/a/ - Animu & Mango

>Will it be ruined by reddit?

How is that even possible? They discuss anime in a completely separate place. How could what they do possibly affect you?

>>932518

Once they like something, /a/ retroactively decides it's shit and won't talk about it and will mock any attempt to talk about it.

>>932504

>Will it be ruined by reddit?

The manga itself is pretty reddit. I don't see how they could ruin it further.

>>932520

>>932518

>They discuss anime in a complete different place

There are loads of rapefugees from there to here, specially when such things happen. You guys are just obnoxious idiots.

But well, Dr Stone has been ruined since the space station arc, which is extremely early on.

>>932534

And it will inevitably be a step down from Boichi's madness.

>>932536

Boichi only draws, he doesn't make the story.

I was the anon that would make the Dr. Stone threads but there was never much to discuss beyond acknowledgement of the series' greatness. I hope the anime does well, but, like TPN, I probably won't be bothered to watch it because I prefer how it's delivered in the manga.

How could reddit ruin something they have no input into unless you actively browsed their community? Kill yourself redditfag

>>932546

>How could reddit ruin something they have no input into unless you actively browsed their community? Kill yourself redditfag

They como here and to 4chan, this is a known fact, and they bring all the cancer with them.

All I feel for Boichi's girls is lust.

>>932529

>Maybe in the case of shounenshit.

I've got bad news for you, anon...

>>932527

>>932532

The anime isn't even out yet and it's already begun. Anons hard at work to pretend that they never liked the manga in the first place.

>>932620

Are you retarded? You may have never found any of us because you live in an echo chamber.

>>932534

>but what the hell is animation bringing to the table?

Ever since the anime announcement I noticed some parts of the manga that looked to me like they were made to be animated. I can't remember exactly what off the top of my head, but basically scenes and gags that would be enhanced by sound and animation, like the panels were a storyboard.

>>932622

Unsurprising. I wonder if Dr. Stone will preach about the glory of renewable energy sources while avoiding nuclear like the plague.

>>932659

He's pulling your leg. Did you forget the entire arc about finding oil fields to power their equipment?

>>932660

I stopped reading when they started cave exploring because I was worried they'd go down the route that was described.

>>932663

You stopped reading because of a weird assumption you pulled out of your ass, and the manga did the exact opposite of what you worried about.

You shouldn't jump to conclusions before things actually happen, you'll only burn yourself unnecessarily.

Anime airs next week.

Is the problem with secondaries that they only became interested in a series once it became a low quality, fashionable, and easier to consume? And how do they always find their way here?

The character designs are fuck.

The shonenshit style of writing where everything has to be explosively presented is ruining it, but then again the stupidity of it helps keeping the mood lighter. Hopefully there will be a limited amount of big archenemies and rivalries.

>>936780

Absolutely. Case in point, >>938413 Some kind of defect in their brain tells them nothing is worth it unless it is animated. The "easier to consume" part isn't even true, reading a manga chapter is much faster than sitting through two chapters worth of anime. They need a downgrade to enjoy anything, it's kind of baffling, really..

>>938415

Anime acts as a simple filter to avoid having to go through the mountains of available manga currently out there. It also guarantees you'll have someone to have a twitter "conversation" with about how epic the latest episode was, which is all they really care about.

>>938415

Congratulations, you can read. Post your name, address, social security number and credit card details so we can mail you your gold-coated phallus.

>>938415

I think there are advantages and disadvantages to both. If you want to enjoy a series fully, you should both read the manga and watch the anime.

For instance, Made in Abyss lost a fair bit of lore when adapted to anime, but I felt the visual and emotional impact of the anime was often better than the manga.

Of course some anime will end up being disappointing, but that's something you have to find out for yourself. You can't rely on other anons to tell you what you'll enjoy.

So is the adaptation any good or?

Goddamn this OP is really fucking good

>>938478

>not being able to opine or discern quality from one episode

What a sad mental disability.

>>938480

A pity >>938461 cannot do it, then.

Time to play unreal world and read Jules Verne.

>>938571

The fermentation process they showed was quite modern for a "stone age" setting. I'm not too sure about mixing the must daily. Wouldn't that introduce more oxygen than desired and lead to more vinegar production? Given that they had bamboo and earthenware pots they could have made an airlock with ease. The fractional distillation was nice. It was still amusing though. I'm sure MC will be as OP as ever to advance the plot, par for the course in this kind of story.

