Thoughts on Pan-Islamism? عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 16:07:14 5bb6b5 No. 17816
Hey /islam/, what do you think about Pan-Islamism? Do you think it would be possible to unite all dominantly Muslim lands into a caliphate? I used to be one, until I realised how impossible it is.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 16:11:40 5bb6b5 No. 17817
>>17816
It's still worth establishing a mostly Islamic state with Sharia
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 16:13:44 5bb6b5 No. 17818
>>17817
Pray tell, how exactly are we going to do that? We've been trying for around 200 years..
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 16:51:24 5bb6b5 No. 17821
>>17816
We can do nothing until Allah permits it.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 16:59:21 5bb6b5 No. 17822
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 17:39:04 5bb6b5 No. 17823
>>17822
If you want to take up arms and go running off to foreign countries in order to change their governments, then knock yourself out. I prefer to live peacefully.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 17:58:18 5bb6b5 No. 17825
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:04:00 5bb6b5 No. 17826
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:08:13 5bb6b5 No. 17827
>>17825
>>17826
That's all you've got? That's pretty pathetic. Not only is it not an argument, it isn't even English. If you don't want to live peacefully, there are plenty of places in the world where you can get your warmonger fetish satisfied.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:23:00 5bb6b5 No. 17830
>>17827
It's not a fetish, it's service to Allah
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:23:56 5bb6b5 No. 17831
>>17830
>>17827
Pretty much. We only live to serve Allah by the sword!
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:26:11 5bb6b5 No. 17832
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:26:49 5bb6b5 No. 17833
>>17830
>>17831
If you were truly Muslim, you'd know that there is more than one form of jihad. The sword is not required.
Also, you can stop with the VPN.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:28:28 5bb6b5 No. 17834
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:29:23 5bb6b5 No. 17835
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:30:14 5bb6b5 No. 17836
>>17833
>vpn
What the [foul language] do you mean?
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:31:38 5bb6b5 No. 17837
>>17833
I know there are many forms of Jihad. But I am doing by the sword!
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:33:15 5bb6b5 No. 17838
>>17835
>>17836
Agreeing with yourself when you're wrong just makes you twice as wrong.
>>17837
If that's what works for you in the UAE, so be it. I have no need of the sword here in the US. We live quite peacefully here.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:42:42 5bb6b5 No. 17839
>>17838
I'm not him, I know him, but I'm not him
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:45:20 5bb6b5 No. 17840
>>17839
Well, your ID changed. So, what we're seeing here is:
ID da0c38 - Ireland
ID 66ca28 - Ireland
ID a3fffb - UAE
So, 2 Irish posters and 1 UAE poster all suddenly in the same thread? Not likely.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:50:33 5bb6b5 No. 17841
>>17827
>>17840
I'm the only Irish poster in this thread yes, I was using mobile data for a bit
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 18:53:14 5bb6b5 No. 17842
>>17841
Fug linked another of your post
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 19:01:24 5bb6b5 No. 17843
>>17841
Well, whatever. I would like to know how in Ireland you're taking up the sword. Muslims have lived peacefully in Ireland for decades. What changed?
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 19:58:20 5bb6b5 No. 17844
>>17843
Im not physically doing Jihad at the moment but plan to heh
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 19:58:50 5bb6b5 No. 17845
>>17844
i posted this ironically ok no get me fbi pls
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 20:07:09 5bb6b5 No. 17846
>>17843
I'm joking as well.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 20:58:51 5bb6b5 No. 17847
It's been done before, it can be done again.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 21:15:44 5bb6b5 No. 17850
This is a verry intelligent discussion.
everytime a group tries to do so they are called 'khawarij' 'terrorist' 'wahhabi'.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 21:59:44 5bb6b5 No. 17851
>This is a verry intelligent discussion.
very nice of u
Wahabbi is a correct term though tbh and it could be done via a legitimate state.
عبد الله 11/15/16 (Tue) 21:59:53 5bb6b5 No. 17852
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 01:20:09 5bb6b5 No. 17869
>>17844
>>17845
Don't worry. The FBI won't go after foreign nationals.
>>17851
Most don't like the term "Wahhabi" because of the implication that they follow a scholar instead of Islam. "Salafi" is the generally accepted term.
I'm neither, so I don't care, but we try to be open/accepting to the various schools of Islam around here.
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 06:39:39 5bb6b5 No. 17873
>>17844
reported :^)
stupid taig
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 08:20:12 5bb6b5 No. 17874
>>17873
It was just a meme haha
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 08:22:35 5bb6b5 No. 17875
>>17869
Salafism isn't the exact same as Wahabbism though, but they are pretty similar, I agree with the point about people using salafi over wahabbi though, I've met people calling themselves salafis,but hardly any call themselves wahabbis.
