[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / animu / arepa / asmr / cafechan / evogames / fascist / sw / vg ]

/a/ - Animu & Mango

Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
Password (Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Oekaki
Show oekaki applet
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, swf, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.


Welcome to /a/, please read the rules before posting.
Reminder that in the event 8ch goes down, our bunker will still be up and running.
Other boards to try: /animu/, /cute/, /rec/, /ameta/, /u/

YouTube embed. Click thumbnail to play.

 No.807943

So now that it's almost over, how does everyone feel about Tales of Autistic Saber?

 No.807984

>>807943

Boring story, boring main character, melodramatic


 No.808003

>>807943

Looks great most of the time. The plot is slow, but it's skillfully written, and overall the events and developments are tied together nicely and fairly coherently. It's a very nice anime. I wouldn't call this a masterpiece, but it's an outstanding work nonetheless, and I have enjoyed it alot. Anime like this are what keep me slogging through the oceans of mediocre crap.


 No.808004

>>808003

I forgot to mention as well: the direction is good; the scenes and events are skillfully created as well, and are portrayed visually in such a way that make the most of the emotional drama in the show, which would otherwise have become a little redundant by this point in the series. The great music also helps with that.

This is a story that takes itself fairly seriously, and that doesn't strive to appeal to the lowest common denominator at the expense of its meaningfulness and internal coherency like we're used to seeing. VE seeks to be a meaningful, character-oriented story, and it does a good job. I have no complaints.


 No.808005

Good art, boring story, blatant heartstring-pulling. Enjoyment depends entirely on how susceptible you are to crying about characters' tragic pasts.


 No.808007

>>808005

>blatant heartstring-pulling

What redeemed this to me was how well the episodes were related to Violet's character development. It was unusually coherent and relevant to Violet's character, which somewhat mitigated the otherwise sappy feeling of the subplots. I would argue that, on their own, each episode is very good, well written, and, well done. However, like I said, looking at the anime overall: there is a small issue of redundancy. I do think, at this point, they've gone "too heavy" with the subplots a time or two too many. But what else can they do? They've got to fill episodes. There's 10,000 more cynical ways often employed by seasonal anime to solve this same conundrum.

You can compare VE to Angel Beats, for an example of an anime that aimed for a similar emotional tone, but that lacked the skill in writing and direction.


 No.808009

Just like clanaids - constant over-the-top melodrama without any proper foundation-setting first. At least it looks pretty though, it's probably the most aesthetic anime I've ever seen.


 No.808011

>>808009

>without any proper foundation-setting first

That's definitely something VE could have put more time into developing


 No.808012

File: 3038248a5918ca5⋯.jpg (106.9 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [HorribleSubs] Violet Ever….jpg)

Meh first 4 episodes, the rest has been pretty good or even great like episode 5 or 10 in my opinion. Episode 11 was OK if a bit shallow and melodramatic with the soldiers conflict, but it served to set up this new Violet. The contrast is very noticeable between this Violet and the one in episode 11.


 No.808013

File: e5213bfc59c2c19⋯.jpg (685.59 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, [HorribleSubs] Violet Ever….jpg)

>>808012

This Violet and the one from episode 1*


 No.808023

>>807943

So did Cyborg Saber have sex with the red haired guy or what? I stopped watching Episode 2.


 No.808038

VE feels like I'm watching the animated version of a hollywood drama. Once its done I can comfortably erase those memories and avoid Kyoani like the plague.

>>808023

Not happening ever. Shes supposed to be a child and Kyoani would never touch such a development.


 No.808044

>>808038

>feels like I'm watching the animated version of a hollywood drama

I didn't get that vibe at all. The first distinctions that come to mind:

>feminine lead isn't an obnoxious feminist archetype or anti-male in some way

>general absence of globalist propaganda in general

>14 y.o. female romance with ~25 y.o man


 No.808047

>>808009

Weirdly enough I love Clannad but hate VEG, maybe the story of Clannad resonated more with me or something


 No.808058

I dropped it after episode nine, so that should tell you all there is to tell. I tried to like it. Was actually surprised KyoAni managed to shit out something this bad. I know they get a bad rep for some of their "design decisions" but making an anime of such low quality is not something I associate with them.