>>932665

How many years after awakening do they pull off oil?

>>938667

>How many years after awakening do they pull off oil?

Not long. They start progressing a lot faster once there are more people around and they have a certain economy of scale for food, shelter, etc. I don't think they've seen their third winter yet, including the one this episode. Part 1 (once the prologue ends) takes half a year.

>>932643

I can't stand senku I stopped reading somewhere around when they were doing that tournament arc because I just really didn't want to keep looking at him. I read that much because I liked every character except him and early on there was a lot more balance between how much time was spent on senku vs everyone else. But once you get into the thick of the tournament arc and they have to collect sulfur I just didn't want to deal with him any more.

There's something kind of disingenuous to me about having a stone-age world and making the main character a super-scientist who can make the stone-age just go away, what's the point of putting characters out of their element and then having the story not be about them learning to thrive in the new environment but rather they just make things like the world they came from, it's just not interesting and is actually frustrating because you know there isn't going to be any problem Senku can't solve because the author has access to google and can just bullshit some Gilligan's island coconut and bamboo radio-wave transmitter to call for help or something because Senku knows the exact chemical make-up of coconut milk and at what temperature you have to boil it to make it put out an SOS. It's cheap bullshit and it's not even transparent.

>>938761

>Boichi, the author

He's the artist, not the author.

So how plausible are all the devices made so far in the manga? The battery-less wireless earphone really has me wondering

>>938785

That left me scratching my tard-noggin', too. Wouldn't it need a ground to work?

>>938785

>battery-less wireless earphone

I don't remember the details of how they worked it, but the only reason a radio receiver needs a battery is amplification. Passive radios were commonplace before batteries became as common as they are today. The only thing unrealistic about that is the volume they're getting.

>>938798

>volume

I havent read the manga but yes a radio receiver can be entirely passive aka microphone. With some clever work on passive amplification devices I suppose they could forego the amp as well.

>>938800

>passive amplification

The additional energy needs to come from somewhere. The best you could do is build a bigger antenna to capture more energy from the radio waves.

>>938730

>what's the point of putting characters out of their element and then having the story not be about them learning to thrive in the new environment but rather they just make things like the world they came from

The point of the story is taking back the modern world, not living in stone age. Senkuu is a super genius walking encyclopedia but I don't see how that makes him unlikable. It would've probably been worse if they had spread branches of science across multiple characters.

Really the only super powers Senkuu has are memory and mental math. Stuff like using brain on parallel are bullshit but people like Von Neumann or Euler were known to recite books they read years ago without mistakes.

>>938801

Constructive interference.

>>938814

Interference with what?

I've been fact-checking the stuff and pretty much all of them make sense, the only actual exaggerations are matters of processing time and the autistically intricate variety of knowledge that one would need to come remotely close to making any of this in a stone world, plus some things having exaggerated effects. Really hyped about how they are gonna pull off a FUCKING DRONE

Is it ever explained how Senku keeps his hair like that?

>>938876

Bird egg protein that has the chemical composition of ChM3u3p3cv5 that is perfect for the stone age. Fucking retard stone age people.

>>938819

The waves with themselves.

>>938806

> The point of the story is taking back the modern world,

And it's bad because it's not like it's happening in steps. Senku just decides he's going to fabricate complex tools and production processes and then it happens. He almost always has a way of getting the resources he needs, has enough time to do what he wants to do and it benefits him in exactly the way he expects it to.

> It would've probably been worse if they had spread branches of science across multiple characters.

It would have been worse if there was a varied cast of characters that had different specielties and skill-sets that they contributed to the group for each-others mutual survival and through shared hard-ship learned more about each-other as people and learned to rely on and trust each-other. Yeah that sounds like the shittiest fucking story I ever heard of. I'm glad we have Senku the wunderkind to know everything and be able to do everything, that sure solved that problem.

> Stuff like using brain on parallel are bullshit but people like Von Neumann or Euler

Neumann was a jew and thus powered by demons and Eulur was a faithful Christian and thus divinely blessed. They as supernatural outliers can hardly be used as counterpoints

>>939045

>it's not like it's happening in steps

Are we reading the same manga? He spent thirty chapters working towards an antibiotic that only took half a chapter to actually make, because there were so many intermediate steps he had to take in order to get everything he needed.

