[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / asmr / cafechan / had / htg / leftpol / sw / travis2k / zoo ][Options][ watchlist ]

/monster/ - The Last Bastion of Romance

Monstergirls
You can now write text to your AI-generated image at https://aiproto.com It is currently free to use for Proto members.
Name
Email
Subject
Comment *
File
Select/drop/paste files here
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Expand all images

File (hide): 3c6cfb5e5cb9ba5⋯.png (539.96 KB, 939x564, 313:188, Gargoyle.png) (h) (u)

[–]

359a29 (6) No.323239>>323241 >>324393 >>325715 >>325723 >>325753 [Watch Thread][Show All Posts]

KC and Crabman came up with our favorite girls. However the canon and catalog they come up are really different from each other. Gargoyles in MGE being a type of Golem while the Gargoyles in MonMusu are Dragons. Anyway, which parts of each written canon do you prefer? Which designs do you like the best?

0c75b6 (4) No.323241

>>323239 (OP)

Crabman made the objectively better Mushroom-girl by a magnitude of infinity.


74fa73 (1) No.324393>>325709

>>323239 (OP)

>monmusu

>canon


359a29 (6) No.325709

>>324393

What are you implying?


b2cbac (1) No.325715

>>323239 (OP)

If crabman could do a proper wan, I'd be all over it.


8adea0 (3) No.325723>>325736 >>325737

>>323239 (OP)

What about those of us crazy enough to brave MGQ?


359a29 (6) No.325736

>>325723

You motherfuckers are madmen.


2b1cd2 (1) No.325737>>325764 >>325768

>>325723

>MGQ

You’ll find directions to /chaos/ in the Rules thread.


96fa0a (2) No.325753>>325768

>>323239 (OP)

I wish I had the MGE gargoyle redesign to post here, but sadly it's only in the book I have and not on my PC. KC's newer gargoyle design looks a lot better and is better than Crabman's version of a gargoyle.


3835b9 (2) No.325764>>325769

File (hide): fa310b7d0a32966⋯.png (348.95 KB, 315x679, 45:97, opinion_discarded.png) (h) (u)

>>325737

>implying MGQ isnt one of /monster/'s primary sources of canon

>being this new


8adea0 (3) No.325768>>325773

File (hide): 7fc58f8fb0b9be6⋯.jpg (108.29 KB, 786x1017, 262:339, autism snek is best girl.jpg) (h) (u)

>>325753

KC's new gargoyle is a good example of how far he's grown as an artist. I'm not a fan of MGE's magical realm in any way but damn, that man has become the personification of what happens when you git gud with drawfagging.

>>325737

>Purge abominations all day erryday except S-2. S-2 is for headpats. Awawawawa.

>Facepunch omnicidal goddess to death

>Make babies with echidna wife

I'm not seeing any negatives here.


06d13f (1) No.325769>>325771 >>325772 >>325777

File (hide): c4ddd1e509b6e47⋯.jpeg (Spoiler Image, 24.63 KB, 259x194, 259:194, F9CC2FB5-C739-4E98-BD37-6….jpeg) (h) (u)

>>325764

When was the last time anyone utilized the canon of the MGQ setting for anything other than Ilias/paladindu memes? If every officially-published piece of media that contained cute monster girls that are popular on image boards was /monster/ “canon”, we’d have to include shit like Star Vs the Firces of Evil to the list, but it isn’t because everyone only likes certain characters in the work and nothing else, so we take the good Waifus out and leave the filth on the floor,

Just look at pic related chucklefuck, tell me shit like it is acceptable on this board


decc07 (1) No.325771

>>325769

What the hell am I looking at?


359a29 (6) No.325772>>325775

>>325769

I swear the artists forgot they were making an eroge and thought they were doing a horror game.


0c75b6 (4) No.325773>>325777 >>325820 >>325841

>>325768

This is exactly my point, you faggots don’t like MGQ, you like Alice and “touch fluffy tail” and literally nothing else about the games.

You worthless niggers, i’ve lurked this board since Autumn 2015, literally the only time I have ever seen anyone talk about the lore or background information of MGQ is the occasional Holocaust jokes about Remina, and those are never even made in context of the games themselves.


b99dc3 (1) No.325775

>>325772

Yeah a lot of the girls in MGQ were pretty grotesque. Maybe it was so you'd want to save your virginity for Alice?


8adea0 (3) No.325777>>325778

>>325773

The only reason I ever got into MG's in the first place is because of MGQ. If it weren't for that I would be ignoring MG's as I can't get into MGE. I can appreciate the art from KC, and I would buy the man a beer for his commitment to drawfagging, but his magical realm is a complete no go for me.

>>325769

Truth be told I take the most for my magical realm from MGQ. The biggest thing I like? They know that shit is hard and human/monster relations are difficult. They are trying to find solutions to these problems that don't involve a donut steel lilim ruler fucking her brains out claiming to "fix" things.