The disjointed pacing and "fill in the blanks" off-screen character progression was something

I was not able to forgive. Remember when Violet couldn't understand how humans felt and was unable to pass her class because of it? Remember how she magically wrote the best letter ever and became the ichiban auto memoir doll overnight, with no explanation? There was no continuity in her character as she would, at times, change her personality radically for no fucking reason. Like that one time when she turned into a sassy, cheeky cunt to help the alcoholic author write.

Anyone who legitimately liked this show is a huge bottom-feeding faggot.


 No.808061

>>808058

That was my biggest issue. She flew through that typewriter school and by next episode was a world-renowned doll. There was no development, we were just supposed to expected to accept it despite the fact that she was a mega autist the episode before still


 No.808067

>>808058

>>808061

There was absolutely some pretty stark inconsistencies in her character development, and this is almost certainly the anime's weakest component. I think you guys are overreacting though. Such things are endemic to anime/manga, and these plot holes are hardly examples of anything unusual. There's only a few of these hiccups, and overall Violet's development is fairly clear and pretty consistent.


 No.808078

Can one of you anons who finishes the show let me know if there was ever any other fan servisu besides the shot of Violet's torso in episode one?

>>808067

You're right, I may be over-reacting by pulling the "stop liking what I don't like" card. Just pretend I didn't call you a faggot.


 No.808095

I think this is a classic example of failing to fulfill your true potential. Could have been an amazingly good and beautiful anime but some things are just not executed well. I think in the end this was supposed to be a show to learn more about how human emotions work and this learning effect is amplified by making the MC and through that the viewer absolutely oblivious to emotion. That way, you begin from scratch and relearn things that you thought you understood. You have to put the characters and the environment at first place, all else would be a distraction!

They followed this very well during the first episodes but somehow got derailed once the focus turned to Violet's past. And here for me the biggest problem arises. This whole war backstory and her being an amazingly overpowered and 14 years old demigod wasn't good at all. It felt out of place with this edginess. One scene you have this strange woman trying to become..human? And in the other one you have her jumping around like coldsteel the hedgehog. For one it totally ruined the immersion that you had in this well crafted world. Showing emotions in a war is a very hard and delicate task and I only know one show that did this correctly. But here they failed with over-the-top nonsense. Also it was wasted screen time in my opinion. You can do this when your anime runs 24 episodes, but not at such a short length. And what otherwise is a minor point then becomes a critical flaw. I would still give VE a 7/10 but it could have been a 9/10 if executed better.


 No.808107

>>808095

I think a good argument can be made for the action being out of place. But it is a rather minor aspect to begin with, and is furthermore an excusable gimmick for sheerly commercial reasons. It doesn't detract from the story and characters much, and is hardly the biggest flaw in this anime.

>>808058

>>808067


 No.808131

>>808107

I absolutely agree with the posts you quoted, but is my point still really that minor? It's a pretty big deal that she was this child soldier and lived through an alternative Battle of Verdun. I am not talking merely about the battle scenes in themselves (although they too are unfitting), I am talking about what we are supposed to think Violet is. And here follows this huge discrepancy that annoys me. We see a grown woman in a belle époque setting, with normal people, normal jobs, normal everything. This woman is different and tries to find something that she is capable of and starts -again- a normal job. But then suddenly we find out she is actually a super child soldier that fought in a war, and not only that, but she fought there as if this was Naruto or Dragonball! The stage is completely shattered if you do that. Let me give a ridiculous example to clarify my point. Imagine watching a Shakespeare play, perhaps Hamlet, when suddenly space knights with lasers come in and shoot everyone. You could have easily prevented that by having Violet grown up in a horrible household and explain her lost hands through an accident. It would not hinder the main objective of the anime in the least, it would even improve it! Do anything, but please don't ruin this fantastic world you created by introducing alien and ridiculous elements.


 No.808134

File: c66250c96bdb985⋯.png (164.4 KB, 413x352, 413:352, c66250c96bdb9859cabb30130d….png)

I think the major issue with Violet is that the art, animation and direction are SO GOOD that it makes even more obvious how the story is boring.

This is a 12/10 technical anime with a meh 5/10 story.

Any other anime with this same story would have been ok and we would have enjoyed, but in this particular case with so much effort and time put by Kyoani it feels like a waste of resources.

It is painful to see how so good animation, voice actors, animators, designers, music, etc. get together to make a story that falls flat in every possible department. The source material is bland, and even Kyoani managed to bring out A LOT out of it, but there's a limit of how much water you can get out of the well.