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 11:26:02 5bb6b5 No. 17876
>>17869
or maybe it's the fact that wahabbism is always connected to islamic-extremism
(Btw BO if you're reading this congrats on the newest child)
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 11:31:30 5bb6b5 No. 17877
>>17875
I've heard people say that Salafism is just the same as Wahhabism. Redpill me on it
عبد الله ## Board Owner 11/16/16 (Wed) 16:26:33 5bb6b5 No. 17878
>>17877
Wahhabism is the Saudi version of Salafism. Not all Salafi follow al-Wahhab, but all followers of al-Wahhab are Salafi.
>>17876
Jazak Allah
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 16:38:56 5bb6b5 No. 17879
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 20:58:21 5bb6b5 No. 17881
>>17874
Hell of a defence you got there Paddy :DDD
عبد الله 11/16/16 (Wed) 22:47:54 5bb6b5 No. 17884
>>17881
>how to take a screenshot
erry time
عبد الله 11/17/16 (Thu) 08:51:42 5bb6b5 No. 17889
>>17881
>/mlp/
>/b/
>9GAG
>reddit
Oh god..
عبد الله 11/17/16 (Thu) 10:59:15 5bb6b5 No. 17894
>>17816
It is what we should all strive for.
عبد الله 11/17/16 (Thu) 11:01:03 5bb6b5 No. 17895
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 07:17:02 5bb6b5 No. 17921
>>17850
Because they usually start loping random innocents heads off
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 17:35:59 5bb6b5 No. 17926
>>17921
see your problem is you only see that part of the video. Those 'innocents' are either killers/spies or they did stuff that deserve to have their heads chopped off. Let's take for example the most hated group ISIS and try and show me where they killed 'loped random innocents heads'.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 18:04:35 5bb6b5 No. 17943
>>17926
>show me where they killed 'loped random innocents heads'.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Henning
Berke 11/18/16 (Fri) 18:19:47 5bb6b5 No. 17944
>>17926
ISIS kill noncombatants and civilians all the time.
Please don't tell me you sympathize with those Khawarij.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:02:17 5bb6b5 No. 17945
>>17944
>khawarij
xD. please go ahead and tell why they are khawarij
>>17943
you chose the worst of examples. sure you may think he is an innocent man but he was firstly a kaffir. secondly ' وإن عاقبتم فعاقبوا بمثل ما عوقبتم به' 'And if you punish [an enemy, O believers], punish with an equivalent of that with which you were harmed'
the uk bombs and kills muslims in syria and all over the muslim word so why shouldn't they do the same to them? is it ok for the uk to do it but not ok for them to do the same?
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:04:39 5bb6b5 No. 17946
>>17945
Are you saying it's okay in Islam to kill all non believers indiscriminately?
Well you are wrong.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:08:32 5bb6b5 No. 17947
>>17946
I never did say so.we are not allowed to harm or touch non-believers that are under protection.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:09:36 5bb6b5 No. 17948
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:18:41 5bb6b5 No. 17949
>>17948
They knew who that guy was and they killed him to incite a war and increase their profile.
That is not a justification.
Non believers don't need a piece of paper to say they have a right to life.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:25:27 5bb6b5 No. 17950
how is that not a justification. they weren't the one inciting the war they are actually self-defending themselves. Btw are you a muslim yourself ? just so we can be clear.
Non believers don't need a piece of paper to say they have a right to life but as soon as they attack muslims anywhere in the word they lose that right it's as simple as that.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:31:51 5bb6b5 No. 17951
>>17950
Alhamdulillah I am a Muslim.
That man was 100% innocent. He went to Syria with a Muslim aid group to give aid to people trapped by war.
Sorry, you have been misled. You can not blame every Christian for the actions of a few """"Christians""""".
It doesn't work like that.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 20:47:02 5bb6b5 No. 17952
>>17951
"And fight against the disbelievers collectively as they fight against you collectively"
What do you consider an innocent?is obama an innocent? is david cameron an innocent? that man was not an innocent. He was a kaffir and not under any protection.His people were bombing civilan muslims day and night but no one cared for them so they want to show them how much it hurts too. sure he may be a non-fighter but he wasn't innocent in their eyes.that's the reason they target kuffar civilans because those wounds hurt more.
just want to clarify for any fbi watching this thread. I am not sharing their opinion just wanting to give an objective view of it
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 21:37:56 5bb6b5 No. 17953
>>17946
Indiscriminately, no. But name me one country that doesn't execute spies when caught. In the US they're shot immediately, no trial.