359a29 (6) No.325778>>325817 >>325818 >>325823 >>325878

File (hide): 4dc842ac88ae8e3⋯.jpg (228.44 KB, 925x522, 925:522, Crabman Canon.jpg) (h) (u)

File (hide): dfadaf8cc730990⋯.png (621.87 KB, 1290x600, 43:20, KC Canon (1).png) (h) (u)

File (hide): 59bfd9b4dc735a1⋯.png (676.09 KB, 1330x629, 1330:629, KC Canon (2).png) (h) (u)

>>325777

MonMusu is more ideal since there is no magical realm or mamono mana. Monster Girls are seen as more like natural creatures aside from the dullahan.


e00e09 (3) No.325817

>>325778

MonMusu is also boring as shit.


5a9731 (1) No.325818>>325823 >>325824

File (hide): 421802bc3a3cb62⋯.jpg (76.57 KB, 680x680, 1:1, 13475023482.jpg) (h) (u)

>>325778

>it's illegal to fuck your waifu

>monsterboys exist

>implying mamono mana is a bad thing


e00e09 (3) No.325820>>325845

>>325773

I like MGQ a lot though. Paradox is very likely to be one of my top favorite RPGs of all time when it's done. The whole series, including part 3, is full of cute girls aside from Alice and Tamamo. Even Amira, the mutant that she is, is charming to me because of her personality. I won't say that every design is a winner in my eyes, I've never been big on taurs, but I'm sure that they appeal to someone's taste.

What I've never gotten is why so many people make a big deal out of the abominations. In a game with over a hundred girls what's wrong with a quarter of them of being designed not to appeal to your dick? They're supposed to be disgusting to show that the enemy faction are a bunch of maniacs churning out abominations because they're crazy for science or just plain crazy. Some of the angels and chimeras may not have been cute, but I thought they were cool. Whenever a particularly disgusting one appeared, I knew it was all that more important for me to not lose. The whole world is being attacked by angels, you don't have time to be fucking everything you see anyway.

Ignoring the fuckability of the girls altogether, I also really enjoyed the plot and gameplay of the original trilogy. The writing may not have made it the next Planescape Torment or Ghost Trick, but it was an enjoyable ride from start to finish. As much as people hate Plansect for being full of Delphinus, the part where Luka royally screws the pooch because his chuunibyou got the best of him and ends up having to nuke everything as damage control is an especially memorable scene to me. The entirety of Heaven was a nonstop thrill ride as well. I came to the final boss fight without even touching my dick. All those friendship speeches, all those almost heroic sacrifices, your aunt lying about her special attack, the music, and even Ilias's design were top notch.

tl;dr I like MGQ.


134a23 (1) No.325823

>>325778

>MonMusu is more ideal

No. I can't believe someone can be this wrong and still be alive.

>>325818

This.


0c75b6 (4) No.325824>>334838 >>335260

>>325818

>That provision was annulled in the first quarter of the story, Kimihito is just being a dickless faggot that won’t make a choice like every single other harem protag

>They are only ever in the background, never go after human women (why you guys care when you constantly claim to want nothing to do with human women really activates the almonds), are considered inferior to humans by their own women, and they only exist at all to avoid having to make up a bullshit excuse for how monster girls could propagate when they couldn’t openly go after humans. They ain’t a threat to you, stop being an insecure faggot.

>Why yes Ms. Danuki, I would love to be subjected to ambient magical radiation that gradually mind breaks me, restructured my body, and turns me nonhuman even though I have a repressed homolust irrational hatred for all things monsterboy.

Dislike Urban Fantasy if you want, but that doesn’t excuse having shitty double-standards.


3835b9 (2) No.325841>>325852

File (hide): a37f5663094b2fd⋯.png (389.17 KB, 554x463, 554:463, economic_wolf.png) (h) (u)

>>325773

>lurked this board since Autumn 2015

>writes like this

>monster girl quest has been in the stick longer than youve been here

Nice try newkiddo.


d88748 (1) No.325845

File (hide): 6e5a2ed602721c7⋯.jpg (192.68 KB, 500x500, 1:1, 1369670236587.jpg) (h) (u)

>>325820

I agree with this guy. The good shit overshadowed the various NOPE-girls and scenarios for me.

bullying the bandits was the best


0c75b6 (4) No.325852>>331415

>>325841

>>writes like this

notanargument.gif

your counterarguments need some actual substance retard, piss of back to tumblr with the rest of the uni-trannies if you can’t actually refute me

>>monster girl quest has been in the stick longer than youve been here

Yeah, and like I said and like only one single person has argued against, this board as a whole almost never talks about the game as a whole; you talk about how it was the entry-point for Monster Girls as a genre and gush about a small handful of the more memetic main and secondary characters, out of context of the games’ setting and plot. No threads about its history, its politics, its ecology, its all just Ilias-bashing and “Hora” posting.


f0c22d (1) No.325858

I'll always love MGE for introducing me to monstergirls years ago.


96fa0a (2) No.325878>>325884 >>331395

File (hide): 6b879521eca92c6⋯.jpg (413.73 KB, 1200x1692, 100:141, 01_AB73ree.jpg) (h) (u)

>>325778

Incorrect. MGE with some modifications is the best. Just gotta make it a more modern time, get rid of the two furshit species, and get rid of the Order. I like the idea of a much longer and much more sex filled life. Fuck having responsibilities and shit. I wanna fuck and cuddle my waifu all day long


e00e09 (3) No.325884

>>325878

Best canon is headcanon.