Some chapters are ok as stand-alone stories, I liked the mother and daughter one, but in general Violet past feels like bad fanfiction and most of the stories are just meh. They are ok but I won't remember then in a few months or years. I won't remember this anime at all, I'll just remember how it was pretty but nothing else.


 No.808135

Violet is just a blank slate reflecting the happenstance work-obligated experiences she has with much more interesting people. The story would have been considerably improved if it centered on basically any other character that has appeared. I've watched all of Violet's awfully paced, time skipping "development," and I still don't care about her character even a little. I feel more for Luculia's alcoholic brother who appeared for a total of two minutes.


 No.808150

>>808135

This is the result of trying to treat a living onnahole like a real person.

That one military guy, whoever the fuck he was, who gave Violet to the Major tried to warn him remember? "She's just a tool to be used."

You can blame all of this show's faults on the major being a little bitch that did the thinking with his fee-fees instead of his head.


 No.808158

File: 94285558d8dbc29⋯.jpg (2.65 MB, 1536x4000, 48:125, dv01.jpg)

File: 64b99e35aae306a⋯.jpg (132.22 KB, 1506x845, 1506:845, d3.JPG)

>>808058

>>808061

>>808067

>>808107

See, this is something I don't understand. The worldbuilding is sloppy at best, the pacing can be very jarring, the episodic drama is sometimes be very shallow to the point of being melodramatic, but Violet has gotten a fairly good characterization and development through mostly showing rather than telling, this may be why some people think her character is all over the place, but the cues are there.

I'm guessing by off-screen development you mean from episode 4 to 5. There was a timeskip, but her basic characteristics and character traits were still appropriate. Violet is shown to be a very literal character in the beginning, a bit self-centered, and she can be perceptive, and later in the show, empathetic, that is when something directly relates to her, like in 1st pic related. This is why she was very eager to know how the story ended in episode 7, it was basically about her, and we later see her finally 'getting' it, not by putting herself in other people's shoes, but vice versa. She projected her own experience and unfulfilled promises onto all the people she's killed as the catalyst to understand why she was 'burning'. We see her struggle during the first 3 episodes, trying to understand what an auto memoir doll does, but we also see her commit herself to her role. She isn't just trying to "find what love is" through that profession, she's focused. She manages to pass the course, but it wasn't because she wrote one letter, it is established that she's the best in class at grammar, vocabulary, typing speed, etc. It is also established that a doll not only ghostwrites but it can be used for many other things; Violet's technical skills alone could land her a job in that industry as a Jr already. She doesn't do an amazing job with that letter, but she showed the headmaster that she's committed and that he can in fact express a client's true feelings on paper. The headmaster "HOPES Violet becomes an optimal doll", she wasn't one yet at that point. You have to remember that was a short term course, this is stated at the end of episode 2, the same episode where Violet learned that people can be contradictory.

Episode 4 was very bad, holy shit I hated it, but it confirmed that Violet had become a decent doll. She's still very literal, specially when it comes to anything relating to love, in that regard she's not only literal but ignorant, the difference here is that she's already aware of that. She's a decent doll now because at the very end, when Violet asks if her letters were good and Iris nods, we realize those letters weren't dictated, but ghostwrited by Violet. In summary, she went from not knowing what a doll was, to completely blowing her first job in episode 2, in episode 3 she showed many character traits that are essential to understand why there was no actual development off-screen, she's focused, committed and extremely proficient in the technical aspects of letter writing. In episode 4 we see her admit her own failings but we also see her perform a very competent job. This is all a setup for the timeskip. What we didn't see in the timeskip was more of the same.

Her growth in episode 5 has to do with her experience as a doll, not as a human being. She's still literal, she still doesn't have a clue what love is, and this is made evident when she makes the princess write her own letters, she's out of her zone and she knows it (something she learned through episodes 2-4), but what's more important, she uses that opportunity to see more aspects of love, she breaks the rules of a doll and lets Charlotte write her own letters not only because that would be best for the princess' current situation, but also for her (Violet's) own sake. She's very involved and attentive with everything that goes on between Charlotte and the prince, she watches them as they confess their love and get engaged in person, then makes a remark with how their love came true. She knows her prose, grammar and structure, it is made clear that she has spent the timeskip working with clients AND reading novels, THAT is as far as her off-screen development goes. Second pic is another example of how she projects other people into herself, that's the only way she can empathize and understand other people at the beginning.