عبد الله 11/18/16 (Fri) 21:39:55 5bb6b5 No. 17954
>>17952
No worries about the FBI. They don't go after foreign nationals.
عبد الله 11/19/16 (Sat) 00:14:40 5bb6b5 No. 17956
>>17953
>But name me one country that doesn't execute spies when caught
Russia and America. That's two. Try reading.
عبد الله 11/19/16 (Sat) 00:26:20 5bb6b5 No. 17957
>>17956
When spies are caught in the US they are shot. Do you not consider that execution? You try reading.
Berke 11/19/16 (Sat) 03:23:53 5bb6b5 No. 17958
.>>17952
>sure he may be a non-fighter but he wasn't innocent in their eyes.that's the reason they target kuffar civilians because those wounds hurt more.
Since when was Jihad about targeting civilians? What place do these methods have in Islam?
And don't cry to me about how "well the US and other western countries kill our civilians so we can kill theirs."
I know there's plenty of innocent muslim blood on my country's hands, but two wrongs don't make a right. That's a childish, and more importantly, un-islamic way of thinking.
Berke 11/19/16 (Sat) 03:31:30 5bb6b5 No. 17959
>>17957
>When spies are caught in the US they are shot.
Not really, at least not if they're high-or mid profile.
Spook work/Covert ops are probably another matter though.
عبد الله 11/19/16 (Sat) 03:34:16 5bb6b5 No. 17960
>>17816
Islam is incomplete without islamism. Because Allah sent down rules for us to apply and follow in our daily lives. Now the question is what type of islamism? There is obviously the militant jihadist type which will never succeed, because they force people before tazqiyah and tarbiya (self purification). Also their biggest flaw is that they depend on technology that they did not create nor that they can replicate, such as the vehicles and weapons. Add to their close mindedness and takfirism on other muslims (even between salafi, see al qaeda vs isis).
The other type is the more moderate political and movements. Such as the muslim brotherhood in egypt, AKP in turkey and iran. These groups are more flexible and willing to work with others, muslim or not. And they are not prone to the use of violence except for self defense in the case of hamas, and pre 2006 hezbollah.
As I see it our best shot is a united federation of independent islamic republics, like Pakistan, Turkey, Iran, Malaysia, Indonesia and maybe Qatar. United army, gold currency and share technology. These are the most successful muslim countries that have a strong ikhwan influence.
I don't think the future of islam is one blob state spanning magrheb to asia. That is improbable and impractical. A united states of islam would be more practical and avoid corruption since each state would have an independent head and thus could ensure their loyalty of the quran based constitution.
عبد الله 11/19/16 (Sat) 07:11:28 5bb6b5 No. 17971
>>17957
The USA and Russia have done exchanges of captured spies plenty of times.
عبد الله 11/19/16 (Sat) 08:04:05 5bb6b5 No. 17976
>>17960
I like this idea and in the current social context I think it would be the proper first political step in creating a Muslim world.
But I also believe the first social step would be getting rid of all the Islamic sects, how did so many sprung up when we are warn about them and against them in the Holly Quran?!?
And brothers, what Isis and others like them are doing is wrong, look at how they torture and take pleasure in the pain of others, it is mentioned in the Quran that a death sentence should be carried out as quickly as possible not by torture.
عبد الله 11/19/16 (Sat) 08:17:34 5bb6b5 No. 17980
>>17976
Sects will not disappear, because humans disagree on certain things it;s human nature. I am against sects or schools in islam, but we are powerless to the fact that it will never go away.
In the end what matters is that we all want what's best for our ummah and we want to live under shariah law, and the quran is our constitution. We can all agree on the fundamentals and the rest will sort itself out.
Mashallah we are diverse and we should be happy of that fact, I sometimes have changed my mind over some interpretations by listening to other brothers of different schools or branches. None of them are perfect, but they all contain valuable gems and some accurate knowledge, and we need to sift through it.
The main reason why muslims are killing each other is politics, if we are all under one wing against the zionist order, then we will not be fighting over a kingdom of dust and ruin our image to the world.
In short, we have to be open minded and pragmatic, but remain focused on the quran, our mawlana.
عبد الله 11/25/16 (Fri) 13:01:52 5bb6b5 No. 18159
>>17980
>against sects or schools in islam
People understand things differently and that's fine. Sufi orders, different madhhabs, different theological understandings are all a good thing. But the Shia should become Sunni
عبد الله 11/25/16 (Fri) 22:49:53 5bb6b5 No. 18183
>>18159
Yeah I accept that there are differences but I don't like the naming and separate mosques. You are right about the shias.
