Sounds nice, but let's get rid of the obvious
>No NTR
>No sharing
If those are met, go ahead, so among your options, 3rd one sounds the bets. It'd be nice to play around the idea of playing as Nick and toying around with Judy, as you move to become the new chief of police, where you start to train her even more, plus you could add other female characters as you advance the story, OC or not, like that sheep girl, you could visit her in jail and blackmail her into becoming your slave, or that singing thing that was voices by shakira and even Judy's mom.
>that's not what I'm here to ask about.
>I'm here to ask about platforming
>I think that a pixelated art style would be a cuter,
>Or go more visual with Renpy into a Trainer-style game?
All that depends on what kind of gameplay you want to implement in the game and what engine will you use. If it's free exploration, then 2D sprites can work with some support CGs, or you can just do what everyone else do and make a management kind of game in ren'py, in which case sprites would be useless I think you can add exploration on ren'py ala RPGmaker too.
>but I don't know how to program.
Well, you're fucked, you can hire a competent coder to help you with Ren'Py and the such, I hope you can find someone competent, and I really hope that you can draw.
>Should I do Python?
Ren'py is written in Python. It says as much in Ren'Py's page. https://www.renpy.org/doc/html/python.html So yeah, ren'py is a good idea, since it seems like there's nothing else, and ren'py coders are kinda cheap and bad at that.
I hope you can actually do this and don't chicken out like the Tigress OP that came a few weeks ago >>34829
I wish you look, since this is something I actually look forward to, and to motivate you to, read this: https://exhentai.org/g/979885/d7b6e2279a/
<Yiff in hell faggot