>>808131

Her inhuman abilities were shown since episode 1, I think we all knew what we were getting into and while I agree with you that her superpowers seem mostly unnecessary, they were there from the very beginning, so Violet's backstory didn't really derail the show, it was setup from the get go.


 No.808163

>>808158

I sincerely hope that KyoAni at least gives you a .5 second shot of Violet's pantsu as a reward for defending the maiden's honour on a Tibetan ox-breeding bulletin board.


 No.808167

>>808163

Don't get me wrong, I don't like her as a protagonist, but she's a well fleshed out character in my eyes.


 No.808175

>>808131

>>808131

>but please don't ruin this fantastic world you created by introducing alien and ridiculous elements.

This is essentially a matter of you having better taste than the intended VE demographic (which is nonetheless still several steps above the median for anime). Most people, Japanese or not, don't know what belle epoque means, let alone have any familiarity with the Battle of Verdun. To you, a plot element which belongs in shounen is a glaring and petulant-feeling inconsistency to these elements, but for the large majority of people, it's simply something that gains their interest and makes Violet more interesting. You're expecting VE to have more attention to detail put into the historical setting than would be worth the effort for the invested interests. The superficial setting as it is now is probably enough for the majority. And if the additional effort was made to polish up the backdrop to that extent, would people even notice the difference?

The naruto ninjapowers have some grounding in the plot, where it validates Violet's having any first-hand combat experience despite being a cute young waifu. Granted that it's, even then, still overdone. And it provides (or was intended to provide) impetus for more captivating action scenes, in line with the necessary demographic appeal that I mentioned earlier. As far as detracting from Violet's character, this seems again a matter of your giving more attention to historical detail and realism than most people will. Because while it's cliche and unrealistic, it is still coherent with her general characterization. It meshes well with explaining her being an emotionally undeveloped drone. So, despite being overdone, it's not inconsistent; it's not something that contradicts her essential characterization.

>You could have easily prevented that by having Violet grown up in a horrible household and explain her lost hands through an accident. It would not hinder the main objective of the anime in the least, it would even improve it!

Yes, but in doing so you'd subtract from the anime essentially all of the action related to Violet. Probably the singlemost, core development scene of her character, which has been screened multiple times throughout the anime, is reliant on an INTENSE BATTLE to emphasize the emotional drama. This change is no small alteration, and would require a pretty immense application of skill to maintain the same level of audience engagement, and might even then fail to retain interest.

VE would probably be better, or at least more intelligent, if it was done as you'd prefer, but would it return the investment and grease the skids for the next project?


 No.808177

>>808158

>The worldbuilding is sloppy at best, the pacing can be very jarring, the episodic drama is sometimes very shallow to the point of being melodramatic, but Violet has gotten a fairly good characterization and development through mostly showing rather than telling

I think this is a good, concise encapsulation of the qualities and flaws in this anime.


 No.808182

I liked the episode with the mother writing future letters to her daughter for when she passes away. The daughter was a bit too smart for her own good with her saying you should spend time with me now while you can tantrum, but it was certainly a compelling moment.

Seeing the time pass for her was also quite touching.


 No.808188

So is this worth watching or better to just leave it in the bin?


 No.808189

>>808188

I believe there is more than enough information posted in this thread to help you make up your own damn mind.


 No.808206

>>808175

I'd say Violet arms have some metaphorical significance, but yeah the super strength needs to go.


 No.808213

>>808182

Yeah that was the worst episode yet because it actually had some potential but it was totally ruined by the fact that the mother SHOULD have spent time with the daughter before she died. Who gives a fuck about getting some letter from your long-dead mother every birthday until you're middle-aged? The girl needs the support and love now. Even the fucking maid started crying.


 No.808214

>>808213

She didn't die right away. The fact that it was a considerable seasonal timeskip implies she lived for at least a few more months.


 No.808293

>>808044

>feminine lead isn't an obnoxious feminist archetype or anti-male in some way

>general absence of globalist propaganda in general

>14 y.o. female romance with ~25 y.o man

Is this what Hollywood is these days? Its been almost 20 years since i consumed their products.


 No.808317

>>808213

>>808214

I also at first felt that the tension in the episode was specious, given that the obvious solution to the circumstance was to nix the (I assumed) prolonged letters to relatives. VE came through in the end though. It was a sweet ending, and validated somewhat the mother's motives for neglecting her daughter throughout the episode. One imagines it would have been obviously been better to simply give the child the straight scoop from the beginning, so that's a bit of a >misunderstanding, but it's not nearly as bad. This isn't the first time I was initially disappointed with the writing of an episode, to later see that much more thought and craft had been put into it than what I had assumed.


