This kind of nonsense really undermines the entire purpose of CYOAs. If you don't follow the rules, then why not just fucking imagine shit on your own? Why have a guided session which was (generally) balanced and/or themed with the pros and cons (or a point system) in mind, if you're just going to go "lol but I don't feel like following it now". Just throw it all away at that point, you've already fucked it all up.