>if there was a varied cast of characters that had different specielties and skill-sets that they contributed to the group for each-others mutual survival

Are we reading the same manga? There IS a varied cast with different specialties, with people being chosen to be revived based on their being the best at what they do. The best eyesight, the best ship captain, the best social manipulator.

If you want a story where every day is a struggle to scrape together the necessities of life in a stone-age world, then read a survival manga instead.

The anime is alright I guess, the manga still is superior like most of the time, hopefully it won't turn to complete crap.

>>938761

Completely unrelated, but anon were did you get this Akiha crop from?

>>939052

To be fair the devices made so far aren't particularly complicated or impressive. Any high school kid can rig up a shitty engine or these entry-level chemicals

>>939060

GPS and drones, though? Even if you have a perfect memory and loads of willpower like Senku, that shit should take years of trial and error to get right.

>>939065

The drone we haven't seen yet, and the "GPS" is just a big antenna that sends a radio wave

>>939065

They call it GPS, but it's only called that for familiarity. That name is only applicable as far as "positioning system", and is really more of an RDF than what we think of as GPS.

Once you have the circuit components working, a VOR isn't that big a leap when you already know it works.

>>939067

That's as much GPS as the Viggen had in 1975.

>>939066

A "drone" by the broadest usage is just an RC helicopter. If they have metal and woodworking putting together small stirling cycle engines with fans is not out of reach. Add in a wire controlled speed governor to pull off basic directional control and its a flying device you control remotely aka drone. I don't see a meaningful usage for such a device but the concept has been around since at least Da Vinci.

>>939105

You have no idea how wrong you are

>>939112

So small spoiler for you: They do awaken many more people as the story goes on but it doesn't solve the problems. There's still the mystery of the petrification phenomenon and then reinventing everything modern civilization takes for granted. After the first episode, they've spent a long time formulating enough of the de-petrification solution to wake up a few people, which brings up the next few conflicts, like deciding who to revive and how to progress, because even if they could awaken every person on Earth, the planet is very different and there is no infrastructure, let alone food, to sustain them anymore.

>>939054

>Are we reading the same manga?

To be fair, no, I haven't read it in a long while. I just came to the thread to vent frustrations I had back then but nobody to talk about it with since my powerlevel is deep undercover. There's probably a lot of criticisms I have in hindsight that aren't very valid because I'm half-remembering vague impressions.and blowing them out of proportion because those are the impressions I remember.

I'm re-reading the manga and there's one thing that I really don't see as feasible in any way. the pseudo-carbon fiber breaking a stone spear like nothing. Can this be reproduced irl? Also the manufacture method seemed really way too simple.

>>939453

Which chapter was that one? I don't really remember it to be able to say.

>>939455

70

>>939461

Yeah, that one was definitely more out-there.

They kind of hand-wave exactly what the binder was but even so, you'd never have the rock break like that. I might have been able to buy it if it had only been the shaft shattering along the existing splits, but not the stone head itself.

>>939453

>>939462

The "carbon fiber" was plant based cellulose fibers from their grass based paper. The binder they swept under the rug but they probably have access to some sort of plant rubber. Drying that out would make some kind of rubber/plastic. They even mentioned that it was an unhardened plastic that they used to make "cellophane". I assume they figured out basic vulcanization too. This is the kind of thing anons can attempt, it sounds worth a try.

The rock breaking was total BS. The paper part of the shield would need to be quite thick to not at least get penetrated by the pointy end of the rock. The rock could have broken or chipped if it already had cracks running through it but an almost explosion of the rock is not going to happen barring one of two cases. One being the rock is as shatter prone as glass and two the spear holder jabbed about as fast as you can pitch a rock at a brick wall.

I'm pretty sure if you were stuck in rock you'd start hallucinating, since that is what happened to people who went in sensory-deprivation chambers.

This ED feels so wrong

>>940100

The rest of the episode felt pretty wrong too, but then I remembered I was watching a Jump adaptation.

>>940159

>rain

I would get missing it on the manga since black and white still panels, but how retarded do you need to be to think it was "rain" in the fucking anime?

>>940128

Tsukasa was 100% in the right. Too bad we have another case of retarded idealist shounen MC who wants to save everyone without anyone being left behind.