 No.808386

>>808188

Absolutely. It still is great. You see us moaning here on quite a high level, make no mistake.


 No.808407

>people complaining about fantasy elements

Do you really want to watch 14 episodes of a polynesian pictogram that is about nothing but the growth of a single character, through a storyline that's already been done before? Because that's what VEG actually is since they haven't really touched the fantasy elements since episode 1.


 No.808435

>>808407

I think people are complaining that the fantasy elements are just there and not being utilized except for when Violet has to "kick some ass" in badly choreographed fight scenes, might as well remove them completely.


 No.808440

File: db02ef72a3c8d27⋯.jpg (106.12 KB, 724x844, 181:211, 1416008147210 (2017_05_12 ….jpg)

>>808213

But see, that was a well-designed conflict. Acting to the future while also focusing on the present is nigh-impossible. You have to prioritize one over the other to some degree.

The mother chose the future, because she knew her daughter was going to grow up without a mother, and wanted to do the best she could to still be "with" her daughter as she became an adult. To give her some semblance of having a loving mother who supports you through your childhood and adult years. The price of this was losing some of her limited time in the present, which could have gone towards the arguably equally important effort of spending time with her daughter while she could. As we saw, the daughter chose this option.

The viewers are going to be pretty split on which side they favored. It provokes deeper examination of the event and makes viewers apply it to their own irl experiences to try and better interpret it.

I think that from a writing standpoint that episode was one of the best in the show so far. It actively engaged the viewer and made them think about the scenario, rather than simply going "here's sad things, now feel sad".

I've been lucky to not lose a parent, but I did lose my mother's parents when I was a young child. I don't have many memories of the grandfather whom I'm so often compared to, even though we spent a lot of time with them. I think it would have been wonderful if I had letters from him that would give me insight into the man he was and what might have been, had he not died of heart disease. Young me would have chosen to spend more time, but now that he's passed those letters would feel like he's still here in a way.


 No.808861

>>807943

It grew on me more than I thought it would, even though I find the autistic supersoldier backstory fucking retarded given how low fantasy the setting is.


 No.808950

Subs will be late again


 No.808957

I dropped it at episode 3 or 4 and now you guys are making me want to pick it up again.

Is it worth it to see more, it was this something you wish you ended sooner?


 No.808958

>>808957

Make your own dumb decisions, faggot!


 No.809018

>>808957

The first 4 episodes were arguably the worst, with episode 3 being the best of that bunch. But if you didn't like the vibe I don't think you should pick it up. It gets gradually better but not by much, episode 5 and 10 have been its highest peaks for me.


 No.809312

>>808957

>Is it worth it to see more

No this show is awful. I am amazed Kyoani has written something so awful. I assume the source material (light novel) must be equally terrible to produce something so unengaging to watch.


 No.809318

What to think of EP12? Would be a good episode if I didn't know that the ride is over in two episodes already. I think it will lead to the final stage being these peace talks and that's it. More dramatic would be if they skip to Violet being in a hospital and just state that the negotiations were successful so that the show can continue doing its thing for the last two episodes. But somehow I doubt that this will happen. I also begin to smell bullshit and can't rule out that they will kill off Violet in the last episode. We will see.


 No.809405

>>809318

There's already confirmed more anime content, probably movies, I doubt they'll kill Violet.


 No.809416

File: 2205eab17ac4c23⋯.jpg (443.89 KB, 735x420, 7:4, amanitas_on_moss.jpg)

>>807943

Visually it's beautiful...

Emotionally, heartbreaking... I can't think of another anime that has made me cry to this extent. I can identify with the numb/dead-inside/delayed-reaction/regret/PTSD theme, but not the 'autism.' The focus of the anime is dealing with unavoidable death and loss in a realistic manner. Solidly a tragedy no matter how much of a happy spin they put on the ending.


 No.809425

File: 457e1a0114acdbf⋯.jpg (159.87 KB, 800x570, 80:57, fly.agaric.jpg)

>>808005

>blatant heartstring-pulling

If you can make your audience FEEL, then you've won. I just wish their was an anime that made me FEEL equivalent emotions of Joy.

>>808009

>without any proper foundation-setting first

It's a shame VE don't make more use of the WW1? Alternate Europe setting. A greater sense of time and space would help especially given how much the Dolls travel, but that isn't the focus of the anime.

