Talking from a romantic attraction point of view, I am at the point in my life where I find myself adoring cakes.
They may be drinking too much, they may be lonely, they may have lost their hopes and dreams, they may have a lot of flaws. But underneath all that, they are gentle and tender, and I think a cake appreciates affection in ways a JK is not able to because a cake has had to do without. I find that very attractive.
Don't get me wrong: JKs, or JSs, are wonderful. They're pure and beautiful and perfect in almost every way imaginable and I love seeing them in all my animu and I love seeing animu all about them. However I find it harder to get attached emotionally to them.