359a29 (6) No.331394

File (hide): dc278e4f827591b⋯.jpg (139.83 KB, 404x600, 101:150, Orc_0.jpg) (h) (u)

KC and Crabman orcs.


99d05e (1) No.331395

>>325878

>Just gotta remove all sources of conflict

Fixed it for you.


e72466 (1) No.331396>>331414

File (hide): 5015e0f99cb65a3⋯.jpg (406.65 KB, 900x1200, 3:4, 501.jpg) (h) (u)

File (hide): 3ad823a39daa435⋯.png (298.68 KB, 484x706, 242:353, 774.png) (h) (u)

File (hide): 3acc39f9b5b8bf9⋯.png (1.87 MB, 1280x1820, 64:91, 3ac.png) (h) (u)

The biggest thing I notice is that Crabman is crazier with his designs on the girls. Crabman's monsters look less human when compared to their KC counterparts. Crabman would give them inhuman eyes or extra arms, for example. Another thing is that Crabman's girls aren't as sex crazed as KC's girls, unless there's a full moon.


b148db (2) No.331414>>331428

>>331396

I like when Crabman's design include some details that show how he tried to make them slightly more “realistic”. A good example is his mermaids' pelvic fins that look a little like degenerate legs. In their behaviour (and culture), they are also more likely to be inspired by the animals they are based on (directly or indirectly through an animal-inspired IRL fantasy creature).

KC's monstergirls, meanwhile, are fantasy through and through. The many that are based on actual mythological creatures try to be (somewhat) faithful to their inspiration, like gargoyles being golems rather than actual living organisms, until you get to the magical realm aspect at least. Their actual designs take more liberties and are just meant to look appealing though (although they sure succeed at that).

I appreciate both approaches; they try to do different things and do a good job each (although KC could really turn down the magical realm a little).


b148db (2) No.331415>>331428

>>325852

>this board as a whole almost never talks about the game as a whole; you talk about how it was the entry-point for Monster Girls as a genre and gush about a small handful of the more memetic main and secondary characters, out of context of the games’ setting and plot. No threads about its history, its politics, its ecology, its all just Ilias-bashing and “Hora” posting.

It might be because it's somewhat self-contained. On the outset there is conflict, over the course of the plot that conflict is resolved, and at the end we get a glimpse of the future that is now to come.

There's not as much setting speculation to be had as with MGE, where you can take things to their logical conclusion and end up with all sorts of horrible/interesting scenarios; nor are individual monstergirl species developed as living creatures as they are in Crabman's canon.

MGQ is kind of a default setting. At the beginning of the story it resembles MGE's world, albeit without the mana and transformation stuff, and at the end it's becoming a utopia for monstergirl lovers. It can accommodate most of the typical writefag stories, but it doesn't lend itself to discussion or large-scale world-building.


ef56fe (1) No.331428

>>331415

MGQ has a shit ton of vore and old testament abominations, thats why people ignore it.

>>331414

the mermaids in crabmans setting cuck people, meros mom was close to shagging kimihito. then you have the ork problems and nonhuman terrorism.


1c5e6b (1) No.334838>>335257

File (hide): 803f340ddbd2125⋯.jpg (425.94 KB, 869x1270, 869:1270, MonMusu Guys1.jpg) (h) (u)

File (hide): 8ed67d40c60db32⋯.jpg (356.9 KB, 870x1263, 290:421, MonMusu Guys2.jpg) (h) (u)

File (hide): 833f555c1f8b743⋯.jpg (318.1 KB, 870x1271, 870:1271, MonMusu Guys3.jpg) (h) (u)

>>325824

>>They are only ever in the background, never go after human women (why you guys care when you constantly claim to want nothing to do with human women really activates the almonds), are considered inferior to humans by their own women, and they only exist at all to

Just in the case of the centaurs and mermaids mostly. Crab has shown more monsterboys lately, and they were pretty popular with human women. At that big convention-thing they went to the human men and the liminal-girls were really hitting it off, and the human women and the liminal-men were really hitting it off.

There were even what appeared to be some completely liminal couples as well.


acc508 (1) No.335257

>>334838

You know i have to agree with >325824 i don't see why it makes people on here so fucking assblasted.


c0d902 (1) No.335260>>335278

>>325824

>I have a repressed homolust irrational hatred for all things monsterboy.

gtfo faggot


5da589 (1) No.335278

>>335260

Not to mention, the physical changes of incubization are minimal. Altered eye color, bigger package, and an improved, stronger, completely healthy body. The MGE is pretty clear that an incubus would be difficult if not impossible to tell from a human by just looking at them.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Screencap][Nerve Center][Cancer][Update] ( Scroll to new posts) ( Auto) 4
38 replies | 12 images | 24 UIDs | Page ???
[Post a Reply]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / asmr / cafechan / had / htg / leftpol / sw / travis2k / zoo ][ watchlist ]