy task to moderate a board that is a huge neon shiny target. You've certainly been here long enough to see that.
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 02:57:54 087008 No. 18368
>>18365
Yeah man but I wasn't attacking anyone, just having some laughs.
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 03:05:20 087008 No. 18369
>>18368
What you say doesn't matter, rather how it is interpreted. What you think may be "havin' a laugh" could be seen as a deliberate attack.
As my father used to say, "What you say doesn't matter. Only the listener matters."
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 03:07:14 087008 No. 18370
>>18368
Incidentally, this is also why you didn't get a ban. I can see all your posts and I know, for the most part, your intent. I knew you weren't deliberately attacking anyone, but this board is intended to be comfortable for everyone.
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 16:05:57 087008 No. 18371
>>18328
>>18330
nah, /christian/ is pretty hostile to /islam/.
These are not traditional christians with the "christian values" we respect.
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 17:02:42 087008 No. 18372
>>18371
This is the same people that used to browse /pol/ (or Allah forbids, still browse /pol/ to this day) so I'm not really surprised if they hate us
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 20:59:41 087008 No. 18373
>>18372
They're obsessed by us, it's pretty funny tbh
عبد الله 12/01/16 (Thu) 23:11:34 087008 No. 18374
>>18373
They are also crusader larpers lmao.
عبد الله 12/02/16 (Fri) 03:27:16 087008 No. 18375
>>18374
We have our share of LARPers. The difference is we make fun of ours and drive them away.
عبد الله 12/03/16 (Sat) 11:59:50 087008 No. 18391
>>18371
I don't hate you. I love you, and want you come to know my Lord.
What are the Christian values you respect?
عبد الله 12/03/16 (Sat) 18:27:01 087008 No. 18397
>>18391
Loving your enemy :^)
عبد الله 12/03/16 (Sat) 21:40:43 087008 No. 18412
>>18371
Your Christian values include the rejection of Christs resurrection, the rejection of the Trinity and the worship of Mohammed.
عبد الله 12/03/16 (Sat) 22:02:28 087008 No. 18424
>>18397
Best answer. 10/10
عبد الله 12/03/16 (Sat) 22:32:13 087008 No. 18442
>>18412
wallahi if you raid we will raid equally
عبد الله 12/03/16 (Sat) 23:54:38 087008 No. 18458
>>18412
See >>18374
>>18442
>we
lel there's no "we" here; good luck trying to raid a board alone, fam.
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 00:48:17 087008 No. 18464
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 01:08:41 087008 No. 18465
>>18412
Those are beliefs not values. Your post demonstrates the problem with your board.
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 01:38:34 087008 No. 18466
>>18346
/islam/ has the best moderation that I know of. I'm not Muslim, I just come here every now and then to try and understand you guys, but I gotta say, its really admirable how you all collectively keep this place free of the trash that permeates most of the popular boards.
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 01:51:06 087008 No. 18467
>>18466
The more popular we get, the more difficult the task becomes. I do, after all, have to sleep from time to time.
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 01:53:56 087008 No. 18468
>>18458
>implying raiding alone isn't real
I came here from the front page and saw this post. This is precisely what has been happening in /furry/ for about 2 weeks.
Don't let your dreams be dreams. Or whatever term you guys use.
Wait, why am I encouraging you people? lmao
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 03:12:37 087008 No. 18470
>>18468
Thanks for the advice.
>>18469
if anyone is interested respond pls we will set up discord and share images
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 08:59:00 087008 No. 18471
>>18467
if only there were some other moderators to help you that have a different timezone. :)
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 18:46:22 087008 No. 18477
>>18468
We are aware that raiding alone is possible and we are aware of how to raid properly. We just don't do it. It's beneath us.
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 18:57:24 087008 No. 18478
>>18471
Finding a volunteer for this board isn't always easy. It has to be someone who is willing to enforce the rules, and only the rules. Someone who doesn't hate particular sects of Islam and can be neutral when it comes to decision making. Someone who doesn't hand out permabans for minor things and has an objective view of the board and its users.
عبد الله 12/04/16 (Sun) 21:47:07 087008 No. 18482
>>18478
I guess you weren't very successful in the past then lol. You won't find someone who doesn't hate a particular sect of islam that's for sure. You can however find plenty who will only enforce the rules and won't abuse their powers. I don't remember that the old volunteer abused his power even though he hate a lot of sects. (not that shia one .that one abused his powers a couple of times).
عبد الله 06/06/17 (Tue) 09:00:06 863561 No. 21061
>If all the white Germans tomorrow, for example, suddenly converted to Islam,
Only the white ones, ok but lol.
>wouldn't Muslims be obliged to respect their wishes if the male elders of all those white German families decided they wanted to be Muslim yet stay white and not be forced to mix with others except to the degree they feel most comfortable with?
Well yeah, defacto because girls can't get married in Islam without a wali.
>After all, most Muslims in the Middle East and other parts of the Islamic world continue to just marry within their own nationalities and language blocks, despite the "there's no racism in Islam" slogans.
Nationality/language =/= race, race = race.
They could even go further and disallow foreigners from marrying their women in their territory like saudi arabia does. It makes sense since the Saudis were open to muhajiroon when they were fighting to establish their first and second state against the hashemites, british, egyptians, turks etc. They took muhajiroon for the third state too. Very few muslims wanted to live in Mecca and Medina before the oil was discovered, even less wanted to fight for tawheed in the Najd. But then Allah blessed them with oil and peace and now so many want to live there as a birthright. Is that fair?
Also if you ever see an idiot who says British created saudi arabia - run. It was a multi-generational struggle and the british were on the side of the turks and hashemites and then just the hashemites until the very end. The ottoman khilafah was rife with disgusting turkish nationalism by the late 19th century which turned not only the sauds, but the hashemites against it too. After the Young Jerks took power in 1908 it was no longer a valid islamic state and was destroyed alhamdulillah.
عبد الله 06/06/17 (Tue) 20:27:30 29075d No. 21066
>>18209
>decided they wanted to be Muslim yet stay white
Becoming Muslim doesn't change your genetics.
>and not be forced to mix
Nobody is forced to mix.
عبد الله 06/10/17 (Sat) 17:45:02 863561 No. 21209
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play. Varg's got a video saying he doesnt think islam is worse than christianity for whites. This is triggering christians.
عبد الله 06/10/17 (Sat) 17:54:36 863561 No. 21210
YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play. Varg: one christian zionist killed more norwegians than all the muslims in norway in the last 40 years.
عبد الله 06/15/17 (Thu) 14:34:57 9bf0ff No. 21340
A lot of Muslims are racist, but Islam is regularly on the middle ground on racism.
عبد الله 06/16/17 (Fri) 02:21:38 0a3152 No. 21366
>tfw a keyboard nazi sees you at walmart and keeps his mouth shut, then gushes about it online
عبد الله 06/17/17 (Sat) 01:37:06 52ae0a No. 21391
>>21209
>>21210
Varg's an interesting character but he views Islam and Christianity as being one and the same: foreign religions from a European perspective. He only cares about preserving pre-Roman European values and traditions (i.e. nature worship).
I wouldn't cite him as a source in a serious debate because he has a sketchy history.
Those first four Burzum albums are some of the best music I've ever heard though