>>940250

Tsukasa's entire speech is a smokescreen to cover the butthurt at losing his imouto since he's a siscon pervert

>>940260

There is literally nothing wrong with being a siscon.

>>940250

Tsukasa is way more of a retarded idealist than MC.

>teenagers are all pure, with teenagers we can live the gommie dream, only reason gomunism didn't work was because old people

>>940279

To be fair to anprim GANG, there's good reasons why the older generation should be revived later, if at all:

>little to no practical survival knowledge

>less capacity for physical activity

>ingrained political/economic beliefs and associations

>short future working lives

>potential chronic illnesses they can't treat

Senku's working time is the most valuable thing they have, and he could get jumped by a lion or stung by a scorpion or whatever at any moment. He needs to be building infrastructure and easily replicable technology, not refining insulin because they happened to revive someone with the beetus. Teenagers and young adults should absolutely be the priority, and you'd have to wait at least a generation until their society is settled enough to dump a load of non-working mouths to feed on them, by which point people are already getting older.

Every successive leader would put off grasping the nettle. There's good odds it would never happen at all.

>>940263

True, but it does make for a very poor base to form your political stance.

>>940350

That they should have lower priority makes sense, especially the actual elderly, pensioners and such. But he didn't even use any of those sensible arguments for his stance, it's like the author wanted to make him look retarded. And likewise, Senku didn't respond sensibly, either, they just had to be black and white.

>little to no practical survival knowledge

This applies to all age groups, if anything I'd expect middle-aged men to be the most well versed in survival; as well as every other field. Around 18-35 is peak physical condition, and ~30-50 is peak capability in whatever field they are in.

>ingrained political/economic beliefs and associations

It's probably better for rebuilding society to have people with ingrained beliefs than a bunch of impressionable teenagers developing their political and economic stance based on a tribal stone age lifestyle they are quickly developing away from.

>>940250

He's only half-right. Reviving corrupt and evil people for the sake of wanting to save everyone is dumb. Thinking you can restart the world as a paradise where only noble savages like himself will thrive and make a peaceful, natural civilization is beyond moronic.

Later series spoilers: Tsukasa does start his own kingdom, but he only revives people who seem strong while smashing the statues of others. He ends up with a Kingdom full of retarded goons and a small inner circle of sociopaths and traitors, one of which wants to kill him anyways, specifically because Tsukasa is a shitty leader and an idiot.

You guys are forgetting Senku doesn't give one milimeter of a crap about making utopias or any politics. All he wants is to restore civilization to the same scientific level it was before the catastrophe so humanity can keep elevating science.

>>940441

But his actions are so inefficient due to his adhd ridden attention span that he's gonna end up causing a famine by accident. He needs a leader who can put him in a lab to teach people how to make fertilizer not be free to run around with a big boat going on pirate adventures where he could get killed.

>>940458

He never claimed to be a leader or even want to be one. All he wants is a big lab to sperg out inside for the rest of his life.

>>938415

Watching films or animation is less involved than reading. All person has to do is just look and listen. To read manga, you need to read text, view images, move eyes from panel to panel, flip pages, and use a bit of imagination to interpret what you perceive. That little bit of work is enough to scare off many people after they were conditioned to watch things instead of reading them.

>>938442

Definitely, each medium can do something other one can't. Manga's greatest strength is that budget is far less relevant than it is in case of animation. However, animation has sound and movement to work with.

I'm feeling the excitement I felt when I read the manga all over again.

Every time a chapter ended with Senku doing something impactful or declaring something absurd I'd get a chill down my spine. I remember particularly the oil chapter, him saying they were going after oil was built up slowly for a few pages, started not so obvious and got more and more obvious until he declared it, the payoff I got when I slowly realized where he was going was great.

These first 2 episodes were really good so far, I felt this mix of excitement and inspiration at the end of both episodes.

>>940639

A big point of the series is that Senku is a godly scientist, but incompetent at almost anything else. Teamwork will be abundant.

>>940639

Where are you reading the latest chapters? Nigger box stopped their updates quite some weeks ago.

>>940677

I use Manga Eden. It has frequent updates, though it also has shitty watermarks.

Tachiyomi on Android gives a lot of options for mango piracy.

How do you call an Ukrainian? A partisan. How do you call 2 ukrainians? Partisan cell. How do you call 3 ukrainians? A partisan cell with a traitor.