>>808044

THIS. Alter-Europe is WHITE.

The only political narrative I can see is Anti-War.

This Anime has the capacity to reach audiences of all ages, especially White people. If there was one recent anime I could've shown my WW2 vet grandfather, this is it. Granted, you have to accept that Violet was/is an outlier genius combatant for a young girl. The auto-mail is also a little jarring given the general level of technology. Maybe if they showed a genius like Tesla + Clockwork, use her to create a prototype...

>>808095

>>808061

>>808131

>>808135

>>808175

>>808206

Violet is a Savant ubermench anons, you have to just accept this. Also the story-line with the redheaded girl who would have been a good yuri love interest but alas was the critical point.

>>808134

>I won't remember this anime at all, I'll just remember how it was pretty but nothing else.

The mother-daughter one was for me by far the most powerful, but the time skip was jarring, especially when the story returned to Violet and she wasn't an old woman.

I think the episodic nature and the fact that Violet doesn't forge any relationships that are lasting, or any that are more important that any others, that results in the vague feeling.

>>808293

No, this is Netflix working with Kyoani, slightly different. Also, Netflix made the Man in the High Castle after-all.

>>808317

>>808440

The Daughter was more mature than the Mother expected. Also it was just one week out of half a year?.. before the Mother died.

>>808440

Yes, my grandparents on my mother's side really didn't think to communicate with future me, and my grandparents on my father's side often couldn't be bothered with present me. Same goes for my parents. Though my parents have been far more suffocating than my grandparents were ever to them.

>>809416

ht tps://ste emit.com/@vox xe


 No.809497

>>807943

>watch this animu thinking it was about war

>its about some gril who is too autistic to understand emotion and becomes a typer in order to understand what "love" means

*clap clap clap*


 No.809663

>"finally it's not another wannabe tearjerker episode!"

>now Violet is Canada

They can't do anything right, not even by accident.


 No.809792

>>809425

>If you can make your audience FEEL, then you've won

It depends. I agree that this anime was definitely a cut above, although there are a few flaws. Complaints about excessive melodrama might be one of the valid complaints


 No.809872

>>809425

>If you can make your audience FEEL, then you've won

By that logic, the most garbage generic shonenshit are all masterpieces too, because they all love those

>girl is being abused and beaten and terrorized and raped

type of subplots or even main plots.

But they're not. Blatant heartstring-pulling is bad specifically because you can tell that the authors were shit out of ideas and went for some generic garbage they saw in a million other anime, and hey, it evoked feelings in the audience there, no reason not to use it one more time! But I'll make the rape scene twice as long, then the audience will FEEL twice as much! Genius!


 No.811027

>>809872

> >If you can make your audience FEEL, then you've won

> By that logic, the most garbage generic shonenshit are all masterpieces too, because they all love those

No, it doesn't follow, and you aren't making sense, retard.


 No.811328

>>811027

So you're saying that the majority of the viewers don't feel anything when watching those kinds of shows and those kinds of scenes? Must be why shonenshit is so unpopular.


 No.811353

>>807943

>>807943

Garbage anime. 4/10.

One of the weakest Kyoani series.

It was so damn disjointed and made me cringe in almost every episode.


 No.811354

>>808134

The directing is garbage, especially in the action scenes.


 No.811362

After summoning all the good in my heart I can give this a 5/10. Between the uninspired story, characters, the all around terrible directing, cutting out the few good things in the novel, the countless attempts at trying to appear deep and impactful most of which fell flat, it's truly fitting to be MAL's AOTS.


 No.811604

People keep complaining about the story and characters but what exactly is wrong with them? I thought they were fine. It was a solid 6, probably weak 7 anime. Definitely above average.


 No.811607

If only the MC wasn't so beautiful


 No.818232

It was pretty to look at, as is to be expected from Kyoani, but everything else was incredibly boring and a slog to sit through.


 No.822505

It is beautiful, easily better than the average anime. Overall 8.5/10.

I am surprised there is so little talk about it, is it not well known? Thought it was popular and would be a big hit. Am I mistaken and are most people passing this along for the seasonal shounen garbage?


 No.829722

This was trash.


 No.829728

>>829722

Why did you bump the thread just to say that? I don't think a single person disagrees with the general sentiment.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / animu / arepa / asmr / cafechan / evogames / fascist / sw / vg ]