عبد الله 11/25/16 (Fri) 22:57:56 5bb6b5 No. 18186
>>18183
Why not separate to an extent? Salafis wouldn't want an Ashari teaching their kids aqidah and vice versa, nothing wrong with that. Each is valid and should have their space. Hanafis want to pray fajr and asr at a certain time so certain mosques will be Hanafi to that extent. Not everybody wants to join a Sufi tariqa or do dawah with the tablighi jamat, no problem.
Where's the issue?
عبد الله 12/05/16 (Mon) 12:09:02 5bb6b5 No. 18520
>>18159
>>18159
>Shia should become Sunni
lole no
عبد الله 12/05/16 (Mon) 12:32:48 5bb6b5 No. 18521
>>18520
How's your extermination going in Mosul :). already more than 6K and more to come insh'allah.
عبد الله 12/05/16 (Mon) 15:49:42 5bb6b5 No. 18526
I'm muslim and I'd rather kill myself than living in shariah controlled government. This is my first day on this board. It's understandable why so many westerners hate muslims because of people like you
عبد الله 12/05/16 (Mon) 16:37:58 5bb6b5 No. 18531
>>18526
>This is my first day on this board.
Welcome to the board.
عبد الله 12/05/16 (Mon) 17:03:50 5bb6b5 No. 18533
Nice map you got there, too bad most of the countries you/the creator of the map has no idea which countries are and aren't muslim
عبد الله 12/06/16 (Tue) 16:18:44 5bb6b5 No. 18586
>>18533
Someone forgot about Sicily.
عبد الله 12/06/16 (Tue) 17:17:05 5bb6b5 No. 18587
عبد الله 12/06/16 (Tue) 17:25:36 5bb6b5 No. 18589
Something seems phony about these threads. Don't mind me, I'm just a spectator. Continue on your honeypots, FBI.
عبد الله 12/06/16 (Tue) 17:50:25 5bb6b5 No. 18594
>>18589
Welcome to the list ahmed.
عبد الله 12/06/16 (Tue) 21:18:58 5bb6b5 No. 18630
>>18589
You've posted. Now your IP is in the database. You will be contacted soon with further instructions on how to properly register yourself.
عبد الله 12/10/16 (Sat) 18:54:13 5bb6b5 No. 18737
>>18586
What does sicily have to do with it? Im just saying austria isnt muslim, nor are India, china and almost all countries they coloured in in europe
Most of africa outside of north doesnt have any real organized religion either, mainly folk-religions and colonisation-era christianity
عبد الله 12/10/16 (Sat) 19:36:55 5bb6b5 No. 18740
>>18737
I think these were all muslim controlled in history.
عبد الله 12/11/16 (Sun) 15:32:34 5bb6b5 No. 18763
>>17960
>Indonesia
Wahhabists are running amok here with the whole Ahok thing.
عبد الله 12/11/16 (Sun) 19:06:04 5bb6b5 No. 18774
>>18763
>w*h*bists in asia
[foul language]ing saudis
عبد الله 12/12/16 (Mon) 00:47:57 5bb6b5 No. 18792
>>18763
Yeah, blame the Wahhabist! What's next? Blame the jews?
عبد الله 12/12/16 (Mon) 01:12:27 5bb6b5 No. 18793
>>18792
blame saudi oil money
عبد الله 12/12/16 (Mon) 01:22:01 5bb6b5 No. 18794
>>18792
It is no conspiracy theory. Wahabbism is, in fact, Saudi salafism. The Saud family controls Mecca and Medina. These are not theories, but undeniable fact. When you're in absolute control of 1 of the 5 pillars of Islam, then you can use that power to convince others that it's "my way or the highway".
عبد الله 12/16/16 (Fri) 08:00:14 5bb6b5 No. 18835
>>18794
That and the oil. And all because the Brits wanted to defeat the Ottomans.
عبد الله 12/18/16 (Sun) 04:06:15 5bb6b5 No. 18888
>>18835
Amazing how a few puddles of ancient pulverized animals can cause such a ruckus.
عبد الله 01/02/17 (Mon) 15:20:30 5bb6b5 No. 19121
>>18888
Not only oil, but also drugs and arms trade. A general push to degenerate islam and weaken it's resistance to such poison. We are a barrier to their satanic profits. So thus the jews will stop at nothing.
عبد الله 01/03/17 (Tue) 01:02:23 5bb6b5 No. 19142
>>18888
Nice quads
I'm back on the thread yes