>>942984

>How do you call an Ukrainian?

Drop a piece of salo on the floor.

Surprised Yuzuriha was revived so early, would've expected it to be one of many dragging plotlines. This episode was better than the second one.

Gunpowder was a big leap forward scientifically. Rather, warfare has provided the impetus for scientific advancement like nothing else. The common theme here is that basic chemistry is the key part of advancing civilization so far. If that creator faggot provided humans with a decent world tutorial we could have progressed so much further in the few million years we have been around. Instead we spent forever messing with basics like flora, fauna, textiles, agriculture, and learning basic mechanics. Hunter-gatherer-scientist should have been the starting point.

>>943112

This is a trashy shonen where science is a super power.

Don't get your expectation too high, it is NOT about a realistic approach to rebuilding society from scratch and showcasing actual techniques to make tools from makeshift conditions. It's just the very very shallow setting that sound promising but in fact it's "power a friendship", "I can make instant bullshit anytime" kind of trash.

I'm not surprised /a/ likes it, it's naruto but instead of magical demon power it's magical science power.

You don't believe let me ask you a simple question:

Where did they get their clothes?

>>943264

He's another retard that hasn't read the manga shitposting.

How Senkuu made all his stuff is explained in a few chapters, and until they make a loom later on all the clothes we see are made from animals.

>>943293

The reaction doesn't always depetrificate completely. This is a plot point later on

>>943265

>>943264

You're the only retards here.

Leather, are you serious?

Do you realize how complex tanning is?

You need a shitload of precise tools to make even the most basic shit.

And you need a shitload of materials which he specifically doesn't have (you need at least lime and sulfur).

I've read the manga and it's not explained... well it is and it's complete bullshit, like 99% of the "explanations". Senkuu catches a deer with a trap because it can't run after it (when in reality it's the opposite. Human are pursuit predators, just follow a deer it's gonna run away every time you get close, assuming it would run away in world without humans which it wouldn't, and it's gonna collapse exhausted long before even an out of shape geek) and then wear it's pelt which he made holes in biting it (which is so retarded it hurts. Have you seen the teeth of a human? Have you seen the teeth of things that need them to pierce animal skin? Also that with stone awls being an actual thing that does exist which should tell you how well the guy that write that shit is versed in paleontology... he's at "didn't open the wiki page" level) and then he wears it...

Now protip: if you wear a dead animal (or person I don't judge) like that, it's just gonna rot.

And that's just ONE example.

Distillation is the same thing, yes some clay retorts exists but they can't make alcohol as they are and probably used something in bronze/copper to make a condensation collector (which, being valuable, is logically missing).

Etc...

It's fine if you accept it's a shonen and science is a magical super-power (like the other chars have all super-powers) but if you think that show is about science and technology or has even the tiniest spec of realism, you need to have your brain take away by social services.

>>943301

>(when in reality it's the opposite. Human are pursuit predators, just follow a deer it's gonna run away every time you get close, assuming it would run away in world without humans which it wouldn't, and it's gonna collapse exhausted long before even an out of shape geek)

Go back to reddit or wherever you heard that from. Only a few nigger tribes in Africa do that and that's not proof enough to say all humans hunted like that. When humans grew two brain cells they used traps or hunted in groups, or are you saying people outran deer to exhaustion in a forest in winter?

>>943308

No.

Because humans used to be so few and deer so many they probably didn't run at all and making a spear and a spear-thrower is about as complicated as rubbing two stones together. Same thing with bow and arrows.

Of that there is plenty of evidence, hell fucking chimpanzee uses spears

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2007/02/chimps-use-spears-to-hunt-mammals-study-says/

https://archive.is/RZfjm . The genius protag is literally dumber than an actual monkey.

Pursuit/persistence hunting was definitely a thing, most hunter-gatherers that still existed in modern day practiced one form or another (on all continents, including whites in Siberia) and humans are far to well built for it for it.

Also instead of hunting deer which is relatively hard... there is plenty of other small mammals that are considerably easier to hunt. Most small mammals hide in places a human can simply dig out by hand.

Even a half brain dead human is still an apex predator.

Trap making requires much more effort and is far less successful, it requires industry and advanced knowledge/stalking of a prey habits.

Nobody uses traps to hunt for flesh consumption, it's used to hunt for fat/skin/furs because you typically make a LOT of traps (because when you make things you don't make just one, it's not worth the effort to mastering the process of making something) in a circuit and then you patrol the circuit to considerably augment the chances you will catch something. The cost is that by the time you get to the caught prey it's guts are gonna starts decomposing, the blood clotting, etc... and seeping in the meat.

Again it's stereotypical of a shonen. Cool initial pitch turns into a very shallow setting with a writer that has very little knowledge of what the subject actually is (because he just thought it was a cool idea and ran with it... for 30 chapters and then it turns into a tournament arc).

You're allowed to like junk.

You're not allowed to pretend that thing is anything else.

>>943301

The science is pretty good, for the most part, but a lot of important stuff is just glossed over or not even explained. If I had to hazard a guess, it's because the writer is prioritizing the story and plot progression over painstakingly detailing every invention and acquisition.

I still enjoy the series overall, but there's some awkward hiccups where the series can't decide if it wants to be a supernatural mystery, a hard science survivalist story, a civ builder about the glorious return of modern science, or a shounen action series where the protag is weak, but super smart.

>>943329

>>943301

Christ fuck, you're pretty dumb yourself for someone trying to decide whether the protag is smart or not.

I don't think this was ever a survival manga, yes there are some aspects of it, it's inevitable in this setting, but most of it happens right at the start when there's only Senkuu and Taijuu living together. They gloss overt his part because this is obvious not the focus, the focus is Senkuu building stuff, they even advertise the manga as a "crafting adventure", probably to appeal to kids who like minecraft.

"Science" is his super power and a lot of the shit he does is explained poorly, but I don't think the core of it is bad at all.

Like the roadmap to antibiotics, they show all the main components they need to make antibiotics, and he goes out getting one by one, making the components needed to reach the final goal, it's not perfect but during this process I didn't notice anything glaringly wrong, I think it's all presented really well.

If you're frustrated because this manga makes some effort to be accurate but doesn't go the extra mile to be 100% accurate and realistic then I don't know what to tell you, it was never going to be this kind of manga from the start, it never sold itself as that or anything, it's like you went to a burger place and threw a shit fit because they don't serve pizza.

>>943509

Using it as a cheap symbol for "this character is smart" isn't as bad as mangling it for a plot point.

Think of it as his motivation or something, wanting to get back to a level of development where that regime of physics is relevant to technology again.

>>943509

It's really fucking dumb, but they explain it later.

>>943509

It's universally recognizable and looks cool to the layman.

While E=mc^2 is pretty overused and lame overall Boichi himself was a physics major so it's not like they're throwing this out without knowing shit. I'm actually surprised nobody mentioned this so far.

Seibuta is completely different, it was like a middle school graduate watched some shitty dumbed down youtube videos and put misunderstood quantum shit in his LN to seem smarter. That Schrodinger shit was the most annoying misunderstanding of QM people do and I had to drop it.

So far in Dr. Stone biology is the most unscientific part, but it doesn't really hinder the story much.

>>943502

That's my fucking point.

It's fine to watch this as shonen (aka the junk food of anime) where science is in fact magic.

Science is definitely not the goal here nor realism, so saying it is (which is most of the thread) ticks me off.

>but during this process I didn't notice anything glaringly wrong

You mean when they ran out of coal?

Because they haven't been making charcoal?

Because they made everything by burning wood so far (and a jar of coal so small you would hardly use it for anything else than a barbecue)?

After going in a place where sulfuric acid occurs naturally in insanely great concentration (which is about as common on the planet as diamond mines. Maybe less)?

When they have lead, sulfur, cinnabar, etc...?

Meaning they can perfectly make some using a old timey lead chamber. The problem is that shit isn't taught in chem 101 as it's 1700's alchemy tech (despite the fact a well stock lab will have the tech, for when you need a small bath of acid and you've ran out of industrial grade). So the author solution to find acid in a "good enough" concentration is by having it naturally occur (which isn't impossible... just extremely improbable).

The author does have knowledge of material properties and isn't making "big" mistakes but the production methods (which is the "cool background idea" past the shonen shenanigans) are at best very truncated... at worst complete BS.

Again I'm saying it's fine it's a shonen, it's Naruto or Bleach.

You should expect as much a show about science, technology and survival that those are shows about medieval covert activity in feudal japan and the mystical ferrying the souls of the deceased.

>>944659

Also, spoiler, they need platinum to make more acid.

If that's the case I'm seriously gonna laugh at the people that though that show was smart.

"why isn't this shonen cartoon meant to entertain readers of a magazine a perfect realistic science dissertation?"

t. the most clueless fucking retard I've ever seen on this board.

>>940374

It worked for Lelouch didn't it?

>>945959

>Man technology is the best I love Elon Musk!: The manga

I liked the part where they unironically did the

>I'm bad guy, I'm tough because I have no frens

>>946227

The state call "law" it's own violence and "crime" the violence of the individual

>>946229

Natives? They were not made into stone like everyone like and kept the human species rolling until now?

>>946065

Why the hell did they have this scene here if they were just going to make it look like shit? If animating and drawing a ton of trees in this perspective was too time consuming why not cut the scene or do something simpler?

>abysmal state of human settlements that had modern knowledge and several thousand years to develop

>"While the enemy is preparing for war against us, let's make a radio!"

>radio made of a single transistor functioning

>with a range of over a km

>carbon fiber made by pouring a thermoplast over paper

>that isn't brittle and can survive blows to the side of the fibers

>modern people didn't introduce cooking and agriculture within a whole year of being awakened

<Will it be ruined by reddit?

It has already been ruined by lack of research and poor writing.

>>947021

I also forgot the fucking fridge which was the most retarded thing the manga has offered to date.

>>939453

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_fibers#History

It's not realistic at all.

>>946315

Folks couldn't be expected to stay up on the international space station forever

>>947021

>abysmal state of human settlements that had modern knowledge and several thousand years to develop

The knowledge would fade within a couple generations. Unlike Senku, they didn't have the luxury of an established village that could support their efforts to blitz through everything, so they were focused on survival. They also had no idea how to revive people, if it was even possible, while Senku had the advantage of it being narrowed down. Besides, Senku's making what he needs, not rebuilding systematically. If he dies, everyone's back to square one.

And there's nothing unrealistic about villages being at that level for millennia.

>"While the enemy is preparing for war against us, let's make a radio!"

Correct, that is what they did. Communication over long distances is useful.

>radio made of a single transistor

It would be a complete waste of pages to go into detail of every single circuit element. This is an anime, not an instruction manual. The fact that they can make the components is the important part.

>modern people didn't introduce cooking and agriculture within a whole year of being awakened

The first year there was only two of them, one of whom was useless at physical labor like working fields.

And in the village that was already managing, they had more pressing concerns.

The fridge and the "carbon fiber" were stupid though.

I don't understand how a chunk of platinum can make "infinite" nitric acid.

>>948448

Platinum is just a catalyst, not a component of the acid, so it's not actually consumed.

>>948448

In theory its possible, but in practice its not. Some of it is manageable but some of it is impossible to achieve. They show some failures but in reality they would have failed a lot more with most of the stuff. Just consider 1/1000 odds as 1/2.

For example making distillery is fucking hard if you rely on luck to do it. It broke once in show, but in reality they would spend days constantly fixing everything and result would be really shitty. Their makeshift constructions are always reliable and they never required maintenance. In reality they would smash half of their stuff out of pure frustration over how shitty everything is.

So technically possible but its as probable as naked man killing a lion. But I dont think they had anything outright impossible. except starting a colony with less than 10 people for it to survive thousands of years. While its technically possible to avoid inbreeding defects with pure luck, we are talking about impossible odds. You will probably have better luck interbreeding with monkeys.

>>947021

>a team of astronauts/scientists cant keep foundations of civilization intact with 10 people and 95% of civilization inact

>one guy can easily rebuild civilization by himself after 99% of everything in ruins

>>948501

No, because of magic petrification.

But really, stop trying to give shit to author for stupidity. Most of it is just "fascinating idea+pure bullshit" exact same premise as most of scifi short stories written not by scientists. it gives people some idea how stuff works, so its okay even if its exaggerated. It wasnt written be genius or even by a handy man who can actually do all of it.

If you want to be anal about something you should look into long fucking list of all misconceptions. Quantum=binary, apple fell and I understood gravity and all the others. Apple story really pisses me off.

>>948504

>You will probably have better luck interbreeding with monkeys.

I sure hope 774 isn't reading this.